I made a list of 200 movies I had never seen but felt like maybe I should have seen, all so I could watch them in alphabetical order and write about them. Here's the list, and here's the next movie:
Braveheart
1995
Braveheart can be defined by the sum of its parts. If we're talking literal math, then you can add together the positive aspects of the film and the negative aspects of the film, and the sum is still going to equal an integer greater than zero. I'll dive into each aspect briefly below, but I wanted to explain first that I don't have anything overarching to say about this film. There is no general thesis. Braveheart is both good and occasionally bad and, regardless of how you feel about the good and the bad, I don't think anyone would disagree that it's certainly memorable. Whether you eventually become engrossed in the film by the time it hits its second hour (like I did) or you eventually find the film too unwieldy to stay interesting and you instead turn to Instagram on your phone (like Pam did), I honestly thing this film is worth a try—this is more than I can say about many of the other films on this list (please don't watch Bee Movie if you don't have to).
Anyways, okay, let's start with the good. I'll start with the most important one for me personally. Braveheart is a classic story of the oppressed defeating the oppressor, and it soars as it continually underlines the importance of the former standing up to the latter, even under threat of death. Mel Gibson stars as William Wallace, a simple man from Scotland who comes to know how cruel England's despot rule is firsthand, and decides to fight back. Wallace is able to rally the country, bringing Scotland's isolated tribes together as one, all with the rallying cry of "Freedom!"
I shouldn't need to connect the dots for you as to why this message is as important today as it was in 14th century Scotland. It is important as ever to acknowledge sincere threats from authority figures and to fight back when necessary. Maybe for an example we could ignore the bright orange autocrat for once and focus on the bedside nurses who are threatening to strike over COVID conditions in hospitals. If higher ups at medical institutions are unable to secure safe working conditions for those whom we were just calling heroes only a few months ago, then I don't see that they have any choice to fight back via a refusal to work in those conditions. Like an even uglier Hamish, I stand by my union sisters and brothers.
Which should show that there is more than one way to fight oppression. Braveheart just happened to choose the bloodiest, most violent manner in which to fight, and I'd argue that this was the right choice from a film-watching perspective. Braveheart didn't just show men fighting with swords and shields, it showcased a spectacle. The various battles stretched on for minutes and never really lost their edge. Fast-paced cuts and extreme gore and a general sense of controlled chaos kept things moving along and interesting. This shit bores the hell out of Pam (we both grew tired of Game of Thrones for different reasons), but I love it. I love intense battle scenes, both because of the adrenaline factor, and also because I love imagining the challenge for filmmakers in pulling something like this off. I can't imagine it was easy for director Mel Gibson.
Hmm... okay, let's talk about the Gibson of it all. The man is obviously integral to the existence of this film, being both its director and its star. He won the Best Director Oscar for his efforts (and the movie won Best Film, though interestingly Gibson was not nominated for Best Actor), an award that was deserved at the time (definitely more so than Ron Howard, who was not nominated, but we already talked about that). The man is so well known that at least two other movies made it onto this list where the only thing I know about them is that Mel Gibson is the star.
And yet it's also pretty important to discuss the fact that Mel Gibson was "cancelled" before the term even existed, and for good reason. All signs point to him being a domestic abuser (the infamous phone call, plus various allegations from victims), as well as someone who has continuously expressed homophobic, racist, and antisemitic beliefs (directly quoting him would require a lot of asterisks on my part). The latter is awful but comes with the sad understanding that some talented celebrities are awful fucking people, Gibson just decided to say it out loud. The former, though—the domestic abuse—would be grounds for the guy never to work again. Yet, he has "bounced back," as they say, directing films recently, and even being nominated for Best Director again for Hacksaw Ridge.
Okay, let's get to the point here. Is Gibson's behavior worthy of shoving Braveheart in a vault and locking it away forever? I mean, probably, but like with all this stuff, it comes down to a personal decision. What are you will watch, knowing what you know? Personally, if Braveheart is going to have a positive effect on me and other potential audience members, and it was created before these allegations came to light, and I'm not benefitting Gibson in any financial way by watching it (I torrented it), then... I personally think it's okay.
But I would understand if you didn't think this way! There's an argument that Gibson's abuse and reprehensible views should tarnish everything he's ever done, and by saying anything good about Braveheart, I'm giving Gibson credit in the realm of public opinion that he forfeited by being an asshole. There's an argument that victims of domestic abuse might feel undeserved pain and trauma by watching art created by and starring Mel Gibson, and my enjoyment of said art is completely discrediting that very real trauma. There's an argument that I myself am not even consistent with my beliefs, since I am willing to watch Braveheart and yet am unwilling to listen to Thriller or root for Odubel Herrera.
These are all valid arguments, and the best I can tell you is that I liked Braveheart despite these arguments, but I will never LOVE Braveheart, again because of these valid arguments. It's possible to enjoy a film created by a shitbag, but it's not possible to unabashedly adore a film created by a shitbag. There's just too much baggage.
If it's true that everyone is allowed to have their own rule when it comes to #MeToo, then I think it's time we stop discussing my rule, because it's not that important to anyone else. Let's talk about something that people had a problem with in 1995, when the movie was released, well before we knew that Gibson was one of the worst people alive.
As you can probably surmise, Braveheart is... not very historically accurate. I say this not knowing anything about the history of Scotland, but instead knowing how to google. It's pretty easy to see that a lot of people were pissed off that this popular movie allegedly presents itself as a historical document, with such complaints as "Wallace's dad lived longer than that" and "there was supposed to be a bridge in this battle." There are dozens, found here and here and here. Historians were in a tither!
Except, I don't see any claim anywhere during the movie that any of this is supposed to be historically accurate. I feel like this isn't the first time I've expressed my opinion on the subject—yup, there was A Beautiful Mind and Apocalypse Now—but I really find it difficult to care about what parts of any given script are fiction and which parts are nonfiction. The purpose of Braveheart isn't to inform, it's to inspire and excite.
Screenwriter Randall Wallace (no relation) seems to have cared about historical veracity about as much as I do. He explained that he learned about the story of William Wallace from a tour guide when he was visiting Scotland. The only information he had when he wrote the script was what he was told while touring a castle. Only after he had completed his own version of the story of William Wallace's epic journey from peasant to freedom fighter did he go back and add in some information about 14th century Scotland. He never intended it to be an accurate portrayal of history; he intended it to be... well, a fucking movie.
There's a responsibility in the audience's reaction to it, too, I guess. Like, it's on us to understand this, the fact that it's a movie and not a documentary. If my reaction while the credits roll is "Wow, I learned a lot about Scotland today," then not only have I misinterpreted Braveheart, but I have misinterpreted the role of film in general.
On the other hand: Scotland's tourism industry shot through the fucking roof in 1996, and according to polling in the area at the time, 39% of the visitors stated that seeing Braveheart had influenced their decision to travel to Scotland to see the castles; I cringe to think about how many of these tourists asked questions like "Did they really paint their faces blue like that?" and "Did Wallace really bang a princess?" I'm saying that it's easy for me to know that Braveheart wasn't accurate, but it's also difficult for me to imagine that everyone understands this. Humans are by and large an ignorant species.
If we're talking about my personal understanding of the film, though, it mainly annoys me more that this is even an issue. It's a fucking movie! Unless it is falsely billing itself as an authentic chronicle of true things that happened, then there's no reason to even talk about it (he says after six paragraphs on the subject).
I don't think it's pointless to criticize Braveheart, because it is not a perfect movie. I just think you should criticize it for the right reasons. If you have problems with the actor/director, then that's legitimate but separate from one's opinion of the film itself. If you have problem with the integrity of the facts, then I don't know what to tell you. If you have a problem with, say, the obscene length of the film? Well, now we're cooking.
There's no reason for a movie to be three hours. I get that filmmakers tend to believe that "epic" movies need to be an epic length, but man, I just do not have the stamina to take in that much movie at once (as was the case with everyone >120min movie in this project, we watched it over two nights). Add on the fact that the first 45 minutes or so were deathly slow—I like Brian Cox as much as the next guy, but shit like that could easily have been cut—and you're left wondering if Braveheart really had to be this long.
And in the romance department, Braveheart was a little weak. There wasn't much of a foundation in that initial relationship/marriage between William and Murron, and it felt especially frivolous in that this was supposed to spurn William to want to get revenge. Plus, you have the whole William/Isabella romance toward the end that feels like it was just thrown in there by the director so that he could make out with two hot women (the only women in the film, basically).
With these last two complaints, though, I don't think I've watched enough movies with a critical eye yet to know if these are legitimate movie-criticism complaints or if they are just personal preferences. Should movies be as snappy and succinct as possible, or is this just some dude trying to watch a movie after 27 nights in a row of interrupted fatherhood sleep? Are movie romances foundational in our understand of any given film, or do I just not care because I'm too busy raising my blood pressure when an old dude getting his hand chopped off with an ax in all its cinematic glory?
I don't know. We still have 178 movies left on the list, so eventually I might be able to confidently say that such and such is a good movie in these ways and a bad movie in these ways and be sure that that's not just me being a fucking idiot. Until then, we have Braveheart.
I'm confident, despite my shaky understanding of film critiquing, that this is a good movie. There's too much icky or wrong or shrug-worthy in there for it ever to be considered GREAT, but on the other hand, the message and the scope of this film just loom too large for it ever to be disregarded in any sense either. If the movies flaws are ropes tied to my hands and feet, and a domestic abuser of a director is a horse pulling at said ropes, stretching my body in pain, then I'm still holding strong, and I'm still fighting for what I believe in, and I'm still yelling "FREEDOM!!!!"
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: We watch Breakfast at Tiffany's, which I think I recall being a reason not to break up.

No comments:
Post a Comment