"Basketball Diaries"
Season 1, Episode 7
Originally aired: December 2, 2001
Do you buy that a character could be so stupid? How about if the character is a teenager? How about if the character is a teenager on Degrassi? These are questions that I constantly ask myself while watching this show. I don't know if Degrassi does enough to justify their decision to have Jimmy Brooks take a performance-enhancing drug and act like a lunatic, but, ya know, this is Degrassi, and Jimmy is indeed a dumb fucking thirteen-year-old, so what can ya do, right?
This week on my favorite television show of all time, Jimmy is feeling the pressures of being a student athlete. Coach Armstrong is telling the team that he'll be making cuts soon, and Jimmy can't imagine a world in which he's not a basketball player—it's his whole persona, the "star athlete," so the pressure is on. Meanwhile, he is getting crushed in English class, his teacher threatening to tell his coach that he's late on his Lord of the Flies essay (he also hilariously claims that the character in that novel he relates to the most is "the lord of the flies").
It's possible that he really just can't handle the dual pressures of homework and practice. It's also possible that he just needs to find a better balance—like, maybe not read a book right in the middle of basketball practice (or maybe just fucking use Sparknotes like any normal slacker)? Whatever the case may be, instead of taking logical steps to balance his life, he instead decides to take one of Spinner's ritalin pills.
It's flawless eighth grade logic: take a pill "just once" to get some energy for the basketball game and avoid the next round of cuts. I've thought a lot about this, and I think I can say that I get the decision, or at least am empathetic toward it. Kids feel pressure, even about stupid and ultimately unimportant bullshit. There's always a temptation to do anything you can to relieve that pressure. Jimmy chooses to take a PED. This is something teens do. (For more proof of this, see a Puke on Your Birthday contributor argue in favor of adderall at the opposite end of her teenage years.)
My biggest problem with Jimmy's decision is from a television perspective—Jimmy on ritalin and Spinner off of ritalin results in two of the most cringe-worthy overacting performances in Degrassi history. To be fair, the acting is so bad that it is funny and thus still enjoyable, but at the end of the day, it's still bad. Jimmy shoves his own teammate to the ground and gets in his coach's face, yelling in uncontrolled macho mania. Spinner, meanwhile, decides to entertain the halftime crowds by pulling down his pants and exposing his asshole. These are things that probably could happen (who wouldn't want to moon their principal?), but Aubrey Graham and Shane Kippel aren't quite there yet in their acting educations, and are unable to give the manic performances any depth whatsoever.
But maybe that's unfair too, I dunno. It doesn't help that the episode is called "Basketball Diaries," obviously referring to the 1995 movie of the same name. In my recent write-up for that movie, I discussed how the young Leonardo DiCaprio was able to rise to the occasion and give the drug-addled performance an emotional heft. Graham and Kippel are no DiCaprio. Not yet, anyway—it's only episode seven!!
So, obviously, Jimmy is cut from the team, which is so frustrating on a logical level—c'mon dude, you are clearly one of the twelve best players on the court out of fifteen, you didn't need to take the drug—but satisfying on a story-telling level—this episode ends on another classic down note, where Jimmy is cut and is at his lowest and then the episode... ends. I love when they do that. There is no resolution because life sometimes does not feature resolution, just constant heartbreak. Degrassi isn't a fucking sitcom.
I just don't know if the episode did enough to convince me that this was a logical step for this character. Up to this point, Jimmy has seemed so confident and calm and cool and collected, at least publicly (yes, I recall that just last episode he was struggling over whether to have sex or not, but that all happened behind closed doors). The first chink in his armor, i.e. his willingness to be reckless with a ritalin pill, results in him completely losing his identity. It's a bit too abrupt of an acceleration of character. I don't know if I buy it!
Here's another way of putting it: judge an episode of Degrassi by the way you laugh. Are you laughing at it or with it? I spent a lot of "Basketball Diaries" laughing at it, which means that it did not achieve what it intended to achieve. It's tough to tackle serious issues when Spinner and Jimmy are so over-the-top and unintentionally hilarious. I wonder how many kids saw this and decided to take ritalin.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5
Stray Observations
- I didn't even touch on the B-plot in the above write-up. This was partly because it's a bit light and forgettable, and partly because it stars Liberty Van Zandt and Ashley Kerwin, the two worst characters so far.
- Liberty is getting salty that she is writing the morning announcements while Ashley gets to read them, feeling like she is doing all the work and Ashley gets all the glory (nevermind the fact that Melissa McIntyre remains the weakest link in this cast, and so all the praise Ashley gets for being a "star" on TV rings so false to me). Liberty finally reads the announcements, bombs spectacularly, Ashley feels bad, etc. Not the best B-plot Degrassi ever came up with. I guess it's trying to show that Ashley is a decent person beneath her bitchy veneer, but I wish they would've come up with a more fun way to get that message across than a fight about the goddamn morning announcements.
- Are we able to link the two storylines thematically? Maybe if we bullshitted a little bit. What is we said that the theme this week is "Don't try to be someone you are not"? A lesson that Jimmy and Liberty both learn the hard way this week (though with opposite outcomes). Otherwise, this seems like an episode where the important A-plot only stretched sixteen minutes, so they came up with a dumb fucking B-plot about morning announcements to fill the other nine minutes.
- So is Jimmy a good basketball player or a mediocre one? The show hasn't really made a commitment to an answer at this point. You would've thought before this episode that he is a good basketball player (he's shooting a basketball in the opening credits!), but he spends the entire episode wondering whether he is in the bottom 20% skill level on the team. I guess this is just a teenager having a low opinion of himself? I would've thought that he would at least be good enough to perform at average level even after spending all night writing a Lord of the Flies essay.
- I did appreciate how Jimmy took Lord of the Flies seriously after Kwan called him out for not reading it. Lots of people I know would've been so embarrassed in class that they would double down, say fuck it, and just not write the essay at all. Nope, Jimmy does what he has to do, writes the essay, and shows true humility when he privately hands it to Ms. Kwan. Too bad twenty minutes later he's doing drugs.
- I had forgotten that Spinner earned his nickname because of his severe ADHD.
- I wonder if kids in Canada with ADHD are expected to regulate their own treatment like Spinner did, or if that's just a plot convenience. I know that in my grade school, the kids with ADHD had to go to the nurse to get their pill. This was ostensibly to prevent other asshole kids from taking meds they weren't supposed to.
- Two linguistic tropes that Degrassi employs often show up in this episode, and I'll always appreciate it. First, Spinner mispronounces a word, saying that he is giving the team "mortal support." Second, Degrassi loves dialogue where a kid is about to curse before being interrupted by another character. This is like the third time they've done it, but it was still kinda funny when Sean says "I don't give a rat's —" before Snake cuts him off.
- More Sean hilarity: after observing how insane Jimmy is acting, he comments "Woah, someone had a nutritious breakfast."
- Most of the other characters beside Jimmy, Spinner, Ashley, and Liberty get pushed to the sidelines this week, and are mostly there for "mortal support" for our main players. Notably, Emma, Manny, J.T., and Toby all end up at the basketball game (where they get to witness Spinners bare ass). I did like how they had Emma call Jimmy a "lunatic," because one, she's right, and two, her motivation is obvious—Jimmy hurt Sean. (Though, I would've liked to see another sour reaction from Toby at that line.)
- Hey, Raditch actually gets something to do this week! He punishes Spinner for, ya know, exposing his asshole to a crowd of people. Dan Woods is so wooden in this scene though—I get that actual teenage actors might not be able to carry a scene, but c'mon Woods, you're a grown adult, what's your excuse?
- TABOO OF THE WEEK: Six (6)—internet predators, underage drinking, pornography, divorced parents, first-time sex, unprescribed ritalin.
- So do we think that Armstrong suspected drug use? Or did he just assume Jimmy was an asshole? If Degrassi had spent even one episode developing Armstrong's character at all (in the like twelve fucking years he's on this show), maybe we'd have a better idea.
- A non-episode-specific-related Degrassi update: Manny just got replaced in that new Disney movie coming out. I am so disappointed for Cassie Steele. I hope she finds a breakout role at some point!
No comments:
Post a Comment