Wednesday, November 18, 2020

The Albums That Matter: Black Sheep Boy

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Black Sheep Boy
Okkervil River
2005

It's not news to anyone that I think of Okkervil River as a hit-or-miss band. Don't let that scare you away—all bands have misses every once in a while. Okkervil has about an average amount of misses, and many of those misses are classified as such because of my skewed personal opinion about slow vs. fast music in general. I hate to make a bigger deal about the misses than I need to (like I did in when this column previously touched on this band), because Okkervil River aren't defined by their misses. They are defined by their hits. This is why I keep coming back to this wonderful band time and time again—when they hit, they hit so goddamn hard.

Many people would argue that Black Sheep Boy is the only album of Okkervil River's that the GREAT. In terms of "my favorite," it's probably a solid #3 in the discography. In terms of "the best," I might have to concede. It's the best. 
 
If frontman Will Sheff is at his best when he digs deep and sings with the full weight of his emotions behind him, then he's at his best all over this album. I don't know why this is a point that I hammer often about Sheff in particular—it's not like he's unique in that he is a better singer when he sings with heft and heart. That's pretty normal for singers in general; like, if you care more, then it's gonna play better. But maybe Sheff's "I give so much of a shit" voice is just that much better than others'. It's just so fucking thrilling to hear his voice strain and crack a little, to picture the veins popping in his neck and he sings with every motherfucking thing he has. He's so good at it... when he reaches those heights. Doesn't always happen. Like I said, hits and misses.
 
But if the general consensus is that Sheff was able to reach those heights more often on Black Sheep Boy than on other albums, then it would be beneficial to ask why that is the case. What was going on with Sheff that Black Sheep Boy, his third album, became such a standout? Well, the more you read about this album, the more a theme emerges—Will Sheff was not in a good place when he created Black Sheep Boy. 

After the non-success of Okkervil's first two LPs, the band was on the ropes. To keep the dream alive, Sheff sold what he owned, and lived in his van. The man put all his chips on Okkervil River, in one more desperate attempt to find success. The desperation and that hunger translates beautifully into what became a very passionate work of art. Sheff is feeling low, and he's channeling all that self-hate and frustration into Black Sheep Boy.

Sometimes it makes me step back and really take stock of what we ask our favorite artists to go through in order to create great art. A song like "Black" could never exist if Sheff didn't find himself in the darkest depths. "Black" is absolutely seething with anger and resentment, vicious bile against the backdrop of a pop song. It's the type of song that makes you want to blow something up, and in that vein it's one of the best songs of all time. It's also the type of song that makes you worried for the person who made it. The world would be an even more terrible place if "Black" didn't exist, which means that we are asking Will Sheff to carry that burden, to internalize the hate that he righteously feels and turn it into something that is going to make other people's lives better. And I don't necessarily think that's fair, sometimes, to ask someone to take on that burden.

But I also try to look at it like it's a choice. Sheff, and others, choose to express what they feel inside through music. This makes them heroic, because of the sacrifice and the stakes, and who knows if it'll even pan out? (Remember—not every musician who goes homeless will find even the mid-tier indie rock fame that Sheff eventually found.) It's heroic because he didn't have to do this. He could've been an accountant, and owned a house when he was 28, and he would've been just fine, or at least as fine as the rest of us schlubs. But he took a chance.

I could say this about any artist who makes an album that I like, but it's especially relevant in the context of a broad discussion about Black Sheep Boy, just because of how dire the circumstances were surrounding its creation, and how well those circumstances translate into an all-timer of an album. If you've ever felt like a black sheep in this world, then Sheff's voice is your salvation.

~~~~~~~~~~~

If this album sounds interesting, then try this song: "For Real"


~~~~~~~~~~~

Stray Observations
  • I'm less interested in the idea that there is a character named the Black Sheep Boy, and that some of these songs are allegedly from his perspective. It's one of those things that the internet fans seem more interested in then even the dude who created it. Sheff's pithy comments on it: "The Black Sheep Boy is a character that crops up here and there on the album." Pretty clearly, it was a defense mechanism for some of the dark shit that he was singing about—it's not Sheff singing, it's the Black Sheep Boy singing. It's easier for Sheff to express these dark thoughts if he can express them through a fictional character. But the BSB is not real, and Sheff is, so I think it's more important to talk about Sheff's motivations than wonder what a sheep's are.
  • I didn't know that the title track on this album is actually a cover. "Black Sheep Boy" was written by a guy named Tim Hardin. I am not familiar with the artist (though I am familiar with one other song of his, apparently—Bob Dylan sings a version of his "If I Was a Carpenter"), but Sheff says that he was obsessed in the mid-aughts. He states that he saw himself in the song "Black Sheep Boy," and was determined to write an entire album based around the ideas the song presents.
  • No exaggeration about "Black" being one of the best songs of all time. It's an easy Top Ten. That's true even if it's a little murky what the song is even about. I've seen interpretations that paint it as a woman telling her past traumas to the protagonist, who gets angry at the abuser and promises to get revenge. I've also seen an interpretation that it's a father expressing grief over the kidnapping of his daughter. Could be both, or neither. I think the explanation is less important than the way Sheff expresses it. His emotions are laid bare.
  • ALBUM COVER: Like all Okkervil albums, the cover art was drawn by William Shaff. I guess that's the Black Sheep Boy at the dinner table? With a... warthog, maybe? And they are sad about there being no dinner? The art is as vivid and memorable as it is nonsensical.
  • Consequence of Sound has a decent 10th anniversary piece from 2015. In it, Sheff talks about how the band had originally been a group of friends who grew up together, but after Black Sheep Boy was complete, bassist Zachary Thomas and drummer Seth Warren left the band. I know I refer to Sheff as a singular entity more so than I refer to Okkervil River as a band, but I found it interesting that Sheff does not see this as "his" band. There is somewhat of a rotating group of musicians though the years, but Sheff says that he doesn't like that, and that he'd rather have a set lineup. I appreciate that sentiment, and I don't think it's too common among many of his peers.
  • I wasn't aware of the existence of the EP Black Sheep Boy Appendix until researching this album. I'm not going to rush to my local record store to listen to a short album of B-sides, but consider it on my radar if I have the time soon.
  • Counterpoint to Sheff's voice being the most important aspect of Okkervil River: the band served as the backing back to 1960s psychedelic legend Roky Erickson on his 2010 album True Love Cast Out All Evil, and it is very good. I only discovered Erickson a couple years ago via the Nuggets garage rock compilation, but his story is wild if you are interested in checking him out (and listening to some more great trying-circumstances-result-in-fantastic-album music.
  • If you're asking what my favorite Okkervil album is, then it's The Stage Names, but only because of timing, not content. That's the difference between "favorite" and "best." Black Sheep Boy is the best.
 
NEXT TIME: Blackstar by David Bowie

No comments: