Tuesday, November 24, 2020

The Albums That Matter: Blackstar

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Blackstar
David Bowie
2016

He is known as the Shadow Man. There's a reason for that. He is a man with many personas, but all of them seem impenetrable and inscrutable to me. They always have. To say I don't "get" David Bowie might be an understatement. It's frustrating as fuck because everyone else is out there having a great time with the guy, singing Portuguese covers and hanging out at art exhibits and I'm over here wondering how the fuck anyone could appreciate the wacky back half of "Heroes". 

On the morning of January 8, 2016, I listened to Blackstar on the way to work, and for the next 48 hours, it felt like I finally GOT IT. So let's talk about that feeling for a little bit, and why I felt it. 
 
I think the short answer is that David Bowie's enigmatic musical stylings blended really, really, really well with the absolutely batshit freeform jazz that takes up the bulk of Blackstar. It's a genre of music that I understand even less than I do Bowie, and yet here they were, mixed together, and it just made sense to me, even though I can't really explain why. 

You can tell I don't know anything about jazz because I used the word "freeform" above, but the more I think about it, I wouldn't consider this type of jazz freeform. It might even be the opposite—the form here is rock solid. The rhythm section—Tim Lefebvre on bass and Mark Guiliana on drums—are so busy all over these tracks, and yet are still able to hold the whole thing in place. Meanwhile, Donny McCaslin is playing sax like a fucking wild man. I have never heard or even heard of any of these guys, but they make this album what it is. 

Well, Bowie does too. I don't want to give all the credit away. There are moments when Bowie feels like he's in a completely different universe and he's bringing me along for the ride—those "Woo!"s on "'Tis a Pity She Was a Whore" are a thrill every time—which is a feeling that everyone claims they have had with Bowie but I had never experienced before. There are other moments when Bowie feels like the same old kook whom I've always known and never really understood—talking gibberish (sorry, Nadsat, ugh) on "Girl Loves Me," dropping his phone in the toilet and looking for "ass" on "Lazarus"—moments that still work, but only because they are against the backdrop of jazz so wild that I can't even remember Miles Davis' name half the time.

I talked a lot about Bowie that weekend with friends and family, because I was excited! It had felt like I was finally given the key to this vast city of knowledge that had been previous obscured from my view. The David Bowie! 68 years old and with a new album! An album that made sense to me! One that I already loved! On Saturday night, I was chilling with Dave, and we talked about it. On Sunday, I was with my in-laws, happy to discuss music from an artist they had actually heard of.

By Monday morning, David Bowie was dead.

The spectre of death already rested comfortably over Blackstar as a whole, so of course an actual death of the actual artist is going to change the narrative. It was no longer a late-career gem, but instead a straight-up swan song. The skronking of the saxophone was no longer Bowie's life force, it was now a funeral pyre. Lines like "Something happened on the day he died..." from the title track were all of a sudden seen as prophetic. I've written before about albums that take on a new meaning when their creators pass away, but this all took the idea to the extreme.

It affected my own personal relationship with the album for sure. I think it I had a gun to my head, I would choose Blackstar as my favorite Bowie album (that I'm familiar with so far), but that's a really uncomfortable opinion to have now that this is the album that Bowie released 48 hours before dying, and I don't try to spread it around too often. It would be like saying that your favorite memory of your friend was the day you saw them in a casket at their funeral. Even if it's perversely true, then that means your relationship with that person was fucked up when you were both alive, and so why are you even at the funeral at the first place?

So I try to pay my respects to one of the only versions of Bowie I know and love by listening to Blackstar every once in a while, and then shutting the fuck up about it. And I'm still out there, trying to figure out who this man was when he was still making music. What is it about the Shadow Man that draws people to him? And what am I missing?

There's still so much to examine in this discography. But I have faith that eventually, I'll find some late career deep cut that is going to resemble Blackstar in some way, and I'll be able to at least tether some appreciation to a part of Bowie's legacy that isn't so macabre.

~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, then try this song: "Sue (or in a Season of Crime)"


~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • I went back and read a few reviews of Blackstar from when it first came out, to see how weirdly they read before Bowie passed away, and holy shit, I completely forgot that this is how the Pitchfork review started: "David Bowie has died many deaths yet he is still with us." I wonder if the writer of that review ever wonders if he murdered David Bowie.
  • I linked to the Life Aquatic interview above, and I'll link to the Prestige interview as well, since I discuss a little Bowie in each. I made it clear in those interviews, and I'll underline the point here—I don't think Bowie is a bad musician. I think he's really good, and I enjoy a lot of his music. I just have an issue with the fact that the general consensus is that he is an unimpeachable genius, and from what I've heard so far, I cannot imagine how we arrived there.
  • ALBUM COVER: Jonathan Barnbrook is the artist on this one, as well as all four of Bowie's final albums. However, the art is credited to "NASA," for reasons that are both obvious and mysterious. Also, fun fact, it took me until right this second to understand that the star fragments below the big star are supposed to spell out "BOWIE."
  • ALBUM NAME: It is unknown if this is why Bowie named it this, but apparently a "black star lesion" is a term for a type of lesion related to cancer, which Bowie died of. Death is sincerely all around you when you're listening to this album.
  • Oh, also, the official title of this album is not "Blackstar," but instead a literal picture of a star, like an emoji. I don't abide by that. I am all about fidelity when it comes to tagging artist names, album names, etc., but I have my limits. 
  • CHARTS: Blackstar hit #1 on the Billboard 200 on 1/30/16. Shit, when was the last time an album in this column hit #1? Fucking ever? I know it was fueled by his death, but still. Better yet: It beat out the milquetoast snoozefest of Adele's 25. Interestingly, Bowie's greatest hits collection was #4 this week as well. I guess the rest of the American public can't agree on what constitutes a good Bowie album either.
  • PREVIOUSLY ON PoYB: I had ranked Blackstar the #5 best album of 2016, which, I dunno, seems a little high? But looking at the rest of the list, I could see it maybe dropping to #6 or #7 at worst. "'Tis a Pity She Was a Whore" was #11 on the 2016 songs list, and got an Honorable Mention in the decades countdown.
  • I've gone back and forth as to whether I should be uncomfortable with the subject matter on "'Tis a Pity," or at least the title, but I think at this point I agree with Stereogum's Tom Breihan, who describes it as "a song that doesn’t even qualify as problematic because who in the fuck even knows what it’s about."
  • Bowie indicated that Kendrick Lamar's To Pimp a Butterfly was a big inspiration for the music on Blackstar. Sure, they both feature some pretty bugged-out jazz theatrics, but the two albums feel opposite to me in ways that I might have trouble articulating. To attempt—the jazz on Blackstar is essential to its being, as they are one in the same; the jazz on TPaB exists more like a hurdle for Kendrick to clear as he achieves his goals.
  • More trivia regarding other musicians besides Bowie: I just read a couple weeks ago the Stereogum interview with Win Butler, who drops a pretty interesting Bowie/Blackstar-related anecdote. Ctrl+F that shit.
  • I keep getting stuck on the final line of the album: "I can't give everything away." What a cryptic way to end your life and your career. I could come up with at least three different interpretations as to what that could mean.
 
NEXT TIME: b'lieve i'm goin down by Kurt Vile

No comments: