Friday, November 22, 2024

Forever for Now, Joe


I have always felt a kinship with the great music critics of our modern times—Lester Bangs, Robert Christgau, and the like. Not a kinship of mind—I will never be worthy of even sniffing the farts from the ass end of their writing abilities—but a kinship of heart. Mainly in that they all seem like miserable bastards. I'd like to think that, in my day-to-day existence, I am not a miserable person. I'm good at smiling with friends and I'm good at hiding the frown from my enemies. But when it comes to music, I fear that I am miserable. Being a music critic (even a very basic rank amateur like yours truly) means exposing yourself to a lot of music, and not all of it can be good. Being a music critic means writing, and sometimes it's just easier to write about negative opinions than positive ones. This is all normal, for miserable bastards like us.

What's not normal, perhaps, is listening to an album that you know in your gut is a good one, but still feeling that suspicion that you're being bamboozled by art that is ACTUALLY bad. And you can hear the goodness and you commit yourself to writing a positive review because you know the album is good and you don't want to say it's bad if it's good. But all that is in service of staving off the misery. In your heart of hearts, you're struggling to connect with the album, even if it's good. You feel this enough times, and you start to know for sure that the thing that's missing isn't missing from the music, it's missing from you.

I listen to Forever for Now and I hear many great shiny pop hooks. I listen to them over and over. I like them a lot. I acknowledge that they are well-made, and catchy. They are designed to do a thing, and they do that thing well. I understood this album and what it sounded alike and what it stood for almost immediately. Save for the last song (which we excuse for "final song is the artsy outlier" reasons), ever single tune on here is big and clear and loud and catchy in very obvious ways. This is pop music songwriting as sharp as a fucking samurai sword.

I admit that I cannot seem to find the emotional center of any of them, though. This is most likely akin to one of those moments when you can't find your car keys and it ain't the keys' damn fault, it's yours for being a shitty seeker, but still, I can't find it. I fear that I have listened to too much music for this to make an impact. I have listened to LP's album many times now, and I can sing along to most of the song, and I can appreciate the sheen of the thing, how the voice is supple and strong, how the music is big in grand, showy ways, but the problem is that I've heard other pop music that sounds strong and big in these ways. Not exactly, but enough to know that this is structure, not style. This is the type of music that I listen to and just can't help but think about how it was made, how some person (LP, in this case, as they are the songwriter, which is great) took an idea and moved it from brain to page to song, all in the service of "making a good song."

And they are good songs! But what I'm saying is that I don't feel any fucking heart in these motherfuckers. And that's probably just me. I'm too distracted by how well put-together they are. Maybe LP really did take their thoughts and feelings and emotions and distill them into bright pop songs. Maybe there is soul in these things after all, and my instincts are way off. Maybe I just can't see through the shiny plastic coating that covers these songs. Am I going crazy? Is it just me? Or are the songs too pristine? I feel like I'm in one of those living rooms in an upper-middle-class family's suburban home that is just for show and decidedly not for sitting in. Where's the fucking sweat, the fucking blood? Where? I don't see it anywhere on this album.

I am so far deep in this dark hole. I hate it, because I want to love this stuff. It's so nice and pleasant, and feels like something that I could love if I was a better person. I could sit here and list all the big moments on Forever for Now and check 'em off one by one as evidence that this is a good album. That "oh-oh-oh" chorus in "Salvation"! The huge, syncopated hits in "One Last Mistake"! The balls-to-the-wall intensity of "Savannah" and how it just keeps building and building! I want to like this shit!

I just wanna put the tab on my tongue and slip into the euphoria with the rest of them. I want to look up all glassy-eyed and see that widescreen bliss three inches from my face. But I can't do it. I hope it's not because I'm miserable when it comes to music but I can't. I can't, and so I'm over here on the sidelines of the dance floor, watching everyone flail about to the immaculate pop music frenzy, and all I can think about is how I'm excluded, by choice maybe, probably by choice, I don't know, but is it really choice if all I can see when I experience Forever for Now is that fake stucco artifice surrounding it? Or is that me being miserable? Tell me! Tell me!

LP seems like a real cool person. I think they are talented, immensely fucking talented, and I bare no ill-will toward them. I wish them every Grey's Anatomy paycheck they can get their hands on. I think Forever for Now is just about the best you are ever going to find when it comes to pop music written in this vein, written and performed with intentions like a trigger, cocked and ready to kill. You will not find as flawless a collection of eleven songs (plus one outlier, I already said that). You really won't.

But I think that's the problem. The songs are too perfect. They are perfect in the way that music should never be. They are so perfect that my first and only instinct is to mistrust them. Probably because I'm a miserable bastard.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

No comments: