Tuesday, September 17, 2024

Top Five Tuesday: The War on Drugs and the National


Headed to a concert tonight at the Mann Center. Shout out to all the PoYB Contributors that are gonna be in attendance and no doubt writing a long, extensive, detailed review of their experiences to be published here. We got Sunny! We got Rachel S.! We got Dwyer! We got my wife and best friend Pam! We got anyone else? If you're reading these Top Five lists and realizing that you bought tickets to the very same War on Drugs / National double bill that I'm referring to, then hit me up! We're gonna crush Aldi seltzers for an hour beforehand in the parking lot!

I am hoping that the Mann Center, like Union Transfer and Johnny Brenda's, does not have a strict No Recording Devices rule of any sort, because I'm gonna bring my shitty little voice recorder and get some audio of the concert. I'll do what I usually do and write the setlist and give some general thoughts. I wasn't kidding about any other attendees writing down some thoughts as well, but we'll see about that.

So that'll be the review. This here will be the preview. My own personal Top Five War on Drugs Songs and Top Five National Songs.

Top Five War on Drugs Songs

Dwyer did a great job ranking (almost) every War on Drugs song a couple weeks ago, so if you're gonna start somewhere, start there. The man knows his Drugs. Should he have included instrumentals? Should "In Chains" have been higher? Should he have stuck to evaluating studio versions of the songs only? Should Kurt Vile have gotten more than a brief mention? Yes on all counts, but ya know, that's the blogging game, baby. This ain't groupthink, these are personal opinions, and should be respected, if not necessarily agreed with. That was a good ranking. Don't listen to a goddamn word he says.

I am pretty fond of this band, but not as much as Dwyer might want me to be. It took me a long time to "get" Lost in the Dream, their big breakout. It's a big sound, and I have a weak stomach. Years later, and it finally clicked for me how good it was. A Deeper Understanding feels just as big but is always gonna be a "Lost in the Dream but again." I Don't Live Here Anymore was a come up but that has more to do with Record Club giving it a boost than an actual measurable rise in quality.

No, I think I've always been a Slave Ambient guy. It's one of those things that the album you discover at an important time in your life is the one that sticks with you, and Slave Ambient is that album for me from that time. I was a bit lost in life, having given up the college dream (i.e. to stay in college forever), against my will, to return to my parents home, work every day, save some money for a sojourn in a far-off city with my then-girlfriend, just clocking the hours and sitting in my room after work and listening to a weird little band from Philly that used to have Kurt Vile in its ranks (also listened to Kurt Vile's Smoke Ring for My Halo a lot around this time). So maybe this is my favorite War on Drugs album.

I don't know. It's all complicated. Ranking songs from an entire discography is tough. All that being said, I just listened to Wagonwheel Blues for the first time last week, and so here is my list of Top Five War on Drugs Songs of All Time.

5. "There Is No Urgency" from Wagonwheel Blues — A band might still be trying to figure out their identity on that first album. That's fair. And maybe, throughout that process, they are gonna sound like other bands. Also fair. No shame in sounding like Dylan or Springsteen, those are very safe touchstones to fall back on. But here? "There Is No Urgency"? Takes some fucking balls for such a band to sound so much like Animal Collective in this context. Certainly not the worst song in this band's discography, I mean, c'mon.

4. "Show Me the Coast" from Wagonwheel Blues — The trick isn't finding nirvana. The trick is to stay there. Once you hit on that perfect sound, there ain't no reason why you shouldn't stretch that shit to ten long minutes. Shit, bro, shoulda made it 100.

3. "Buenos Aires Beach" from Wagonwheel Blues — I love that we get a little "oh!" at the end of the first verse on this song. That oh would earn a few more exclamation points as War on Drugs progressed and matured. Me? I think there should be as many exclamation points as you can possibly fit in there. Murder me with the oh.

2. "Taking the Farm" from Wagonwheel Blues — Nice groove.

1. "Needle in Your Eye" from Wagonwheel Blues — Are you there, God? It's me, Joey. I haven't talked to you in a really long time. Not since like junior year of high school when I decided you didn't exist. But I need you to exist now, God. I need you to hear me, hear my plea. My desperate call for help, from my lips toward the heavens. Please, God, please. What I need, more than anything else, is to go to the concert tonight and show up early and see the War on Drugs roadies getting all the shit on stage and see them dragging that goddamn (sorry) Wurlitzer out onto that stage, see the big Wurlitzer and know for certain that War on Drugs are playing "Needle in Your Eye" live for the raucous Philadelphia crowd. Please. I know it's a lot to ask. I know I haven't been going to church lately. But I need this. Thank you, Dear Lord. In your name I pray.


Top Five National Songs Songs

Alright, alright, I'm actually going to take this one seriously. I didn't need to actually rank my favorite WoD songs. It doesn't matter. Someone else already ranked their songs. I said what I needed to say about that ranking. You can click on any of the links in that original ranking and hear the songs and decide for yourself. Wagonwheel Blues really is a great album though. I wouldn't mind hearing "Needle in Your Eye" live. We'll see.

The National, I mean, what more is there to say on this blog that I haven't already said.

How about this: I hate the "sad dad" descriptor that I see constantly. Calling this band by that description seems way too glib. I mean, it's not necessarily untrue, but being a sad dad is not really something to celebrate. It's real and painful and it's hard-earned. Sleep Well Beast soundtracked the autumn of 2017, when Pam was pregnant and I did something so horrible while blackout drunk that I will never actually write what it was on this blog (so it musta been real bad, hoo boy). By the winter/spring of 2019, that baby was almost one, and I was still blacking out, and one time shipped the baby to my parents so I could go out and drink a lot and wake up and keep drinking and write about Sleep Well Beast and then stop at the Wine and Spirits at Frankford Terminal so I could keep drinking on the El and then got to my parents' and blacked out again while the baby slept and I told my parents who knows what. I get sad thinking about this, and my thoughts about the National are wrapped around them and refracted through them in sad but also beautiful ways. Sad dad indeed.

And that's the Sparknotes version of my story with only one of their albums (either my favorite or second favorite and either their second best or third best). Boxer was one of four albums that defined the pivotal freshman year of college. Alligator soundtracked a really dark winter break. I Am Easy to Find found life in the early stages of Record Club, and remains so important to me. Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers showed up late and stayed even later. High Violet missed me due to financial reasons, but made its way back around for critical reasons. Trouble Will Find Me was the sound of my life right on the very cusp of falling into the groove that I still find myself trapped in today. 

I'm not here to rank the albums. Thank god. Imagine seeing Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers at like #6, and how fucking suicidally painful that sight would be. Jesus fucking christ.

They aren't going to be playing any albums in full tonight anyway. The songbook is too deep. So let's rank some songs. There are more than five good ones, obviously. I'm not doing any honorable mentions because, again, if you wanna hear more songs from this band, you can do the work yourself. It's worth it. Even the last two albums they put out, both in 2023, have some bangers that I'm excited to hear tonight. You can't really go wrong.

But here are my five favorites, after much hemming and hawing. There aren't going to be many surprises. The National have very many great songs but the cream of the crop are that way for many. Just a symptom of being able to crank out more than five songs that could easily work as the song of a generation. What a shame.

5. "I'll Still Destroy You" from Sleep Well Beast — Okay, but if there was going to be a not-necessarily-consensus pick in this bunch, I'd slot it in at #5, and I have done so here. When I hear this song, I am brought right back to those crucial months of my life in the autumn of 2017, when an impending fatherhood made me fear that I wasn't good enough for all this, that I was going to fail. Pretty boilerplate new-father anxieties, you see... but then again, not every song can speak to them so painfully as this song can.

4. "Lit Up" from Alligator — There's always a lot of talk about the National needing to "go back" to how they used to sound, a harder sound that involved more of Matt Berninger screaming and less of Aaron Dessner bathing us in a warm tub of bleeps and bloops. But, ya know, it's tough to ask the old vanguard of indie rock legends to do this, to make new hits like the old hits sounded like. If you really are that butthurt about Bryan Devendorf trading in his drum kit occasionally for a electronic drum pad, then all you gotta do is put on "Lit Up." Hear that anthemic chorus again. Feel the catharsis of a band in the pocket.

3. "Bloodbuzz Ohio" from High Violet — The thing about the National is that their lyrics don't really make sense on first glance. "I was carried to Ohio in a swarm of bees." But, c'mon, you know as I do (or pretend I do) that this isn't how poetry works. What does the swarm of bees mean to you? Figuratively speaking? Oh, I remember my bees, back at the turn of the decade, when I was still getting my bearings straight on the whole post-college thing. It makes sense that "Bloodbuzz Ohio" would be the song that made me feel like I could be bigger than I was, since it's also the song that made the National bigger than they ever were before. This is the sound of an indie rock band reaching stadium status.

2. "All the Wine" from Alligator — My perception of the power of this song collapsed around the same time that I stopped acting like its protagonist. The irony is that, with newfound clarity, I see an even greater power in "All the Wine." I see sadness in what I lost and what I thought I had. I see joy in living in the moment, which can happen no matter what is or is not coursing through your veins. I see a peace in being who you want to be, the person you need to be in any given moment.

1. "Fake Empire" from Boxer — Looking over the tracklist on Boxer, I am thinking that maybe there are a few other songs on that album that make me feel more than "Fake Empire" does. The thing about "Fake Empire," besides the fact that it's a perfect song, is that I'm not the only one who feels this way about "Fake Empire." It's a well-known song. It's well-liked. A lot of people might consider it the National's best and, like me, one of the best songs of all time, full stop. But I wonder if maybe something like "Brainy" or "Mistaken for Strangers" or "Green Gloves" or "Apartment Story" shouldn't be here instead. Then I listen to the songs again, and each one is like a punch to the gut, almost too painful to bear. They are all just too tightly tied to maybe the biggest, weirdest, saddest, most volatile months of my entire life. I seek "Fake Empire" for protection above all else. Maybe we can just pretend its about the 2008 Obama campaign, instead of what it's really about, to me. That feels better. That feels more endurable.


I don't have a "bucket list of bands I want to see live" or anything like that, but if I did, these two artists would both be on it. Glad to cross 'em both off the list that doesn't exist on the same night.

No comments: