Degrassi: The Next Generation
"Rumors and Reputations"
Season 1, Episode 10
Originally aired: May 20, 2002
Here's the deal with these reviews: I know no one reads them, and I barely make the effort to write them. I love this show unabashedly, but there is a limit to my love, and having the obligation to write about episodes regularly tests that limit mightily. There are only twelve episodes in Season 1, so my goal is to make it to the end of the first season, and then go on permanent hiatus. This will fulfill my New Year's resolution, and will have achieved the secondary goal of just filling space on the blog (guys... I do not have enough ideas in my head to fill 730 blog posts this year... I'm sorry...).
And while I will miss actually watching Degrassi—like I said, amazing show—I think this episode confirms in my mind that I'm making the right decision. Nothing really happens in episode 10! Unless you count Spinner dropping a container full of earwigs on Ashley's lunch, which is admittedly some sweet action. But that's a silly B-plot. Over in the A-plot, we have a lot of talk, and not a lot of movement. There is no fireworks factory here, just a slow burn of a painful and false rumor.
The cold open begins with Emma, ever the busybody, peeking into a classroom, where the genial Coach Armstrong—whom you may remember from when Drake took adderall, and who moonlights as a math teacher—is helping Liberty with her homework. Emma, though, because of her past trauma, views the interaction as insidious, assuming that there might be something inappropriate going on. She inadvertently starts a rumor that Liberty and Coach Armstrong are "doing it!", which isn't particularly ideal for Liberty or Coach Armstrong, since, ya know, it isn't true.
One of the bigger issues with this story is that it requires all the characters to be a lot dumber than usual. I'm not saying that seventh and eighth graders are typically wunderkinds, but c'mon. Liberty, the chick who is so in your face that it's annoying, is going to be hiding this inappropriate of a secret? And you're going to believe the rumor when fucking Paige Michalchuk tells you, of all goddamn people? And Emma is going to be so obtuse that she is able to trace the rumor back to... herself? C'mon, kids, we're better than this.
But that's not even my biggest issue with the A-plot (because, let's be real, this isn't the first or the last time our characters act like a bunch of dumdums). My biggest issue is that, if you have been watching this show from the beginning, then Emma's actions here are, yes, really ignorant and irresponsible, but also kind of understandable! How can we forget that Emma was almost molested in the fucking pilot episode!
I don't think the show forgets, but it's such a curious decision that they don't even mention this once throughout the entirety of "Rumors and Reputations." They let the audience infer the reasoning behind Emma's behavior. I'm not asking that they beat us over the head with the fact that Emma was sexually abused—especially after not acknowledging it or calling back to it at all during the seven intervening episodes—but I think it would've been helpful to subtly call attention to it at least once. This isn't just Emma being a dick, but I could see a portion of the audience reading it that way. No, this is Emma processing her trauma in a really inappropriate way! She, and the show, really need to address it.
I know these are fictional characters in a fictional Canadian school, but let's address the issue on a human-to-human level for a second. Why isn't Emma in therapy? Being tricked into a grown man's hotel room and being held against her will with the threat of violence and rape is an incredibly large ordeal for a child her age to go through. That shit will fuck you up, possibly severely. And yet (repeat a point in my review for that episode) Emma is never shown to be addressing it, and the adults around her don't seem too worried about getting her the help that she needs. If Spike had found her a goddamn therapist, then maybe Emma would have been able to see the Liberty/Armstrong interaction as an innocent one instead of twisting it in her head to fit a template that was created when she was abused. Wildly irresponsible on her mom's part.
But, ya know, no one said that Degrassi was a logical show. It's great at creating drama—literally creating intense drama out of nothing here—but it's less confident in its ability to tell coherent long-form stories. You knew that already, though. You're watching Degrassi! And reading about it! Why?!
Normally, Spinner's B-plot would be delegated to a postscript in a review like this, but I found it to be pretty fascinating, the more I thought about it (and not just because the greatest but now-defunct Degrassi blog is named after Spinner's call to "Boycott the caf!"). Spinner finds himself in pretty much the opposite position that Emma does when he finds a bug in his food. This is the truth, there really was a bug, but because it's known that Spinner has a contentious relationship with the lunch lady, and is a troublemaking rascal in general, no one believes him.
So Emma is spouting bullshit and everyone instantly believes it, but Spinner is spitting truth, and everyone laughs it off. I don't really blame anyone for their reaction to Spinner—even after eight short episodes with the dude, it's been made pretty obvious that he would be the type of person to make up some nonsense like this—but it's still a pretty sweet set-up, how they show the opposite of Emma is such a humorous way.
Now, Spinner actually has a leg to stand on because of the very real bug he found; he could probably effect real change if he goes about exposing the truth the right way. Instead, then he goes all Project Veritas on everyone and decides to try to fake another bug incident. He's just so dumb, you guys. He pours bugs on Ashley's sandwich, and immediately Ashley is like, "Dude, you put the bugs on there, what the fuck do you think I am, an asshole?" And he does this in front of Kwan (whom he refers to earlier in the episode as "Wrath of Kwan"—drink for every adult pop culture reference this show makes), so it was an extra dumb plan.
I know, I know, this is all for laughs, and I did laugh a lot. I always laugh when it comes to Spinner, who is a sincerely lovable stupid oaf. But the title of the episode is "Rumors and Reputations," so this plotline was essential in mapping out the true meaning of the second word. Had the incidents occurred to opposite characters—had Emma found an earwig in her lunch slop and Spinner seen Armstrong and Liberty in a private study session—then Raditch would be footing the bill for an exterminator and Liberty could continue treating her dyscalculia in peace. Instead, Emma's reputation as a stalwart defender of the truth and Spinner's reputation as a bullshitter cause the whole school to flip upside down in the course of a single day.
I just need more. I need someone to acknowledge that Emma is in dire need of some behavioral health therapy before she goes off and drunkenly contracts chlamydia in a depressed rage (oops, spoilers), and I need someone to acknowledge that one close-up of a disgusting earwig was plenty enough to get the point across. C'mon, Degrassi, do better. We only have a limited time left with you.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5
No comments:
Post a Comment