Spending time with The Writing's on the Wall this week felt like a puzzle piece falling into place for me, at least in the context of Record Club. About a year ago, we listened to Essentials by Erika de Casier, and I remember at the time struggling to connect the dots between the album and specific touchstones of the late-'90s. Well, here it is—Destiny's Child was the band on the tip of my tongue. Erika de Casier, as well as pretty much every R&B/pop fusion act of the past twenty years, was influenced in some fashion by this group.
Thou Shall Give Credit to the Appropriate Parties
I mentioned for Essentials that the guitar sound—that fluttery, ornate fingerpicking style—as well as the busy drum machine and the off-the-wall sound effects (wind chimes, bubbles) were all recognizable from a not-so-distant past, and sure enough, they are all here. They started here, as far as I know. It interested me enough that I did like 5% more research than I usually do. From that, I think we can attribute that signature style to songwriter Kandi Burruss and producer Kevin "She’skpere" Briggs. Sure enough, the sounds that prominently feature this style all list Burruss and Briggs with songwriting credits. "So Good," "Bills Bills Bills," "Bug a Boo," and "Hey Ladies" are all highlights, and that's in part because they are laying the groundwork for a pop sound that still exists today.
Thou Shall Be More Than the Sum of Your Hits
Whenever we cover massively popular albums in Record Club, there comes the question as to whether the album was popular solely because of its hit singles, or if there are some songs without a Billboard presence that are actually enjoyable. Unlike Jagged Little Pill and diana, The Writing's on the Wall is mostly defined by the songs that everyone knows, which I'd argue is to its detriment. The hits are hits for a reason, don't get me wrong—the sexy lurch of "Say My Name" and the classic high school gymnasium good times anthem "Jumpin, Jumpin" still land magnificently after all these years. But there's also a whole lot of boilerplate pop-by-numbers in between the high points. I'll hold up "Hey Ladies" as the song that I fell in love with this week having never heard it before (i.e. it was not a single, but should've been). It might even improve on the formula that worked for the four juggernauts on the album—as always, a hard horn section brings a song to the next level. But for every "Hey Ladies," there's four or five "Where'd You Go"s.
Thou Shall Not Discount How Well This Has Aged
I wasn't pop culture saavy enough at age ten to know it at the time, but apparently The Writing's on the Wall had a reputation as "an album that hates men" around the time of its release. In the bubble that I live my life in, those themes play really well in 2020. It's not about "hating men," it's about taking agency as a strong female. Beyoncé Knowles could see the changing tides in 1999 (note the title of the album!) and hasn't really lifted her foot off this particular pedal in her entire career since. She's weaponized feminism. As a big fan of feminism, it's interesting to see this happening all the way back in the late 1990s, and I find myself wondering how empowering it was to the girls who grew up with this album.
Thou Shall Employ a Hokey Gimmick
I could see an argument that the Godfather shtick employed at the beginning of the album is retroactively justified now that Beyoncé really does have as much power and influence as Vito Corleone, but I still don't buy it. It's just a silly thing that doesn't bother me all that much. First tracks are easy to skip. Plus, we condone any and all stupid fucking gimmicks here at Puke on Your Birthday.
Thou Shall Grade the Album
2.5 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment