Monday, March 16, 2020

Your Favorite Movie: The Sting, with Jeremy B.


Welcome back to Your Favorite Movie, where we... well, you know. *places finger on nose*

The mark this week is Jeremy B******. The story is that Pam had friends from high school, who were friends with Jenn N***, who married Jeremy. The moral of that story is that it's a wonderful fucking thing when a friend-of-a-friend-of-a-friend eventually becomes simply a friend.

The con this week is The Sting, Jeremy's favorite movie of all time. I didn't mention this in the interview, but I actually watched this one in grade school. My school had the bright idea to have kids come to the gymnasium on Friday nights to eat pizza and watch a movie, ostensibly so the kids would keep away from the riff raff on the mean streets of NEast Philly. The first and only movie night featured The Sting. I was the only asshole who watched the whole thing. Whether this speaks more to the magic of this movie (that it could captivate even some dumb fuck seventh grader) or to how overly serious I take movies that I watch (all my other friends spent the night, ya know, hanging out and talking), I dunno. But suffice it to say that I enjoy this movie, and I enjoyed talking about it.

Jeremy and I and our respective wives Jenn and Pam hung out before social distancing became the norm, and we ate some pizza and talked some movie and had a nice night. Our discussion is below, transcribed with Jeremy's permission, edited slightly, and beginning in media res, during a conversation about TikTok that, were I to transcribe it in full, would really show how old we all are.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe: Alright, if you had a TikTok account, and you had to create a "challenge" for "The Entertainer"—

Pam: Are you recording right now?

Joe: —by Marvin Hamlisch—

Jeremy: Yeah, are we on?

Joe: Yes. I don't actually want to start the interview like that.

Jeremy: I'll tell you, though. Remember the old cell phones that had the preprogrammed ringtones? "The Entertainer" was the very first ringtone that I had on my phone.

Joe: Is that why everyone still knows what "The Entertainer" is?

Jeremy: It could be! This was a movie that I watched when I was fifteen, for the first time. The back story is... we would go on vacation to Florida. I grew up without cable. Zero cable. So not a lot of exposure to—

Joe: You just had The Sting on repeat. [laughter]

Jeremy: No, no, what happened was, we were on vacation in Florida, and it was late at night, and my dad and I were the only ones awake. The Sting came on the TV, and he's like, "This is a great movie." It was just the two of us. And we just watched it. It's hard to explain, but my dad and I didn't have that... he was never... like, I didn't know what my dad liked for music, he wasn't very into movies, he just didn't have a lot of opinions. It's not like something where you grow up as a huge Beatles fan because your dad was a big Beatles fan. I had to find a lot of that stuff by myself. I became a huge Jimi Hendrix fan on my own. My dad skipped going to Woodstock to stay home and do laundry. He just passed on it!

Joe: Because he didn't want to.

Jeremy: No.

Joe: So it wasn't that he didn't share his opinions with you, it might have been that he didn't have opinions at all?

Jeremy: Right. He just didn't have really strong opinions. So as a teenager, ya know, it was kind of an adult moment, for fifteen-year-old me, when it was ten o'clock and I should be sleeping, and he was like, "this is a great movie," and we sat, just the two of us, and watched it together.

Joe: This is one of the few times you connected to your dad via pop culture, I guess.

Jeremy: Yes.

Joe: When was this?

Jeremy: I was fifteen, so '95 or '96?

Joe: So a couple decades after The Sting came out.

Jeremy: Oh yeah, easily. It could've been Turner Classic Movies for all I know.

Joe: But not... it's almost been fifty years since it came out at this point.

Jeremy: And what fifteen-year-old even knows about this movie, right? A few years after seeing The Sting for the first time—and this is just background knowledge—I worked at Blockbuster Video. I worked at three different movie places. I started at a place called Video Update, which was a chain, but not a very big one.

Joe: Before Blockbuster put everything else out of business.

Jeremy: It was a Blockbuster competitor, yeah. I also went to Rowan University, and at Rowan there was a little mom and pop video store called Movie Man Video and Tanning. [laughter] The daughters of that owner ran a hair salon where I got my hair cut, and I was complaining about Blockbuster, and she's like, "Ya know what? Let me make a phone call." She calls her mom, down the street at the video store, and I had an interview right after I got a haircut, and I was hired on the spot. So my last video store experience was Movie Man Video and Tanning.

Joe: That's pretty funny.

Jeremy: I would clean the tanning beds. As gross as it may be, they made most of their money off the tanning, and the adult video section.

Joe: You couldn't watch the adult videos while you were tanning, could you?

Jeremy: No, but do you know how many perverts asked if there were cameras back in the tanning beds? At least once every other shift, I was asked that question. But in general, growing up in the '90s, and working at three different video stores... you name a movie that came out between 1997 and 1999, and I could probably describe to you what the cover of the VHS looks like.

Joe: If we were playing "Your Favorite Movie" Bingo, one of the spaces would definitely be "I got this movie from Blockbuster." So it's cool that you actually worked at Blockbuster.

Jeremy: Boondocks Saints! Have you ever seen it?

Joe: For better or worse.

Jeremy: Cult classic. I could tell you all about the cover. We only had one copy, it was on the bottom shelf. Stuff like that.

Joe: So you had people jerking off to Boondock Saints in the back?

Jeremy: Potentially! Video Update had an adult video section in the back too, which was weird. Blockbuster never did. For Movie Man, that was a huge revenue stream for them.

Joe: I don't know how to connect any of this to The Sting... can you jerk off to The Sting?

Jeremy: Some ladies might find Robert Redford to be—

Pam: I love Robert Redford.

Joe: Do you feel like you could rub one off to The Sting?

Pam: I think so.

Joe: He's hot in this movie?

Pam: Absolutely! Jenn, do you agree?

Jenn: Um, I mean... Robert Redford is probably not my type. [laughter]

Joe: You're more of a Paul Newman gal.

Jenn: I could see how he would be attractive to someone though.

Pam: I love Robert Redford.

Joe: You're into the ruffians?

Pam: He's not a ruffian! I mean, he plays a ruffian in the movie, sure. But he's so clean cut.

Joe: Even the ruffians were clean cut in 1936.

Pam: Is that when this movie takes place? 1936?

Jeremy: Yup.

Joe: I think you were looking at your phone when they flashed the date on the screen.

Pam: I was either crocheting or dealing with Martha.

Jeremy: Joliet, Illinois.

Joe: How far is that from Chicago?

Jeremy: Not far, but back then it was far enough away that you could hide out in Chicago after messing up in Joliet.

Joe: They took the train from one to the other. Is that long enough for a poker game?

Jeremy: That was the start of the plot. The guy they grift at the beginning was a numbers runner for the mob. They grifted him and stole however much money from him.

Joe: I think it was eleven grand?

Jeremy: Right, which is however much money now. I did the math at one point, it was hundreds of thousands of dollars. But no, that train I think was actually to New York. The train was from New York to...? I don't know. [Editor's note: Apparently there was a famous train that traveled from New York to Chicago and vice versa, famous enough to have it's own Wikipedia page, anyway.]

Joe: When you were fifteen, watching this, the plot wasn't too complicated for you?

Jeremy: No, I don't think so.

Joe: I feel like everything I read about this movie is like, "It's a very complicated plot, but..."

Pam: I could follow it... so it's not that complicated. [laughter] I'm pretty bad at following movie plots.

Jenn: I had to ask a couple questions here and there.

Jeremy: But nothing that I was like, "C'mon Jenn." We paused it a couple times.

Jenn: I ask a lot of questions during shows and movies.

Jeremy: That's fine.

Jenn: But I got it.

Joe: It's interesting to think about, for me, the things that they decided to reveal to the audience, versus the things they held back until the end. We as the audience were grifted—not as much as Lonnegan, but definitely grifted a little bit!

Jeremy: You have to think about, this last viewing of the movie was number whatever for me, but it was Jenn's first time seeing it, so I had to keep my mouth shut about the plot points, because I didn't want to ruin the con for her.

Joe: What a reveal, though. So fucking good.

Jeremy: I don't know if it's a plot hole, but the FBI agent you see at the end of the movie, you also see at the beginning of the movie, talking on the phone about the numbers runner. I don't know how that got into place.

Joe: Ah... I didn't notice that.

Jeremy: The bald guy. He's there at the beginning, talking to the numbers runner. But then he shows up at the end, and that's a big plot point.

Joe: I'll have to look up what the deal with that was. [Editor's note: It's possible that it was just two different bald actors. The guy posing as the FBI agent is definitely played by Dana Elcar. The guy at the beginning, Combs, is played by Arch Johnson, who is not bald on his IMDB page but was bald in this movie. I am not 100% certain the latter is who was being referred to by Jeremy, but it's possible. They do look similar.]

Jeremy: It feels like a bit of a plot hole to me. And think about Robert Redford, right at the beginning of the movie, he comes into all this money and drops three grand on a roulette roll. Right?

Joe: Would you ever do that?

Jeremy: No.

Jenn: Oh, should we talk about Draft Kings for a minute?

Jeremy: ...No, we shouldn't talk about that.

Jenn: Jeremy's really into Draft Kings,

Jeremy: I got into sports betting after the Super Bowl. But, like, five dollars a game.

Joe: I was going to ask if you lost three grand yet.

Jeremy: No.

Joe: You haven't lost three grand in 1936 money.

Pam: [to Joe] You put a hundred dollars on black in Vegas, didn't you?

Joe: I did. That was the most I've ever bet at one time. I had won a hundred dollars from Drew A*******, because he thought the Eagles were going to lose to the Patriots in a regular season game where the Eagles upset them, and he had to pay me a hundred dollars, so I just dropped it on black. I lost it right away.

Pam: If the Eagles had lost to the Patriots, you would've had to give Drew one dollar.

Joe: He gave me 100-to-1 odds. I grifted him!

Jeremy: Here's the context where he drops three grand on roulette. [looking it up] In 2020 dollars, it's like $52,600.

Pam: Insane.

Jeremy: Can you imagine going into an illegal gambling house, and dropping that kind of cash on the table? And the dealer—and I think this was a point I had to explain to you [Jenn]—it wasn't really made obvious that the dealer hit a special button on the bottom of the table, and fixed the roll.

Pam: Oh, I don't think I picked up on that either.

Joe: Martha might've been crying during that part too.

Jenn: That's a question I had. How can you guarantee that loss?

Jeremy: They don't explain it. I'm guessing magnets? 52 grand!

Pam: I guess that's why, at the end, they're like, "Don't you want your cut?" and he's like, "Nah, I'll just blow it."

Joe: I was like, c'mon dude! At least take a little bit of it! That was a very elaborate scam you just pulled off. I guess it was just a revenge thing.

Jeremy: Totally revenge. Luther, to me—without knowing much of Robert Redford's character's background—the Luther character in the beginning was a real father figure toward him. And to see that happen, to see him get pushed out of a window like that... it was just the ultimate revenge.

Joe: You know how Luther is actually the father of?

Jeremy: That's James Earl Jones' dad, yeah.

Joe: Yup, Robert Earl Jones. Which is the only piece of trivia that I wrote down. [laughter]

Pam: The only piece of trivia that you found?

Joe: Nah, ya know, I always go on IMDB trivia, but there wasn't much else that was worth mentioning in this context.

Jeremy: I will say that, from a trivia standpoint, he's a main character—and I call him a main character, but I don't know the actor's name—but Kid Twist. You know the Kid Twist character?

Joe: Oh, the guy who pretended he worked for Western Union?

Jeremy: My favorite scene is when he gets off the train, and Paul Newman's in the station, and they give him that little swipe of the nose.



Jeremy: I love that. I so wish there was a way to incorporate that into my life in 2020.

Joe: Could you use it as a parenting thing, maybe?

Jeremy: Maybe. Just something.

Pam: You and Jenn can make that into a secret sign.

Jenn: You and Brian would do something like that.

Jeremy: Yeah, me and my friend Brian would definitely be in cahoots like that. But just the concept that there's these guys around the country, in the 30s, that somehow you can telegraph them—

Jenn: Right, because you're not text messaging, or sending emails.

Joe: I guess you have to know what bar to go to. "All these guys? They'll work in tandem with you to create this elaborate ruse."

Jeremy: Right, "Who's on the list?" when they're in the back room. "Oh, the Big Montana's in from New Orleans."

Joe: What did he say? "These guys, they have to be quill." That's some '30s lingo right there.

Jeremy: The other guy from the beginning, who acts as the mugger, and he gets his nose bashed in by the cop?

Joe: Yeah, um... the Erie Kid?

Jeremy: The Erie Kid. There's the scene where he and Kid Twist are talking, and he's like, "Luther Coleman was a friend of mine..." and he's kind of holding his nose. Kid Twist goes [snaps] "You got moxie, kid." [laughter] Love it. "Moxie" is a word that we don't use enough. Picture this guy coming off the train with a really nice suit, a fancy hat, and a cane.

Joe: Do you think that that was realistic, that all those people could come together to flawlessly pull off such an elaborate scheme?

Jeremy: [laughter] No. What's the saying about a secret? "You can keep a secret—one is good, two is too many." Literally dozens of guys. From the guy who actually lends out the equipment for the horse race—that's another great line, the guy is like, "What do we need?" and he's like, "Who's the mark?" "Oh, Doyle Lannegan. Do you want a cut or a flat rate?" And the guy's only main line is "Flat rate." [laughter] For one line in a movie to set up how impossible—just to move the plot forward enough for the audience to know how impossible this is going to be. "Flat rate." Classic.

Joe: This is the only time I'll mention it, because I dunno who's seen it, but have you ever seen the show Community?

Jeremy: Of course.

Joe: During the season on Yahoo Screen, there was a Sting episode. Did you ever see that one? "Grifting 101."

Jeremy: Man... I feel like this is a huge hole in my life. [To Jenn] Did your dad cancel Hulu yet?

Jenn: We have some time.

Joe: So they take a class called "Grifting 101," and they get grifted by the teacher [laughter], and they try to then grift the teacher, but no one knows how to pull it off. So they're like, "Let's watch The Sting." And it's a smash cut to two hours later, and they're all asleep, and were like, "That... was a terrible movie. But what did we learn from this?" and Jeff Winger's like "Well, all we have to do to pull off a grift is..." and he consults his notes, "...build a wire transfer studio and hire a hundred actors and have them all act in unison perfectly." [laughter] I thought of Pam, because Elroy is like, "That movies was terrible!" and they were like, "You were asleep the whole time!" [laughter]

Pam: I didn't say anything bad about The Sting! I was asleep because Willow woke me up at 2:30 and I had to sleep on the couch with her.

Jeremy: You know how there's certain movies where like—in certain circles, The Godfather III does not exist. The Godfather was over after Part I and Part II—

Pam: Well that's good, because I've never seen Part III.

Jeremy: I think that's a good thing. But they made The Sting II.

Joe: Good, yes, let's talk about it. Have you seen it?

Jeremy: No. It should not exist.

Joe: How so?

Jeremy: Well, Doyle Lonnegan's in it.

Joe: Oliver Reed plays Lonnegan.

Jeremy: Does he?

Joe: I only know that because I recognized him from talking about Gladiator, which is the movie Oliver Reed died during the filming of.

Jeremy: Really? Interesting. I only know him from The Sting II. But if you read the Rotten Tomato reviews, The Sting II is just...

Joe: It's actually at 0% on Rotten Tomatoes.

Pam: What? Really? How many movies are at 0%?

Joe: Right? It can't be that bad.

Jenn: It kind of makes me want to watch it. Is it like The Room?

Joe: I mean... I don't know how much you want to talk about The Sting II.

Jeremy: Not a lot.

Joe: I did read the Wikipedia article about it, and I thought it was interesting how the people who created it didn't want to call it a "sequel," but it pretty much was anyway? Like, instead of Johnny Hooker, it was "Jake Hooker." Instead of—Jackie Gleesen played Newman's character—so instead of Henry Gondorff, it was "Fargo Gondorff" or some shit like that.

Jeremy: Think about the end of the original movie. Henry Gondorff, his character is just done. That was the last big thing. He taught Robert Redford what he needed to know, to potentially move on and do other grifts around the country. But Paul Newman just wanted to be done. Him and the madame from the merry-go-round just rode off into the sunset.

Joe: You're right that it doesn't make sense to have a sequel to this. But it sounds like The Sting II actually was a sequel, despite the fact that it wasn't billed as a sequel. Lonnegan, he was played by a different actor, but the character was looking for revenge for getting his money stolen.

Jeremy: It's like Ocean's Twelve, how it was a revenge movie.

Joe: Was it? What, revenge for the Ocean's Eleven conclusion?

Jeremy: The character who got grifted in Ocean's Eleven ended up helping them grift someone else, the Al Pacino character.

Joe: Yeah, so... I don't think anyone will be saying that The Sting II is their favorite movie. Apparently, in a Simpsons episode, Grandpa Simpson is trying to do a grift, and he's like, "No one is going to know this one, because it's from The Sting II." [laughter]

Jeremy: Think about too, do you know the release date of The Sting? I know it was in the '70s.

Joe: '73.

Jeremy: So The Sting II, do you have that date?

Joe: I do not. It was probably the early '80s? [Editor's note: 1983.]

Jeremy: Right, so think about the time span between the early 1970s and the early 1980s. The culture changed.

Joe: Everyone was sick of Scott Joplin at that point, I guess. If we are still playing Your Favorite Movie Bingo, then we can also talk about the musical that is based on this movie.

Jeremy: Ah, see, you're pulling out deep cuts. I have no idea.

Joe: It was actually only performed at one place—The Papermill Playhouse, in Millburn, NJ. Which is apparently close to Manhattan. It's close enough to Manhattan that Harry Connick Jr. played Henry Gondorff.

Jeremy: That's brutual. [laughter]

Joe: Featuring such songs as "The Thrill of the Con," and "Don't Treat Your Friends like Marks"! [laughter]

Jeremy: [sighs] That's awful. In my opinion, there are certain things that just need to exist as an enjoyable entity by itself.

Joe: That's not how they world operates these days!

Pam: No, it's not.

Joe: If there is a product that can be resold, it will be resold as many times as possible.

Jeremy: It's like the bastardization of Star Wars. We could go down that rabbit hole.

Joe: We could, but we shouldn't.

Jeremy: People have strong opinions about that. I dunno. I like The Sting. It sits by itself. It's enjoyable. It's not anything that I need to watch on a daily basis, or a monthly basis. To put this in the context of today—and feel free to... this is all printable. My dad passed away in August.

Jenn: Your dad passed away in July.

Jeremy: Late July, early August. It was July 28th.

Joe: You were trying to get a gotchya moment over his dad's death?

Jenn: I'm just saying! If it's an important date, you should know it!

Jeremy: It's on my calendar. But no, this conversation, happening now... I do have special moments with my dad, those father/son moments, and this was one of them. It was awesome! A part of me watches the movie, a little bit of my enjoyment stems from the fact that I enjoyed it originally with my dad.

Joe: You said your dad liked the movie before you guys watched it together. Did he say why?

Jeremy: No, and that was the best part. He wasn't someone to explain himself. When it came on, he simply said, "This is a good movie." And at fifteen, that was a very strong opinion from my dad. He was never like "You need to listen to this music" or "You need to watch this movie."

Jenn: It's funny you say that, because my dad... you could make the best dinner in the world, and you'd ask him, "Did you like dinner?" and he'd be like, "It was okay." [laughter] And that meant it was good. Maybe generationally, not being very expressive. So saying "This is a good movie" means "This is the best movie."

Jeremy: Both my parents were the same way. My mom saw the Beatles at Shea Stadium in the '60s. She grew up on Long Island. She loved the Beatles, but not to the degree that I had Abbey Road memorized when I was six. For whatever reason that might be, they never imprinted a lot of their upbringing on me. So during those moments when my dad did say something simple like "This is a good movie," that was huge. And it sticks with me twenty years later. I think, as you guys grow up as parents, there are going to be these very simple moments in your life that just stick with you as a dad, and stick with you as a mom, stick with you forever.

Jenn: Or stick with their girls. A passing comment that you don't think is important—

Jeremy: I can't speak for the kids, but...

Jenn: We all have those things that you remember your parents saying or doing, that to them, it wasn't... it was just a normal moment. But we have the memory.

Joe: I guess if the argument is that your dad didn't have many of those pop culture moments that you could share with him. Had there been more of those moments, The Sting wouldn't have been as special.

Jeremy: That's exactly right.

Joe: But I feel like I'm going to be the type of dad that's going to be like, "Oh man, you should definitely check out this album." So that's going to be less special, is what you're arguing? Which is fine. I need to know this before it's too late.

Jeremy: It could! An example from my current life as a dad. Spotify is a thing that exists, and my daughter is really into Disney's Descendants. Do you know what that is?

Pam: I am aware of it, but Willow's too young.

Joe: The kids of the villains, right?

Jeremy: It's a musical—yes, Willow is definitely too young. My kids don't get bused to school, I have to drive them, so it's like a ten-to-fifteen-minute drive with them in the morning. "Dad, put on Descendants." There was one day when I just couldn't do it. Just couldn't do it. I had some satellite radio station on, and it was a live Rush song—

Joe: Right after Peart died, probably.

Jeremy: It could've been. It was live, so there was a Peart drum solo in it. I didn't say anything, I just kept it on. The drum solo starts, and they're both like, "Wow!" And I love Rush. That was one of the other bands I "discovered" with a friend. I was like, "Did you guys like that?" And they were like "Yeah!" So the next day, I Spotifyed....

Joe: "three hour Neil Peart drum solos"? [laughter]

Jeremy: No, just some of the classic Rush songs.

Joe: "Tom Sawyer"?

Jeremy: Yeah, I started with "Tom Sayer," and then went to, um...

Joe: That's all I got.

Jeremy: [sings the song] Another one of the classics. [Editor's note: no idea] And I explained to them a little bit about the band. I said to my son, "Remind me when we get home to show you a YouTube video of this drummer." I don't think you understand the full impact of Neil Peart unless you're seeing it. I showed them the video, and was like "Look, he has drum all around him. And now they're moving!" Their jaws dropped. And I say all that to make my point that—I might never play another Rush song for those kids again. But maybe that sticks with them?

Pam: It probably will.

Jeremy: That'd be pretty cool, in my opinion. Let them become their own people, their own human beings, without forcing them too much into what my life was. That's the big thing as a parent, right? I don't know if I'll ever sit [my kids] down and force them to watch The Sting because I watch The Sting. That's not the way to raise your kids. They have to have their own experiences. It's organic. The way your two girls are going to grow up is going to surprise you in fun ways, but you'll never expect it.

Joe: But would you be comfortable with, say you're at [your son's] 21st birthday, and someone mentions The Sting, and he says, "What's that?"?

Jeremy: Yeah, absolutely.

Joe: Okay. I admire that, because I don't know if I—

Pam: You would not be okay with it?

Jenn: That you played something before for them, but they don't remember it?

Joe: Yeah. I think I'd even prefer them to be like, "Oh yeah, I know that band. They fucking suck ass, but my dad did play them for me." I dunno.

Pam: I'd be okay with them not knowing.

Joe: But I'm saying that I admire the willingness to hold back and let them explore it on their own.

Jeremy: I think you have to. To me as a parent, your kids have to figure things out for themselves. Whether that's letting them fail in a controlled environment... I mean, sometimes they are going to fall down and bonk their heads, and you'll be there as parents to pick them up and tell them they are okay.

Joe: Sometimes they are going to get pigeon dropped, and you'll be there to replace the five grand that they lost.

Pam: The difference between me and Joe is this. Now that Willow has preferences for things—I'll say "What do you want to listen to?" and she'll say "Baby!" I know she's talking about "Baby Shark." So I'll put that on. I hate "Baby Shark." I hate it! But I'll put it on, because that's what she wants to listen to. Joe says "What do you want to listen to?" and she says "Baby!" and he's like, "Nope, what do I want to listen to?" [laughter]

Joe: But I've been asking her her entire life, since she was a day old, whenever I go up to the iPod, just to talk out loud, ya know? And now all of a sudden she's telling me an answer I don't want to hear. So I'm like, "...fuck that."

Jeremy: There's a light at the end of the tunnel.

Pam: She's not going to like "Baby Shark" forever.

Jeremy: God help you if she does...

Joe: So eventually, instead of picking Olaf's Frozen Adventure for the 237th night in a row, she's going to say "Let's watch The Sting."

Jeremy: "I heard this Robert Redford guy's got something going on." [laughter] But yeah, let's get back to the movie. The other big thing that I think you [Jenn] really enjoyed, or had a question about, was the female character that Robert Redford falls for.

Joe: Loretta.

Jeremy: But we don't know anything about her.

Joe: That was a pretty good twist. That was one of the things that they held back from the audience.

Jeremy: The guy who was allegedly hunting Robert Redford was actually there to protect him. I don't know how much spoiler alerts we need for this.

Joe: I feel like people don't read these interviews if they haven't seen the movie anyway.

Jeremy: The Sting is one of those movies where I'd hate to spoil it.

Joe: The entire joy of the movie is to get to the end and have this elaborate complex grift collapse in on itself, and everything pulls together perfectly. So good.

Jenn: We were talking about plot holes in the movie. To me, that waitress is a hole in the movie. I dunno. Like, how did she get placed in this restaurant, know that he would be going to this same restaurant, and wanting to fall for her? Ya know what I mean?

Joe: It was explained away because she was called a "professional."

Jeremy: She was "the best." And "the best" knows where to be and how to be.

Pam: I guess that's all you have to say? [laughter] Movie magic!

Jeremy: Looking at the cast list, you know who else I really love? His character name was J.J.

Joe: Oh yeah, the dude from Rocky. Mick!

Pam: Did you actually look that up?

Jeremy: No, that wasn't him. [laughter] Burgess Meredith was Mick.

Pam: I don't think you can have the voice of J.J. and also the voice of Mick. [laughter]

Joe: Okay, then what's J.J. from?

Jeremy: I think the thing that most people would recognize him from is a show called My Favorite Martian. [Editor's note: His name is Ray Walston.]

Joe: I saw that on his Wikipedia page, but I didn't recognize that one. I just thought he was Mick.

Jeremy: My Favorite Martian was this show that was like, he was a stranded martian on Earth.

Pam: Was that '80s or '90s?

Jeremy: [reading off phone] 1963 to 1966.

Pam: Oh wow. The '60s.

Jeremy: Oh, and he was Spicolli's teacher in Fast Times at Ridgemont High!

Joe: I'm so tired of talking about that fucking movie! I feel like every interview this comes up.

Jeremy: Does it really? That movie—

Joe: We're not talking about it. Fuck.

Jeremy: I have no strong feelings about it either way. Clearly you hate it.

Pam: He hates it.

Joe: If you're still playing Bingo, dear reader, you can now cross off the "Fast Times" space. Does anyone have "Bingo" yet?

Pam: Oh Mr. Hand. [laughter]

Joe: Do you feel like this movie—and Pam is probably going to roll her eyes—

Pam: Oh god. I know what's coming. Go ahead.

Joe: Does the movie feel topical? In that the movie the villain might seem like... a villain in America right now...?

Jeremy: The money-hungry mobster?

Joe: A money-hungry cheater, yeah.

Jeremy: Eh...

Joe: Or is that a stretch?

Jeremy: I think that might be a stretch. Just because I think there's something to be said about being part of the Mob, and being part of this villainous group.

Joe: Did they say the word "Mob" though?

Jeremy: I think they did. They talk about "numbers runner" for Doyle Lonnegan.

Jenn: I don't think they ever said the word "Mob" specifically.

Joe: But when you're looking at the character traits of Doyle Lonnegan, the first one isn't "Mob." The first one is "cheater." "Money-hungry."

Jeremy: "Businessman." "Finance." Yeah. He uses his financial career to hide his nefarious gambling earnings, and whatever else he was into.

Joe: So...

Jeremy: He'd be the 1% now, right?

Joe: He's a little trump-ish, I would say.

Jeremy: I like Doyle Lonnagen more. I'd hate to degrade him like that. [laughter]

Joe: I guess that leads to the question... I assume that a lot of boomers who voted for trump would also be watching The Sting and rooting against Doyle Lonnegan. My question is, what kind of person would root for Doyle Lonnegan? Or like, what type of person would watch The Sting and think, "He's right"? [laughter] Maybe this is also a leading question. I'll ask, is there such a person?

Jeremy: I hope not. There probably is!

Jenn: Joe's point is that those same people are going to be pro-trump. How can you be so obviously against one, but so pro the other?

Joe: I think it more speaks to my confusion as to how people could like trump. I would be confused as to how someone could root for Doyle Lonnegan, but I don't think people do. And I would be confused—and I was, and I have been for three years now—how people could root for donald trump. And they do! So...

Jeremy: I mean, here you have this candidate in Bernie, basically offering free health care, and free college education, and people are like "No! That's awful!"

Joe: Right? And then those same people could watch a movie like The Sting, which has these guys who are, ya know, not legally taxing Doyle Lonnnegan, but stealing his money, and they are the good guys!

Jeremy: It's a whole Robin Hood scenario. Bernie wants to take from the rich to give to the poor.

Joe: Did you ever think about The Sting from a moral perspective?

Jeremy: 100%.

Joe: I feel like I get into these types of discussions in these interviews a lot, and I have sometimes felt like I was trying to come off like I was on a moral pedestal. I'm not... if we are going to examine whether grifting is unethical, I don't want it to seem like I am judging Henry or Johnny.

Pam: [sarcastically] Ya know, isn't he kind of doing the same thing Jordan Belfort did in Wolf of Wall Street? [laughter]

Joe: Right! Pam speaks to my point—

Pam: Did you read that interview? When Joe freaked out?

Joe: I did, but only because when you watch Wolf of Wall Street, it's not made clear...

Jeremy: It's a tragedy.

Joe: And maybe that's the issue, that Wolf of Wall Street made it seem like he was the hero protagonist. I took offense to that, because he was a criminal. But at the same time, watching The Sting... it's a very fanciful and elaborate, but still criminal act, that Henry and Johnny took part in. And I didn't have the same issues that I had with Wolf of Wall Street, or other movies that I've had this same type of argument about. So where are you coming from, in terms of the moral aspects of this?

Jeremy: I think every movie has a time and a place. Whether it's Robin Hood robbing from the rich and giving to the poor in Medieval England, or this movie, where it's 1936, it's the Depression, people were out of work, it was hard to make a living.

Joe: You were expecting people to do the pigeon drop, and that was okay because of the Depression?

Jeremy: Luther Coleman was a family man. He had a wife and kids. Grifting was just what he knew how to do. As a black man in 1930s America, what other opportunities did he have? Johnny Hooker didn't seem like the type to want honest work. I guess in the 1930s, that was okay. I think maybe you could make an argument that it was crummy of them to grift strangers, and the whole movie hinges on the fact that it was an accident that they pulled a grift on a guy that was connected.

Joe: So that adds into it too, that the people they were grifting were worse people.

Jeremy: They were purposefully targeting worse people.

Joe: Originally.

Jeremy: Yeah.

Joe: And then it turns into "We're gonna grift this murderer."

Jeremy: Because that's what Doyle was, a murderer. He put a hit out on all three of them.

Joe: It was definitely just something interesting to think about, how we rooted for these guys.

Jeremy: I mean, what do you think about the Robin Hood aspect of it?

Joe: Well, Robin Hood was stealing from the rich to give to the poor—which is definitely a Bernie Sanders type thing—whereas these guys were—

Jenn: Keeping it for themselves.

Joe: They were robbing the richer to get more rich. And to revenge a death.

Jeremy: I like to think that Johnny Hooker gave his cut to Luther Coleman's family.

Joe: That would've made more sense than "I don't want that money."

Jeremy: Even just a one-liner.

Joe: Can you think of a time in your life when you tried to grift someone?

Jeremy: Actually, I can think of something. When I was in college, I was in a fraternity, and I was in charge of throwing the parties. We needed to make money to keep going. It wasn't that I needed to buy fancy clothes or cars, it was that we needed money to throw the next party. So I would purposefully buy the cheapest vodka you could find, and mix it with cranberry juice in bulk—because cranberry juice isn't sweet—and then pour off little shots for a dollar. So maybe twenty dollars for two handles of vodka and two things of cranberry juice, mixed in an igloo container, and sell shots for a dollar. People would be like "Oh god, this is so strong!" when in reality, it was the cranberry juice being so tart that they were getting "buzzed" from it.

Jenn: But you didn't lie about what it was.

Jeremy: I never lied about what it was, but I never said anything when someone claimed it was "strong." I kept my lips zipped regarding that.

Jenn: I think that if that's all you can think of, then... you're a good person. [laughter]

Joe: That's probably closer to grifting than the examples I could think of in my own life.

Pam: It's just the same thing a bar would do.

Jeremy: Exactly.

Joe: So it's expected? That's just capitalism, I guess?

Pam: Yeah.

Joe: Could anyone else think of any grifting they've done?

Jeremy: Anything you want to put on the record too. [laughter] No, I treat others the way I want to be treated, so I don't... I try really hard not to be a grifter.

Jenn: [laughter] "I try so hard not to be a grifter!"

Joe: "Sometimes I take eleven grand from the mob!" The closest thing I could think of was, one time in my youth, we went to Wawa at the end of the night, and I had a highlighter in my pocket, and I went outside to "take a smoke" and marked the receipt with the highlighter.

Pam: You didn't pay for your sandwich?! What a grift! [laughter]

Joe: I was thinking about sneaking beer into the dorms, but that was more smuggling than grifting.

Jeremy: More of a Han Solo than a Johnny Hooker.

Joe: There was one time at a strip club, the stripper was like, "You have to give me more than a dollar if you're going to keep talking to me." The dollar that I had originally put in her g-string had fell onto the floor, so I just picked the dollar up and put it back in her g-string, acting like it was a second dollar.

Jeremy: I mean, strippers are the modern con-women, right?

Jenn: Yeah, they're grifting. [laughter]

Joe: So we can agree that... grifting is bad... [laughter] But I just found it so interesting that we can all agree on that, and then root for the grifters.

Jenn: Here's a question. If you had an opportunity to steal from a bad person, and not get caught for it, knowing that it could better your life—and again, no repercussions—are you going to do it?

Joe: Fuck yeah.

Pam: Absolutely.

Joe: So you're saying that it depends on who the victim is.

Jeremy: Context matters, yeah.

Pam: If they can afford to lose that money, then it's not going to hurt them.

Jeremy: Or if someone earned that money through cheating, or screwing up the environment... I dunno, I'm a big proponent of just making sure that people—I forget who said it, a comedian?—you don't look in the bowl of the person next to you to see if they got more food than you, you just look in their bowl to make sure they got enough. At the end of the day, I think that's what the problem is. There are too many people without enough basic coverage of their daily needs. In health care, in clothing, in shelter. It's not the right thing to be doing.

Joe: You're speaking my socialist language, man. [laughter]

Jeremy: It's not hard to figure out universal health care, in my opinion. Maybe you have a different opinion as a nurse—

Pam: No, I'm in favor of universal health care.

Jeremy: How is it that every other country can figure it out? Things I've heard is "Well, there's less people in Finland, and that's how they're able to do it." There's gotta be a way to figure it out. There has to be.

Joe: There is.

Jeremy: And it might not be perfect, especially right away.

Pam: What it is now is certainly not perfect.

Joe: Right. With the type of insurance people have now, how can you be so naive as to be against universal health care? How does America have so many fucking people who are against universal health care?

Jeremy: Or the people who argue against universal health care, but are on welfare at the same time. They get government benefits, but they somehow are able to disconnect—

Jenn: It's the same people who were like, "Obamacare is trash! I'm on the Affordable Care Act!" Like, "You know that's Obamacare, right?"

Jeremy: I have a really hard time biting my tongue when people throw their own religion out there, as a reason to be "Christian," and yet... I've said this to people. If Jesus Christ came back, in the year 2020, and took a look around, can you imagine the hell that he would raise? There's that story in the Bible, when the moneylenders were lending money in the temple, and he knocked down all their stuff. I'm not a great Catholic, but—

Pam: This is right in my Jesus Christ Superstar wheelhouse.

Joe: There's a Jew traveling around the country talking about health care and basic necessities right now, and his name is Bernie Sanders!

Pam: You're a Bernie Bro, aren't you?

Joe: What?! Do you even know what that means?

Pam: Brian M******* is a Bernie Bro.

Joe: A "Bernie Bro" is when you support Bernie Sanders and you make fun of anyone who supports any other candidate. I don't do that.

Pam: Brian doesn't do that.

Joe: Yes he does, he talks shit on Elizabeth Warren on Twitter all the time!

Pam: Alright.

Joe: Okay... we're going to far down the rabbit hole. [laughter] Unless we can connect Bernie Sanders to The Sting, I think we need to circle back. Okay, the previous interviewee has written down her question.

Pam: Who was it?

Joe: Meri, and we talked about A Love Song for Bobby Long. Have you seen that one?

Jeremy: I have not seen that one.

Joe: Drunk John Travolta. It was fine. She asks: "How does this compare to Butch Cassidy?" I have never seen Butch Cassidy [and the Sundance Kid].

Jeremy: I've never seen it either.

Joe: I know that it was the same team of Redford and Newman.

Jeremy: Yup. Did it come out before?

Joe: Oh, and it was the same director too, George Roy Hill. It was 1969.

Jenn: Maybe we should watch it.

Jeremy: As much as my movie knowledge is moderately extensive, there are some classics that I just never bothered to get into.

Joe: You're preaching to the choir, man. I've never seen any of this shit.

Jeremy: Westerns is a whole genre that I never felt excited about, I never got into. Outside of Blazing Saddles, I can't tell you... although—and again, this might be tangential, and really just because my dad liked the movie—Jeremiah Johnson, another Robert Redford movie, about a man going into the woods and living among the land. Not a "cowboy movie" per se, but a really stoic film about pulling yourself up by your bootstraps.

Joe: Yeah, that... it's times like these where I feel like I'm the worst fucking person to be conducting these interviews, because I don't really watch movies like that.

Pam: But that's why you're doing this.

Joe: True. I just wish I could speak to... this is the only Robert Redford movie I've ever seen, for sure.

Pam: No, you've seen The Way We Were.

Joe: That's right. And we can talk about that. That actually is connected to this movie a little bit. Talk about The Way We Were, Pam.

Pam: Have you guys seen it?

Jeremy: No.

Pam: It's Robert Redford and Barbara Streisand. And they're dating, they date for several year, but they're incompatible. He's a jock, she's really politically active, and really smart. Basically, it boils down to that she's too much of a complex woman for him. They talk about it in Sex in the City. Have you seen that? They talk about it with Big and the woman he's going to marry. What was her name?

Jenn: Natasha.

Pam: Natasha. I think that's what they talk about. They say that Carrie is like the Barbara Streisand character, she's the complex one.

Jenn: Oh, the Hubbell comment!

Pam: Yeah! At the very end, Barbara Streisand sees him with his new wife, and she's this beautiful blonde, probably more... simple? And she goes, "your girl's beautiful, Hubbell." That's all conveyed in Sex in the City.

Joe: This is all stuff that I would normally cut with pleasure from a normal interview, but this is important context—

Pam: [mumbles] Sorry...

Joe: —because Marvin Hamlisch wrote the score—well, he adapted the score for The Sting. Adapted it from Scott Joplin, and his whole ragtime thing.

Jeremy: Marvin Hamlisch is no slacker.

Joe: So he won the Oscar for Best Original Score for The Sting, the same year he won Best Original Song, for the title track to The Way We Were. Starring the same person, Robert Redford, who also apparently had a busy year that year.

Jeremy: That was the name of the song and the movie, yeah! I know that song, but I don't know the movie.

Joe: That song hit number one on the Billboard charts.

Jeremy: Really?

Pam: It's so slow.

Joe: "The Entertainer" by Marvin Hamlisch hit number three.

Jeremy: At the same time?

Joe: Around the same time. "The Entertainer" actually peaked at number three behind a number one song called "The Streak." Are you familiar with that? It sounds like something Larry the Cable Guy would do. It's literally about people getting naked and running around. And it was based on... so, at the 1974 Oscars, Elizabeth Taylor was being introduced to announce the Best Picture winner, eventually announced as The Sting. But the host was introducing Taylor, and some asshole ran behind him naked. [Editor's note: And I may have overstated the connection by just a hair. In his The Number Ones column, Tom Breihan writes that the song came out five days before the Oscars, but that it was the Oscars incident that propelled the song to number one, rather than inspiring the song in the first place.]

Pam: At the Oscars! Can you imagine if that happened now? That would never happen now. So much security.

Jeremy: They would see that person coming from a mile away.

Joe: So Mark Hamlisch saw the penis of the guy who inspired the number one song that blocked him on the Billboard charts. Mark Hamlisch is one of two people who has ever won a PEGOT!

Pam: What does the P stand for?

Jeremy: Pulitzer.

Pam: One of two? Who was the other one?

Joe: Another composer. I didn't recognize him. [Editor's note: Richard Rodgers. I should also note here that some people consider the "P" in "PEGOT" to be a Peabody Award, and if that's the case, than the three PEGOT winners are Barbra Streisand, Mike Nichols, and Rita Moreno.]

Pam: Not John Legend?

Jenn: He's EGOT.

Jeremy: He's young enough to come out with something.

Joe: All Lin-Manuel needs is an Oscar to get that PEGOT.

Jenn: He can get that.

Jeremy: What's his Pulitzer?

Pam: I think it had to do with Hamilton. He also wrote the music for Moana. He was nominated.

Joe: He was expected to win for that. What beat him? It was probably Frozen.

Pam: No, they weren't out at the same time. [Editor's note: It was La La Land's "City of Stars"]

Jeremy: Lin-Manuel's got that movie coming out this year.

Pam: In the Heights?

Joe: Would that be eligible?

Pam: Certainly. It's based on his musical.

Joe: I wasn't sure if it would be an "original" song, since it's based on a song he already wrote.

Pam: Oh, I don't know. It could be Best Adapted Song.

Joe: I don't think they have Best Adapted Song.

Jeremy: Lin-Manuel has to win an Oscar.

Pam: He's going to.

Joe: Nah, fuck him.

Pam: What?!

Joe: But let's keep talking about the Oscars. Out of the 32 movies I've talked about so far, it's only the fourth that's won Best Picture. [Editor's note: The Godfather Part II, The Silence of the Lambs, and Gladiator.] Which is big! It beat two movies I've heard of, and two movies I haven't. It beat American Graffiti and The Exorcist, and then Cries and Whispers? And A Touch of Class?

Jeremy: Nope, I have nothing on either of those.

Joe: It was a pretty much a Swedish Romance, and a British Romance, I think.

Jeremy: I mean, American Graffiti is a pretty decent movie.

Joe: Yeah, it is. George Lucas lost to George Roy Hill for Best Director that same year. It stars Richie Cunningham, right?

Jeremy: It's like a more cinematic version of Dazed and Confused.

Joe: That's a bad way to describe it! It's a more primitive version of Dazed and Confused.

Jeremy: I think it was more eloquent.

Joe: Eloquent? Get the fuck out of here. Oh my god.

Pam: Dazed and Confused had no plot! We talked about this!

Joe: Are we saying American Graffiti had a plot?!

Jeremy: Not at all. Don't mistake me at all—if you forced me to pick a second movie for this, it would be Dazed and Confused. If there is a movie that I can quote more than any other, it's Dazed and Confused. Especially Matthew McConaughey.

Joe: Let's see... it was Best Original Screenplay. Best Score, we talked about. Best Costumes, Art Direction, Film Editing. It only lost three out of the ten it was nominated for. It lost Best Actor. Jack Lemmon in Save the Tiger, a movie that Marvin Hamlisch also scored.

Pam: Jeez.

Jeremy: I told you, Marvin Hamlisch is no joke.

Joe: It lost Best Sound to The Exorcist. Can't beat the screams, I guess. "The power of Christ compels you!"

Pam: Ugh, I can't. I'm going to have nightmares tonight.

Joe: And lost in Cinematography. So overall, big year for The Sting!

Jeremy: Think about 1974, you're putting out a movie that's based in the '30s, and no one is the same. Kid Twist is dressed differently than Kid Erie, and Robert Redford... I don't think a lot of people think about that when they go into a movie theater, but period pieces—

Jenn: I was going to say, period pieces usually do win Best Costumes and stuff, because it's so...

Pam: Obvious.

Jenn: Yeah. You can't just go to the store and buy...

Jeremy: A zoot suit.

Joe: It tried to look like a 1930s movie, despite being made in the '70s. What was the most 1930s aspect of it, in your opinion?

Jeremy: Oh man, the cars! That sticks out to me constantly in movies, in any period piece. Growing up, my mother—this is a tangent, but it's one of my favorite stories—when I was born, my mom had this car that she had bought brand new in 1973. It was a 1973 Chevy Impala. It's the biggest boat of a car you've ever seen. It's massive. And she drove that '73 Impala until 1993. In '93, they bought a Dodge Grand Caravan, that she drove from '93 until... they got rid of it in 2019. It might not have gotten a lot of use toward the end, but that minivan lasted forever.

Jenn: But the reason cars are so loved is because they remodeled cars every year. You could take an Impala from '73, and it would look different than the '74, it would look different than the '75. You take a Honda Accord—"Uh, that looks like an early 2000s Honda Accord, but I can't tell if it's a 2002 or a 2003..."

Jeremy: That's where my head's at. You picture this 1973 car that's still drivable in 1997, when I'm learning to drive. I drove this car because my dad was like, "This could be your car." It didn't have power steering.

Jenn: "Dad, I literally can't pass a driver's test in this car." [laughter]

Jeremy: It had very little rust. It was a great car. 1973, because of the oil embargo, it was too late in the game to be a "classic car." So no one is really collecting it. My mom's dream was to sell that 1973 Impala to Hollywood, to be used in a period piece.

Joe: In The Sting III!

Jeremy: Right? I think about this all the time. You're setting a movie in the '80s, and all these cars are straight-up '80s cars. Stranger Things—the fact that they can constantly pull out these '80s vehicles that are in pristine condition, and drivable? It might be movie magic. It might be a Honda Civic engine in a Chrysler Barron Convertible. But the point is my mom had this vehicle that she dreamed of donating or selling to Hollywood.

Jenn: "Make it to the big screen."

Jeremy: She wrote to Hollywood—

Jenn: "Dear Hollywood."

Joe: "Dear Mr. Hollywood."

Jenn: "Please buy my car."

Jeremy: Because of my mother, and that tiny little desire of hers, it always lead me to look at certain parts of movies, like the cars that were being driven. And full circle here—you're talking about a 1973 movie driving 1930s period cars. And I don't know enough about cars to know if it was a 1940 Packard in a 1936 movie, but that's pretty cool to me, that Hollywood can pull that off.

Jenn: Tie it back to technology. They can't just google on the internet to see who's selling cars from the 1930s, or contact dealerships and be like, "Hey, we want this for a movie." How do you even find them?

Pam: I feel like it's collectors. Jerry Seinfeld, for example. From watching his Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee, he has so many cars.

Joe: [Seinfeld impression] "What's the deal with grifters?"

Jenn: It has to be word of mouth, a network that can find you the cars that you need.

Joe: I personally thought that the most 1930s aspect of it was how empty everything felt. I tried to look it up. Apparently George Roy Hill watched a bunch of '30s movies, and found that there were barely any extras in these movies.

Pam: No one ever walking around in the street, I noticed that too. It felt like they were under the El at Kensington, except they painted it, and nobody was there.

Jenn: That's a good point. That's not realistic, that in a city, in any daytime setting, that there would be no one on the street. No passersby?

Joe: When someone gets shot in the face?

Pam: That blood was practically pink.

Joe: Do we feel like Robert Redford should've won the Oscar for Best Actor?

Jeremy: It's hard to say who he was up against that year.

Joe: He lost to Jack Lemmon. I've only seen him in that one movie—

Jeremy: Grumpy Old Men?

Joe: No.

Pam: Glengarry Glen Ross?

Joe: Yup, that's the one! It's a badass movie.

Jenn: What's the one when they're on a jury? Twelve Angry Men?

Jeremy: Good call!

Jenn: I've seen a movie!

Pam: I was just at jury duty last week.

Joe: Twelve Angry Pams.

Pam: Wait, Robert Redford wasn't also nominated for The Way We Were, right?

Joe: Nope. But he was eligible for a nomination that year. I actually didn't really know anything about Robert Redford or Paul Newman prior to this, besides the salsa.

Jeremy: And the salad dressing!

Joe: I was distraught to see—sorry, Pam's going to roll her eyes again—in the lead up to the 2016 presidential election, when trump released his book, Crippled America, Robert Redford was quoted on the back of it.

Pam: This was before he was running for president?

Joe: This was while he was running for president. It was his "I'm a nominee" book, with a ghostwriter and shit. "America needs a shakeup" he was quoted in saying on the back. I looked into it. 2020 Robert Redford hates trump. 2016 Robert Redford was all about "give him a chance." Robert Redford also is very into environmental issues, and trump is very into dismantling environmental laws and agencies.

Jenn: He doesn't believe in global warming...

Jeremy: I gotta say, the only other Robert Redford movie I can confidently say I saw was A Walk in the Wilderness. Which was a two-year-old movie with Redford and another famous actor. It's a movie based on a book about a guy who decided to hike the Appalachian Trail at a really old age.

Pam: I wonder if Robert Redford—have you guys seen Watchmen? If you haven't, maybe I shouldn't say anything.

Joe: That's right, he's the president in that.

Pam: But he's not actually in the show. I wonder if they had to ask him "Is it okay if we make you the president in this?"

Jenn: He's referred to as the president?

Jeremy: The actor Robert Redford is the president in this alternate universe.

Jenn: I mean, stranger things have happened. If trump can be president...

Jeremy: Ronald Reagan, if you remember, was a pretty serious actor before he became president.

Jenn: You ask me to remember as if I was around. [laughter]

Jeremy: Sometimes I forget.

Joe: I didn't know that Robert Redford was the founder of the Sundance Film Festival. So he's known as the "Godfather of Indie Film." How about Paul Newman? We all know him from his most famous role... Cars.

Pam: He's a voice in Cars? I didn't know that.

Joe: He was in Cars 3 as well. That was after he died.

Pam: So it's like Don Rickles. Man... Disney. They are pillaging dead people's voices for characters!

Jeremy: To Paul Newman's credit... we joke about seeing his face on salsa and salad dressing, but that Newman's Own company, he started that way before it was fashionable to start a GMO-free, gluten-free, any of the buzzwords we hear today, and 100% of proceeds go to charity. I dunno, I think that's pretty badass, when you have that much money.

Pam: And that's been around forever, Newman's Own.

Joe: If only he could figure out how to, in one shot, sell $500,000 worth of salad dressing... without... someone knowing. [no laughter] We're barreling toward a conclusion here.

Jeremy: I think movies are all about a time and a place. It's hard to replicate that. It has to be organic. If it's not organic, it's not going to stick. You can't have any expectations that your kids or your significant other is going to love a movie as much as you do. It has to happen by itself.

Pam: I feel like most of the movies you've talked about, with very few exceptions, people have been like, "It's my favorite movie because I grew up watching it. I watched it in this environment." So it's never going to mean the same thing to other people.

Joe: What does that say about us as humans, that we appreciate things more in the context of our relationships?

Jeremy: I think it speaks to the fact that we're constantly looking for unique experiences, but also experiences that connect us. There's something to be said for—even something silly like reality television. You're all watching Survivor together, and you need to watch it live. Or everyone watching Lost together—you couldn't DVR lost, because if you went to school or the office the next day, and people were talking about Lost, you were out of the loop, were out of the tribe, you were out of the conversation. Certain things are a time and a place because it happens organically, and other things are timely and important because it brings us all together. Even silly stuff like The Masked Singer.

Pam: Oh, I love The Masked Singer!

[Editor's note: I can't believe I'm ending this transcription by cutting a long conversation about the fucking Masked Singer.]

No comments: