Thursday, August 3, 2023

Never Seen It, #112 of 200: Mulholland Drive

Am I watching 200 movies that I've never seen before 'cause I thought that's what you wanted to hear, or did I think about what you said and answer cause I truly believe that to be right? (SPOILER WARNING right here at the beginning, though the warning should be implied for all Never Seen It entries at this point.)


Mulholland Drive
2001
David Lynch

This is probably the most important film I've seen so far in this movie project. I say this under the assumption that this Never Seen It thing is designed—on purpose or by accident—to educate me on what it means to "understand film." In that respect, Mulholland Drive has given me an integral lesson on what that means.

That lesson, stated as succinctly as I can manage: A film does not have to spell out what it is trying to tell you in order for it to tell you something. This isn't the first time I've run into this phenomenon in the past 112 movies; there have been films that speak to its audience on a deeper level than what is on the screen. But Mulholland Drive takes that idea to its absolute limit. Like, compared to The Master, for instance, whose "purpose" was obscured but at least told a coherent story, Mulholland Drive does not make any sense in terms of plot or story.

Maybe "does not make sense" is an ignorant way of putting it. Let's try it another way: Mulholland Drive has no agreed-upon meaning, and everything, from its plot mechanics on down, are left open to audience interpretation. I push back from saying "doesn't make sense" because that's something that e.g. my father-in-law would say about this film, if he ever deigned to watch it. There is a certain type of movie watcher who dismisses a film if they are not told by that film explicitly what to feel. What I'm ultimately trying to do by watching all these movies is to gradually move away from that safety net, and attempt to find some ability to interpret film on my own accord.

Like, okay, say my first reaction to Mulholland Drive really was, "I don't get it." And it was. But what's different now is that I am going to sit on it for a little bit before running off to the internet for "answers." I slept on it and mulled on it for a while, and tried to see what I thought about the film after picking it up and turning it over and exploring it a little bit. I'm not saying I'm at the point where I can come up with my own answers instantly and totally. I'm just saying that I'm at the point where I know that "I don't get it" isn't going to suffice. I interpret that reaction as a complete unwillingness to interact with art in any sense other than on the surface. I also interpret that reaction as a cowardice in exploring yourself and how art changes you.

Mulholland Drive is a great movie to think about these ideas because it sincerely does not hold your hand in any sense. It is an incredibly difficult film (which is okay to say as long as "difficult" is a compliment, which I believe it is). It is confusing and disorienting on purpose. Director David Lynch provides no answers for anyone who is brave enough to ask. There was apparently a list of ten clues provided in the original DVD release, written by Lynch, that even now, to me, read as completely nonsensical (check them out on Wikipedia). This is all by design. If you are looking for a definitive answer as to "what happens in Mulholland Drive," then you'll be met with countless dead ends.

See, this is what I'm saying, though: it doesn't fucking matter. You don't have to know exactly how the plot gets from A to B to C to D in order to feel something. This is what I learned about film and about myself after watching Mulholland Drive. No, I have no idea what the purpose of the monster behind the dumpster was, and I question why Robert Forster showed up for like two minutes to talk about what I guess was a red herring, and I still don't really know whether the first two hours were a dream or an alternate reality or what. But I do know that there is something here. And I do believe that that "something," whatever it is, is worth pursuing.

It's worth pursuing even if you end up imposing your own meaning (***PLEASE SEE TODAY'S SONG CHALLENGE SELECTION AT THIS JUNCTURE***) onto it. Which at first seems backwards and scary. I.e. I didn't make this film, I'm just consuming it, and, like, how could my interpretation be valid in the same way that David Lynch's interpretation is valid? If those interpretations are opposing, does that invalidate one of them? Could one of us be wrong? And does that make me a shitty film critic?

Mulholland Drive (in my interpretation, at least) says: No. It does not tell you what its purpose is. It instead asks you to fill in the blanks yourself. An unkind reading of that ask is that it gives cinephiles an inflated sense of purpose, but put that reading aside until we're finished movie #200, please. A kind and I believe correct reading is that this is a trust-building exercise: Mulholland Drive trusts us to take from it what we need, and we in turn trust Mulholland Drive to provide something that we need, and to give us the space to explore that need without judgment or impatience.

I used that space to make peace with the fact that I just spent two and a half hours of my life pretty confused and bewildered, and to come to terms with the fact that this is a good thing. Mulholland Drive was a workout, a benchpress for the part of my brain that I'm trying to sculpt like Roger Ebert. And yes, I'm going to have a spotter—sorry to extend the metaphor—when I'm lifting all that psychic weight. There are resources, i.e. plenty of lovingly crafted write-ups about Mulholland Drive already. I used them, and added them to my own understanding of the film.

What spoke to me the most, both in the film and in the critical appraisals when they pointed it out, was the idea of "fakeness." How this is a fictional film, and that we obviously can't say that it's real, but that there was plenty that was revealed as "fake" within the film's world too. The (arguably) climactic scene at Club Silencio makes this idea explicit. There is "no band," and yet we hear music. There is a beautiful, haunting Spanish-language rendition of a Roy Orbison song, and yet the song continues to be sung even after the singer passes out, and so: fake, too. But that's the fucking point! The MC is saying "this is fake" and then that's proven true.

And so my own interpretation is that this is the point of the entire film (and you can consider what happens at Club Silencio as a bold-script underlining of that point). This is David Lynch saying that the film is fake, and that all film is fake. Fake, fictional, whatever, based-on-something, or created whole cloth, it's all fucking fake. And yet... the magic is real. We still feel something. We still experience this art, and change in a way that can never be undone. The rabbit is pulled from the hat and we know that it isn't actually magic but it feels that way. It's a trick and that trick is both that we know it's a trick and that it doesn't fucking matter that we know it. The facts of the matter are useless; the interpretation of those facts means everything.

So in a way, we circle back. I don't get what is "happening" in Mulholland Drive, but that's okay, because I know what is happening in me. And I love Mulholland Drive because I believe that it is saying that that's okay. Not only is it okay, but it's essential. It's saying that this is why we watch movies. Not because we need to be spoon-fed some sort of lesson or told exactly how to feel as the credits roll. We watch movies because we know that we're going to be able to use them as a conduit for self-actualization.

GRADE: I'm giving this 4.5 pukes out of 5, even though it probably deserves a full 5. I'm hesitant, though, because 5/5 feels like an act of arrogance, like I'm coat-tailing everyone else who has already written about how great this movie is, and saying something like, "See! I get it too! I'm one of you!" I'm not quite there yet. I also feel like David Lynch would be cool with me subtracting a half a puke off the score due to my own insecurities.

NEXT TIME: We're checking out My Fair Lady, hopefully with a couple more bloggers' input, and hopefully with much fewer existential crises.

No comments: