This will be the third Top Five list that I write about Bob Dylan, but seeing as the other two were published in 2008, I remain unsatisfied. It's especially important that I wrote in my intro to the Top Five Bob Dylan Songs list that "one's 'favorite song' changes from day to day, so this list will probably be wrong by tomorrow." Twelve years later, it's certainly changed.
I think my song ranking has changed so dramatically for Bob Dylan because my opinion about this artist has changed so dramatically as well. When I was a lad, there was a bit of hero worship—Bob Dylan just seemed so fucking cool, like he didn't give a fuck, like he was so fucking flippant about his obvious genius, and that caring-about-not-caring attitude was appealing to the teenager I was at the time. These days, however, I tend to hold Bob Dylan a bit removed. I no longer hero-worship, because I'm older and I'm able to see that at least 75% of Bob Dylan's genius is pure quackery. Great songs, but to say he is a "hero" because of it is overstating it. I've learned to kill my idols.
In any case, the five songs chosen for that 2008 list were no doubt chosen because they were quote unquote "important," as opposed to them being the best songs. I'm here to correct that. I am resigned to the fact that Dylan is basically a crazy, cranky old man who talks nonsense and has somehow accrued followers who take that nonsense as gospel. Not because, but despite all that, he's got some fucking bangers, and here they are.
Top Five Bob Dylan Songs (Again)
It's a little weird that I've started gravitating toward Dylan's slower stuff. Not that "Visions of Johanna" is necessarily slow, but it's definitely more heartfelt than the party mode Blonde on Blonde usually operates in. I guess it's that when Dylan shows his emotions, then I know he's not being a snarky asshole.
I don't think it's because of this song's prominent placement in The Big Lebowski's soundtrack, but that doesn't hurt.
The best apology song of all time, mainly because Dylan deals with a fight with his significant other in the same way I do—"Can't we just sweep this under the rug and forget it ever happened?"
Well, there's the thing about gravitating toward slower Dylan—that applies here too. There's also the whole nostalgia thing—the CD that came with Rolling Stone's Top 500 Albums issue included this song. That's probably the more likely culprit. It really was a simple twist of fate that this song was able to open up a whole different world of music for me.
Alright, fuck it, I wasn't completely wrong in 2008. No critic that calls this one of the best songs of all time is wrong. My theory is that vitriol toward another human being can rarely be turned into any sense of bombast or epicness, and the fact that Bob Dylan pulls it off flawlessly here says everything you need to know. This is one big "fuck you" stretched over six-minutes-plus, and it's delicious.
HONORABLE MENTIONS: "Ballad in Plain D," the joys of which I discovered when I covered Another Side of Bob Dylan for The Albums That Matter; "On a Night like This," which is the best quasi-cowboy Dylan song (the man has had a lot of phases); "You Changed My Life," which makes me think that I should try out some more of Dylan's "Born Again" music, past the tracks that are on The Bootleg Series.

No comments:
Post a Comment