Wednesday, November 27, 2024

It's Not Too Late: YSC, Day 164: Nate

Prompt: "The least appropriate song to play at the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade"

Selected by Nate


"Give Me the Painkiller"
Nails
Every Bridge Burning, 2024

Ten years ago, a nearly defunct blog published a long list of its best albums of the year. The final accounting looked like this:

20) Todd Terje — It's Album Time
19) Tokyo Police Club — Forcefield
18) EMA — The Future's Void
17) Real Estate — Atlas
16) The Both — The Both
15) The Holy Mess — Comfort in the Discord
14) Jeezy — Seen It All: The Autobiography
13) The Lawrence Arms — Metropole
12) The Men — Tomorrow's Hits
11) Joyce Manor — Never Hungover Again
10) Future Islands — Singles
9) Freddie Gibbs and Madlib — Piñata
8) La Dispute — Rooms of the House
7) Sylvan Esso — Sylvan Esso
6) Against Me! — Transgender Dysphoria Blues
5) Ought — Today More Than Any Other Day
4) Cloud Nothings — Here and Nowhere Else
3) Future — Honest
2) Run the Jewels — Run the Jewels 2
1) Cheap Girls — Famous Graves

A genuinely insane list that does not include some of the year's best work, including Liars' Mess, Rich Gang's Tha Tour, Nothing's Guilty of Everything, the blog's favorite album, Floor's Oblation, Single Mother's Negative Qualities, Pup's self-titled, War on Drugs' Lost in the Dream, goddamn Metamodern Sounds in Country Music, Parquet Courts' Sunbathing Animal, Taylor Swift's 1989, Shabazz Palaces' Lese Majesty, Dude Incredible by Shellac, Under Color of Official Right by Protomartyr, and Ultraviolence by Lana Del Rey. Unclear why the naming convention switched toward the end there, too late to correct it.

Here, now, from the distant remove of the future*, It's Album Time, Forcefield, The Future's Void, Atlas, Comfort in the Discord, Seen It All, and RTJ2 would be removed from the list altogether. Fine albums, but their charms were temporally bound and did not reach into the future. Cheap Girls would be presented with an asterisk, since the band's lead singer has confessed to non-specific sex crimes (which, fair enough, not for us to know what other people's sex crimes are, defining what is or is not a "sex crime" is not something to be pursued on this particular HTML). That leaves room for seven new additions, which makes the list look more like this:

20) The Both by the Both — Ted Leo and Amiee Mann, two legends of the game coming together to make an album that ignited the slim Venn diagram of their collective fanbases. "Volunteers in America" and "Milwaukee" both stand ten-toes down a decade later.

19) Singles by Future Island — Insane that this is what broke the band, since this is a perfectly fine album but certainly of no greater songcraft than what the band would produce in the years to come, and certainly not as electric as the high-water moments of In Evening Air. Is this the last time a late-night TV performance effectively broke a band? Could be.

18) Guilty of Everything by Nothing — The shoegaze revival freak's shoegaze revival album. Title track is a hole one can fall into forever if so inclined.

17) Mess by Liars — The word more or less turned away from Liars after Drum's Not Dead (or maybe after whichever album had "Plaster Casts of Everything" on it), but this slice of glitchy, dance-y, art-pop is every bit as mutated and warped as the band's freakiest stuff.

16) Honest by Future — 100,000 OLD WHITES, I'M JUST ONIONS.

15) Transgender Dysphoria Blues by Against Me! — The title track on this thing is incredible and, in all honesty, goes a long way toward all the positive attention that is given to this album and its groundbreaking nature. Taking none of that away and going purely on songs, there are some really great ones here, but not as many great songs as others, such as...

14) Sylvan Esso by Sylvan Esso — It says nothing of this album's quality, but this group sustaining a career into the present while many of the others on this list have limped from the spotlight is a lovely outcome and not the one that one might have expected hearing "Coffee" for the first time (or the 100th time, where it still works).

13) Piñata by Freddie Gibbs and Madlib — Revisiting this a decade later and it's clear why this was both something of a breakthrough and also lacking in a cultural footprint. Gibbs and Lib made '70s Blaxploitation movie and pressed its spirit into .wav files.

12) Tha Tour by Rich Gang — Rest in peace, Rich Homie. Rest in peace, Young Thug's tenure in Atlanta.

11) Sunbathing Animal by Parquet Courts — Holy moly, how white-hot this record's twang-punk really is. The title track alone is well worth the revisit, as is "Ducking and Dodging," which is basically just the title track again, and thank god for that. "Instant Disassembly" is probably the one that'll stand the test of time, but it betrays what's really going on here.

10) Dude Incredible by Shellac — Rest in peace, Steve Albini. Rest in peace, the concept of riding bikes. Rest in peace, all those dudes killed at the hands of other dudes when seeing the babes on the beach. Shellac often got louder and nastier than they do here, but rarely did they get funnier.

9) Metamodern Sounds in Country Music by Sturgill Simpson — Dude changed the game, showed up in a Scorsese movie, then chased his own joys into jam-band glory. We stan a king, etc.

8) 1989 by Taylor Swift — The big pop shift was really the last album, and this one has basically unlistenable after "Wildest Dreams," but there's some real pop wizardry going on here and even the embarrassing songs (of which there are more than a few) are endearing in their sincerity. Some of these qualities will curdle over time, but here they remain fresh and tasty.

7) Negative Qualities by Single Mothers — A triumph of acerbics, a testament to being an asshole without apology, a noise-rock album for the smart and wounded (let's be real) men of the world who just want to drink beer and be as mean as they can be. The U.S. government should fund the production of one of these albums every eighteen months, lest Canada truly become the light of the western world.

6) Under Color of Official Right by Protomartyr — Not much scholarship regarding Protomartyr on this here sexting blog, so in summary: Detroit post-punk that borrows moves from the Fall, borrows a pen from Vonnegut, and slaps together as astute and tuneful a documentation of the failing American psych as one will find in Trump's world (or anywhere else, for that matter). There was an album before this, but here is where it starts.

5) More Than Any Other Day by Ought — The band imploded under the weight of its own ambition (and under the weight of its youth, and perhaps under the weight of its lead singer's aspirations, though that's speculation and not reporting), but for a minute there, millennials had their own Talking Heads.

4) Never Hungover Again by Joyce Manor — The absolute pinnacle, the highest possible art-form of being a sun-baked moron. If you gave 1,000 pop-punkers 1,000 years they could not come up with a better sub-60-second song than "Catalina Fight Song."

3) Tomorrow's Hits by the Men — In retrospect, the beginning of the end of the Men's era of rock-solid consistency. At the moment—and even now—it's the last-gasp of classic rock as a genre lurching to life and ripping out the throats of its enemies.

2) Rooms of the House by La Dispute — This is a very loud podcast / the most literary and literate post-punk album worth anyone's time / a relationship in dissolve stretched over years / either the least-emo emo record or the most-emo emo record depending on where one's heart is at. It's hard to revisit because it requires a complete run, but it's easy to revisit because its conversation remains robust and engaging.

1) Here and Nowhere Else by Cloud Nothings — The standard, the vanguard, the calvary, the last band standing. All hail.

Song of the year from here in the future: "Go to Jail" by Chief Keef. More on this Wednesday. Here is a playlist of the year's relevant jams.


*Submitted on 11/26/24

1 comment:

Gilson said...

Man that La Dispute album really does absolutely rip.