Prompt: "A song about breaking the rules"
Selected by Zach
"Listening"
The Everything-You-Knows
from I Think You Should Leave, 2023
My favorite book is The Great Gatsby. It's a masterpiece. There's no fluff, no extra word that doesn't need to be there. I can't pick a best part, or a favorite thing, but one thing I like? The fact that it has an unreliable narrator. Nick Carraway feels very trustworthy; you want to believe everything he has to say about his relationship with Jordan Baker. If you actually look at what happened, though, Nick's story falls apart. I imagine if Jordan Baker were to tell her side of the story, you'd see Nick as a tremendous asshole, a person who ghosts multiple women and treats the people closest to him at their most emotionally sensitive moments.
I'm curious how much unreliable narrator energy I'm putting out in the post below. I want to occupy the moral high ground; I want the other main character to seem as monstrous as they can appear in my brain. But maybe I'm wrong? I wonder if I'm Nick Carraway sometimes, trying too hard to fight the others who I perceive as "wronging me." Maybe I come on too hard. Maybe I'm too sensitive. Maybe I assume the worst in people, when they're all just really doing the best they can. I don't know. I'm definitely exposing things here, irrefutable facts about my life that are plastered on the page, text messages whose content can't be argued with, only interpreted in different ways. Maybe I'm unreliable. Maybe I'm right. Maybe I'm nothing, just digital dust. Or maybe I'm the one that fucked it all up and I'm just using her as a strawman to make myself feel good again.
Oh, and Tim Robinson actually got Turnstile to write a crazy song (that's also legitimately good) for a crazy sketch in his crazy show. How is this relevant to anything below? I have no idea. But I do LOL every time I watch that sketch.
Remainder of Wednesday, August 28: Right before I go to take my brother out for his pseudo bachelor party I get a couple of voice notes from A. The first one is very encouraging. She tells me she often needs time to process things. She lauds me for my patience. I feel really good. The second voice note is shorter. It brings me all the way down. All along I had known she was going to come to Israel on September 9 for two weeks, in part for a wedding she was planning on going to, but also to see me. This was keeping the fire burning—knowing we already had a plan to see each other again. The voice note said this: "Oh, by the way, this is a big thing, but I can't come to Israel—flights are too expensive and work got in the way and I have a bunch of stuff happening in New York and I'm afraid of the war."
I am incredibly bummed. Thankfully, I have the entire car ride to downtown DC for the bachelor party to talk to my brother and his matchmaker girlfriend about what just happened. They talk me off the ledge and advise me to be positive with her, to leave her a voice note that night thanking her for the communication and being very understanding about why she isn't coming (I mean, these are very legitimate reasons) and asking if we can check in to talk on the phone Thursday. I hatch a plan to go to New York for the final three days of my drip (Wednesday-Friday next week), and to maybe even switch my flight so it leaves from New York so I can stay for Shabbat. I go out with my brothers; it's great, my brother's girlfriend gets my other brother's partner and future wife very drunk. I leave her this voice note. I feel OK again. All is not lost. Still, I sleep terribly.
Thursday: There are various wedding things going on. Actually I can't even remember what I did Thursday. I guess I ran five miles? I went to pick up pizza for dinner? My future sister-in-law's family is all coming for dinner, and we are meeting them. I'm very curious about them. Meanwhile, A has not responded to my voice note at all, has not acknowledged it. Around 5:30, I transfer all the data from my old phone to the new phone I just bought. Throughout that process any WhatsApps I received from 5:30-8:30pm don't come through. I freak out. What if I missed A's text? I don't want to reach out. I need to play it cool, give her space. But this is too much. I send her a text telling her the situation. She writes back. "Hey, can we talk later tonight?" I don't know if she would have responded if I hadn't prompted her but I'm just happy we'll get to talk. We get on the phone at 11 PM. I tell her I understand why she's not going to Israel, even if I'm disappointed. As I'm talking, she tells me that she booked a flight. "I found a cheaper one," she said. "I'll only come for one week. Is that OK?" There's camping with her synagogue the week of Sept. 6, a communal dinner Sept. 13, a birthday weekend Sept. 27. Semi-commitments. I know she could get out of them. I find it a bit strange she's prioritizing them. But my brother's girlfriend says she wonders if A cares so much about her community because she never really connected with her family and didn't really find any kind of community until she turned 30 and so now it has an outsized presence in her life. I buy this explanation. I'm also so happy she's coming to Israel in the end—very relieved. I don't mention the planned New York trip for the end of my stay. I would prefer to hang with my family anyways; I barely get to see them. Still, dating has priority, and if going to New York feels right, I'll keep that idea in my back pocket. "Can we have Zoom breakfast together tomorrow morning?" she asks. I am very excited. Communication!
Friday: She wakes up late and this delays our breakfast by 30 minutes but we get in some time. And it's a nice chat! Friendly and date-ey. We say we'll talk after the wedding. She wishes me well. I'm feeling like things are in good shape—I don't HAVE to go to New York for three days even though I could, I'll see her in Israel September 16-23, and maybe that'll be the in-person launching pad we need. A few final pre-Shabbat texts later and I'm swimming in the wedding waters—out-of-town family guests are mostly already around.
Saturday: A ton happens outside of A. It's a wonderful day. I text A to ask her how her Shabbat was.
Sunday: Six hostages are found dead. "It's a really hard day," A tells me. I agree, it's a hard day. It's also the day of my brother's wedding! Nothing can really stop me from being happy. A doesn't ask me about the wedding once. "Today is just so painful," she keeps saying. And it is! But her incessant texting about pain as I'm dancing at my brother's wedding frustrates me.
Monday: I think we exchange some voice notes. She told me she likes hearing my voice. I can't remember. I've adjusted my communication at this point to "infrequent."
Tuesday: She says she liked some of the photos I posted but doesn't ask about the wedding. She talks about how sad she is about the news event. I leave her a voice note about that. "Thank you," she says. "That was exactly what I needed to hear." A second voice note about more wedding things going on during the week and about finding time to talk goes unacknowledged. Something is just off. Before I go to bed I text her. "Hey, I wasn't sure if you were going to respond to my other vn tonight, I wanted to see if we could find a time to chat this week." She writes back, telling me she just got home, asking if we can talk Wednesday at 9 PM? But I'm going to the Orioles game. I ask her if 9:30 PM works.
Wednesday: No communication until 6 PM, when I'm at Camden Yards. "Can you talk right now?" she asks. "My dinner got canceled." I didn't know there was a dinner, a coworker in town from California that she told me about, a voice note about how busy her week has been. Fine! It has been busy. But I just can't fully get behind it. I'm intense in relationships, I know this, and maybe I go overboard. But I always find a way to communicate. I tell her I'll call her between 9:30-10 PM, after the game, a game the Orioles lose to the White Sox 8-1. She says that's fine. The game ends. I text her to tell her I'll call at 9:50. She writes back, telling me she's on another call about planning events for her community. A call she hadn't previously mentioned. We don't end up talking that night, either; she told me her call stretched to 11:30. I can't keep up dealing with this flakiness. I'm still sleeping so badly. It is after this night that I decide the best course of action is to just back off as much as possible. I can't be making this happen almost alone.
Thursday: I don't reach out at all. She asks me at 8:30 PM how my day was, I say "aight," I ask her, she says it's been hard and painful. Sad emoji from me. And we move on. Nothing more.
Friday: Nothing from her until 4 PM. At this time, I am standing with a high school friend, who is visiting his sick mother. His mother isn't doing well at all. I'm saying goodbye to him. My flight is on Saturday night, and I have to finish packing. Shabbat starts at 6:55 PM, and after that I have to turn my phone off and be fully packed. I also had a few errands to run. A busy time. A rundown of the texts:
A (4:08 PM): Hey :) it's been a tough week. Hope you're holding up ok. I've been reflecting though and noticed that I'm not ready to explore a long-distance relationship. Obviously we've been struggling with connecting virtually after our strong connection in person. And I just don't think I'm able to be more present which is what you need. So I feel it's best to wish you my absolute best and unfortunately part ways. I wanted to send this message as a text so you can respond (if you choose) but that's how I'm feeling. I'm sorry the circumstances aren't different 🙁
Z (5:51 PM): Thx for the message
Would like to chat for a min if you can just call in the next hour
A (6:01 PM): I'm not free for the next hour 😕
Z (6:05 PM): I need 5 minutes
It will make a big difference for me
(6:19 PM): I know you're busy and I understand why you thought you should text. but it's really rough for me to have to sit through Shabbat after reading just a text, not getting a call about this, and not be able to at least speak my piece. I don't know what you're up to now but I really would appreciate you making a few mins to speak w me before Shabbat. I really feel like after all the emotions that were poured into this I want to go into Shabbat feeling like I don't have a big terrible weight on my body, esp as I'm flying Saturday night.
A (6:23 PM): I'm really sorry but I'm genuinely not free. Do you want to leave me a voice message and I'll listen to it after Shabbat ?
Z: (6:25 PM): Next time please think about how a text like that might be received before you send it if you're not free to chat
I don't want to vn
I understand the message and I totally accept it and I appreciate you telling me
But I feel totally silenced rn
Nothing more. Shabbat begins. I turn my phone off. My brother and his wife (weird to say!) are around. That is so nice. I'm sad to leave. I live so far away. Why am I living so far away? I know The familiar homesick feeling starts to creep in. Coupled with this pre-Shabbat news from A, I don't feel great. I do wish she had at least called.
There's the eternal debate about how you break up with someone. Personally, if I've gone on at least three dates with someone, I always call to end things. I didn't used to do that. Breaking up with someone SUCKS. I've stayed in relationships for way too long just to avoid that phone call. In that way, I do appreciate that A didn't draw things out, especially if she was already feeling that way. And it was obvious something was up. I'm not shocked. But I'm sad. What whiplash! Such a promising start, and such a denouement, all within three weeks, all within one trip to the US.
And I'm frustrated. It's one thing to text someone to break up with them. I can understand it. It's another thing to text someone and then be unavailable to talk, especially when you know there are only three hours or so left before a 25-hour no-phone time area begins. That's what makes me mad. I'm also just frustrated that there's basically been no communication between us lately. I haven't been sleeping. This thing took over my life, with the backdrop of a great family joy just there the whole time too. Now I understand that the source of that lack of communication was her uncertainty about the whole thing, but knowing that didn't make anything easier.
Saturday: I fly out at night after Shabbat. I saw old friends during the day, read on the couch, took a walk as the sun was setting. A great day. My sadness has faded a little bit. Thank God. But I still feel unsettled, like I need to have a conversation. The biggest difference between the US and Israel? How quiet things are. The silent forests of Jerusalem crackle louder with the sounds of spiritual energy than do the blaring horns of Manhattan. A hasn't written me a text. I get on an airplane and fly away. I only get through one movie—Interstellar. Not recommended to watch Christopher Nolan movies on airplanes—too hard to hear, too hard to understand.
Sunday: I land in London for a long layover, walk eleven miles around the city, witness Rex Orange County fans. No communication with A. Plane movies: Matchmaking (cute and poignant Israeli movie about religious dating, very inside baseball, but I appreciated it), half of the original Aladdin (fun and nostalgic and interesting how evil they make Jafar, it's like a joke, only had the stamina for part of it, I don't think I've seen it since I was ten), A Star is Born (the perfect emotional plane movie, I think this is my third time watching it on a plane, it's just so good). I wanted a romantic movie. Love and Basketball was an option. I kind of wish I had gone for it.
Monday: I land in Israel and go straight to work. I'm falling asleep. It seems that I need to reach out to A. I still want to have that conversation. She probably won't reach out. I don't blame her for this lack of communication. She is probably afraid of doing the wrong thing. I hand write her a letter in my journal, take a photo of it, send it to her, explaining how I'm feeling and asking her to talk. I wait for her response. I get it eventually.
Tuesday:
A (9:51 PM EST, 4:51 AM Israel Time): Hey Zach, thanks for writing down your thoughts and sharing them with me. I wanted to write my feelings as a text because I wanted you to have a chance to see my words and process them. But I hear you on how that was difficult. Would you like to talk tomorrow evening around 7 PM ET?
A (9:51 PM EST, 4:51 AM Israel Time): Hey Zach, thanks for writing down your thoughts and sharing them with me. I wanted to write my feelings as a text because I wanted you to have a chance to see my words and process them. But I hear you on how that was difficult. Would you like to talk tomorrow evening around 7 PM ET?
Z (11:43 PM, 6:34 AM): Thanks A
7 PM et is 2 AM here, I will definitely be asleep
Would need to be later in your night, like 11 PM or so, or anytime in your daytime before 3-4 PM
A (8:44AM, 3:44PM): Today I am booked with back to back meetings so I can't during the day. And I won't be able to do after 11 PM
How about tomorrow during the day my time?
Z (8:49 AM, 3:49 PM): Sure, I could def do before 11 AM, then prob also free after 3/3:30 PM, there could be some flexibility in there too
All those times eastern
A (10:13 AM, 5:13 PM): Hows 9 AM ET?
Z (10:56 AM, 5:56 PM): That works
A (1:13 PM, 8:13 PM): Let's reschedule to Friday morning actually, can you do that?
Z (1:21 PM, 8:21 PM) [steam coming out of my ears]: I can do 9:30
Wednesday: No response from A when I wake up. It's far too early in the morning for anything. I'm still jet lagged. She's had the entire afternoon and evening to confirm our talking time. What the fuck? I've been chasing this stupid person for two and a half weeks and she remains just barely out of my reach. I spend half an hour typing out an angry text, then delete it. I settle on this:
Z (11:38 PM, 6:38 AM): Can you please confirm this??? Truthfully I'd still rather talk today. This whole thing is just weighing on me and I need to move on. But if today truly doesn't work I will be flexible to Friday, even though it's not preferable.
Just let's please lock in a time that I can rely on. Thanks
The whole work day goes by.
A (9:28 AM, 4:28 PM): Fine. I can make today work. I'll be at my office.
Z (9:30 AM, 4:30 PM): Thank you
A: I have to say this whole thing is making me extremely uncomfortable. I think we said what needs to be said, and we always knew that the logistics would be hard. I don't know how productive a phone call is going to be without you getting angry at me like you are about me having trouble scheduling it.
Z: I can call in 15 if that works
I've been feeling extremely uncomfortable too for multiple weeks now
Because we haven't spoken
I really just need to have a final phone call to move on. That's it
A: Let's talk in 15
I wish I could just let it all go. I wish I could not care about talking to her. But I want to do it anyway. There's a hole inside me that needs filling.
So we talk. I reassure her that I'm not mad at her, that that's not what this is about. I can feel her relax. I just want to talk, since we've barely done that. I want to hear it all from her voice. She says that's exactly the issue, that throughout this whole thing she's realized she needs physical proximity, that long distance doesn't work for her. I tell her that's cool. She apologizes for sending a text. I tell her that's fine, but what was hard for me was the lack of availability after that text was sent. She says she had a hard week last week, that she pulled back even more when she felt like I was just one more person expecting something from her. I told her that makes sense, that normally I'd have been there much more for her, but that I wasn't able to be there for her because I just didn't know where I stood. That I didn't quite feel safe. I said I had never planned on a long relationship of talking on the phone from different continents, that maybe if we'd seen each other in Israel and it had gone well I'd have decided to take another trip to the US, and then who knows? My last long-distance relationship nearly killed me. I want to find my partner, not date someone for days and hours and many, many weeks. She said she heard me but that she just can't do long distance. I told her she's a good person. She said the same. "That wasn't so bad, was it?" I said. She agreed.
And we said goodbye. The phone clicked off, and I was alone on the bus.
We turned uphill, went through the tunnel. Around a bend, I saw a lane closed on the other side. Big wooden pallets had fallen off a truck and they were blocking traffic. A policeman was directing cars around. Behind me, a child perked up. "Mommy, what is that?" he asked.
"Oh, a truck must have had a little accident!" she told her child.
And the child went silent, seemingly satisfied with the explanation of something out of the ordinary.
Unless—he wasn't?
Maybe he just needed a few minutes to process. That truck, strong, all steel and metal. Starting its drive with confidence, like most of us. Around the first bend, something didn't go right. There was a blockage. A policeman came. The child came, only curious. Seeing something that went wrong. His mother explained it to him, but he still wondered. Why did it happen? Why did the wood pallets litter a perfectly clear road?
I got off the bus. There was a breeze in the air. It was a cloudless day. I also started uphill, walking into the city, to the train, to the next place. Someone was waiting for me there. The day was nearing its end, but it wasn't over. Soon I'd meet that other person, on a bench, a destination still a few miles away.
But it wasn't really that far. The wooden pallets and that risky bend in the road were somewhere behind me. And I didn't want to look back.
6 comments:
I am envisioning this blog post being discussed in a high school English class in the same way that The Great Gatsby might. A frustrated jock in the back complaining, "it just seems like this guy is spending so much damn time with the text messages trying to schedule a breakup call!" and the teacher getting really excited, clasping her hands together, saying to the class, "well, what do we think? what do you think that the author is trying to convey with the text messages? what are we learning about Z? and about A?" and so on, trying to get the class involved in a discussion that maybe 30% of them are interested in, and the other 70% are just trying to get through, just get to lunch, so they can TikTok their friends. Book discussions are wasted on the young.
I commend the absolute guts of steel it takes to post one's one breakup text messages on a blog, you're at least twice the man I am.
Also, imagine running five miles and then just forgetting that you did it. Couldn't be me!
Also also, Os lost to the White Sox? Os are frauds.
3 comments...no juice.....
Here's the fourth, calling Anonymous a pussy-ass bitch until he or she puts his or her name on their comment and/or writes his or her own damn blog post with this much heart and soul in it.
Thank you for posting the update because I’ve been really close to asking for one. I’ve been thinking about this saga all day. I’m especially annoyed at A being so aloof in conversation and then on the day of your brothers wedding was really asking for a lot of support. I’m sorry that it fizzled so fast but it’s for the right reasons. Which is really a big eye roll to hear from people.
All I know is that the person who’s out there for you will be all in. Glad you got to spend those last days with family!!
This is Zach - Joe your comment made me LOL especially since I’m a sucker for a good high school English Lit discussion, looking forward to the Nate breakup texts column on this blog, and Sara - your comment just touched my heart, the fact that this story stayed with you all day and that you’re in my corner makes me feel so good.
Post a Comment