Prompt: "Your least favorite holiday song, played waaaaay too early in the year"
Selected by Zach
"All I Want for Christmas Is You"
Ingrid Michaelson ft. Leslie Odom Jr.
Songs for the Season, 2018
I've never actually celebrated Christmas in my life. One year, I was with a segment of my mom's side that does the whole thing, a tree and all, and that's the only time I've ever come close to doing Christmas. It seems fun for those who do! But also stressful?
Anyway, I don't like holiday music, and I'm happy I live somewhere where I don't have to hear it from Thanksgiving onward, or even earlier. I don't like this song, and I would not be sad if I never heard it again. But I'm sure many of you have already heard it, either on the radio or while you're walking around Target or whatever other American capitalist marketplace or on an advertisement during an NFL game. For those of you that have heard it already, I am sorry. That's unfortunate.
HOWEVER. I originally picked the Mariah Carey version of this song before I realized there are absolutely endless covers of it. I saw Ingrid Michaelson has a version with Leslie Odom Jr. And I like Ingrid Michaelson, I think? At least I remember liking some of her songs like a decade ago, none of which I can remember now. And Hamilton, as musicals go, is cooler than most (even though I'm on the record saying I'm not a musicals fan), and I know enough to know that Leslie Odom Jr. is in the original Hamilton cast.
So I listened to this version. And I still hate it. Nothing can save it for me.
As a side note, why is every top comment under pretty much every music video on YouTube something like this (this is the top comment for the Ingrid Michaelson version here)?
"Last Christmas I heard this version for the first time. My husband and I had just found out that our efforts to adopt had fallen through for the second time. I cried when I heard this song, because all I wanted then was a child. Well here we are almost 9 months later, and I am feeding my little 7 month old son. Those tears of grief are tears of joy when I hear this song now, because it captures that heartfelt longing perfectly."
2 comments:
The original is a bad song because it's overplayed. This is a bad song because it's slow and boring. Despite all this, and despite not celebrating Xmas, I would still recommend Love Actually for some hate-viewing (as it features the original version of this song way before it became mega-popular).
Ingrid Michaelson: no thanks.
Post a Comment