Tuesday, March 10, 2020

Should I Watch This? The Good Place

Should I Watch This? Sam S******* wades through the glut of television content to offer his view on whether a TV show is worth your time. The only connective tissue for this column is that Sam watched it.


Show
: The Good Place

Season: Four (released 2019-20, episodically, like TV used to be)

Episodes: 13; each between 22 minutes and 54 minutes (the finale is the longer; most are under a half-hour).

How to Watch: NBC. On-demand through your cable provider, though you may have to buy the first part of Season 4 now, as the streaming services haven't yet got this season.

Genre: Philosophy class sitcom

You'd Enjoy This Show If You Like: Kant, the Golden Rule, Cheers.

You'd Hate This Show If You Dislike: the Judeo-Christian version of the afterlife; Becker.

People Involved: Another titan of a TV show from Michael Shur, known for other legendary sitcoms as The Office, Parks and Recreation, and Brooklyn Nine-Nine. Kristen Bell and Ted Danson star as this great ensemble cast deep dives into the hows and whys of the universe.

The Pitch: Eleanor and the Gang reunite for the final season where they get the chance to pitch the Judge of the Afterlife (Maya Rudolph) on the fairest way to resolve whether a person is good enough to earn his or her place in the Good Place.

Should I Watch This? As much as I love this show, I honestly must answer this question in the negative; no, you should not watch this season.

Season One and Two produced some of the best moments in TV history. Shur crafted a wacky but simple after-life scenario where moral philosophy was the theme without walloping you over the head. The Jacksonville Jaguars, happy hour margaritas, and Tahani's name-dropping endeared you to the characters and allowed you to digest the morality play without thinking too hard.

But then it got complicated, and the jokes didn't expand. Episode-to-episode you had to follow along some convoluted rule system where the good guys generally won, and the references stayed the same. It got stale to me. It reminded me of Jersey Shore after the cast realized they had to be insane or Arrested Development on Netflix. Jason's friends yelling about Gardner Minshew (the current Jaguars QB) felt forced and without the ease that Jason rooted for Blake Bortles. Plus, Chidi turning to the camera and explaining how the Wikipedia entry for John Locke applied to the scenario became more noticeable.

That said, the finale was awesome. Those 54 minutes perfectly encapsulated the spirit of the show without the forced rhetoric. The show concludes with a beautiful goodbye to our old friends and offers a meta commentary about when you should hang them up.

Unfortunately, this near-perfect denouement doesn't excuse the two prior seasons. Maybe Season 3 should have wrapped it up with this finale as the button. I'm sure it's hard to walk away from the opportunity to share your story with these fun characters (and the $$$), but I wish The Good Place possessed the same self-awareness its characters had. If you want to see how it ends, maybe just skip Season 3 and 4; you won't miss any new jokes or memorable characters. You'll be rewarded with a heartfelt goodbye to Jason, Eleanor, Tahani, Michael, Chidi, and Janet, and save a few hours of your life.

No comments: