Showing posts with label Song Challenge+Zach. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Song Challenge+Zach. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 31, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 180: Zach

Prompt: "A song about forever"

Selected by Zach


"On and On and On"
Wilco
Sky Blue Sky, 2007

"So Moses, the servant of God, died there, in the land of Moab, at the command of God.: (Deuteronomy 34:5)

There's an idea that God dictated the entire Torah (Hebrew Bible) to Moses, who wrote down every word. If this sentence is part of the Torah, and it tells us that Moses died, how could Moses, himself, have written it? His death would have clearly precluded him from writing these words, or any further words at all.

Rashi, the foremost Jewish commentator on the Torah, brings the following answer: God did dictate these words to Moses, and Moses did write them down. When God told Moses to record his own death, however, Moses was overcome with emotion. He was unable to write the words with his typical steady hand. "God dictated the words," Rashi tells us, quoting the Tannaitic sage Rabbi Meir. "And Moses inscribed them with his tears."

Every time I think of YSC ending, I think of this idea.

Something so immense is coming to an end. We've all spilled so many words on this blog, about literally everything in our lives. How does one end such a project?

I picture myself sitting in my room, with a blank page in front of me. I have nothing new to say on Day 180. I want to wrap this up, and I don't know how.

So I cry.

I cry, and my tears fall on the page in front of me. And then, before I know what's happening, the tears that fall on the page start to take shape.

They form their way into words. Words that I don't know how to write myself. Words about everything and anything. About my dreams, and about anyone else's dreams. About hot takes on trivial music, about love letters to our favorite bands. About our families, and our soul-sucking problems, about love and hate and wars and political candidates and pop musicians and motherhood and fatherhood and Wilco and the Philadelphia Phillies and delis and sobriety and Bandcamp and commuting and so many other topics, literally any topic you can think of. Sentences multiplying upon themselves, words and words and words that spin and spiral out of control as the tears just keep falling and the tears just keep morphing and so you keep writing and writing and you don't even know what's coming out anymore, you can't even control it, the story just comes pouring out of you, you watch it take shape, you can't believe it, you can't believe you're capable of something like this, you never realized your soul could write the story of your life all on its own.

And then, out of nowhere, the tears stop.

I thought this life would go on forever. I thought I could write another 180 books with my tears, another 180 posts, the well never drying up, another endless resource in a world full of them. But the faucet has gone dry. There's no more crying to be done. Every word has already been written.

I take a step back. And my mouth drops open with wonder.

My tears have filled the page entirely. There are too many words to count. They all come together, blurring into the other. I can't read each word from this far away. But they've unmistakably bent themselves into a story. One that covers all of me and all of everyone else.

All along those tears, those words, moving me, step by step. To wherever "there" is. The endless journey, trying to get "there," and it hits me like a lightning bolt—I'm there, now. I'm there, and there's nowhere else to go.

***

So I type up these last few words as I listen to the Wilco song, the one I've cried to so many times, the one I'm crying to once again.

"Go ahead and cry," Tweedy sings. "On and on and on, we'll stay together yet."

There are only a few words left for me to write, only a few more tears left for me to cry. I want them to go on forever. I want to keep writing. Deep inside my heart, though, I know something. That there are no more words left to write.

Because we'll all stay together yet, however we will.

And I close the document, copy it to an email, paste it inside, type JMK's name into the "To" bar. I take a deep breath. My cursor hovers over the "Send" button.

And off it goes, and off we all go, into the scary and beautiful future.

Monday, December 30, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 179: Zach

Prompt: "A song that lacks closure"

Selected by Zach


"Videotape"
Radiohead

YSC Contributor Appreciation Post

I can't do what Nate did. But Nate did inspire me to share my thoughts on what each of you have given me over the course of the year. It's more than you probably realize.

I'm doing this without taking lots of time to look back at everyone's individual posts, so it's off the top of my head. Here we go:

Allison: Allison is the master of the concise post that felt like it dumped a bucket of cold water on my head. She is a brilliant writer. I have watched, in real time, someone's brain work in an entirely different way from mine when reading her posts, and it's inspired me. I'm also inspired by Allison's career change just a few years ago, when she took a chance on herself and now makes more than she used to. Yes, it's nice to make more money, but it's really nice to take the leap and see it pay off. It's something I'm steeling myself to do soon, but I haven't gotten the courage yet. If I do, you can bet I'll be thinking about Allison along the way.

Brianna: Reading Brianna this year was like drinking a warm cup of tea with a purring cat sitting next to me. I always felt soothed reading Brianna's posts, which is a real accomplishment when you're talking about the filth of camping out at music festivals. Brianna has a real talent for writing in a way that has warming and calming rays of light shining through. It's honestly hard to explain in a way, but I always knew I could settle into her posts. I also loved some of the teacher talk and I can just tell she's good at teaching but is really humble about it too.

Bridget: Bridget was another master of the short post, and brought an enthusiasm to YSC that lifted me up and threw me for a loop. Every time I read a Bridget post, I felt like dancing, regardless of whether it was a song to dance to or not. To know Bridget is to know someone who takes everything she can out of life and enjoys the hell out of it. To know Bridget is to know someone who stands in awe of human life, who brings it into the world and enjoys most seconds of it, but not all seconds of it, because sometimes she'd rather be listening to a "bop."

Gilson: Gilson is a writer who takes on big subjects with a deft tone and a sensitive and smart touch. I was in awe of the way he was able to devastate me within just a few lines. I went to the depths learning about addiction from him, and I felt a brother-esque bond with him in being a fellow someone who swings for the fences. Gilson consistently stayed true to himself musically and personally and pumped out strong musical choice after strong musical choice.  I always knew I could count on Gilson for a steady hand and the emotional knockout punch I needed that day.

Joe: What can I say about Joe? YSC gifted me a new Internet Friend this year. At the end of 2024, I can safely say that even though our in-person meetings have been limited, Joe is a Friend, beyond just the level of Internet Friend. A supportive and encouraging and open-minded human who manages to maintain an astronomical level of commitment and dedication to the things he cares about—his family, his friends, the blog, musical appreciation, hating Billy Joel and other hacks. Joe tries to get the best out of everyone, and for that I am very grateful.

Maeve: I felt like I was on the best carnival ride ever when I read Maeve’s posts. There is no one who can match Maeve in embracing who she is and doing it in a way I've never seen anyone else do it. I loved all the things Maeve wrote about, and I stood in amazement as she talked about what a boss she was at her job (told in the most humble of ways). Maeve's dedication to this project was clear even when that presented its challenges, and I felt right there with her, cheering her on, because she deserves it. I will very much miss reading Maeve's posts; she takes a simple gray day and adds endless color to it.

Nate: One only needs to look at Nate's "Year in X" recent posts to realize we are working with a man of commitment, incredible dedication to the people he cares about, and, above all, a truly amazing writer. I stand here in pure awe of Nate's writing voice. The effortless way that he manages to write something a little different every time, to mix it up and still keep giving the people what they want. There were also a few times during this year that Nate's hand seemed to reach through my computer screen and touch my beating heart in ways I never expected. He is a syrup-hearted man who plays a curmudgeon on TV.

Sara: I felt so supported by Sara this entire year. I always knew it was going to be good when Sara commented on my posts. She made me feel good about my dating choices, about my writing about Maryland, and about my life (her comment about "why is every detail about you so funny" was one that will propel me to lean into my life and, yes, write that memoir). I knew beyond a doubt that Sara cared, and that was awesome. But enough about me—Sara's posts were consistently simultaneously off-the-wall and sensitive and grounded and I couldn't get enough of them.

Sunny: I viewed Sunny as the sage observer of this blog throughout this year. He is the one who could take any subject, anything that anyone else wrote about or anything he wrote about, and effortlessly turn it into gold. You never knew what form that gold would take. It was like taking part in the actual Gold Rush—you had to search around a bit before finding redemption—but that redemption found you, and it was a wild and awesome trip. I also really felt loved by Sunny this year—this managed to shine through in his comments, which often weren't the most direct; this allowed them to be infused with unmistakable care.

***

"Videotape" is about someone passing into the next world, but it's unclear what their legacy will be in this world as they're leaving it. They encourage the listener to watch the "videotape" they've left behind. Or something like that. And I feel that energy so hard with what YSC has brought me.

Transitions are not easy. There is something that's ending, something big and grand and something good. I shed a tear for that. 

I left my entire soul on the pages of PoYB this year, and all of you who have read the posts are familiar with it. That means I'm familiar with all your souls, and leaving that consistent immersion into the life of other people's souls—people who I really like and care about and, dare I say, love?—is such sweet sorrow. I'll miss this. I'll miss all of you.

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 179: Joe

Prompt: "A song that lacks closure"

Selected by Joe


"Sesame Street Presents the '80s: Loose Goose / Colors (There's Like a Million) / Two Heads are Better Than One / Count to Nineteen / Super Grouch / Tuck Elmo In Before Before Bed Oh-Oh / Bake Cookie / Don't Stop Your Reading / Always Gonna Be Your Friend"
The Sesame Street Cast
web video, 2017

Saturday, December 28, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 178: Zach

Prompt: "A song you regret has not been chosen yet by anyone during either iteration of the Song Challenge, because, damn, you have such a good reason to choose this song"

Selected by Zach


"I Want It That Way"
Backstreet Boys
Millennium, 1999

For this one, I tried to think of the most popular song that exists that:
  • Is firmly in the wheelhouse of the YSC age range / listening bracket;
  • Has not yet been picked for SSC or YSC.
I think it's this song. 

It's shocking to me that it hasn't been picked yet for any reason. It's the top karaoke song, the top song that people get excited about when those first few guitar notes hit, the top song to belt out along with others, the top song for '90s nostalgia. You may be more of an *NSYNC person (I am), you may hate this song, you may hate the whole boy band culture, but you can't escape this song. It was part of all our lives at some point. We have, as a group, picked endless amounts of well-known music from all eras. Somehow this one slipped through the cracks.

I guarantee that "I Want It That Way" brings up at least one somewhat significant childhood memory for each person reading this.

Thursday, December 26, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 177: Zach

Prompt: "A cold or empty or bitter song that represents something that you lost or some feeling that you've been searching for and could never seem to find"

Selected by Zach


"Time"
Hans Zimmer
Inception: Music from the Motion Picture, 2010

Sometimes you know you're searching for something, but you can't put it into words. Sometimes it feels like the peak of my life would be accepting an Emmy award, for some screenplay I wrote. Then I think about how I'm 38. 38, just a sidestep away from 50. 38 really snuck up on me. 38 is OK, but 50 is where I should be CEO. I should have won that Emmy by then. It's hard to come out with good art after 50, no? Most of the bands I like came out with their stuff before the age of 40. And then I know 40 will be here before I know it. 

I am more creative these days. But sometimes I feel like I've accepted a life that feels mediocre. Showing up every day to the same job. Commuting is a topic that's been written about a lot here on this blog, and the phrase "commuting loser" that Sara recently used in a post has stuck with me. I really feel like a loser when I get on the bus, again and again and again. I so desperately want to quit. I can quit. And then I just picture the safety net under me of a stable salary. More than that, almost, I picture the safety net that's an easy answer to the question "so what do you do?" I can tell people I work on the light rail, and people immediately think it's cool. It's so nice to have an answer to that question. But is it worth my unhappiness?

It is important to build transit projects. But I'm in the depths of how the sausage is made, and it's just not how my brain works. It's like I'm living two separate lives—one at work, one not, and I'm generally doing well in the other life, but the work life has such an outsized influence on my time, and the other life is just not as good as it could be. No one is keeping me at my job. They just fired the #2 of the project, and no one knows why. They sent a message to the company WhatsApp group. "Following a decision taken mutually" was the phrase used to describe the circumstances of his departure. But everyone knows it wasn't mutual, and the CEO prides himself on speaking great English, and then he writes messages like "following a decision taken mutually" and I laugh. I don't expect him to speak perfect English—I certainly don't speak perfect Hebrew—but he thinks he speaks perfect English, so he gets less leeway, especially when he's writing a message that's straight-up a lie and expects us to believe it. Morale is low these days. Also, office gossip is the only thing that keeps you going sometimes. I wonder if they'll fire me. I kind of hope they do, in a way, because if you get fired here, you get three months unemployment from the government at your current salary, and you get a free course in a trade. I can learn to be a pastry chef if I want to.

I want to be a hero. I want to be better than this. I want to be Christopher Nolan in a lot of ways. To decide to make a movie about dreams, and think up the idea for Inception, and do endless amounts of research about dreaming and lucid dreaming and world building. And then to have the power to convince Leonardo DiCaprio and Joseph Gordon-Levitt and Tom Hardy and Elliot Page and Michael Caine and Cillian Murphy and Marion Cotillard to all be in your film. And then to deliver, and make one of the greatest movies ever made. I'm writing the background of a novel now and I know I have a lot of research to do. But it's hard for me to even put in ten minutes away. I feel such anxiety when I start writing. I don't feel anxiety writing these blog posts, perhaps because I feel no pressure to make them good? But I know I want my novel to be incredible, and the enormity of pulling that off is enough to make me want to take my bat and ball and go home. But Christopher Nolan has ostensibly pushed through that feeling, multiple times. He was 39 when Inception came out, close to my age. He had multiple box office hits to show for it. What do I have to show for my life?

More than I realize, I'm sure. I don't need to be Christopher Nolan. But I do want to be bigger than I am right now. 

"Time" isn't exactly cold or bitter. It's more cathartic than anything, and represents the end of a process. But there's an undercurrent of darkness, of yearning, of wanting something more. It's not a happy song. Its power is in making me feel like I'm still searching for that thing, that nugget that will make my life feel really good. That will make my life feel like something to be proud of. 

Sometimes I wish I was better at settling for mediocrity. Sitting outside an office park and smoking cigarette after cigarette. These people look dead already. "It's Wednesday," they say. "Halfway to Friday!" I can't stand this. Why are you wishing your life away for a shitty weekend that's coming? But sometimes I wish I could be like that, put on a tie and jacket every day and take a briefcase and put in hours to profit the company dime. Because that's what people do. I want more. I can't help it. I just want more.

Monday, December 23, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 176: Zach

Prompt: "A song that, to you, represents the true meaning of the holidays"

Selected by Zach


"Complete Picture"
Sammy Tweedy
single, 2023

Different creative ideas I've had:
  • A person has a fancy event coming up in Los Angeles, where there's been a drought for 300 days. He gets a special haircut, gets dressed up in a suit, puts on cologne. He spends lots of money getting himself ready. When he leaves the house, it somehow, impossibly, starts raining. He puts on the dark green raincoat he bought at Target that almost never wears. When he gets to the venue, no one notices his haircut, or his suit. "Your COAT!" everyone exclaims. "WOW!!! The colors just pop!"
  • A person goes to the cafeteria at his mediocre office building. They're all out of sodas and seltzers and juices. All that's left is kombucha. "Ah... OK, I guess I'll have a kombucha," he says. "How do you pronounce that?" All of a sudden, someone comes up to him. "You drink kombucha?" they say. "Wow. COOL." He thinks it's weird, but moves on. Then two other people come up to him. "Kombucha," they say. "I heard it prevents cancer. And helps your IMMUNE SYSTEM." Eventually the scene devolves into hipster ghost-like characters chasing him down like he's in a haunted house. The ghost-like characters can't stop saying things about how amazing kombucha is for you, and how cool he is for drinking kombucha, but are talking as if they are the walking dead.
  • A person parents their children for an evening, finally getting them to sleep. When they go into their bedroom to turn in for the night, five of their friends surprise them by sitting at a table they've set up next to the bed. They are there to judge the parent on how they parented that day. They hold up scores, like judges in the Olympics. Nate and Joe will each get perfect 10s for bringing their three girls out together in public.
  • A person invites 10,000 people to a stadium concert. Once they arrive, they play no music. They instead begin chopping apples and preparing ingredients to bake an apple pie. They place the prepared pie in the oven. Right after they've closed the oven door, they say the first line they've spoken since they arrived on stage. Here's what they say: "I want to make out with the batter I used for this apple pie." And then they make out with it. Slowly, and passionately, with lots of tongue.
  • Go to a Waxahatchee concert and say hi to Spencer Tweedy, who plays drums in her band. Speak Hebrew with him, because he knows a little bit. Ask him how to get in touch with his brother Sammy, who spent time in Tel Aviv, who was canceled by his classmates at Sarah Lawrence. Go say hi to Sammy, whose birthday is today. Ask him what it's like to actually get canceled. Ask him what it's like to withdraw from college, to enroll instead at Tel Aviv University to finish your degree. Learn from this man. Ask him to play you his song "Complete Picture" on Christmas Day. Tell him that you've searched far and wide, but that this song is the one that least represents the "true meaning" of the holidays. Which is, in fact, why it represents the true meaning of the holidays to you. Because you're a holiday nihilist. You like Sammy Tweedy. You want to see him in Tel Aviv. But he's back in Florida, back in Chicago, and you're all alone in a foreign country, on Christmas Day, but you don't feel sad, because Christmas isn't your holiday. It doesn't matter. Because you have a recorded song by Jeff Tweedy's son to keep you warm, and that's probably enough.

Saturday, December 21, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 175: Nate

Prompt: "A song that you would gift to someone else in Song Challenge if you picked their name for the Song Challenge Secret Santa"

Nate is Secret Santa for:


"Song for Pete"
Hovvdy
Hovvdy, 2024

Happy holidays, my son. Know this was no easy feat; your love of experiment (DAUGHTERS!), to discover and to be discovered (MUSGRAVES!) makes fulfilling this prompt a tricky one. I took a few spins through Ishay Ribo's latest, Sof Chama Lavo, but I must admit that I found it texturally a little one-note (which I am sure betrays the nuance and spiritualty that you have clearly found in his music). I quite liked "Shetach Afor"—has some great drive to it!—but I have, alas, chained myself to songs only from this year. I also considered sending you this fan-made complete version of "Listening" by the Everything-You-Knows, but I assume Joe would have hip-checked (hockey term) as a repeat. Unfortunately, you are not allowed to click that link and listen to it 10-15 times like I did while writing this.

Ultimately, I am leaning on the idea that, to borrow from a religious practice followed by neither of us, that the light in me will recognize the light in you. Here’s a song that I listen to all the time, and in the listening is generating its own meaning within my life. May it find purchase in you, too. A little trip-hop in your Americana. I'll go a step further and say that, in times of trial this year, I turned to this song to lift me out of self-pity / justified sadness. It worked, sometimes. There if you need it kind of a thing. Peace in our time, an Orioles World Series soon after.  

THE YEAR IN ZACH

Best Post: I've known Zach longer than I know everyone on this blog (save BJG), and as a regular reader of his blog before it was defunct, I thought I had a good sense of what to expect. Some of that came to bare; detailed Wilco analysis, cogent and thoughtful reflection on religion and its place in one's life, a kind and quiet voice that masks a fiery rage to rival none other than Dennis Reynolds. Orioles illness and hockey worship, of course, though I have to admit that I didn't see Bernie Williams coming.

What I did not expect is was there all along: a courageous willingness to share himself, warts and anxieties and all. More than almost anyone else, Zach let us know about him this year, deeply and fearlessly, even when he was afraid in the process. I know many on the blog followed along with me, jaws agape and breath bated, during the nearly-real-time A ordeal. I know many of you must feel the same sense of joy that I do, seeing Zach's year of finding love in a hopeless place come to a moment of romantic resolution. I know many of you must feel the same sense of insight and perspective that I did on his views on the ongoing conflicts in and around Israel, living in a war zone in a time of war. You got to meet my friend this year, and I did, too. He's your friend now, too.

However, his best post? Why, it was the grocery store rankings. Service journalism at its finest, long live Price Chopper.

Most Deranged Post: It's funny. When I initially started to re-read Zach's posts from the year, the memory of his year-long search for love loomed so largely in my mind—to say nothing of his posts about religion, mental wellness, and politics—that I expected there wouldn't be very much mania to highlight.

This, as it turns out, was a very stupid thing to think. Blogging makes a fool of us all. For example:
  • Sharing a picture of your zemer Zodiac Killer notebook
  • Checking a friend's twitter page just to make oneself mad online, as if there are not enough ways to make oneself mad online without seeking them out
  • An excellent Sunny impression
  • We should unshackle ourselves from utensils and let the slop spill from our mouths freely
  • It is time to be plowed by Bryce Harper
However, none is more deranged than Zach's sincere and heartfelt salute to your king and mine, Kim Jong Un.

Best Song: Zach is dead-on about "Old Town Road."

Guster count at time of publication: 6

One to re-read: I will cheat and share two: the so-obvious-it-hurts failed date recognition, and his reflection on the failed peace attempt of the Clinton-era.

In conclusion: You are right about musicals, WXPN, WEXT, and about jacking off too much. You are wrong about Jonathan Davis and the worst thing you could do. Every song reminds me of an ex too. See you at the Tel Aviv poetry jam, bring the weird nachos.

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 175: Zach

Prompt: "A song that you would gift to someone else in Song Challenge if you picked their name for the Song Challenge Secret Santa"

Zach is Secret Santa for:


"Star Star"
The Frames
Set List, 2003

I could have picked a Pearl Jam song. I could have picked a Guns N' Roses song. I could have picked the Replacements, Drive-by Truckers, the Hotelier, Stereophonics. I could have picked an Old 97's song, a band I know he discovered through XPN. Gilson is a man who knows his music and knows the music he likes and enjoys the music he likes. He only deserves to be gifted more of it. It will make him happy. I am sure of this.

And I want to make Gilson happy. He's been through stuff, and he's been open about writing about it here. We have different lives and different paths, but I have felt a kinship with him throughout the year (watch this space for more on this). I don't know if his love language is gifts, but I have a feeling he likes them.

It's fun to give gifts, gifts that you know the other person will want. The highest level of gift giving is completely altruistic. You give a gift with no expectation you will get any thanks for it or benefit from it.

I'm not on that level. So I'm occupying a slightly lower perch. I'm giving Gilson a gift I know he'll like, but I'm not doing that in an entirely altruistic way. Because I want to also give him a gift that I, myself, will also like. That I'll benefit from, just a little bit. 

So. I know Gilson likes the band the Frames. He's mentioned them a few times in reference to his semester spent in Ireland. I've gotten excited when he's mentioned them. Once is one of my favorite movies. "Falling Slowly," while not a Frames song in the movie, apparently started as one, and that song deserved every vote it got for Best Original Song. That was my original choice.

But I put on the Frames in preparation for the pick, just played through their music on Spotify. One other song stood out. 

There's a version of "Star Star" out there that the band seamlessly combined with "Pure Imagination" from Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. It's on a live album. 

There's something about that movie that's just magical. I love it. And I love "Pure Imagination," probably its best song. Separately, Glen Hansard has a way of evoking emotion from any lyric or line or riff. And the way he integrates that song with another emotional knockout—"Star Star"—is just so wonderful.

I'm gifting this to Gilson, because I know he'll like it. I'm gifting it to myself, also, because I like it. And then, again, I'm gifting it to Gilson. Because that's what this is about.

"Close your eyes," Hansard tells the crowd. "Count to three. Make a wish."

At the end of the day, we're all kids. We've been through shit. Breakups, sobriety, whatever. Somehow this song stretches from 1971 (Willy Wonka) to 2003 (the Frames) to 2024. And to 2025. To whatever next year brings.

This is a gift to Gilson. Attached to it is a note. A blank note. For him to fill in, with whatever he wants. Perhaps he'll tell himself "listen to and enjoy whatever makes you happy, and stop being guilty about it." With whatever his Uncle Jim would want him to have. With a prayer for himself, to be able to forgive himself for anything he feels he needs to be forgiven for.

From one person who "gets big feelings fast and wants to take those big swings" to another—here is your gift. Gilson, you deserve it all.

Thursday, December 19, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 174: Zach

Prompt: "A song that you know for sure makes someone else think of you when they hear it"

Selected by Zach


"Ways to Go"
GROUPLOVE
Spreading Rumours, 2013

Last night, I was having dinner with someone special.

"What bands do you like?" she asked me.

And I rattled off a few bands. Anyone reading this could probably guess a few of the bands I named (what a cool thing about YSC, for people to know you and your music taste so well after a year of seeing your choices). We agreed on some (Guster chief among them). I asked her who she liked.

"I love GROUPLOVE," she said.

The only GROUPLOVE song I could remember is "Ways to Go." I started singing it. I referenced its appearance on a Girls promo for Season 3 (side note: how fucking good was Girls? The further I get away from watching it, and the more I realize I haven't heard about Lena Dunham in a while, the more I appreciate it). As we were walking home, she turned to me. "Now I'm singing GROUPLOVE," she said. So I know for sure that if she were to hear "Ways to Go" at this moment, she would think of me.

But that's not the point of this post. I want to tell you more about S. 

S and I went on our first date on November 12. But we met well before that. 

Late April 2021, Yom Haatzmaut (Israel's Independence Day). My friend organized a camping night on the outskirts of Jerusalem. I went. I was new to Israel then, but I knew a bunch of people there. A high school friend who lived in Tel Aviv, people I knew from America, others I'd picked up along the way. I brought the person who I was dating at the time. And S. S was there, and was one of the people I'd never met.

Somehow the person I was dating, me, and S ended up sitting on the same side of the campfire. I don't remember exactly what we talked about. But I do remember thinking S was awesome. 

I had mixed feelings about the person I was dating at the time. Either way, I definitely liked S. She had talked about how she was into hiking and meditation and was on a real religious journey—all things I very much connected to. I loved that.

The person I was dating didn't stay the night. We all went to sleep. The next day we all did a hike together, and S was there. We chatted a bit, and my affinity for her grew, which was complicated, of course, I was dating someone, someone who my gut told me probably wasn't the one. 

Later that night, I hosted Shabbat dinner. I debated—should I invite her? Is that too much? I barely know her. But it's not weird to invite people you barely know to Shabbat dinner, and so I did. She came, along with a few others from the camping trip. It was nice. I told the person I was dating that I invited her. She agreed that S was awesome—after all, the three of us had spent the camping night hanging together. Everything was good and above board and nothing was inappropriate.

That person and I broke up soon after. I dated someone else right afterward. It was a very volatile month-long relationship. I was pretty upset when that one ended. S had been on my mind. I texted her the next day. "Would you want to get coffee sometime? You can let me know!" She wrote back that she was visiting her family in the US, that she'd get back to me when she was back. 

I never heard from her after that. I never really knew why, but I wasn't in a place where I was going to wait for her. I started dating someone else right around that time, a six-to-seven-month-long relationship that ended early 2022. Then I started dating the person from Chicago. Right as that relationship was beginning, I went to my friend's house for Shabbat dinner. He didn't know I knew S, and I didn't know he knew her.

"My friend called me today," he said. "He got engaged! To someone named [S]!"

Cool, I thought. Nice! It had been many months since I had asked S out, and I had kind of written it off, and I had started dating someone. I honestly didn't think much of it.

A little more than a year later I was voice noting with a friend from the US. He told me he had spent the weekend in Denver on a trip from New York.

He told me he had been at a Shabbat dinner in Denver, where he was sitting with his friend and two women who he met at the dinner. He and I had once taken a different trip to Denver, and one of the women told him she was back and forth between her hometown of Minneapolis and Israel. So he brought up my name. "I know him!" she apparently told him. And mentioned the Shabbat dinner I had hosted her at, two plus years prior. He shared her name with me. It was S.

S is from Minnesota. And as far as I knew, she was married and living in Israel. 

She was apparently in Denver for a hiking trip, as was he. "Wait, but isn't she married or something?" I asked. He said it really didn't seem like it. I didn't understand what happened, or why she was in the US, or anything. 

"I don't know what your deal is," my friend told me. "But anyone would be lucky to be with her."

So it seemed like her engagement hadn't worked out. But she was in the US. I didn't know what was happening with her. And I didn't text her, didn't pursue anything. After my Chicago experience I was very wary of reaching out to anyone in the US for dating.

And another year went by, with all the things that happen in a year. By then, the volatile relationship person was married. Chicago person was engaged (she's getting married on Sunday). Denver friend was married. Things change in a year. It was Yom Kippur, and I was leaving the morning services, for an hour break before I had to go back for the afternoon prayer. As I was walking out of the synagogue, someone caught my eye. 

I didn't recognize her at first. It was three plus years since I had seen her. Then it clicked. I went up to her.

"S?" I said. 

And it was her. She had just moved to Tel Aviv, for an internship in social work. I couldn't believe she was living in Tel Aviv. Tel Aviv doesn't generally attract hippies. But there she was, right in front of me.

(I've since learned that her engagement didn't work out and she's very grateful for that, that she had moved around Israel a bit, had spent time in the US, and decided to totally change her career and pursue social work, which she couldn't be happier about. She did just come back to Israel with the intention of staying.)

Yom Kippur ended, and I moved on. I was on a break from dating, and even though my crush on S had never fully been extinguished, I wasn't sure what to do with the information that we now lived in the same city. There were also other things going on, other dating ideas that had been percolating. 

I ran into A #2 and asked her out, and she said yes (I wrote about that somewhere in YSC). The day she said yes, I went to Shabbat dinner (are you sensing a theme here?) at a couple who I'd never been to before, about two weeks after Yom Kippur.

I walked in, and there was S.

It wasn't a total shock. We're all part of the same community. But it was a small meal—the couple hosting, another couple, and me and S, and that was all.

We talked at the meal. The crush was there, 100%. I was supposed to go on a date with A #2, though, and I didn't want to mess around.

When A #2 told me that she had started dating someone else and couldn't go out with me a couple days after that meal, I was relieved. It opened the door for me to ask out S.

I still wasn't 100% sure. She had just moved to Tel Aviv, wasn't her life crazy? What if she wasn't interested? What if she said no, and I had to see her around all the time now?

I talked to my therapist. Afterward, I drafted a text. I sent it to my friend. She vetted it, and gave me some feedback. It was a Wednesday, and I woke up with a fever of 100.4F. I took a sick day. That morning I made the final edits to the text and, after taking a deep breath, hit send. I scrolled through my roommate's movie selection and decided on Manchester by the Sea after realizing I didn't have the patience to get through Killers of the Flower Moon. I waited all day.

The next morning, I saw she had sent me a voice note. As a defense mechanism, I convinced myself that she would say no. 

"Hey Zach," she said. "I was also thinking about how we should date. I want to go out. I'm busy for the next two weeks—I'm moving, I'm starting an internship, my life is insane. Can I get back to you when I'm free?"

So it was a yes! I celebrated, with an asterisk. Because it's happened to me more than once that when someone says they'll get back to you, it doesn't always happen. 

I told her that was cool. I asked how long it might be. She said two weeks. And I immediately lowered my expectations.

But a week and a half later I heard from her. She was ready to meet up. Pleasantly surprised with how quickly she had gotten back to me, we made plans to get a drink. That was November 12.

Since then we've gone out eleven times. I have to say it's going very, very well.

Typically I'm full of anxieties about the other person when it comes to dating. It's my own stuff, sure, but it's also my gut telling me something's not right. I don't trust my gut often enough. It's why I'm still at my job. But with her I don't feel all those familiar anxieties, and I kind of can't believe it.

She's smart. She's adventurous. Looking into her eyes is like looking into the depths of the ocean. She doesn't care that I'm not sure about my job situation—she embraces the excitement of it. When I told her that I feel weird that I don't exactly know where my career is going and how I can be a provider, she laughed. "Yeah, I've always wanted to date a guy who hated his life and made tons of money," she said, with just the right dose of sarcasm. It made me feel so good when she said that, and I felt so supported by her. She loves the outdoors and wants to do long backpacking trips. She has an incredible smile. Religiously, we're pretty much on the same page, which is not a given for me. She loves Israel and wants to live here. She's incredibly close with her family. She's been through her fair share of challenges in life. She's a meditator, someone who goes off on two-month long silent meditation retreats and doesn't look at her phone or communicate with the outside world for that entire time. We vibe. We get along. She's so pleasant to be around. It's like a burst of light when she comes into the room. I like just listening to her talk—about anything, about her day, about whatever. She's so easygoing, and lets me be me. I've had to negotiate roommate politics when having her over to my house, but the way she's handled my anxieties about how those politics could affect her has been nothing but calming and affirming. I feel so lucky to be dating her. I want her to be happy.

And I'm scared, too. I don't want more heartbreak. I've had enough. Neither does she. I think we're both holding back, just a little bit, because we're scared of that. It's also only been a month plus. I'm trying to take things as they come, to let them happen, rather than artificially move them along. But we've had some of the big conversations already and they've felt like they've come at the right time. They've just been integrated into the fabric of our regular time together, rather than being talked about as "issues that NEED to be brought up." I'm still scared. Sometimes I feel like I have to be perfect, that if I make one mistake she'll run away. This isn't healthy. There's humanity in the imperfection. We're not God, we're not angels. I've talked about this with S. "What if the imperfections are the things to celebrate?" she asked. It's true. And yet. 

But these are my own anxieties, things I'm going to have to work through on my own. They don't have to do with her—they'd come up no matter who I was dating. It's a new experience to not have anxieties about her, if she's right, if we should or shouldn't keep dating. I just feel really good about how it's going right now. And I want to continue. I have no doubt about that. Because of that (and S and I have talked about this, and she feels the same way), there's all this extra space around us. That space isn't taken up by anxiety. It's just there. I kind of can't believe it. That's what I've been wanting. And yet—what do I do with that space?

I'm trying to let go of the fear. I recently read an incredible list of life lessons that I really connected to, by someone named Nabeel S. Qureshi. Number 5: "Later, you'll be nostalgic for right now." 

This is the good stuff, right now. The excitement of meeting someone new, of not being sure where it will go. 

Yeah, it's scary. Yeah, I don't know the answers. Yeah, I have my own things I'm working through. Yeah, I want to meet someone and start a family and S seems like someone who I could potentially do that with. Yeah, I don't want to get hurt, and I don't want to get my hopes up too much.

That's all true. It's all true.

But right now all I have is me, and her. And we're here, and we're spending time together. Things are unfolding, because that's how life works. Things will continue to unfold, however they will. I have no control, really. 

What do I do with all this extra space? Enjoy it. Enjoy the hell out of it. Because it'll never come again, and I'll miss it when it's gone, no matter what direction it goes.

Right now S is somewhere in Tel Aviv, and I'm standing in my office in Neve Ilan. She's on my heart. I'll see her soon, maybe today, maybe tomorrow, maybe next week. I'll see her, and we'll say hi, and we'll smile at one another, because we're just happy to be together in that moment.

That's all I know, and that's all that matters.

It's Not Too Late: YSC, Day 13: Zach

Prompt: "A song that's not about sex, but would be funnier if it was"

Selected by Zach


"Long Hard Year"
The Drifter Luke
single, 2018

This is not a well-known song. It's a song by an artist from Seattle named Luke Abbott. My brother played bass in his band for a time period. It's a very catchy song, and I've known that since I first heard him play it live in 2017. and I've found myself playing it over the years. I'm curious if others like it. The YouTube version is live and slowed down and not as good, so I'd recommend listening to it on Spotify for the full experience.

The song is about a long hard year. It's not about sex. But I like the idea of this song being about a LONG and HARD "year" if "year" meant something else. I don't need to spell it out. We've all been to middle school.

I honestly don't like Luke. He didn't pay my brother and made anti-Semitic comments to him. I probably shouldn't be listening to his music. 

Cancelling is a topic that I'm noticing comes up again and again in different ways through YSC, and I'm almost watching myself from afar dealing with it, not knowing which direction it's going to go each time.

Monday, December 16, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 173: Zach

Prompt: "A song that has the same exact title as a song that was chosen already for Song Challenge, but is in fact a completely different song"

Selected by Zach

The same exact title as Nick's song from Day 5



"Amsterdam"
Keep It Together, 2003

This was one of the easiest picks for me. I've picked six Wilco songs, and this pick gives me six Guster songs. Sounds about right.

I'm guessing this is the second or third most famous Guster song, behind "Barrel of a Gun" and maybe "Fa Fa"? I'm mad they didn't have any songs on that XPN list, but eff XPN anyways. Guster is the most misunderstood band of the last 25 years. 

One of my recent delights has been to learn that comedian Alex Edelman is friends with Ryan Miller and the others from Guster, and performed "Happier" on stage with them during one of their concerts. Alex Edelman also unintentionally helped Ryan Miller become the writer for the musical Safety Not Guaranteed (Allison: as the musical expert of YSC, is it good?), as actor Nick Blaemire spotted Miller at the afterparty for the final night of Edelman's standup show and was inspired to ask him to write a musical adapted from the movie (Miller had already written two songs for that movie, which starred Mark Duplass and Aubrey Plaza, who I also both love). I also learned that Alex Edelman is friends with Regina Spektor, whose song "Human of the Year" is the theme song for his stand-up show, for which he won an Emmy (Writing for a Variety Special). A Guster, Alex Edelman, and Regina Spektor triangle is a perfect one for me. 

I have three specific ideas for posts I want to write before this whole thing is over. That means five other posts (including this one), plus one more I'm late on that will be fulfilled. Six posts that can be filled with anything at all. And I feel an urge to "make these posts good." Historically, I've been a big "make things big at the end" person. When, really, it's not about the ending at all. The best moment of your life does not happen on your deathbed unless you're already dead and you appear in a dream and you're in the movie Inception and you're finally telling your son that you love him, albeit indirectly.

So a post about Guster feels right for today. And about Wilco. Because "Impossible Germany" was #6 on the 885 song list, and I would not have predicted that.

It's Not Too Late: YSC, Day 62: Zach

Prompt: "A song with an adverb and a preposition in the title"

Selected by Zach


"Cowboys Are Frequently, Secretly Fond of Each Other"
Willie Nelson
single, 2006

Fascinating. A song about how cowboys are often gay. This is the plot of Brokeback Mountain. Willie went for it. When I found this song, I found myself wishing it came out in like the '70s, that it would be ahead of its time. But it came out in 2009. I'm still into it.

I once went to a thing called Cowboy Camp in Mosquero, New Mexico during my cross-country bike trip. It was actually a few miles outside Mosquero. We saw signs for it and didn't know what it was. Turns out it was a Christian gathering of cowboys. We heard songs like "I Just Found Out Jesus Loves Cowboys." The cowboys who were there taught us to lasso. Later that night, we went into town, to the saloon. The cowboys who were there asked the women from our trip to dance. There was something about New Mexico ranch hands in a hat and boots squiring sunburned women from East Coast cities around a dance floor in an American village with a population hovering around 100.

Saturday, December 14, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 172: Zach

Prompt: "A song that doesn't make any fucking sense to you how it would even come to exist"

Selected by Zach


"Detlef Schrempf"
Cease to Begin, 2007

I don't know how anyone writes a sad song that makes people cry on command. There are many attempts, but only a few that hit. Sufjan is of course a master of this, but so is Ben Bridwell.

I now present the Top 20 athletes I currently have or have had crushes on:

20. Detlef Schrempf, basketball, Seattle Supersonics, 1990s: Obligatory.

19. Sarah Sellers, marathon, Boston Marathon, 2010s: Out of nowhere, finished second at Boston on a day with the worst weather possible. 

18. Jaime Sale, figure skating, Salt Lake City Olympics, 2000s: I remember having a crush on her when she was robbed of a gold medal by the judges, only to have it reinstated.

17. Bryce Harper, baseball, Washington Nationals, 2010s: I'd be scared of Bryce in bed, but I'd agree to whatever he wanted.

16. Ken Griffey Jr., baseball, Seattle Mariners, 1990s: I don't know why Seattle, as a city, seems to turn me on. But there are an outsize number of Seattle athletes I have crushes on.

15. Tim Tebow, football, Denver Broncos, 2010s: He might be basic, but I respect him and eff the haters. 

14. Andy Murray, tennis, Wimbledon, 2010s: He is by far the most authentic and coolest tennis player on the planet.

13. Cal Ripken Jr., baseball, Baltimore Orioles, 1990s: This is more of an obligatory pick, but he was my first athlete I fell in love with, and therefore requires mention here. I don't have the feels for him though.

12. Nancy Kerrigan, figure skating, 1994 Olympics, 1990s: Everyone knows who Nancy Kerrigan is and why. That poor woman.

11. Emma Navarro, tennis, US Open, 2020s: I was watching the US Open this year and developed a crush on Emma Navarro, so there you go.

10. Adley Rutschman, baseball, Baltimore Orioles, 2020s: He's just so cute. Look at that baby face!

9. Brady Anderson, baseball, Baltimore Orioles, 1990s: He's jacked, and he once hit 50 home runs and patrolled center field for some of my core childhood memories.

8. Alexi Pappas, middle distance runner, various races, 2010s: Great social media presence, great attitude, likes to smile while running through pain, filmmaker.

7. Caroline Wozniacki, tennis, singles, 2010s: I always liked her intensity and her embrace of the Wozzilroy nickname when she was dating Rory McIlroy.

6. Aly Raisman, gymnastics, Rio Olympics (?), 2010s: Adorable, and said yes when spontaneously asked on a date by an NFL player which made her pretty cool in my eyes. This is also great.

5. Alex Ovechkin, hockey, Washington Capitals, 2010s: He's brought me more joy than any other one athlete, and what is a crush, other than an expression of potential joy?

4. Maria Sharapova, tennis, singles, 2010s: She is so beautiful and was an awesome champion.

3. Alex Morgan, soccer, US Women's National Team, 2010s: I don't like that I created this list. It's not ranked accurately. Also, I can't even get to 20 athletes, really. I barely even know who Sarah Sellers is. I just respect her running. Which is crushworthy, but not really? Alex Morgan is beautiful and determined. Is that good?

2. Anna Kournikova, tennis, singles, 1990s: Here's the problem with this list: I'm afraid to say here that a woman is hot. Because then I'll be seen as a perv. So I stacked it with men, both because it's kind of unexpected, and because I wanted to deflect those accusations. Sexuality is a spectrum. I can't say I'm particularly naturally attracted to men, although there are certainly cases and exceptions. I put Anna Kournikova on this list. And it's scary, but I'm going to say it anyways: Anna Kournikova made it to this list exclusively because she is incredibly hot. I wanted to say that about Sharapova, too, but I couldn't bring myself to, and, anyways, I like Sharapova for other reasons. Will I be canceled? Let's see.

1. Joey Cora, baseball, Seattle Mariners, 1990s: See my comment on my AIM screen name.

Thursday, December 12, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 171: Zach

Prompt: "A song that you believe sucks but that you fear will be reclaimed by future generations as a bellwether or high-water mark of the era"

Selected by Zach


"Don't Know Why"
Norah Jones
Come Away with Me, 2002

There isn't a single Norah Jones song I would play on repeat. Which isn't to say that her music is bad! It's objectively solid. But she falls into the category for me of "why did this person make it so big?" I don't understand why her voice and piano vaulted over so many other artists that feel similar. That's a common theme for me, with Noah Kahan and many others. But I feel like there will be a pushback from the TikTok generation in future generations. The young people will want to hear slow songs that don't make their hair frizzier than it already is. And Norah Jones fits the bill. She will probably be reclaimed, and I still won't get it. And when she is reclaimed, it is her most famous song that will be reclaimed first.

There was a poetry open mic in Florentin that I would go to once a month. Lately it stopped, and I don't know why. I was talking to a couple other guys I know from Tel Aviv poetry world, and they're also sad it's gone. So we're talking about starting our own open mic. We met for drinks last night to hash out a plan. Sometimes you get together and make a plan for any project but the to-do list is just a little too vague and you're not sure anything will ever get done. I have a feeling if I want this to happen, I'm going to have to do most of it. Which I'm cool with, basically, because I am a slight control freak. Should it be at a bookstore? In a cold backyard somewhere? Who will come? How will we get them to come? Will they buy alcohol somewhere? None of the 20-somethings who used to come really bought alcohol from the last bookstore reading, which I never understood. Is that a Gen Z thing?

Monday, December 9, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 170: Zach

Prompt: "A song about..... um, I don't know. You tell me. Pick something funny that should have been included in this prompt. 'A song about ____.' Make it a good one."

Zach's Prompt: "A song that other YSC contributors redeemed for you, then ruined for you, then redeemed for you again, and meanwhile you hadn't even realized you were doing a whole internal monologue in your head that you thought had to do with the other contributors but then you know thanks to years of therapy that it just had everything to do with you and your own shit and you just have to keep trying to confront your own dark turmoil and doesn't that mean you're still hopelessly codependent and maybe you should talk about that with your therapist too but you're not going to because this week you'll just talk about your new girlfriend for one full hour and blow $140 and realize you could have spent that money at a Stephen Starr restaurant but then you realize you haven't heard about Stephen Starr for at least a decade and does he even still have restaurants in Philadelphia and the only reason you're even bringing him up is because you know all the YSC contributors will know who he is and therefore they'll get excited that you brought him up and you'll make them happy and by making them happy you'll be happy yourself and isn't that just your codependence rearing its head again and you realize it's hopeless, your situation, but it's not, you just have to pay for more therapy and switch therapists and maybe if you do that your hair will stop going gray and you'll live to 100 and see your great-grandchildren be born and isn't that the entire point of life anyways?"


"Cardinal"
Kacey Musgraves

I listened to a lot of Kacey Musgraves this year, pretty much exclusively thanks to her being mentioned on YSC. Sara was the first to clue me in to her with the best song / worst song on your favorite album prompt. Maeve's made a mention or two of Kacey. We all reviewed her album on RC around the time I learned about her. All this activity around this March embedded her music into my consciousness at a specific and annoying but ultimately hopefully less important period of my life—when I was moving into a new apartment with a roommate with a stick up his ass and an abrasive personality, when it became abundantly clear that the person I was dating was a total flake and an unreliable communicator, when I was sleeping on an air mattress, when the glass door at my friend's apartment inexplicably had shattered when I came home one day and one of the two cats I was watching there has since been missing and still hasn't come back nine months later, when I got a piece of glass stuck in my foot (and it stayed there for a month and a half), when I started to get nervous about my upcoming birthday, when I was stressing about packing up my entire old apartment by the end of the month (it was full of items that weren't mine), and so on and so forth. It was a hard time, but I listened to Kacey Musgraves during that time, and I learned about a new artist I actually liked. Did it make the time period easier? I don't know. But it did add a nice color to a time that, otherwise, felt unstable and oh god why do I need to end paragraphs so neatly, can't I just be insane and get spiritually electrocuted and have my hair go on fire and not really care what point I'm making and how that affects what other people think, why is this prompt so perfect for me?

So thank you to Sara, Maeve, Nate (for picking the basic-ass song I needed), and, really, also to Brianna, Bridget, Gilson, Sunny, Allison, and Joe for picking Deeper Well for RC through popular vote (just gonna assume we all voted, why sweat the details?) and of course not everyone voted so why am I even thanking everyone and I'm not name dropping everyone here because I'm codependent. I swear, but of course that's the main reason I'm doing it please just please tell me you love me, oh pretty please, over and over again, that's the good stuff, ahhhhhhhhhh and that's the good stuff, that's the fuel I need to get through the day and this week and this year and maybe my entire life?

Joe, in his abundant humility, would never assume that one of his creative initiatives (in this case, YSC) unquestionably changed someone's musical choices, and, therefore, someone's life, and even if he did, he would never put it out there in public. But I'm here to say that this creative initiative has had a real effect on my music listening this year (and probably for the rest of my life). Sometimes we need other people to say the true things about us that we'd never say about ourselves and you LOVE that sentence, Zach, don't you, you love reading your own writing, isn't it just so good, isn't it so genius, you're such a good writer, the whole world needs to know your talent, shut up, you're nothing, the whole world isn't seeing your writing and there must be a reason for that because maybe it's just not good enough and your poem got rejected from Fahmidian Journal this week because they don't want to read about your Arab Friend and maybe you'll never get published and you'll die alone.

This song feels like March 2024 to me. The slightly warmer air, longer sunlight, a different smell in the air. And stress. Lots of stress. That's fine. It's OK for songs to remind us of the mediocre times too no nothing is OK, everything is wrong and the world is upside down and we pretend like we're normal and neat and we button up our shirts like everyone else but inside we are just animals waiting to be released but we can't release ourselves because we need paychecks and bathrooms and healthy food and we've lost the hunter-gatherer in us and if the black bears of the eastern United States decided to rise up against us we won't be able to fight them because we're too busy talking about how the world makes us feel on Zoom to our therapists and we're just striving to stay alive until we hit a full century but the bears will kill us all anyway or maybe it'll be some new Gestapo we didn't know about until now and none of those hours and money spent on self-love will matter at all.

Saturday, December 7, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 169: Zach

Prompt: "A song about cycles"

Selected by Zach


"Belly of the Beat"
Grimes
Art Angels, 2015

I will stay in the spin cycle
Never get sad, never get sick, never get weak
From alcoholism
Drug addiction
Pornography
Eating only red meat
Men of God telling me what to do

These are the most enjoyable topics

When I move in cycles
I am most happy
Like the Barbie doll I can't get rid of
She stares at me with an evil smithy smile
I look back with empty eyesight

Meanwhile, the broccoli sits in the refrigerator
Its beta carotene will never enter my body
I'm committed to cycles
Of the highest order
Even if they will turn me inside out from the ground up.

Thursday, December 5, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 168: Zach

Prompt: "A song about traditions"

Selected by Zach


"Peace"
Zusha EP, 2014

You see, I have this tradition. I shorten my own lifespan in order to please other people. I've been observing it for 38 years and 243 days. 

Sometimes the tradition plays the long game, like when I stew in silence when my brother don't call me and I feel forgotten. Sometimes it plays the short game, like when my roommate tells me he wants to live with me again next year and that he thinks I should live with him again and how can I ever tell him that his general existence drives me absolutely crazy?

In both traditions, I feel my hair turning gray. My insides feel chewed up. I feel days, weeks, years being shaved off my life, like a snake shedding its skin. 

It's worth it. It's worth it to live shorter if it means not angering other people. It's worth it to miss birthdays and future grandchildren in order to avoid confrontations. 

Except I feel the tradition wavering lately. It's on the edge, trying to hold on tight, by the skin of its vicious teeth.

Last night I talked to myself in the shower. Well, I didn't really talk to myself. I talked to someone else.

"You're pretty cool. I'm so lucky to be dating you. I've wanted to date you for more than three years. You've been at the top of my list. I'm afraid the other shoe will drop, like it always does. So I'm trying to impress you by tapping into my masculine energy. I think that's what'll impress you the most. I'm going to do my best to be decisive, be a little aloof, talk less about my feelings. I try to not talk too much about my job situation because I think it's unattractive to not know what you want as a man trying to build a family and a home and aren't I supposed to be the main breadwinner and I know that the world isn't like that anymore and you've told me you want to make really good money yourself but still what will you think of me if I quit my well-paying job to work in a coffee shop? So I try to talk about it for a hot second and then change the subject but you're pretty perceptive and I'm sure you notice. Friends tell me that it's unattractive for a man to be overly emotional and I really think that's bullshit but there's some part of my brain that thinks there's a small kernel of truth there and that if I bring myself, my full self, to you that you'll want to run away. I want to tell you everything.  I want to tell you how I feel about you but I'm afraid it'll also scare you away and anyways I don't know how I really feel about you. To say 'I like you so much' would be grossly inaccurate because do I really like you, like, really, or do I just like the idea of you? All I know is that so far it's been really nice spending time with you. I can tell that you're holding back, too. You were engaged once. It makes sense. You told me you think I'm enigmatic, that I have a lot of layers to me. 'In a good way,' you made sure to add. I think that means you're still trying to figure me out. That makes sense. We've been out on six dates and already my brain wants to convince me that if someone put a gun to my head and told me to decide to either marry you on the spot, or lose you forever, I'd marry you. And that's bad behavior but there are too many layers there convincing me to move forward in unhealthy ways and at the same time stay in the same place in unhealthy ways and the only way I can get to clarity, real clarity is by going for a fast run and feel the weight in my body from all the ways I've been shortening my lifespan and anyways I went for a fast run last week and I don't have it in my body to do it again today. So I'll ask you to go hiking tomorrow but we'll have to take lots of buses to get there and I know you want to hike, you told me yourself, but I want to seem like I'm listening to you but that I also have my own thing going on like my own friends which I do but then I want it to seem like I'm doing my own thing all the time and that I don't need you but that I want you and that's a very narrow needle to thread and I feel like I have to be perfect around you and that's impossible, of course, just impossible but I still try because nothing else has worked up to this point and I don't know how to get to the Point B that I'm trying to get to. I can't tell you everything. I just can't. I've made that mistake before, at least I saw it as a mistake, but was it? I genuinely don't know. I'd be happy to sit there on the beach chair next to you and just sit there and we could look into each other's eyes and you're a meditator, I mean, you went on a two-month silent meditation retreat once! So it's not foreign for you to stare into someone else's eyes, especially someone you want to spend time with (at least I hope you do? I hope you're not doing what I do and keep dating people even though you know you want to end, just like I stay living with the same annoying roommate and in the same suffocating job because it will make other people happy and here we are at the same point of the circle where we've started, we've gone round and round again and I so badly want to put a stop to it but anyways I think you do want to spend more time with me, legitimately), but I can't bring myself to do it with you yet, and I know it'll happen when it happens and I have no control but I hope I'm doing all the things right. I don't want to make any unforced errors with you even though isn't life just a series of unforced errors anyways? This is a beautiful but harsh world. Of all the people in the world to understand another human quitting a job because they're not happy, you're one to understand. You've done it yourself so many times. And you left your living situation just last week because you weren't happy. Now you're happy in your job, and you're happy with your roommates (and does that also mean you're happy dating me?) You, in fact, refuse to be unhappy. And I love that about you. I think it's so cool. You inspire me with your smile and your listening abilities and your professed desire to be authentic and confident and your balanced attitude toward spirituality and religion and your love of hiking and the outdoors and how you wrote a book on living a zero-waste lifestyle but now you'll buy a cup of coffee to go with a lid which obviously isn't zero-waste but you understand that you live in the real world and you don't want to be extreme and how you're super close with your family and how you really love them and how you want to live in Israel and are really smart and athletic and how you learned Hebrew so quickly, it's just amazing, and how you know how to lucid dream and how the other night after we ate dinner which you paid for which I super respect because I am so happy to pay and I have paid for basically everything up to this point but the fact that you offered and did just means something to me and anyways you said you wanted to walk to the beach so we did and you asked me about intimacy and I told you how I felt about it and you told me how you felt about it and everything you said made so much sense and I liked you even more and then you saw some beach chairs and even though it was close to midnight and you go to bed at ten you made a beeline for them and I followed and the sand was cold but sitting there with you under the stars that were clear because there was nearly no moon was nice but also scary because I knew I was getting deeper into the hole with you and I just really, really don't want to get hurt again, even though of course it could happen, I really don't want it anymore, I've been through it too many times and I'm sick of it. Maybe you'll like me more if I work in a coffee shop. Maybe you'll like me less. Maybe it doesn't matter what you think! You don't get a say in my life yet, and I shouldn't give you one. Because codependency is unattractive but I don't want to care if it's unattractive or not because either way it's harmful to myself and that's really what matters in the end. Let's go for a hike this week. I want to be alone with you on the top of a mountain. There's not much that I want more right now."

That's what I told this person in the shower. 

If I told her that to her face, would I magically grow back all those years I have the tradition of losing, by pleasing other people?

The most famous sentence Rebbe Nachman ever wrote was this one: ".אין שום יאוש בעולם כלל" Transliterated: "Ein shum yei-ush ba-olam klal." Translated: "There is no despair in the world at all." Those are the only words to the song I picked here.

Rebbe Nachman's followers have a tradition to live like this. With absolute joy and by eliminating despair. They drive around in trucks, blasting happy music. They dance no matter who is watching, on street corners and highway off-ramps. 

The old tradition holds on so hard. It doesn't want to die even though I want to murder it. It clings to life with the tips of its fingernails. 

The most unattractive thing is to live according to what other people want and I feel like I'm in a vise grip. So I stand here at work, typing this. It's all I can do right now.