Welcome back, after an incredibly long COVID-induced absence, to Your Favorite Movie. In this ongoing, on-its-last-legs series, we interview a friend (sitting at least eight feet apart) about their favorite movie of all time, learning a little bit about the film in question and maybe a little bit about the interviewee as well.
In the hot seat today is good friend and PoYB contributor Sam Fran S*******. At this point in my life, I feel like I hang out with Sam more than most other friends. Some of that is due to having children of almost exactly the same age, and some of that is due to having similar employment situations (geographically, at least), but I'd argue that most of that is due to having similar interests in absorbing pop culture and processing it together—book club, movie club, Record Club, Sam's there. In any case, I appreciate the friendship, and appreciate the fact that Sam genuinely wanted to get together on a Thursday night and talk about a movie for over three hours.
The movie in question is the 1972 film Sleuth, a whodunit-type film starring Michael Caine and Laurence Olivier. This is one of those Your Favorite Movie films that I had never heard of before Sam chose it for this project. If you are in the same boat, I would probably ask you to stop right now and watch the movie. I cannot picture anyone enjoying this long (very long) interview without having seen the movie, but on top of that, there are some major spoilers in the interview that are going to ruin the movie-watching experience if you don't watch it first. Just google "watch sleuth 1972 online free" with ad-blockers on or whatever.
Sam and I sat on his porch a few weeks ago with Sam's wife Hannah (she of Clueless and Beetlejuice) with a couple beers (well, not Hannah, she is like ten months pregnant) and had a good discussion. The following was recorded with Sam and Hannah's permission, and transcribed from the very pleasantly cricket-soundtracked audio recording. I'm glad to have Your Favorite Movie back, though I cannot promise there will be too many more of these. Anyways, enjoy the movie, enjoy the interview, and now let me go rest my fingers from typing all this.
~~~~~~~~
Sam: You could have a fake interview within a fake interview?
Joe: I guess so.
Sam: Or you could have a really hard take, and you're like, "That's not my take, this is my take!"?
Joe: Right. And, I'm not as witty as Laurence Olivier. And I don't think me and you, or me and Hannah, have that type of relationship, like a rivalry-type relationship. Nor do we disagree about anything regarding this movie, probably.
Sam: I hope not.
Joe: I liked this movie a lot. You liked this movie a lot. Hannah?
Hannah: Yeah, I loved it.
Joe: So... I dunno. I guess I would like to know what you want to get out of this interview?
Sam: Well, I feel better about my choice, having watched the movie again. Because I was going back and forth—as an avid reader of this series—of "Why am I choosing this movie? Why do I say that Sleuth, a 1972 movie that I saw once when I was in high school, why is that my favorite movie?" And having watched it... I guess I was interrogating myself throughout the course of reading all these interviews, like, "Well, I don't really have all these connections to this thing, like a lot of other people." For a lot of people in your series, nostalgia is a common theme. People watch their movies with their families, on Christmas or on vacation or whatever.
Joe: They watched it when they were young. It's the movie they've "always watched."
Sam: Yeah. Just like albums you listen to when you're fifteen are more important to you then than they are now. People leaned on this idea in the interviews almost to a fault, except maybe Dwyer, and the dude who did Wolf of Wall Street. Everyone picked movies from when they were a lot younger, and even Dwyer's was from when he was in college.
Joe: Right.
Sam: So what am I trying to get out of this? Reading all the other interviews, and then watching this movie, I had a lot of self-evaluation. Just going through that process was worth it for me. I'm happy with my decision. It really does reflect a lot of things I like in movies, and in culture, and in art, in a lot of different ways. I'm happy that it doesn't suck! [laughter] The reason I've always said that this was my favorite movie was because I put this in as a computer password reminder. "What's your favorite movie? Sleuth." I was going to say Mallrats, but I wasn't sure if I could remember whether I would type "Mallrats" as one word or two words, so I felt that was a bad answer to a password question. [laughter]
Joe: But at this point, you might forget whether it was Sleuth 1972 or Sleuth 2007.
Sam: Which I've never seen.
Joe: No?
Sam: Have you?
Joe: I actually watched that too to prepare for this interview.
Sam: Who is the British actor in that one? Is it Ewan McGregor?
Joe: Jude Law.
Hannah: Ah! I gotta watch that.
Joe: We'll definitely talk about. But I only ask about your expectations because—and I don't remember what interview it was after—but you told me "Yeah, I read it, but you didn't really talk about the movie at all." So, I came to this interview expecting to talk about the movie itself. As opposed to talking about, ya know, "Let's crack open Sam Fran S******* and find out what makes him tick." I want to do that too, but...
Sam: I mean, I guess it was an amateurish opinion of this series, which I think has gotten better over time, because you do really crack into people a lot. You have people who aren't really used to talking about themselves, exploring things, and it seems almost like therapy at times.
Joe: Whether you want that or not, I don't know.
Sam: Yeah, I don't know if I want that.
Joe: [laughter]
Sam: In reading them, though, I did eventually like that aspect.
Joe: Well... I'll do what I want to do for each interview too. [laughter] I didn't take it as an insult, I just want to tailor the interview for you.
Hannah: I think what was nice about your interview with me is that Sam also found the time to explore himself in my interview.
Joe: [laughter] Yes, himself and his love of '90s rap.
Sam: And his protection of it!
Joe: So, I don't know man. Where do you want to start? Maybe we can start with just talking about the nuts and bolts of the movie?
Sam: Sure. And I guess the thing I would say right at the outset that cuts against this movie—not cuts against it, but cuts against people reading this particular interview, is: I really, really, really like this movie, and I really, really, really like this story. And you can't possibly talk about the movie without talking about the multiple, multiple, multiple spoilers about the movie. Most people have probably not seen this movie, because it's not available to even rent or buy on the internet. It's very difficult to find, for seemingly a somewhat popular movie that's well-regarded.
Joe: Did you ever research why that was?
Sam: No. Is there a specific reason why?
Joe: It's a very weird reason, but we'll get to that.
Sam: But... spoiler alert. See this movie. It's definitely worth watching.
Joe: Do you feel like it's an easy movie to watch?
Sam: It's a little longer than it should be, but other than that, yeah. I think it's really digestible.
Hannah: Especially for something that—I guess we are spoiling this?
Sam: Yes. Starting now!
Hannah: Especially for having only two actors in it. I think that's really hard for a movie to do.
Sam: I agree. I think it kept my attention. But there's so many great things about this movie that keep your attention. It's a beautiful set design. A beautiful... I wish I could buy or rent it so I could've seen it better. If you watched the same stream I saw, it was Italian subtitled and grainy footage.
Joe: Probably. I did the torrenting.
Sam: Seeing the full, clear version would've been cool. Seeing all the little miniatures, the fake books. I think the plot holds your interest. I think the dialogue is cutting. And it's a lot more social economic, social-class-stratifying discussions than I remember. Like, I was just hooked into the "crime mystery" aspect of it the first time watching. I was really much more interested in the two characters this time around. I thought it was an interesting character study for these two people.
Joe: For sure. So let's start with the "murder mystery" aspect to it.
Sam: Or whatever type of mystery it is. A heist...?
Joe: Right, because technically there's not a murder until the end. A fake murder?
Sam: Did he die at the end? Are we taking Michael Caine as dying at the end of the movie?
Joe: I took it like that.
Hannah: Did Waverly sister die at the end?
Sam: Did whose sister die?
Hannah: Waverly.
Sam: From Clueless?
Hannah: No. [Editor's note: Hannah is referring to a play that she and I acted in back in 2009 called Recent Tragic Events. I wrote about it briefly HERE.]
Joe: Oh god. There's actually a lot of connections to other La Salle plays, but I was not able to connect Sleuth to Recent Tragic Events. [laughter]
Sam: Well there you go.
Joe: I know you guys are probably more familiar with the "murder mystery" genre than I am. Are there tropes in this movie that make it a "murder mystery," even though it's technically not a murder?
Sam: It's not really a murder mystery, but it's definitely mystery.
Joe: A whodunit? But it's not even that either.
Sam: So there's this big trope of a group of people, somebody dies, someone solves it. I think they are playing with some of those things. And they're playing with the audience's expectations of those things, where you have the fake inspector, as Michael Caine. So that is a trope. An aloof detective swoops in, being very clever. And the other guy is a murder mystery guy, right? He writes murder mysteries?
Joe: Yeah, and he has... I guess he plays into the tropes a little bit in his writing. Like, "the cops are idiots, and the sleuth has to figure it out." And before the reveal, I thought the movie was playing against that trope, in that this cop is a very smart cop... even though he ended up not being a cop at all. So, I don't know, I guess I was just wondering if this movie ended up playing into any of those tropes.
Sam: In and around it, and it's playing with some of the ideas of it, but it's not a murder mystery itself. Do you [Hannah] think it is?
Hannah: No. If I were to take one theme from the movie, then it's "practical jokes can go too far."
Joe: [laughter] Which is a lesson that we can all take to heart?
Hannah: I mean, especially, as someone who loves doing that kind of stuff. It was a good reminder.
Joe: Do you feel like that was ever the point for either of them? Did either of them start by thinking it was a practical joke that was taken too far? Or was "practical jokes" just an excuse for them to take it as far as they did?
Sam: I think it was more "hazing." Hazing is, in and of itself, malicious. You can tell yourself it's in good fun, but it's generally for you, not for the betterment of the other person. Whereas you do a practical joke against a good friend of yours... I don't know, I don't really like practical jokes. Hannah, you like practical jokes. What's your defense of them?
Hannah: Defense of practical jokes in general?
Sam: Yeah. What's your defense of, in college, when you told me you were pregnant?
[laughter]
Hannah: Um...
Sam: Or when you told Chris McBride that Melissa was hit by a car?
Hannah: [laughter] I think that maybe it is a blurry line. It's more about the joker than the jokee. I think there's some satisfaction in seeing the real reaction of people, and being in control of that reaction. Right? That's definitely what happened here.
Joe: For sure. That they are trying to one-up each other.
Hannah: In the case of me telling Sam I was pregnant, it was in good jest. In this case, obviously, the guy was motivated by "stop fucking my wife."
Joe: Now, did you [Sam] feel like that was in jest?
Sam: Oh no. Not at all.
Hannah: Afterward!
Sam: Oh, oh, I thought you were talking about Laurence Oliver and Michael Caine. I mean... it was a 25-second span that I believed she was pregnant. If she had strung me out over the course of a day, I think it would've been a lot shittier [laughter] than being in the quad, sitting on a bench, having to grapple with that fact.
Joe: [laughter] A bench in the quad.
Hannah: Very early in our relationship. Months, maybe.
Joe: Is there any part of you that wanted to make Sam feel small?
Hannah: That's a great question, because that gets to the heart of what I was saying. The joker feels like they have that control.
Joe: Right. What's the line?
Hannah: Exactly. That's the whole point of the movie.
Sam: But it's how far you take it. Like, in a Jim and Dwight blood feud, they just keep pushing it, and extending it over the course of time. I think it's... having the consideration that this would be painful the other person if I continue to do this.
Joe: There's gotta be some difference, though, between filling somebody's work phone with nickels and then taking the nickels away so that he hits himself in the face with a phone, versus telling someone that you strangled his girlfriend. [laughter] That is something that probably something that Dwight would tell Jim, though! "I strangled Pam."
Sam: But maybe if we're putting Dwight and Jim onto—I don't even know their names.
Joe: Andrew and Milo.
Sam: Okay, right. Andrew, the Laurence Olivier character, is way more sadistic and intense, and believes that the person has been killed. He pulls what Milo believes to be a loaded gun, and shoots him in the head. So much so that Milo collapses and pisses himself. Versus, Michael Caine... well, I guess he's bad too, but at least he's getting Andrew back for it.
Joe: Yeah, I guess that would be a good question, if we're going in this direction. Is there one character who is more villainous than the other? Can you watch this movie and say "This person was the bad guy, and this guy lowered himself to this bad guy's level"? There's no "good guy."
Sam: Yeah, I guess there's not necessarily a good guy. Michael Caine is smug, he's the young hotshot, he's everything that Laurence Olivier says he is—
Joe: And probably was at one point.
[Hannah exits to attend a Zoom birthday party.]
Joe: What do you think... how would you define the core of the argument they are having? The overall argument, how would you define it? What does their conflict consist of? I don't know if that makes sense.
Sam: Yeah, it does.
Joe: Like, here are two guys who don't like each other—why? Is it just because of a woman? Or is there more to it?
Sam: I think there is a smart class struggle mapped onto this. Old money versus new money. They purposefully make Michael Caine, a very very very British person, be someone of Italian ethnicity, in the least believable way—and then use a bunch of Italian slurs throughout the movie—to show, ya know, a "foreigner" versus someone from this country. The aristocracy's willingness to lash out in the most extreme ways necessary to stop, or thwart, or make new money feel pain. This is still the '70s, right? After Woodstock, during the Cold War, before Margaret Thatcher, I think? The U.K. is in a period of rebellion, when the squares are against the people who want to live a little more unconventionally, and I think there is that over this. For these two particular dudes... is Laurence Olivier just upset because one of his "toys" is being taken from him without permission?
Joe: Yeah.
Sam: And Michael Caine is a kid who is like, "Well, you're not even playing with this toy anyway, so why do you care?"
Joe: Is it a comment on the masculinity, and how it can be toxic, I guess? That's kind of how I saw it.
Sam: They interrogate masculinity a little bit in this. They are both bragging at different points, and they both have the piss taken out of them a little bit. In the Italian subtitles, it was "fertilidad."
Joe: You said it best, it was another "toy," like his wife is a "toy." This female who we never see, his wife is just an object, who they are fighting over, basically.
Sam: What does that say about this movie, that there are no women in it? I mean, there are only two people in it. It's a conversation between them, and the conversation is inherently about a woman. Michael Caine is sleeping with Laurence Olivier's wife.
Joe: Do you feel like—I'll quote you from your Tentanda Via album review from November of last year—you talked about music is "more gendered" than you originally thought before listening to that album. Do you feel like movies are gendered? Do you feel like this movie in particular is perhaps a male movie?
Sam: That's a great question. That review, and a Rachel S. review, spurned us to have a text conversation about each other's perceptions on this different albums, and how we perceived certain albums because of our genders.
Joe: The album you may also be talking about is MUNA's Save the World, which Rachel picked and reviewed. I know she reached out to me after that and said that she wished more girls had reviewed this album—because it was just me, you, and Nate that had reviewed it—
Sam: And we were all like, "Yeah, it's fine." She really liked it. And the next week, the opposite happened. We all liked the dude album, and she was like... "it's fine." We talked about it. Obviously, even in marketing terms, the big blockbuster films like the Fast and the Furious movies are marketed toward dudes. That genre of "bro college movies" or whatever... movies are gendered historically.
Joe: Anecdotally, Hannah really like Sleuth. Pam really liked it, though maybe not as much.
Sam: And I really liked Clueless. And I think you felt the same way. You had a perception about Clueless when you were younger—
Joe: Right, I think I had the misconception that Clueless was going to be... too "female gendered," I guess? Then I appreciated it more. It was a low bar that I had set for myself, maybe.
Sam: Maybe a lot things are a matter of preconceived notions. I had mentioned the Fast and the Furious movies, but two people I know who like those movies the best are Maeve and Bridget. "The D*** Boys" [laughter] love the Fast and the Furious movies. And love basketball! And I feel like they are always in situations where people are like, "Uh, do you actually like the Sixers?" Like, I was at a Sixers game with Maeve, and some guy was like "Uh, can you name this guy?" And I was like, "Man, she's got fucking season tickets! Fuck you, dude."
Joe: So that brand of asshole was trying to "gender" a team.
Sam: Yes, a men's basketball team that Maeve loves and knows more about than most people.
Joe: Absolutely. So, would the question of "is this movie gendered?"...is that an asshole question?
Sam: Well, I mean, it's two dudes in a pissing contest. It's written by a man, it's directed by a man, it stars two men.
Joe: Do we think the D*** Boys would like this movie? They would probably like it.
Sam: I think they would like the twists. I hope they stopped and streamed the movie before reading this. Movies are packaged to be gendered. They are marketed on certain channels in certain frequencies.
Joe: Subtly or unsubtly.
Sam: Whether or not the filmmaker's intention is that.
Joe: Does it matter? Whether this movie is gendered or not?
Sam: I think it could matter... [laughter] The Wolf of Wall Street always sticks out as an interview of yours that is very... interesting. Because you very much interrogate that person as to why he likes this thing. The intention of the movie, I believe, was different than what he perceived it to be.
Joe: Well, it's intention versus what you take out of it. So, I can say that what Ant took out of it was probably the wrong thing to take out of it. But I can also question what Scorsese intended for it to mean, and I can disagree with that as well.
Sam: And, what Scorsese says, and what he shows—like, when you show big parties, and midget-tossing, and fun drunk-driving escapades... well, are you really intending to shine a light on this, or are you having fun with it? A lot of things you could say about the Joker movie, which I did not like very much. I don't know how you could walk away from that movie being like "This is a guy I want to be like." It's so bleak, and it's so miserable, it's so sad. How can that be a person you want to be? How is that an incel rallying cry?
Joe: But whose fault is that, though? This brings us back to the Oldboy interview, we talked a lot about this. Is there a responsibility on the filmmaker's part to make a movie that is not going to be misinterpreted? So, say that Ant S*******'s favorite movie of all time is Sleuth, and what he got out of it was that women are objects, and that if someone takes your woman, you have a right to shoot him in the chest with a gun. You could get that out of this movie.
Sam: You could. The end result of this and The Wolf of Wall Street is that the people are brought to their knees in a humbling way. But the path that takes you there... I think this movie is more like Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? than The Wolf of Wall Street.
Joe: For sure, absolutely.
Sam: In that it's painful, at times. It's not as painful.
Joe: I mean, I don't want to talk about The Wolf of Wall Street that much.
Sam: I don't either! A movie that we both, I think, agree is a pretty good movie!
Joe: I do not think that Jordan Belfast was "brought to his knees and humbled."
Sam: I mean, I guess him speaking at a hotel convention...
Joe: His undeserved reemergence, as a figure in that scene. Anyway!
Sam: Yeah, Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? was a movie that was similar. It's a movie about "games." It's about pushing the envelope too far.
Joe: This is a movie you referred to as "nothing really happens but drinking and yelling."
Sam: [laughter] I said that?
Joe: You've already written so much on this blog, man, that I could quote you forever.
Sam: I probably said that when I ranked my favorite movies, right?
Joe: Yeah. But, okay, use that as an example. Should anyone watch Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? and emulate the main couple? If that's what you get out of it, if someone misinterprets a movie, and gets something out of a movie that they shouldn't have... is that the fault of the movie?
Sam: Bad movies are easier to misinterpret. Sheer statistics, sure, some people are going to misinterpret it.
Joe: The better the movie, the dumber you have to be.
Sam: Sure. But, okay, should we not listen to rap music because a few knuckleheads that thought Ice-T was telling them to kill cops?
Joe: That's fair. And... I didn't plan on asking any of these questions, so I'm not sure...
Sam: But to your point—Mike Nichols creates Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? in such a painful, visceral way—how could you possibly walk away from that movie with the idea of "alcoholism is fun" or "this is the way you should behave with your spouse"? They are miserable, and it is painful to watch.
Joe: You could say the same about Sleuth, right? No one is happy in this movie?
Sam: No one's happy. Neither of them are happy with their circumstances, and even Michael Caine, who is portrayed initially as this rising young buck, is able to be tricked by Laurence Olivier, not in the actual plot of everything, but the idea that he will not be enough for the woman who loves him. And he thinks that he needs purport a fraud—which he initially thinks is wrong. He's like, "I'm not going to do that, I don't want to do that," but then he's like, "Maybe I do need that money. Maybe I don't love this woman as much as I think I do." Um... I started out confident in what I was trying to say, but now I forgot what my train of thought was.
Joe: You were saying about how the characters weren't happy.
Sam: Yes... but then Hannah texted me a question about Jude Law being hot, so...
Joe: [laughter] We'll make a note. I'll make a note that says "hot" next to his name.
Sam: We'll go through her questions at some point.
Joe: To me, this doesn't seem like a movie you could misinterpret as "these are people you should emulate."
Sam: It's a fun romp. Which is what... that's the line you have walk as an artist and a filmmaker, that it can't be too fun. Or it can't be taking too much joy from a serious or traumatic event. That's like the whole thing of, like, "Oh, you can't make jokes about sexual abuse." Well, it's a really hard topic to make jokes about, and a lot of people aren't going to hit that mark. So no, the people at the Open Mic Night at the Grape Room shouldn't be making jokes about sexual abuse!
Joe: I feel like there has to be... there's room for those types of jokes and this type of behavior, as long as the end result doesn't leave those jokes or behaviors hanging. Like, had this movie started and ended with Michael Caine in a clown outfit, trying to break through a window with a little hammer, it would've been easier to misinterpret the intentions of the movie. But it ended darkly, and it ended in way that you knew that these characters are not exhibiting behavior that you or I should emulate. Same with Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, and same with Oldboy—who, ya know, if you're a school shooter, and you're emulating Oldboy, then you've wildly misinterpreted that movie.
Sam: Did you talk about—I didn't read your American History X review, but did you talk about that part, that aspect in the movie?
Joe: Yes, but I guess in the opposite way? I went into the movie assuming that they were going to present a nazi and ask you to empathize with that person. Whereas what's-his-name's character, Ed...
Sam: Edward Norton.
Joe: Yes. He came out of prison not a nazi. They were asking to empathize with a reformed nazi, which was, I guess, a little easier of a pill to swallow. But, the way that Sleuth ended, I don't think the director or the actors or any part of the filmmaking process is asking you to empathize with either of these characters. It could even be... a parable, maybe? Like a warning. "Don't be this type of person." Did you see any of yourself in either of these characters?
Sam: I've thought about that already, because that's definitely a trope of this series. I have a list of Joe K*** Tropes. "Does a character reflect you?" is definitely a trope.
Joe: [laughter]
Sam: But it's a good interview question. It definitely opens up conversation.
Joe: I guess if you're reading along, you should drink every time a trope is used.
Sam: I mean, I brought up the capitalism and class stuff already.
Joe: Yeah, we can get into that a little more. Give me like two more beers and I'll start going about capitalism.
Sam: But so... I don't know. I'm so "go with the flow." I'm not really a "keeping up with the Joneses" type of folk that this movie—I think that's a big theme, with these two guys competing against each other. I would say that, at times—not so much the way he's portrayed in this movie, but the way he lives his life—the Laurence Olivier character. He has a house, he likes it a certain way, he has a particular way he does things. I think I fall into, ya know, "I want to look this up before I read this book," or "I want to watch this TV show"—I think I drive Hannah crazy the way I want to consume media, or watch a movie or whatever. The particularness of him could be like me. But in the... they're both wealthy dudes, though, and...
Joe: It might have been almost a trick question, because both characters have similar motivations. And that's why the conflict is so large, because they are so evenly matched. Despite what each of them wants to think of the other, as far as the classism and fucking the guy's wife and whatnot.
Sam: Yeah, but you asked who's the good guy and who's the bad guy, or is there one, or are they both bad... Michael Caine's character, despite the fact that he looks down upon his family and his roots, does come up from nothing, and he does go match for match with this seemingly Oxford-educated rich person. He's an owner of two hairdressing salons, and he's modestly successful. He's getting Andrew's references, he has a very witty repartee with him. You would think he's a young guy coming up in the social scene of this community. You would think that he might be the son of the guy's business partner or something. But he's not! But I think that makes him more likeable. You get his perspective, versus this other guy who's just a rich dude.
Joe: I guess that also makes him the person who falls farther throughout the course of the movie. That he started from that moral position—not financially—
Sam: Which one?
Joe: Milo. At the start of the movie, he was definitely the good guy at the start of the movie.
Sam: A very American story, right?
Joe: Right, pulling himself up by his bootstraps. But, that means he had a lot farther to fall.
Sam: Ethically, morally.
Joe: Right! He was definitely, in my opinion, the one who brought himself down to Andrew's level.
Sam: Seemingly—I've been saying "seemingly" a lot—but he debases himself. He never had to interact with this guy ever again.
Joe: But he had to come back and try to win twice over.
Sam: Plus he had to break into the guy's house to set up the second prank. And he went to the police too, which I guess is a crime. It seems like he should've... whatever, I guess rich people get away with stuff.
Joe: What, that he actually went to the police and had them come—?
Sam: No, what Laurence Olivier did to him, that prank is a crime, I would say.
Joe: Assault, I guess?
Sam: You could argue it's attempted murder. You don't know!
Joe: I don't know about British Law.
Sam: It's common law. You could make that case.
Joe: Okay, so the way—
Sam: Once we need a stopping point, I need another beer.
[Bathroom break and beer break, including a moment caught on tape when Sam cracks open a beer and says "Oh, that's good!" to himself.]
Sam: Can I ask a question now?
Joe: Please. About Sleuth?
Sam: About Sleuth. Did you pick up that it was Michael Caine?
Joe: I did.
Sam: At what point? Like immediately?
Joe: Nope. There were certain mannerisms. I feel like if I was in 1972, watching this movie in theaters, I wouldn't have picked up on it.
Sam: And I don't know how big Michael Caine was at that time.
Joe: Not big? I know he was nominated for an Oscar for either Lead Actor or Supporting Actor in 1966, so he wasn't, like, a minor acting in '72. But definitely no one in 1972 had seen Alfie as many times as I now have seen Muppet Christmas Carol. I was familiar with enough subtle Cainerisms.
Sam: And Michael Caine is a caricature at this point, a little bit, from those Trip movies. It's an impression that people do. He's just a friendly figure who's been around a long time. When I first saw Sleuth, I did not pick up on it, and I was totally floored.
Joe: Hey man, that's awesome.
Sam: That experience is why this is my favorite. I was so shocked by it. It was such a reveal. I was like, "Oh my god, he killed that guy, I can't believe he killed him!" And Hannah picked up on it about halfway through his inspector routine. As soon as he came out this time, now knowing the great, great, great spoiler that I thought it was the first time... I was like, "...oh boy." It was so much less... It's not obviously Michael Caine, but you should definitely be able to pick it up the way that you and Hannah were able to pick it up.
Joe: Yeah, it wasn't immediate. I was almost disappointed when I realized it. I knew when I realized it that it was going to be a reveal that I had picked up on, and I shouldn't have.
Sam: It stinks to outsmart things sometimes.
Joe: I kind of thought about—have you ever seen Breaking Bad?
Sam: Yeah.
Joe: The twist ending to season four, where they show the plant in Walter White's backyard that he used to poison Brock.
Sam: Oh, yeah.
Joe: And that was... I knew that because of the internet guessed it beforehand.
Sam: I was like that with Game of Thrones stuff a little bit. I had read the books, but theories after the books. There's only so many ways you can do a certain thing, and if you devote enough time and energy to thinking about what could be the eventual result, you'll eventually come up with one of the correct one. And then it's like, "Oh, I got it."
Joe: It's a weird balancing act, enjoying something enough to want to know more about it, and not wanting to know too much. And that's more toward TV, I guess. If this was a six-part miniseries, and the whole third episode was Michael Caine in a costume—
Sam: And the world figured it out.
Joe: Right. If you figured it out in the week between episodes three and four, that would suck! And it sucked figuring it out here... I guess there was a moment when I was like, especially because of the fake cast list at the beginning—
Sam: Which is actually what tipped Hannah off.
Joe: Okay.
Sam: Because it's like "And introducing blah blah blah"—
Joe: "Alec Cawthorne as the Inspector."
Sam: That is a trope in murder mysteries.
Joe: Is it really?
Sam: Yeah. The Agatha Christie movies—Murder on the Orient Express, Death on the Nile—Hecule Poirot, the Belgian detective, was in a very James Bond-way portrayed by different people in different movies. So it was like "and we're gonna have this guy play the detective!" Introducing "this person" as the "famed detective" who's going to solve the thing.
Joe: I was going to ask, is that something that happens these days? Because I couldn't think of any other examples of a fake cast. This was a cast of six people.
Sam: And the marketing was like that too.
Joe: Yeah, I guess they purposefully did that for the '70s audience.
Sam: I think it was this movie where they asked the audience—I had recently heard, when Knives Out came out, I was listening to a podcast about murder mysteries, and I think they talked about how this movie, in theaters, they played something like "And please don't spoil it!"
Joe: I haven't seen Knives Out, but—
Sam: Not Knives Out, Sleuth.
Joe: Oh, they did this in 1972 you're saying? Interesting.
Sam: Knives Out is... not that good.
Joe: Apparently there was a reference to Sleuth in Knives Out. I guess the murder mystery that Andrew was talking into the microphone about in the very beginning—"Death by Double Fault"—a character in Knives Out referenced solving that crime in real life. Never seen Knives Out, but... there's some IMDB trivia for ya. [Editor's note: since conducting this interview, Pam and I have watched Knives Out. Two notes. One, yes, they referenced the murder on the tennis courts, but there was a way more obvious Sleuth reference—Captain Jack Tar was in the background in a whole bunch of scenes at the mansion. Two, I might've liked Knives Out better than Sleuth, but that's neither here nor there.]
Sam: Well I'm sorry—I really wanted everyone to be floored by it. As I got to it, I was like, "Eh, everyone is going to pick up on this, nevermind."
Joe: And that probably wasn't Michael Caine's fault, right? It's pretty hard—
Sam: I feel like they could've done a better job disguising him. They could've shot it differently. I don't know.
Joe: Do you feel like Michael Caine is a good actor?
Sam: I really like Michael Caine.
Joe: As an actor?
Sam: I mean, I don't really know anything about him personally. I like Michael Caine being in movies, I guess is what I mean.
Joe: Is it outrageous to say that I don't appreciate him as an actor?
Sam: Well, it's not like you're saying you don't like Meryl Streep or Daniel Day Lewis or somebody. I know you have opinions about Daniel Day Lewis.
Joe: Definitely... maybe it's similar in that I don't appreciate them as much as the general public seems to appreciate them. So Daniel Day Lewis is a higher bar because he's known as the "method actor who takes this so fucking seriously." Whereas, I'm pretty sure that I read that... what's his name, the guy who plays the police captain in the Dark Knight trilogy?
Sam: Gary Oldman?
Joe: Gary Oldman said that Michael Caine nailed every take, just "because he wanted to get back to playing cricket."
Sam: Or like, I heard that Anthony Hopkins took Westworld—I think this was a joke—to put another wing onto his beach house.
Joe: So it's both different and the same, Daniel Day Lewis and Michael Caine. Daniel Day Lewis, people take him way too seriously. He's a good actor.
Sam: Michael Caine is cashing a check.
Joe: I guess. It's noted in his Wikipedia that in the '80s, that's what he said he was doing.
Sam: And he's in what, Jaws 3 or Jaws 4 or something?
Joe: Jaws: The Revenge. But that's not even what I'm saying though. If he did that, I get it. But movies like the Batman trilogy, what else have I seen him in...? Every fucking Christopher Nolan movie. And Sleuth 2007. I don't know if I think he is the all-time great that people think he is.
Sam: I'll answer this in two ways. I'll say it this way so I remember to come back to the other thing I want to talk about. I'll even introduce it like this: One, he's not even close to being as good as Laurence Olivier is.
Joe: Yes, we definitely need to talk about him.
Sam: And two—this will seamlessly come back around, and we'll all be like "Oh, I see what Sam is saying"—two, I like to look at actors like in sports, like the idea of a "replacement level actor." Who is good, who is bad, and who is just fine. Are you just as good as the average baseball play. Are you a little better than that? Are you a little worse than that? And I would say that Michael Caine is just a little better than replacement level. He has a certain charm and charisma to him that makes his appearance in this movie like, "Oh, Michael Caine is in this!" But is he elevating the content? Like, I watched Ford v. Ferrari not that long ago—Matt Damon does a fine job. But fucking Batman, whose name I can't remember—Christian Bale, he elevates the content in that movie. His performances in that, in Wolf of Wall Street, in the Batman movies, even though he is doing a bunch of bullshit method stuff, he's elevating the content. He's doing a better job than this is reading on paper.
Joe: Christian Bale was in Wolf of Wall Street?
Sam: The Big Short, I mean. Other Wall Street movie.
Joe: Thank you for clarifying. Sorry, continue.
Sam: They elevate the content. I don't know if Michael Caine is elevating the content as an actor. I think his persona is doing it sometimes. And that's fine! But that's it. But he's not exuding life into this character. Whereas I feel like Laurence Olivier is elevating this particular thing. Michael Caine comes off like "I am reading this witty dialogue in a functional-to-above-average way." Whereas Laurence Olivier is this person. Like, I believe that he can step into this person's shoes. Maybe this is a perfect character written for him—I have not seen as much Laurence Olivier as I would have liked to, and I will continue to try to see him. He's so exceptional in this movie.
Joe: For sure. Yeah, and I don't know if it's a matter of Michael Caine's typical acting style fitting this role pretty well? I don't have any complaints about Michael Caine's acting in Sleuth.
Sam: He's good in this movie.
Joe: For sure.
Sam: Plays off Laurence Olivier well.
Joe: Definitely.
Sam: Good old man / young man chemistry.
Joe: Absolutely. And... which is especially interesting in 2020, because I've always known Michael Caine as an old man. To see him in a role as a young man—
Sam: When he wore a younger man's clothes.
Joe: Right, exactly. He exudes a little more energy. When he thought he got shot—that was a legit scream.
Sam: Yeah. And the camera work does a little bit of the work there. There's more intense camera work there than... well, whatever, we can talk about the camera later.
Joe: I did promise you that we would talk about the nuts and bolts of the movie. As opposed to—
Sam: I mean, we are just talking about this movie. We're not really talking about me.
Joe: We can move onto you.
Sam: Break me apart.
Joe: No, I want to talk about the movie. I want you to come away from this interview saying "Yeah, that interview actually talked about the movie." I want another movie buff, any movie buff to read this interview and say "They know this movie. They weren't just talking about themselves." Okay, so we are in agreement about Michael Caine.
Sam: Can I ask this question from Hannah, then?
Joe: Sure.
Sam: It's sort of on this point about Michael Caine being young. "Is Jude Law too hot for that role?" Did Hannah ask this while she was here? "Is Michael Caine as hot as Jude Law is?" Like, in that period of time, was Michael Caine as hot as Jude Law is in his period of time?
Joe: Probably not?
Sam: Jude Law is still hotter in 2007 than Michael Caine is in 1972. And is he too hot for that role?
Joe: Ya know, it's interesting... and we can talk about Sleuth 2007 at this point.
Sam: Yeah.
Joe: One of the biggest differences between the two movies is that there was a lot more homoeroticism in this new one.
Sam: I don't think that really comes across at all [in the original]? It feels like they really don't like each other at all.
Joe: I watched the 2007 version second—
Sam: Oh, thank god! [laughter]
Joe: Obviously. But I noticed the homoeroticism in this one. It was explicit.
Sam: That could be that these people are narcissists, they are in love with themselves.
Joe: Possibly! I guess I read something, or maybe I thought about it more—that in the 1972 version, there were moments that possibly could be interpreted as homoerotic. It depends on whether you want to interpret it this way or not, but when Andrew had some choices of phrase that could be taken as homoerotic. When Milo was taking off his police outfit, Andrew seemed excited? No, he seemed excited when he was changing from his regular clothes to the clown outfit. He said, like, "Oh yeah, strip down to your undies," that type of thing.
Sam: I suppose. I mean, that's a very playful scene. He's goading Milo to get into this mindset.
Joe: I only wondered, after I saw the 2007 version, whether in the 1972 version it was just Andrew being playful, he's just fucking around with Milo, or if because it was filmed in 1972 that they couldn't explicitly say that this had some homosexual undertones. By the time 2007 rolls around, Hollywood isn't going to blackball anyone for having Jude Law rub Michael Caine's crotch while they are rolling around in bed.
Sam: Does that happen in that movie?
Joe: Okay, so they cut out the whole third act premise that the older character thinks that the younger character killed his girlfriend. None of that exists. Basically, after the costume comes off, they pretty much just peacock around for a while, and shove guns in each other's faces, and then Jude Law is shot. That's how it ends.
Sam: They just yell at each other a lot.
Joe: Pretty much. And just talk about the nature of their one-upmanship. And Jude Law kinda goes off the deep end. Oh, and Michael Caine, who is Andrew in this one, offers Milo room and board if he leaves Andrew's wife. He says, "If you forget about her you can live with me and we can be pals forever," basically. And Jude Law is like, "I don't want to live in the guest room, I want to live in your master bed." He goes to the bed, and is rolling around with a gun in Michael Caine's face.
[Hannah returns, having sufficiently Zoomed for the night.]
Sam: We're talking about Jude Law now.
Hannah: Oh good!
Joe: I guess that's what spurred it, your question. I was saying how the 2007 version was a lot more homoerotic.
Hannah: Oh?
Joe: And they're kind of coming on to each other, but not really.
Hannah: What?
Joe: It's a lot more explicit than the 1972 version. [Editor's note: Joe recaps the thing he said a minute ago so Hannah can catch up.]
Hannah: So fun.
Joe: It was not as fun! If we're talking about the comparisons between the two versions, "fun" is definitely what we should be talking about. It was not as fun.
Sam: I imagine this part of the conversation will be bracketed, saying "Joe recaps the thing he said a minute ago so Hannah can catch up."
Hannah: Can it also say "Sam weirdly sitting in chair so that his groin is thrusting in the air in an uncomfortable way."
Sam: [weirdly sitting in chair so that his groin is thrusting in the air in an uncomfortable way] ...
Joe: Talk about homoeroticism! This is how he is reflecting the movie in the interview.
Sam: That's the only question I had asked.
Hannah: I left my phone upstairs, I forget what I sent.
Joe: Well, we can talk about the 2007 version for a little bit. For some reason I thought you had watched it. So I wanted to be prepared for this section.
Sam: Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't mean to give you two for the price of one.
Joe: No, it's all good, the new one was only 88 minutes.
Sam: And this one was like 125? It was a little long.
Joe: It was over two hours. And this might segue into something I wanted to talk about. This one seemed a lot colder? I dunno. I feel like the 1972 version was brightly lit. It was a very lively scene, just because of the way the mansion was set up. Whereas in this one, Andrew lived in this sparse, brutal, neon-lit mansion. Sparsely furnitured. A lot of the directorial choices were weird. A lot of the shots were through security cameras—it felt like The Wire season one for a bit? A lot of it would be something like Jude Law being in focus, but Michael Caine's character was seen through a mirror, that kind of thing. A lot of blue light.
Sam: I flipped through some of the IMDB stills of it. A lot of it did seem like a Steven Soderbergh thing.
Joe: I think it was purposefully shot like it couldn't have been a play, a theater production. Whereas 1972's version felt like a play. I know that was the point. I know that was something you appreciated in it.
Sam: Oh, loved it. Loved it, loved it. And I loved the mansion. Hannah texted me "Sam said the set was beautiful, and I thought it was creepy but well done." I just love these big British estates. I love everything about them. And I loved how they put a bunch of kitschy bullshit in this particular British mansion. I like that the mansion—like New York—was a character in this.
Joe: [laughter] Right.
Hannah: You didn't think it was creepy?
Sam: Yeah, the toys and stuff were creepy, sure.
Joe: Do you feel like that was purposeful, that it was creepy? Like, do you feel that the director of Sleuth 1972 put that in there because he knew it was going to be creepy?
Hannah: Yes, because of the way the cuts were. He was always cutting to things like, "This is creepy." Right?
Joe: I guess that was a big question I had... I mean, I'm not a movie buff enough to know what a director is thinking. But I did notice that the director had a lot of still shots, and a lot of brief cuts to a lot of random bullshit in the house. During conversations.
Hannah: We talked about this.
Joe: Tell me about it.
Hannah: We thought that that was—well I guess you did, since you had already seen it—
Sam: I agreed with you though.
Hannah: I thought they were insinuating something, like they kept going back to the portrait of the woman, or the thing on the mantel. It was like, "Oh, that's going to come back into play at some point." And it never did! Why were they cutting to it?
Joe: So answer the question. Why?
Sam: I think it was subverting audience expectations. Like, "We are not a murder mystery. This is what a murder mystery would do, but this will not come back into play." It was so overt—
Joe: It was excessive.
Hannah: So excessive.
Sam: And having even seen the movie before, I convinced myself that, "Isn't there a scene where the Edgar Allen Poe statue falls on his head?" I thought I remembered that happening, because they kept showing the Poe bust over the fireplace. And nothing ever happened!
Joe: I feel like there was even a part where they were talking about the clues in the house, and then there was a still shot of the Edgar Allen Poe statue for like six seconds, which felt like an eternity, as if they were saying "This is a clue." But it wasn't.
Hannah: Yeah. And normally watching a movie I would be frustrated by that, but at the end, I was more like, "It's interesting that they kept doing that." I don't know why it didn't piss me off. In another movie, it might've pissed me off.
Sam: The cheekiness of it.
Joe: Okay, so state what you think the director was trying to say. I felt dumb thinking about it. That was a directorial choice, to show these things in these shots. What was he trying to say?
Sam: I think it was "This is a thing that happens in murder mysteries, and I'm going to play it up to an excessive degree."
Joe: These are red herrings.
Sam: These are MacGuffins, these are red herrings, these things don't matter.
Joe: Another La Salle play!
Sam: Red Herring, yeah! Shout out to Pam, the "flat-foot in heels."
Hannah: ...
Sam: ...Which is her character in Red Herring.
Joe: I was still in high school. [Editor's note: I promised that we would connect this movie with some other La Salle Masque productions, but I don't think any more came up. So let's do that here, very briefly—director Joseph Mankiewicz directed the film version of Guys and Dolls, and produced the film version of The Philadelphia Story. These were both plays that La Salle performed. Sorry to all the Buttfucks reading this who were expecting more Masque talk!]
Sam: I think that's all it is. I don't know who the director is, I didn't recognize his name. But I think it was him thumbing his nose at that genre.
Joe: We can talk about him. Joseph Mankiewicz.
Sam: I think I had heard of him, but I couldn't immediately place him in things.
Joe: So this was the last movie he ever directed. And he directed maybe a dozen or two movies.
Sam: A couple big movies too, right? Or, nothing...?
Joe: He won the Oscars for both writing and directing All About Eve and Letters to Three Wives. Neither movies I've seen.
Sam: I haven't either. I've heard of All About Eve.
Joe: So he's definitely an Old Hollywood director, or... an Old Hollywood movie person. And I don't know much about the whole Old Hollywood scene. And I only know this because I watched Ben-Hur recently, and wrote about it—just the whole idea of Old Hollywood, are you guys familiar with that?
Sam: Yeah.
Joe: Do you wanna talk about it?
Sam: You mean like the studio system? Like, the classic idea of these big budget romps, or whatever? The same actors, interchanging directors and plots?
Joe: Yeah. So I guess that the studios owned the players.
Sam: Long contracts.
Joe: Actors, directors, screenwriters. So Mankiewicz himself was a screenwriter for Paramount first, and then a producer for MGM, and then a director for Twentieth Century Fox. This is a Twentieth Century Fox movie. That's why he directed this movie, because he was under contract.
Sam: Sleuth?
Joe: Yes.
Sam: That still exists in 1972? [Editor's note: It didn't—Old Hollywood ended unofficially in 1962, and it was absolutely awful interviewing that I just jumped right to the next thing without addressing my error.]
Joe: That's the other thing. There's a construct of a movie that is considered "Old Hollywood." There's certain aspects of a movie—the way that a movie is shot, it's called the "180 rule." Where people in the '40s, '50s, '60s, were still thinking of movies as theater shot on film, so everything has to be shot on this 180-degree field, as if it were a stage. Versus this movie, which I don't necessarily think adheres to that rule. Like, I'm thinking of that ultra-close-up when Michael Caine thinks he's getting shot.
Sam: And him scratching the blood off the railing.
Joe: Well, even before that, when he's got the gun on the back of his head, and he goes [Michael Caine yell]. that's not 180 degrees. That's us only seeing him. There's other shit, like Old Hollywood is basically like you gotta hold the audience's hand, because they are not going to understand time jumps, they're not going to understand flashbacks. They're not going to understand unreliable narrators. So I think I was confusing... at first I thought that Sleuth was part of the Old Hollywood tradition, because it was based on the theater production, and that's kind of what Old Hollywood was—sorry, I feel like I'm monologuing at this point. But... Joseph Mankiewicz comes from that tradition. All his movies are Old Hollywood. Laurence Olivier is an Old Hollywood actor. He died a couple months after I was born. I don't know any of his other movies, basically, besides this... My point being that this is not an Old Hollywood movie, even though Old Hollywood and Sleuth both have "based on a theater production" type... production... I don't know... what do you have to say about that? Either of you? Save me please.
Sam: It's based on a play. Even though it falls within those contours of that, I think Old Hollywood doesn't feel like a "play," though. Because they take what is in a play and turn it into a movie. Whereas this movie still feels like it could just be a play. It uses the set well, but it is still just two people talking. That's the contours of a play that I want to see. It's very much up my alley. I want to hear two smart people talking about a thing to completion. I could see this as: "Two guys jerk themselves off, intellectually, and now I'm smarter because I saw it."
Joe: And I think that idea is not Old Hollywood, in and of itself.
Sam: No, it's too boring. How do you [Hannah] think about all this?
Hannah: I don't think I'm academic enough about movies to know.
Joe: I don't think you have to be academic, though. You've seen Wizard of Oz, right?
Hannah: Yeah.
Joe: Name a scene from Wizard of Oz.
Hannah: Um, Munchkin Land.
Joe: When they're doing the dance?
Hannah: Yeah.
Joe: Okay, you can picture that scene through a camera, right? And the camera takes in the scene, as if it were a stage. There's no close-ups of Munchkins. There's no points-of-view shots of Dorothy. This is a production that could be played on stage. Whereas I don't think Sleuth necessarily adheres to that.
Hannah: No, it definitely doesn't adhere to it. But that's nothing something I think about when I'm watching movies.
Sam: But you did pay attention to the close-ups.
Hannah: More because they didn't lead to anything from a plot perspective. "Oh, good close-up, maybe this will tie in with the plot later."
Sam: Not "good close-up," but that the close-up happened.
Hannah: But I only noticed it because I thought it would be part of the plot. I don't know...
Joe: Do you feel like there was a part of you that only noticed it because you knew you were going to be interviewed about it later?
Hannah: No.
Joe: That's how I felt.
Hannah: But you do these all the time.
Joe: No, I mean, would I give a shit that there were 23 one-second shots of a laughing puppet if I wasn't going to be talking about it later?
Hannah: No, it had nothing to do with the interview. I thought it would come back to the plot later.
Sam: Well, the laughing puppet did actually come back later. The only one that does.
Joe: What, that Andrew used it to boost his own ego, but then it came back around and made him feel lower once he lost? He wasn't laughing with the pirate anymore, the pirate was laughing at him.
Hannah: Are we supposed to believe a woman could live in that house? There's no way.
Joe: [laughter] That's good, we need this perspective.
Hannah: Why?
Joe: We actually talked about whether the movie was gendered toward the male point of view, while you were gone. I know you said you liked the movie. Do you feel you liked it less than you would've because you are a female?
Hannah: No. I don't know. That's an interesting question. That's not a question I considered.
Joe: And it's not an important question.
Hannah: But when you watch something in this movie that is supposed to represent a woman, you're like, "A dude definitely wrote this."
Sam: You do sometimes expect a woman to not be in a movie if a male wrote it.
Hannah: It's realistic. No, there was no gender issues in the movie to me. Even the representation of women in the movie was fine. It was more just like... a woman would never live on this set. [laughter]
Sam: You also texted me: "His wife looked old, right?"
Joe: The portrait of her?
Hannah: Yeah. [laughter] Well he was older, right? The older rich guy?
Sam: I assumed that she was older than Michael Caine but younger than Laurence Olivier.
Joe: A cougar situation for Michael Caine.
Hannah: Well I had a long time to look at it, because they kept showing it. She had greys in her hair. Like, "She's having a tryst with this younger guy, that's interesting." But the question I cared about—which is gender-related I guess—is the hairdresser question I asked you.
Sam: Her other question was "Was owning a hairdresser a more masculine role when this movie was released?"
Hannah: The fact that he owned a hair salon was like, "That's a weird thing."
Sam: Why?
Hannah: I think today, a guy who owns and operates a hair salon, who has no career in hair, would be—but I guess the didn't comment on this at all either way for him. But you would assume he was not a hairdresser?
Sam: I thought they did.
Joe: I feel like Andrew would have felt the same way you do, in that he... degraded Milo, or insulted him by saying "Oh, you're just a hairdresser."
Hannah: But do you think he is a hair artist? Like someone who works with the hair? Or is he a hair salon owner? I assumed the latter.
Joe: I hadn't really thought about it. I was just thinking about it from Andrew's point of view, like, "Oh you have anything to do with dressing hair? You are lower than me because of that. This is just another reason why I'm shitting on you."
Hannah: Do you think that was career-related?
Joe: Yeah.
Sam: Or was it just because he was a person working with their hands?
Joe: I'm not sure.
Hannah: He was in the same class as someone who would own another type of business. But, to me, it was specific like, "You're a dude who owns a hair salon, who I assume does not do hair? Tell me more about that."
Sam: I don't know why you assume he didn't do hair.
Hannah: It just never came up.
Sam: The only time it came up—it was later, when he was doing his costume exchange: [Michael Caine impression] "Well, you know, when you own a hair salon, you run across certain people in your time."
Hannah: Did he say he did his own makeup?
Sam: No, but he said... maybe it was implied he did his own makeup? I mean, how many people did he enlist to do this thing?
Hannah: Anyway, I just thought it was an interesting thing. And it very well could be a thing at the time, businesses that were owned by men. Right?
Joe: I did not do that research. I just assumed that that career was chosen for Milo because it was a career that Andrew could degrade, in the process of taking every potshot he could at Milo.
Hannah: I saw the degrading happening, and I wondered if the degrading was because of the hair—"Why are you a dude in the hair realm?"—or was it because he was just that class of business owner, and I'm of the elite?
Joe: Probably the latter. Probably a classist thing.
Hannah: In which case, hair is a weird thing to choose. It made him... by our standards today, a little bit more of a pussy? I dunno.
Joe: It's interesting, because in the 2007 version, Milo is not a hairdresser, he is an out-of-work actor, but Andrew, multiple times accuses him of being a hairdresser, and Milo's like, "I'm not a fucking hairdresser!!" So I guess they were both commenting on 21st century viewpoints of hairdressers, and also commenting on the original version.
Hannah: That's interesting.
Sam: Out-of-work actor is such a character shift, because that's pathetic, whereas this is like, "Well, at least this guy is a small business owner, he's doing okay." The shop in Brighton is doing well, from what I understand.
Joe: I think it might just be one of those things that makes the 2007 version not as good. They didn't think about it that far.
Sam: And you had said it wasn't as fun? This one is a fun caper.
Joe: Ya know what? A lot of it came back to Michael Caine. I don't think he did well in the Andrew role.
Sam: He's better as the young buck.
Joe: How do you feel about Michael Caine? Do you feel him to be a good actor?
Hannah: In this film?
Joe: In general.
Hannah: ...Yeah. But I'm not saying he's an actor that has a lot of varying roles. He's not a diverse actor, but I think he does well in what he does.
Joe: I dunno. Maybe I didn't think he did well in the remake because Laurence Olivier did so well in the first one. Laurence Olivier was so playful. Michael Caine was just cold and angry. That's how he played it—I don't know if that's how he was asked to play it, or that's how he would've anyway. Having not seen, do you think that Michael Caine could do a good Andrew?
Hannah: No.
Joe: Why?
Hannah: I don't know. Is Andrew like... who's Batman's butler?
Sam: Alfred.
Hannah: Yeah, is Andrew Alfred-like?
Sam: Michael Caine plays that character.
Hannah: That's what I'm saying!
Joe: You're saying that Andrew is not Alfred-like, and that's why he wouldn't be a good Andrew?
Hannah: No, I'm kind of taking it back. Maybe he would, because he's played a stuck-up British character already?
Joe: But Alfred it so calm. He's so level-headed. He contrasts with Batman in—
[Mount Airy neighbor yells something from sidewalk.]
Hannah: I would have to see it. Here's what I'll say about Michael Caine. He's primed for a Mama Mia 3. He would be a perfect fit for that type of role. One of those guys like from Mama Mia 1 and 2, who kind of play themselves in every movie, but are good at it?
Joe: He already played that role in Austin Powers: Goldmember, so... [laughter]
Hannah: For the record, I'm comparing him to Pierce Brosnan, who I would put in a similar category.
Sam: Stellan Skarsgård, who I think is a pretty good actor.
Hannah: But both of them play themselves in every movie. And Colin Firth, who definitely plays himself.
Sam: Does he?
Hannah: Oh yeah.
Sam: Academy Award winning Colin Firth?
Joe: So thumbs up or thumbs down for Michael Caine's acting abilities?
Sam: I'd say neutral to positive. How about you?
Joe: Down.
Sam: Wow, you think he's bad?
Joe: But just barely.
Sam: Negative one Nates? [laughter] It doesn't sound like you're giving him neutral Nates, so...
Joe: If it pisses Nate off to give him Neutral Nates, I'll give him Neutral Nates.
Sam: No, I think as long as you're saying "Nate," Nate is okay with it. [laughter]
Joe: I don't hate Michael Caine as a performer, and I feel bad saying negative things about him.
Hannah: What don't you like about him?
Joe: I've never been excited about one of his performances.
Sam: Not even when he was like [Michael Caine impression] "And that's how the Cider House rules!"
Joe: Never seen it.
Sam: It's fine.
Joe: I do know that he was nominated for an Oscar for that movie. So, there's only been four actors in history that have been nominated in five different decades for an acting Oscar. Two of them are Michael Caine and Laurence Olivier [Editor's note: the other two are Jack Nicholson and Meryl Streep]. So, choose your own adventure: would you rather talk about Olivier first, or would you rather talk about the Oscars?
Sam: I'd rather talk about Olivier. We already did a little bit, but I want Hannah to talk about him.
Hannah: I need to get some water.
Joe: What other movies of Laurence Olivier's have you seen? I haven't seen any.
Sam: I don't know if I have. Which is shitty.
Joe: Well, he's Old Hollywood.
Sam: Old Hollywood, but I've watched a lot of old movies.
Joe: He died seventeen years after this movie. The last seventeen years were not the most productive years.
Sam: Was this his last big movie?
Joe: It was his last award-nominated movie.
Sam: People got nominated for Oscars for this?
Joe: Yes. You already chose your own adventure to talk about Laurence Olivier.
Sam: Well, whatever.
Joe: So let's talk about him.
Sam: Well, I know he is "Sir Laurence Olivier."
Joe: And Sir Michael Caine. Every fucking British actor is a Sir.
Sam: I definitely thought for the longest time that Laurence Olivier played Lawrence of Arabia. [laughter]. Because of the Laurence. But I have since found out that that is not true. I think it's Peter O'Toole? I mean, he was a Shakespearean actor too, right?
Joe: Yeah, he did a lot of Shakespeare. He was a stage actor first, or primarily? The only movie that he had any part of that I would have any idea what he was a part of was the Frank Ziffereli version of Romeo and Juliet. He was the narrator for that. And I only know that because I interviewed Sean about the newer version of Romeo + Juliet. But... I don't know shit about Laurence Olivier.
Sam: It seems like he would be great in other things if he was like forty years younger, even if he had like a Jack Nicholson-ish career, if he made it to the 1990s.
Joe: I just don't have many notes on him.
Sam: This movie made me want to watch more movies with him. I've been on a pretty big kick of watching a lot of Hitchcock movies lately, and that inherently goes with watching a lot of Jimmy Stewart or Cary Grant movies. They're great! They are really good actors, and that is the reason those actors are still "around." So I feel like I'll pound some Olivier movies. I'm not super interested in watching Shakespeare movies. I'm more interested in watching original movies where I don't sort of know what's going on already.
Joe: Well that's interesting—
Sam: I like to read Shakespeare. I'm not against Shakespeare or anything.
Joe: Let's connect at least three things you've said in the past two minutes.
Sam: Okay.
Joe: Hitchcock's Rear Window, you wrote about that on Puke on Your Birthday. You said that you liked movies that seemed like a play. Which is this, and which is Olivier's whole fucking thing.
[More Mount Airy neighbors yelling from the sidewalk.]
Joe: At least three middle-aged women have yelled to you so far from the sidewalk.
Sam: Just two. Two of them were the same woman twice.
Hannah: This is the excitement of Mount Airy, Joe!
Joe: What would that lady think about Sleuth?
Hannah: She'd love it.
Sam: Well she was just yelling a reference to "The Hounds of Baskervilles," which is a Sherlock Holmes story.
Joe: Did she really? Why did she say that?
Sam: Because all those dogs are barking over there.
Hannah: Because she's listening to our conversation.
Sam: And when you go back and listen to this conversation, it will be inaudible because of all those dogs barking.
Joe: What were we talking about?
Sam: Rear Window.
Joe: How you like movies that are like plays.
Sam: I like movies with people talking. I like crisp, good dialogue. That's not necessarily Hitchcock's thing, but it was in Rear Window, to an extent. I really liked Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? too.
Joe: Talky.
Sam: Sure. I liked the Linklater Before Sunset movies. Two people, walking around, talking about life. I can get into that. I think it's a niche thing. I think it's hard to be a commercially successful thing when you do that. When something hits the right path, and has the right charisma, I like that.
Joe: The Ringer posted an article today—"Top 20 Bottle Episodes." Not all the episodes were technically bottle episodes, but they all featured the same idea, in that they were an episode of TV featuring people just talking, and that's it. Every episode that I had seen on that list, I loved. So I'm right there with ya. I love this type of shit. I love people bouncing ideas off each other over an extended period of time. It makes me feel smart, I guess? Which is not something I feel often? Maybe that's the wrong way of putting it.
Sam: Well I think the fly-on-the-wall feeling of, "Wow, there's a very intelligent thing happening in front of me here, can I absorb this?" Interesting concepts that I have never thought about in this way. Even though I enjoy action movies, you don't explore that in the same way.
Joe: You don't think about it later, like, "Ah, that was a good point that that character made."
Sam: Later, in different scenarios. Do you [Hannah] like when people talk this much in movies?
Hannah: I think just the volume of talking, the cadence, the points being made. There's a lot more that went into this movie besides the talking that made this movie great, right? The tone, the speed, the back-and-forth. I think that's also a lot of it.
Joe: So if Michael Caine and Laurence Olivier sat on a stage with no setting, no props, no sound effects, no score, and they read this script, would it be as exciting?
Hannah: Obviously not. It couldn't be as exciting.
Joe: But would that be a good movie?
Hannah: No.
Sam: In person, that might be interesting.
Joe: Like, over Zoom in 2020?
Sam: I mean, it might be fine because it's not eight people interjecting. But this again goes back to the balancing point we were making before. That's good art, right? Balancing the medicine of dialogue with the plot, and action, and interesting shit happening. That's why it's hard to do. It can't just be two people talking. That's why all these podcasts are shitty—
Joe: Shitty. Full stop.
Sam: No, podcasts are great. This should be a podcast. But no, there's an art to it.
Joe: Are you familiar with the term "mise-en-scène"?
Sam: I don't think so. I'm not going to pretend I do.
Joe: I learned this phrase so we could have another way of talking about the movie. Apparently this is a critic's phrase, that describes how every aspect of a scene is trying to tell you something. Like, "this particularly scene has a good mise-en-scène because of the lighting, because of the motivation of the character ,because of where it is set." That's the mise-en-scène .
Hannah: What does "mise-en-scène" mean? Is is French?
Joe: I think it is French, and it literally means "place on stage" or something. Okay, well, this is me trying to reflect the movie into this interview. This is me being your rival, saying that I know the movie more than you.
Sam: Yes!
Joe: I'm kidding.
Sam: Or is this particular setting, on this porch, during COVID, on a summer night, with murder mystery themes—
Joe: A year ago Sam said that we don't talk about the movies enough in these interviews, so I'm trying to drop some fucking French words into them.
Sam: Is there a particularly scene in this movie that has a notable mise-en-scène that people like?
Joe: I don't fucking know, man.
Sam: Let's talk about the opening scene of the movie for a second then, because I think it could be what you're talking about. Michael Caine is forced to go through this puzzle to find Laurence Olivier.
Joe: I thought you were going to say about during the intro credits, when they were doing the close-ups of the little puppets.
Sam: Oh. I was talking about the maze.
Joe: Okay, so mise-en-scène. What is the setting of the maze trying to tell you about the scene?
Sam: That it's a game. Laurence Olivier is forcing him to do this thing. Part of the dialogue is—well the backdrop of it is Laurence Olivier doing a voiceover for a murder mystery novel that he's writing. Death by Double Fault. And when they get into the scene together, it's just a very passive-aggressive dialogue. He offers to give him a drink, but has none of the things that Michael Caine wants in the drink. Or maybe he does have all those things, and doesn't want to give them to Michael Caine.
Hannah: He does have booze hidden in a statue. That was cool.
Sam: All of that was cool.
Joe: Mise-en-scène. All that setting, the props and shit, tell us about Andrew, about how he is mischievous and deceiving.
Sam: And yet he is only comfortable when he is the one making the rules.
Joe: So is there a scene that, besides the dialogue, tells us that the roles have flipped, and now Andrew is the subjugate, and Milo is running the gambit?
Sam: I can't remember the scene exactly, but we talked about when Milo starts to use the puppet against Andrew.
Joe: Especially at the end when he's holding all the buttons, and all the toys are laughing at him. I don't know, should we run through the mise-en-scène aspects, and you can talk about your favorite examples?
Sam: I think you're going to have to delete this. [Editor's note: I was tempted to. Sorry for pressing this very boring mise-en-scène point so hard, everybody.]
Joe: There's certain aspects of any particular scene that could add onto the sense of mise-en-scène, i.e. what the filmmaker is trying to say about that scene. The first is setting—there aren't too many in this movie—what about the setting any particular scene tells us what we should be feeling about the movie?
Sam: I can only picture... it's important when they go down to the basement, it seems.
Joe: So what about the basement tells us about what we should be feeling about the characters or the plot or the overall feeling of the movie? Based on where they are.
Sam: Well, early in the movie, it's where Andrew feels most in control. And he exploits Milo in a lot of different ways. He makes him dress up, he scares him with the skeleton, he makes him look through all the novels he's written. It's demonstrating his power of him.
Joe: And now that I'm thinking about it, the camera was looking up the steps whenever the action moved to the basement. Whoever was in control stayed at the top of the steps, and whoever wasn't was fluttering around in the basement.
Sam: I don't remember the order of who came down first.
Joe: But when Andrew was looking for clues about his girlfriend's death, he was down in the basement, and Milo was at the top of the steps, acting haughty. So the mise-en-scène—I'm going to keep using that term—
Sam: Yeah, you're really hitting it.
Hannah: Is this what your readers care about, Joe?
Joe: Absolutely not. They've already stopped reading. Do you care about this? Should I keep going?
Sam: Finish this exercise.
Joe: About the basement, or in general? Should we keep talking about the basics of filmmaking process? Should we keep talking about the filmmaker's meant about the particulars of the movie, or should we move on? Do you give a shit about the setting, or the decor, or the lighting of the movie?
Sam: I... do... I don't care about mise-en-scène. [laughter]
Joe: I'm trying to say that's an umbrella term for talking about shit that I normally wouldn't care about. If you want to talk about the lighting of any particular part of the movie, then a movie critic would be talking about the "mise-en-scène" of the movie, because of the lighting.
Sam: I don't know enough about the lighting to talk about this movie in that way. Hannah doesn't want to talk about this anymore.
Hannah: I'm going to go to bed. [laughter] Which may be an indication for how your readers will be feeling at this point.
Sam: Let's do a little lightning round with Hannah, though.
Joe: Okay. Hannah. Do you believe this movie is pro-cop? [laughter]
Sam: The murder mystery genre does fall victim to that.
Hannah: No, I think this Blue Lives Neutral. [laughter]
Joe: I guess it depends on how you feel about each particular character. Andrew, as a writer, feels that cops are stupid, and writes to that effect. Milo, who dresses up as a cop, tries to prove Andrew wrong.
Hannah: But it's more about them, and each other, and not about cops. We don't have to make this about cops.
Sam: Andrew does make that point several times, though. But I do think it's just a "you're not as smart as you think you are" thing. Because a cop wouldn't have picked up on all that shit, because a cop wasn't in that house, doing all that. Milo was portraying a hyper-alert cop. There's no way anyone else would've picked up on all that stuff.
Joe: Okay, so last summer, Sam said that the Harry Potter album we were reviewing was "art for nerds." Do you feel like Sleuth is "art for nerds," or can the general populace appreciate this movie?
Hannah: I think people in general can appreciate this movie. I think it plays to different levels of intellect.
Sam: The recent example of this movie was Knives Out, and people liked it. It did better at the box office than it did at award season. Around Christmas, it was a good movie people wanted to see. I heard people talking about it! I was at court and the judge was like "I saw this movie the other day, it was a good movie."
Joe: But the judge's older sister isn't coming into the room saying "This is a fucking nerdy movie!"? [laughter]
Hannah: No, I think it can be appreciated. It's really about... practical jokes, ya know?
Joe: What about the Britishness of it?
Sam: It's pretty British.
Joe: I know just from what you've written about on the blog that you are a lot more tolerant of British art than I am.
Sam: Most of those things, Hannah and I watched together.
Hannah: What aren't you tolerant of?
Joe: I just have trouble with understanding what they are saying. British accents in general.
Hannah: Maybe that is a barrier to entry for this movie.
Joe: But do you feel like... say, besides that, if I have no interest in watching The Crown, because of the Britishness of the show—or Downton Abbey, that's probably a better example—if I had no interest in watching that because of the fact that it is a British show and it employs British drama tropes—meaning I have no appreciation of those tropes—is there anything about Sleuth that would make me feel the same way?
Hannah: I think to appreciate who the rich character is, you have to appreciate what a crime novelist would write. They reference a lot of Sherlock Holmes-type stuff.
Joe: Which is British art.
Hannah: Yeah. You could probably translate that to an American-type crime novel, but if you can't...
Sam: I don't think you're ever supposed to believe that Andrew is like Shakespeare. I think you're supposed to believe that he is, at best, Stephen King. Or Dean Koontz, or Dan Brown or whatever. I feel like the barrier of entry would be: Can you tolerate Frasier? [laughter] As an American person, if Frasier is too high-brow for you, then maybe...
Hannah: Frasier is a great example though. Because he's a person like that, but he's playing against people who aren't like that. Like his dad, right? Frasier is a great comparison.
Sam: So if you can't get past the idea of what you think Frasier is...
Joe: And Frasier is only a lovable character because he's playing against the non-pretentious characters.
Hannah: I took Milo to be more like Frasier's dad. A normal dude, kind of gullible. Kind of a clown.
Joe: I'm going to look for another question, since I've never watched Frasier. But I have seen the fourth and fifth seasons of Cheers.
Hannah: So if I were to say "tossed salad and scrambled eggs," that means nothing to you?
Joe: I know that's the theme song to Frasier!
Sam: I think that Frasier is a series of whodunit murder mystery plots, essentially. There's never a murder, but a caper is occurring, and everyone is in the scene, and everything moves around really quickly, and you have to figure it out.
Joe: One person is hiding something. Is that a British thing?
Hannah: I don't know.
Sam: I think these types of movies are British often, or at least European.
Hannah: Did you ask the caviar question?
Sam: I did not ask the caviar question.
Joe: What is the caviar question?
Hannah: Do people just eat caviar for dinner? That seems like a non-realistic rich person thing to do!
Joe: Does someone do that here?
Hannah: After intermission.
Sam: Before the inspector comes. When the inspector comes in, Andrew is eating caviar on toast.
Joe: I guess I do remember this.
Sam: And the inspector is like [Michael Caine-as-inspector impression] "Hmm, I've never had this."
Joe: Maybe that was a moviemaking choice, like, "How can we show that this is an accomplished asshole? Have him eat caviar on toast."
Hannah: Did Sam talk at all about his grandfather?
Joe: No.
Hannah: I think this would be something your readers would appreciate. Before you put on the movie, you talked about what this meant to you in relationship to your grandfather.
Joe: Tell me about your granddad. Tell me about how he was an Andrew or a Milo. [laughter]
Sam: So, my entrance to the movie was that there was a period of time in the late-'90s, early 2000s, when my family was tape-recording a lot of things for each other. Whoever had HBO would record The Sopranos and Six Feet Under. We had Turner Classic Movies, so I was recording a lot of movies for my grandfather, who was a big movie buff—a big Old Hollywood person.
Joe: [laughter] Sure. A big Laurence Olivier fan.
Sam: He would just call me, and I would record—he would go through Inquirer's TV guide section.
Joe: I can picture it.
Sam: He would be like, "Okay..." And I would program my VCR, and record however many movies I could get onto three VHS tapes. I don't know if he asked me to record this, or if I had started watching older movies because I was doing that. And I came across this movie.
Joe: So you were watching these movies as you were recording them?
Sam: Sometimes I would, or sometimes he would say, "Oh, this is a really good one." He was a fairly important figure in my development, my consciousness of "shit I like," and who I am in a lot of ways. I got in the habit of watching older movies and appreciating them, or at least getting past the "old black-and-white movie" barrier. Even though this is a color movie. But I don't know if he asked me to record this, or I watched it myself. Without that, I would not have seen this movie.
Joe: So that was the first time you saw this movie.
Sam: When it was on Turner Classic Movies in like 1998. Before this, it was the only time I had ever seen it.
Joe: Yeah? And that impacted you enough that in the summer of 2019, you were able to still say that it was your favorite movie?
Hannah: That's what I thought was really interesting.
Sam: I mean, Hannah and I are both like... we don't like to watch movies multiple times. Especially now. I only have a finite amount of time. I don't have time for retreads. I would like to experience something new. So while there other, more classical movies that fit the style of this project... I don't know. I've just liked this movie for a long time. And the reveal was just so shocking to me, that Michael Caine was the inspector. All the trappings around this movie were so interesting.
Joe: It's interesting to me, though, because there are plenty of movies with shocking reveals. But no one has ever told me that their favorite movie is their favorite because of a shocking reveal. And I'm not trying to say that's not a valid reason. But why hasn't anyone said something like The Sixth Sense?
Hannah: Especially if someone saw The Sixth Sense once twenty years ago.
Sam: Which I did, and it was!
Joe: Great fucking movie. Possibly because of the reveal? But what about Sam says that a shocking movie reveal means more to you than it would someone else?
Sam: Story is always important to me. I like the idea of being told something interesting, something new that's interesting, and being surprised is interesting to me. I think, over time, you see the same things often. There are a lot of patterns in life. Like, I feel like I've seen all the people that exist in the world. Either physically, or type. I just know what everyone is. Music is the same way—you're just a version of a thing that I've already heard.
Joe: Every review can be a comparison—"this sounds like X," or "this sounds like Y."
Sam: Which is the struggle with Record Club. So the first time you hear something, the first time you see a thing, the first time you're "twisted," in a way, I think is formative. And, I don't know, this movie just got me at the right time. It stuck with me. And thank god had it had all these other elements to it when I watched it twenty years later.
[Editor's note: Forgot to mention that Sam was trying to clean Maggie's stroller while we are talking about this.]
Hannah: Can I pause this right now? You're driving me nuts. These [Clorox wipes] are a commodity. We only have so many of these. And you are literally rubbing the same spot on the stroller over and over, and throwing them on the ground. In the dark. So my ask to you would be: Clean the wheels, roll it inside, and in the light tomorrow, will not use our precious commodity to clean the same spot over and over again. You don't need to do this right now. You're talking to Joe. You don't need to do this right now.
Joe: [laughter] Do you feel like that monologue could be applied to either Milo or Andrew?
Hannah: [laughter] What is the precious commodity in Sleuth? "You're wasting the caviar!"
Joe: The wife probably, right? And Andrew is just rubbing the same spot over and over again. [laughter] While me and Jack Tar, the third-party jackals, are just laughing.
Hannah: Well we learned later that he wasn't rubbing that spot, right? Téa [Andrew's mistress] was like, "Listen... he's not rubbing my spot."
Joe: Right, she said he was impotent. Do we believe Milo when he's saying that?
Hannah: What does he have to lose?
Joe: I dunno, I kind of thought that Milo was just getting heated, and was dropping ever barb he could on Andrew. Because he was "in the lead."
Sam: Let me grab one more Clorox wipe to clean these wheels. [laughter]
Hannah: But don't you see what I'm saying? I was watching you do that, and it just felt so silly.
Sam: I was thinking that every time I rubbed it, it got more dirt.
Hannah: But you're doing this in the dark! Don't do this in the dark.
Joe: [laughter]
Hannah: Joe's laughing because he knows he would get yelled at for the same exact thing. Let the record show that Clorox wipes, during the 2020 COVID crisis, were a rare commodity.
Sam: You can't buy them anywhere.
Hannah: Alright, that's it for me.
[Hannah exits stage left.]
Sam: I want to be your longest interview, Joe. I want no one to read this. Who's your longest one so far?
Joe: Me and Pam talked about Dazed and Confused for a while.
Sam: I wonder how many people read it?
Joe: Three? Alright, choose your own adventure again. Do you want to talk about Oscars or Klosterman?
Sam: Ah, yeah, let's talk about Klosterman.
Joe: Okay, at this point I will direct readers to the Klosterman essay. [Editor's note: Here ya go.] Do we think that Andrew and Milo are nemeses or archenemies?
Sam: Well, one does shoot the other. Actually, they both shoot each other. Wait, no, one shoots the other one twice.
Joe: So probably archenemy?
Sam: Maybe it's different for both of them.
Joe: I feel like maybe they come into this relationship thinking that it's going to be a nemesis situation. But once that blank's fired, they are archenemies for life.
Sam: Is it possible that Andrew wants this person, who sleeps with his wife and is trying to take over—that's it.
Joe: That marks him as the archenemy?
Sam: It's not so much that he's sleeping with his wife, it's that Milo is trying to infiltrate into his world. He has a cottage in their area during the summer, ostensibly to sleep with this guy's wife during that time. Not only is he quietly doing it away from me, he's doing it here, in my area. That's too far. I'm going to hate you forever. Archenemy.
Joe: Do you feel like Milo is approaching it from the same direction?
Sam: No. He's more of a rival. He's a problem.
Joe: As far as Milo is concerned, Andrew and his wife might as well be divorced anyway. They're not banging, they didn't have any type of relationship, Andrew's wife hates him, at least according to Milo.
Sam: And Andrew has a mistress!
Joe: That's right. Exactly. So Milo could come into this thinking that Andrew is a nemesis.
Sam: And based on who Milo is, he's probably slept with other dudes' wives before. We're lead to believe that he was a lothario who is doing that kind of stuff. As a hairdresser too. He's definitely a hairdresser, I don't know what Hannah was talking about. [laughter]
Joe: I guess as far as the nemesis/archenemy thing goes, Milo shows up at the house of the husband of his mistress. That requires some balls. And that would require him to think about Andrew as a nemesis. Because if he thought of him as an archenemy—
Sam: He would never deign to show up in the first place.
Joe: Right.
Sam: And he's never even met him before. I guess at the beginning, how could they be archenemies?
Joe: They know of each other, probably. Is it possible to be an archenemy of someone you've never met?
Sam: And never had communication with?
Joe: Well let me ask you: do you have an archenemy?
Sam: Ah, I knew it was going to come to this.
Joe: Is that on your Your Favorite Movie tropes list?
Sam: More like, turning a portion of the movie back on the person.
Joe: Alright, readers, drink up.
Sam: At this point, I don't think I have an archenemy. In college, there was a dude I particularly didn't like. I feel like I was constantly bombarded with him across all the things that I did. We were in the same Freshman double, which is FYO ["First-Year Orientation"] and two classes you take together. He wrote for the newspaper, and he played frisbee.
Joe: Who? I'll redact it.
Sam: [REDACTED] He might've lived with Stephan at some point? In an assigned-housing way. And he hung out with Masque people, because he was dating Alyssa O***** at one point. But I was constantly in these scenarios where he... I just thought he fucking sucked. And we had enough similar interests where we were always around each other. He was... "sycophant" isn't the right word. He was just a stoner, rich dude from Connecticut, who would know I was going somewhere, leach onto me, go to the thing I was going to, I would begrudgingly take him, and then he would do something like drink all of one person's alcohol and throw up. And we weren't even friends, I didn't even want to bring him there.
Joe: It almost, to me, sounds like a nemesis.
Sam: Yeah, because I was breaking bread with him. He was very pockmarked, and someone we played frisbee with said he looked like "the clown from Saw." And we all referred to him as "Saw."
Joe: Oh no. Okay, that sounds like archenemy talk. [laughter]
Sam: We were playing frisbee one time, and usually at the beginning of a possession, you would throw the frisbee and say who you got, and I was like, "Alright, I got Saw." And someone was like, "Hey man, you can't say that. He doesn't know he's called that." That is the person I immediately thought of. There are probably more folks.
Joe: But you also strike me as the type of person who would want to see the best in people. And that's not necessarily conducive to having nemeses and archenemies.
Sam: But I don't mind petty grievances either. What, are you saying that Mehow is yours? In a cartoonish part of your life, he was probably your archenemy.
Joe: Absolutely, but I'm well past that.
Sam: And you don't really give a shit about that dude at this point?
Joe: No... well, I care only in that I don't want any petty-ass, decade-and-a-half bad blood to be just chilling, between me and some person I haven't seen in ten years. At one point, sure, but I think it's a good example about how I now try not to be anyone's archenemy. At this point. What would be the purpose of hanging on to that?
Sam: Only seeing it through your lens, it did seem like you guys were archenemies.
Joe: Absolutely.
Sam: It seemed as if he was directly targeting you, and it seemed as if you were reaching out toward him.
Joe: Look, there is plenty of ancient evidence that I could drop right now, that, yeah, that if I was trying to make that case, that I'm the Milo, and Mehow is the Andrew...
Sam: But he would shoot you in the chest, in that scenario.
Joe: I guess he would've. And then what would've been Jack Tar in that situation? Wait, no, this wasn't the point of me bringing this up. To talk about this. You brought Mehow up!
Sam: Aha! Turning it back around on you.
Joe: I've already talked about him in at least one other interview.
Sam: In the Oldboy episode, right?
Joe: That was the main one, and that made the most sense. I guess that was an archenemy talk we were having. Do you have a nemesis? Okay, first, can Andrew and Milo be considered nemeses at any point? At least according to Klosterman.
Sam: Yeah, I think so. Because Milo comes back.
Joe: They are very cordial toward each other, despite the fact that they are into the same woman. But it's more of a tricky situation. I feel like Klosterman nailed it when he said that this idea of nemeses and archenemies in general is more of a woman thing. We won't name names, but you can probably think of a nemesis for Hannah, and I can definitely think of a nemesis for Pam. Easily. But I can't think of an nemesis for myself.
Sam: And I don't think Hannah would say the same thing I said about myself. I don't even think she would know who that guy is. Which should prove how important he is, if the woman I've been dating for the past thirteen years doesn't know who he is.
Joe: The point of archenemy is that you don't want to give them the time of day, and your wife shouldn't know who he is, because if she did then she would know how important it is to you, and that would be a detriment to you, as the archenemy.
Sam: It would just be an internal struggle. That if a scenario is brought up, then you will exterminate it immediately, without hesitation.
Joe: But as a nemesis, your wife would have to know that, because you would have to set boundaries on how she could respond, because it's a delicate act of social interaction. Which, like I said, that's totally how it was at the beginning of the movie. They were feeling each other out. I feel like the first act was them being nemeses, and then the blank was fired, and Milo pissed himself, and they became archenemies.
Sam: I like the idea of it, but without a personal history between them, I think that particularly dynamic is harder to find.
Joe: True. I almost wonder if it would be more interesting—would this movie exist if Andrew was into the idea of an open marriage?
Sam: But again, I go back to this point—I don't think he was necessarily opposed to the idea of his wife cheating on him. He was more opposed to the idea of his wife leaving him, because he had this possessive interest in him.
Joe: I guess. I dunno. I feel like the whole possessive thing, and the whole "I don't give a shit if you're banging her just don't steal my toys," I feel like that was all a front. I feel like he gave a shit. I feel like he really gave a shit. And the fact that he was trying so hard to one-up Milo, he had to play it cool.
Sam: Or do you think Milo mattered? Do think this is the first guy that she cheated on Andrew with? That she slept with other guys, but the fact that she was going to leave him for Milo—
Joe: I feel like if you asked Andrew that question, then the answer would be that Milo didn't matter, and that Milo wasn't even a turd below his shoe. But in the grand scheme of things, of course he was important. It was so important that he had to set up this elaborate fucking thing to make Milo feel like he was going to die.
Sam: It was so elaborate. But he's also a murder mystery writer, so maybe it came off like that to us.
Joe: But where's the line between "I'm just having fun" versus "I'm trying to scare the living daylights out of my cuckold"? I feel like it skewed toward the latter.
Sam: Was it too unbelievable?
Joe: The whole scenario?
Sam: Why would Milo be like, "Yes, I believe that you really want me to steal these jewels." It's hard to buy that. I would be suspicious.
Joe: Sure, absolutely. But maybe it was a matter of having dollar sign pupils. If someone came up off the street to your porch and was like, "I'll give you $80 if you're able to grab it out of my pocket." Would you do it?
Sam: No.
Joe: Even if it was such a simple task like grabbing it out of his pocket?
Sam: Can I see the bills?
Joe: Sure.
Sam: They're like hanging out of his pocket?
Joe: Yeah.
Sam: I would be like, "I dunno man, get out of here."
Joe: If someone is walking up to your porch unannounced, and saying that you can have $80 if you do a simple task. I dunno, I would think twice. I might try to grab it. And Milo—
Sam: He thought twice. Initially, he was like, "No."
Joe: He saw the amount of money. He saw the amount of zeroes.
Sam: And he saw the bottom line of his beauty shop.
Joe: Andrew was a good enough convincer, that he should take the opportunity.
Sam: But wouldn't you think he would do it in the middle of the night? He's going to wear a clown outfit and run through the yard. And Andrew is yelling at him as he's breaking into the house. What's the ruse? Why does he have to do any of that?
Joe: To me, that felt like more of a movie appreciation than a reality appreciation.
Sam: And it's very British. It's very slapstick-y. He's walking up the ladder in the biggest way he possibly could, and the ladder is like falling out of his hands as he does it.
Joe: The camera is capturing the whole grounds, and you just see him in these huge shoes, tripping over the ladder. It was good. It was at the point where I was like, "Okay, this is going to be a good movie." Because it was funny, I guess. I wasn't thinking about "is this realistic?" at that point.
Sam: When he's dressing him up in the outfit, and they're being silly... yeah, it's all very fun at that point.
Joe: It's a fun movie in general. Even the point when the gun is being pointed in someone else's face—it's such a heightened sense of drama, that we as the audience can enjoy it.
Sam: That was a pretty high-stakes scene.
Joe: Did you feel like connected to that scene? Like, were you nervous for him when he had a gun in his face?
Sam: I might've felt more nervous about it this time, even knowing the outcome. I did not recall the focus they put on Michael Caine grappling with the fact that he was going to die. Which comes up later, and I thought it was pretty powerful. I think this movie is better than a murder mystery because the focus on the two characters is so important. It's a very good character study. It's not about solving the thing. Solving the three ruses are kind of MacGuffins. They don't really matter. We're really just looking at these two dudes, and their motivations, and the extremes that they will go to. That's outside of what a lot of what these murder mystery movies do. You don't get that depth of character. You just get the smug detective who knows what's happening, who's smarter than everyone else. And even though I consume a lot of these movies, and I read Sherlock Holmes short stories, there's a little bit to me of "Well, you're just writing this, so you can just make it up." I liked that it mattered less what actually happens in Sleuth. Even though they tied it up pretty well. The last half hour did drag a little bit though.
Joe: What, with him finding the "clues"?
Sam: Yeah. I honestly didn't remember whether Téa had died or not. I was happy that she didn't die. If she does die, then this movie is way darker, and more intense and crazy.
Joe: Look, having seen 2007 Sleuth, where they cut the whole last half hour, I would say it's necessary. If you're trying to figure out who "wins" the "best out of three match," then... well, I don't want to say the winner is definitive, but there's a lot more to the "third match" in the 1972 version.
Sam: Sure. There's a lot there, it's very dark. It's more reminiscent of the first act. The second act is more of a romp—the inspector is insinuating "it doesn't matter if there isn't a body," but Laurence Olivier knows that he didn't kill Milo. He's not dead. He has in his head that "I'm a rich dude in this particular area, I know I didn't kill him. I can figure this out. I'm not just going to go to jail." Whereas in the third act, he does not know what's happening. And it's so clever that Michael Caine has devised a ruse within a ruse. But... what happens at the end? There are cops coming, right? How does that happen?
Joe: I guess Milo has assumed that he was going to push it too far, so far that he was going to be injured in some way, and was going to require police assistance. So when he did push Andrew so far that he was shot, the timing worked out that the police were actually coming to the house. Andrew realized at that point that he had been pushed so far that he "lost." And Milo knew that he "won"—even though Milo was also literally dying, he knew that he won. That was more important to him than life itself.
Sam: That's kind of an afterthought in the movie.
Joe: How so?
Sam: We don't dwell on it, it just happens very quickly.
Joe: What, the final gunshot?
Sam: Yeah. Well, obviously the movie has an end. There are repercussions. A lot of fallout after the first two ruses. And this is the third ruse. You really think he preemptively called the police before the night?
Joe: Are you asking me whether the movie wants me to think that, or that it's believable in real life?
Sam: I just didn't understand what was happening. Why are the police coming? You're saying it's because Milo said "Come at ten o'clock" or whatever... because "I know at ten o'clock I'll be shot"?
Joe: Maybe not necessarily shot, but "I'm going to be in this situation where I need the police."
Sam: And the police were like, "Yeah, sure, we'll show up"? Not even that, but "we'll sound the alarms." I know, movie magic and all that...
Joe: Hey man, British police.
Sam: In a small town
Joe: British police stand in front of the queen's palace for hours at a time without moving, so they are pretty crazy in general.
Sam: Yeah, that last little bit needed more grounding for me. I don't know.
Joe: Well—and let's say this is the final time I mention the 2007 version—there is nothing like that in the 2007 version. They cut the whole third act. They're acting like they're going to make out, and all of sudden, Andrew shoots Milo, and Milo falls down three stories and dies. Cut to credits. No police involvement.
Sam: I mean, I really don't want to watch that movie. Is the dialogue enjoyable?
Joe: Yeah... I think... it's comparable to the old one? In terms of it being a witty back-and-forth? I don't think Michael Caine portrays the character as well as Olivier does. I don't think Laurence Olivier had high aspirations beforehand—and this is my segue into other random bullshit I have written in my notes. According to the playwriter, Anthony Schaffer—and the play opened in 1970, written by Anthony Schaffer, who also ended up writing the screenplay as well. But apparently, in 1970 or '71, Laurence Olivier attended the play, and asked the person playing Andrew "Why are you doing this shit?" basically. And Anthony Schaffer was like, "Yeah, he sure wasn't saying that a couple years later."
Sam: Interesting.
Joe: Yeah. He also said—
Sam: Olivier?
Joe: Schaffer also said that Michael Caine felt really weird around Laurence Olivier at first? That Laurence Olivier was this big name, and Michael Caine wasn't as big at the time. I guess they themselves felt like rivals for a while.
Sam: I like that. I feel like that type of energy feeds really well into a movie like this.
Joe: For sure. I guess Michael Caine, off camera, made a crack about some other Old Hollywood leading man bedding every woman he ever costarred in a movie with, and one of his old costars was Laurence Olivier's wife, so they were pissed at each other or whatever. So it kind of reflected behind the camera a little bit.
Sam: There does seem to be a real tension between them
Joe: They definitely did a good job with that, regardless of what I have to say about Michael Caine's performance. I thought he did a good job in this. And I think he does a good job in Muppet Christmas Carol.
Sam: He's a good Scrooge.
Joe: He definitely does the same yell when he gets shot with a blank bullet in this movie, and when the light goes off in his apartment, right before the Marleys get there, and he's beating his coat rack in Muppet Christmas Carol—[screams in cockney accent].
Sam: I mean, you only have so many notes that you can play. You have to use them in the right scenarios.
Joe: You know what, if he's channeling Milo Tindle in Muppet Christmas Carol, then that's fucking great. I'm into it.
Sam: Wait, now that you say that—there's a shot of Milo's car hidden, halfway through the movie. What was the significance of that?
Joe: That was the second shot of the car. The first shot was when he was getting in the car briefly. They had zoomed in on his initials. And later on, they zoomed in again when it was in the woods, as if to say that "it's possible that Milo was murdered!"
Sam: And that Andrew hid the car.
Joe: So I guess the eventual assumption is that Milo hid his own car?
Sam: That makes sense. It seems unnecessary.
Joe: As is the constant cutting away to all the automata in his room. Let's talk about the Oscars, because I thought a lot about the 1973 Oscars were interesting.
Sam: Yeah, I didn't look this up. I was surprised this would get nominated for anything.
Joe: This was one of three movies in history for which every actor was nominated for an acting Oscar. One of the other ones was Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, where all four got nominated. All two actors in Sleuth got nominated for Best Actor.
Sam: Oh, Best Leading Actor? Which I guess, that would never happen again, right? They would never do that.
Joe: Probably the most recent example was Friends, where they all refused to be "Supporting Actor."
Sam: It would have to be some morality shit. But that's right, there's no "supporting actor" in this movie. They are both lead.
Joe: Apparently there was a third movie that was just one actor, and he was nominated, so fuck him. But, yeah, so they were both nominated for Best Actor.
Sam: Neither won?
Joe: Neither won. Marlon Brando won for The Godfather.
Sam: And he's a supporting character in that!
Joe: It's been a while since I've seen that.
Sam: Isn't Al Pacino the lead?
Joe: Who's to say with the Oscars, man. The Oscars gave it to Brando. Brando refused to show up. He was boycotting.
Sam: And the Indian went on stage?
Joe: Yup. He said how Hollywood degrades Native Americans in their movies.
Sam: Which is fair.
Joe: Which is absolutely fair, but I was curious about how Caine and Olivier felt in the audience, like, "The fuck? I'll take that award." We can assume they were—not pissed, but disappointed, like, "Just give me the award?"
Sam: "I would just be a normal person about this." [laughter] They obviously split the vote.
Joe: That's possible!
Sam: Prosperity would say that if either one won over Brando, it would be undeserved.
Joe: You think it would be undeserved if they beat the Godfather?
Sam: It's an iconic role. It's a role for an A-list actor.
Joe: But you're saying from the Academy's perspective. I'm asking from a Sam perspective. Who acted better, Marlon Brando in Godfather, or Laurence Olivier in Sleuth?
Sam: That's a good question, Joe. That's why I kept this as my favorite movie. The Godfather is not my favorite movie.
Joe: If we're talking iconic roles, sure. Any fucking ten-year-old could do a Marlon Brando impression. Doesn't that piss you off, though, that that would even be a question? Me and you both know that Laurence Olivier did better in Sleuth than Marlon Brando did in Godfather.
Sam: Brando is just doing Brando at that time.
Joe: But I don't even know shit about Marlon Brando besides this, and maybe Apocalypse Now where he acted in the shadows.
Sam: Brando's good. I'm not gonna talk shit on Brando.
Joe: Sure, but the Academy is absolutely going to see Brando in this "iconic role" and give him the award, just because of that. As opposed to the actual substance and depth of that particular role.
Sam: It's not like Laurence Olivier was some up-and-coming actor. He is a dude who's won a couple awards.
Joe: Okay, so let's talk about another award that Sleuth lost, and it was Original Score.
Sam: I love the score, but it's so goofy-'70s-movie.
Joe: Absolutely. And in fact, it was the sixth movie nominated, because Godfather was originally nominated, but then later on they found out that the Godfather score borrowed themes from the composer's movie from like three years prior. It was "original." So they had to re-vote, and they chose John Addison's Sleuth score.
Sam: And it did not win.
Joe: Yeah, so anyway, it lost to Charlie Chaplin, for a movie that Charlie Chaplin had scored—yes, scored—a 20-year-old movie that wasn't screened in L.A. until 20 years after it was released in general. So if anyone wants to tell me that the Academy isn't a bunch of fucking starfuckers, then talk to me about how Charlie Chaplin won for scoring a 20-year-old movie in 1973.
Sam: Well, I mean, the Academy has changed a lot. Diversity is important now. the voting body is a lot different at this point in time.
Joe: They're still starfuckers.
Sam: Starfucking is done! Moonlight won a couple years ago, and Parasite won last year! Things are changing.
Joe: You can name the exceptions to the rule, if you want.
Sam: I think they're getting better, and they are listening to people griping about it for a long time.
Joe: Tell me if this is the norm or the exception, the loss in Best Director. Mankiewicz lost to Bob Fosse, which I know you know because you wrote about Fosse/Verdon. He directed Cabaret.
Sam: Cabaret is supposed to be very avant-garde, very different. So I don't know, what's the directorial beauty in Sleuth that's innovative?
Joe: You tell me.
Sam: I think... Joe, there's a thing called "mise-en-scène" that's very important.
Joe: [laughter] Not to the academy, apparently!
Sam: I have not seen Cabaret. Cabaret is supposed to be visionary and different, so... visionary and different are things they like. I can see "visionary" and "different" being reasons they give something Best Director, versus Picture. And that's why they are two different categories. It's hard to comment. I know Cabaret is supposed to be important.
Joe: Because Bob Fosse is important.
Sam: I mean, he's a fucking psychopath.
Joe: Well, the Academy loves psychopaths... Okay, here ya go. Let's circle back to three hours ago, when you watched it through an illegal stream. Apparently the prescription company Bristol Myers Squibb owns the streaming rights to this movie. And that's why it's not streaming anywhere.
Sam: Because they're not selling it? They're just not distributing it for some reason?
Joe: Apparently in the 1970s, they were like, "Yeah, let's buy up a couple movies."
Sam: And at this point they are just sitting on them?
Joe: Yeah, "Why should we give these properties to anyone else?"
Sam: But wouldn't they make some money selling it to Netflix?
Joe: Would they?
Sam: Is it so incremental—?
Joe: Or, does Netflix have any motivation to buy 1972's Sleuth? I wish they would, it's a good fucking movie. But how many fucking views is Netflix going to get?
Sam: Sure. Bristol Myers Squibb is not incentivized to allow cable platforms to rent or sell it?
Joe: They have no motivation to go above and beyond to let other people get their properties.
Sam: But they're not making any money on it now by letting it sit.
Joe: They don't give a shit. Well, okay, we're talking about the same thing. Bristol Myers Squibb makes billions and billions of dollars for price-gouging mediation, basically. It's because of their scumbaggery that we had to illegally download this great movie.
Sam: But they are acting against their own interests. What is the long-term gain of sitting on an intellectual property when you can continually make money?
Joe: It's a give-and-take that doesn't exist—
Sam: What, there's a Disney Vault-esque scarcity for Sleuth?
Joe: It would be different if Netflix was knocking at the door, saying "We want to give you $500,000 to stream Sleuth on our platform," but Netflix doesn't give a shit, because they are already paying billions of dollars for their own original programming. And legitimately how many streaming hits is Sleuth going to get on Netflix? Close to zero?
Sam: So I'm not saying Bristol Myers Squibb takes a pennies-on-the-dollar, Spotify-type deal to license the thing on Netflix. I'm saying... what's the downside to putting it on Comcast, Verizon, whatever, so I can purchase it, so I can rent it? What's the downside of that? The only option I would've had was to order a DVD of it, right? That would be the only way for me to legally watch this movie.
Joe: Well, unfortunately, it's because, according to Bristol Myers Squibb, licensing their property for even $500,000 is fucking nothing to them.
Sam: It's not worth it, yeah.
Joe: Why would they go through that process? And to be clear, I'm pissed off about all of this. Why should a billion-dollar company own this good, niche movie? And why should any of the dozens of streaming services not give a shit enough to own this instead?
Sam: I'm constantly going through my lists, looking for movies to watch or whatever. There's usually some sort of rental option. Only in the rarest of rare circumstances are there literally no options. I have a website where I can punch in a movie title and it tells me where I can get it. The first category is streaming platforms, the next is rent, and the final one is buy.
Joe: So you're the type of person who, if it was only streaming through Amazon Prime for $3.99, you'd buy it.
Sam: No, but for this particularly thing, I would've. Or during Oscar season, I might rent a thing. There's usually a thing. This movie had nothing in any category, because of what we were talking about.
Joe: The insanity.
Sam: I have a list of 200 movies that I'm constantly cycling through, adding, watching, whatever. Almost never is there no option. Usually you can, like, buy it on Apple or whatever, and I say, "I'm not going to do that," and I'll just go to the next movie and watch it for free. It just seems against their own interest. ...I like that this is the thing we're most passionate about, because it's a nebulous, who-cares-about-it thing.
Joe: It's not a who-cares-about-it thing. It's money thing. We're paying for so many fucking streaming platforms, it doesn't make sense that you wouldn't be able to watch Sleuth. It's not like it's the most popular movie ever, but—
Sam: And I don't even care if I can't watch it for free. Why can't I purchase it? It would cost so little money for them to do this. All they would have to do is say "Here's a file we have on our server. Here you go."
Joe: So I guess it's just a pissing match between billionaires.
Sam: Or they're just not incentivized.
Joe: They don't give enough of a shit to piss over it.
Sam: And I think people purchase these things through packages, like, "I own 200 movies," and Bristol Myers Squibb probably owns like 25 movies or something. They're not marketing it for some reason. They might not even know that they have this... this is so funny, that they own this movie.
Joe: It's fucked up!
Sam: I could probably still rent it at the library if I wanted to. I didn't try that. A rental DVD.
Joe: I wonder, would Blockbuster have had it? When Blockbuster still existed. Like, one copy?
Sam: Of course. I would think so.
Joe: Maybe. The 1972 version?
Sam: It's an Oscar nominated movie! It's not "just a movie that came out in 1972." The La Salle library might have it. That was definitely an underutilized resource. I think toward my junior or senior year I started renting movies from there... Alright, let's close this out, Joe.
Joe: Yeah, what else we got? You have notes, right?
Sam: I feel like I just have jokes. Let's see... "capitalism."
Joe: Okay, how this relates to capitalism.
Sam: We've kind of talked about it, but you haven't really talked about it. I gave my classist rant earlier.
Joe: I dunno... I feel like Milo is trying to jump from a poor class to at least middle class. He's trying to make that jump. And as we all know from living in America, that's not a jump that's particularly easy to make. Especially because Milo tries to make it, and he gets... murdered.
Sam: [laughter] True! The murder rate in jumping classes is high.
Joe: He tries to match up with the "billionaire"—I don't think that Andrew is an actual billionaire—
Sam: He's doing well for himself.
Joe: —but he's the same type of character as like a Jeff Bezos-type character, where he feels like he can buy his way into any situation, he can buy random bullshit according to his heart's desire, and feels superior to people who are not like him. Whereas Milo is—yes, he's trying to get into that position, and he's banging that person's wife, but he's also earning a living by doing hair. He's the worker who is earning the value of his labor. Do you want me to keep going, or is this joke over?
Sam: No, I'm actually interested in what you're saying. I wanted to ask—because you had talked about him coming up by his bootstraps. I think we've both looked upon Milo favorably.
Joe: More or less.
Sam: I mean at the outset of this thing.
Joe: Gun to my head, good guy or bad guy, Milo would be the good guy.
Sam: At the beginning at least.
Joe: Maybe even at the end.
Sam: I more or less agree with that. But the one thing he cannot get over—this is the chip on his shoulder—he's so ashamed of his father. We didn't really talk about that. I thought that was interesting.
Joe: I don't know if the movie made a big enough point about that.
Sam: Really? I thought it did.
Joe: Maybe through Andrew, when Andrew continually pressed that.
Sam: Well, Milo had an anecdote about his father. He felt his father was a sap. And he felt like his father believed in the "American Dream," but he didn't believe in hard work, perseverance, and his father didn't know how to get ahead, and Milo lived ashamed of that. He didn't want to make the same mistakes his dad did.
Joe: I could see that. I would have to rewatch the movie to pick up on that.
Sam: It's just one monologue, and then Andrew harps on it a bunch of times.
Joe: I kinda thought it was one of those situations where Milo felt that, he never expressed it out loud, and then Andrew's pressure, plus Milo's subconsciously wanting to either relate to Andrew, or get to his level, made him express out loud his deepest shame about his father.
Sam: Right, he's not talking about it the whole time. Maybe in a therapy way, he can't externalize the feelings he has about it.
Joe: Are you saying that you want to talk about your father? [laughter]
Sam: No, my dad's super great! I constantly admire my dad's ability to... I don't know if "survive" is the right word, but to be able to say, "Alright, what's the next thing? Let's do this." I don't know how stressed my dad gets about stuff.
Joe: Working at the post office, I can assume he's a little stressed right now.
Sam: Well, he can retire at any point, but yes. It's an interesting time for them. Did your dad retire yet? Since he is also a postal worker.
Joe: No, he's I guess three years away from retirement?
Sam: My dad is of age. My dad also worked at the Navy Yard, which is also federal, so all that shit combines.
Joe: Neither of us feel about our fathers the way Milo feels about his father.
Sam: No, because I think me and you both have an appreciation for a middle class lifestyle. There's a path of... I don't know what the right word is... the struggles that these two characters are grappling with are just not concerns of mine, largely. I'm not worried about that opulence that they are trying to figure out.
Joe: Well, you're not a classist. You're not worried about getting cuckholded. You're not the type of person who would escalate a rivalry with another male.
Sam: But I am person who, at this point, is benefiting from wealth, to an extent. I live very comfortably. I have a wife who does very well. I think we try to think about the class dimensions of that, and live our lives in a positive way.
Joe: So you're not like Andrew, who is trying to degrade someone who is below him, financially at least. Though I always wonder, as far as the rivalry aspect of this whole thing goes, do you ever express any of that in the courtroom? As a lawyer? Do you feel like you pull any... just the way they go back and forth in the movie.
Sam: I feel like my strength as a lawyer does not lie in the courtroom. I think I'm a consensus builder and a problem solver, which is a particular skill set that is necessary. But I'm not the person I'm going to hire... I mean, I work in government—so I'll talk obliquely—so I'm not being "hired" by things. I solve problems and get things done, more so than, "I'm going to rip your throat out." That's just not the level of lawyering that I do.
Joe: Okay, so turn that back to the movie. Do you feel like that mindset could have benefited either Andrew or Milo?
Sam: Consensus building and problem solving?
Joe: Would that mindset have been possible for either of these characters?
Sam: I think at one point in time, Milo believes that that is what's happening. When he thinks that the two of them are part of a heist to steal the jewels, to defraud an insurance company—he came into the scenario like, "I'm cheating with this guy's wife, I coming into his house... Oh, we wants to commit this heist? We can both benefit from it!" I think he thinks that's what's happening. "Yes, that's what rich people do. They're cold. It's all about profits and bottom lines. Yes, yes, I'll go along with this!" And it's almost like he should've been—"No, that was a good idea. Let's go back to that. Let's figure it out." A lot of the first act of the movie is talking about the logistics about, like, how to hire a fence, how do you distribute these jewels through Europe—"Oh, I'll make 2/3rds profit from it" and so on.
Joe: And they were relatively calm about the fact that Milo was having sex with Andrew's wife.
Sam: He says it within a minute of them being inside the house. They're outside, they're cheeky, and you don't even know why he's there, I don't remember the pretense. "I invited you over because you're in the community" or something. I almost thought he was a news reporter or something. Well, I'm glad you actually liked this movie!
Joe: Yeah, absolutely! So, alright... is there a concluding statement you want to give? Like, "This is my favorite movie because..."
Sam: This is my favorite movie because: It so accurately predicted the things I would like in movies as I got older, and it continues to be the things I like. So my teenage self is correct about the person I would become eventually. My interests, I guess, have not changed in twenty years.
Joe: You're talking about what you appreciate about the movie, versus what you can learn personally from the movie.
Sam: I don't know about that. I have a quasi-personal connection to it, in that I was watching movies like this in a period of time that were influence by a person who was important to me. But...
Joe: No, I guess I'm saying... when you watched it while you were a teenager, and when you watched it this past week, there wasn't anything that you saw in any of the characters or any of the behavior that made you say, "This makes more sense to me now, now that I'm older"?
Sam: No.
Joe: And that's fair! If it was more of the moviemaking aspect to it.
Sam: It was more of "Oh, I get why I liked this then," because it's a bunch of the shit I like now. And it's a better version of things that I watch now. It's like, "I like this particular version, because it's a better made version of other things that I watch, and I want to be good, but aren't as good as I want them to be." Not always the case, but often movies come up short. This was fun. It was good, it was fun, it's still good. I'm glad it has held up. I'm glad to be able to say that it is still my favorite movie and will continue to be my password answer of "What is your favorite movie?"
Joe: If anyone wants to try to hack into Sam's Facebook account, here's your chance.


No comments:
Post a Comment