Thursday, September 12, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 132: Joe

Prompt: "A song about breaking the rules"

Selected by Joe


"Fuck the System"
System of a Down
Steal This Album!, 2002

There were goodhearted chuckles when the bride's little brother, ten years our junior, incredulously asked from the backseat if this car was equipped with an iPod, an honest-to-god, old-school, click-wheel iPod. I said yes. Explained that I had gotten a new one a few years ago from Etsy with a bootlegged amount of gigs on the thing, probably equipped to handle the pace at which I devour new music for another seven years or so. And then another dude from the back, a friend already familiar with my music peculiarities, chimed in about "insulting the artist" by "stealing" their music, and so on and so on.

Nothing I haven't grappled with before. Certainly wasn't going to be grappling with it in public with intoxicated friends, trying to pay back some karma with some designated driving through unfamiliar suburban locales. No, the grappling has all been internal, a sweaty balancing of ethics and artistic desires, now turned outward through the blog post and a need to fill the damn space with something.

Here's the fact of the matter: I rarely, if ever, pay for music. The means through which I acquire the music are unimportant for the purposes of this argument. What matters is that I don't pay. I take for free. This is quantifiably different than most. I assume that the majority of listeners pay $10 per month for a streaming service, most like Spotify but maybe Apple or maybe even something else. There are those who don't pay because they don't listen to that much music and YouTube videos with ads gets 'em by. There are those who have found better but still financially inconvenient ways to support the artist. Okay, let's put those to the side too. My point is that the standard right now is paying $10/month. I am paying close to $0/month.

Here's what's not different: how much of our respective payments are going toward the artists we are listening to. The musicians aren't getting shit from streaming services. Your ten dollars is not supporting the artist you are listening to. It is instead supporting the corporate suits who fucking hate music and fucking love money. Yes, I'm stealing money from the artists, but let's not pretend my money makes or breaks. I'm stealing a couple pennies a year from the musicians I love. I'm stealing hundreds of dollars from the fucking artless suits who want to take advantage of people like me. None of this makes me right, per se. I'm still in the wrong. But the margins are softer than what the asshole in the backseat of my Kia wants you to believe.

Another reason that I like having music on my iPod that doesn't necessarily make it right but definitely makes sense in the society we live in: I like the idea of ownership. Trusting some faceless fucker to "keep my art safe" in their cloud or whatever is just not something that I will ever truly believe in. I don't like the idea of some shitstain deciding that it's no longer feasible to allow me to listen to such and such an album, and removing it from the library without warning. I don't like the idea of depending on this structure to deliver my music when I need it, and then having to eat shit when that structure inevitably fails as I enter the Regional Rail train tunnel. I don't like how those who don't care about music also don't care about proper capitalization rules in song titles. I like having a box in which I keep all my music, tagged meticulously and to my liking, always available as long as I have headphones and a forethought to charge the iPod in advance. There's comfort in that.

This is not a justification either, just an explanation: I am making a conscious choice to engage in the art that makes me happy, by any means necessary. Take everyone else out of the equation and just focus on me—I have a choice. I can either steal music and listen to that music and use that music for emotional stability and find some peace of mind through that music, or I can refuse to listen to music without paying full price for it with all that money going directly toward the artist and... end up not listening to much music at all. I don't have excess money. The only reason we're in the black right now is because I gave up drinking. If I picked up a vinyl-purchasing habit, we'd be right back in the red. It's just not feasible (for now—there's always the possibility of a Powerball win). I'm choosing selfishly, yes. I'm choosing to be happy. That's just the way it is.

Now this is more of a justification, albeit a rather weak and shaky one: what we are doing here on this blog is theoretically more valuable than paying the creepy-ass Spotify CEO for the privilege of casually listening to his music library. I'm not just listening and discarding and forgetting. I am listening and then passing along the shit that I love. I am writing literally millions of words about music to make the case that you should be listening to this music too. I could pay an artist $0.002 per stream, or I could pay nothing and then convince through the blog two people to each pay an artist $0.002 per stream, effectively doubling this specific potential income stream of the artist. I'm certainly not pretending that Puke on Your Birthday has anywhere close to a far reach, that's why I purposefully used the example of "two people." This is the same model that any music blog is using, just on a smaller scale. You think the writers at Stereogum are paying for their damn music? Hell no, they get it for free, because getting that music into the hands of a writer with an audience is more valuable than convincing someone to listen to those same songs in a vacuum. Again, PoYB is operating on such a smaller scale comparatively that I'd be surprised if you weren't currently pointing your finger at me and laughing like Nelson from The Simpsons, but it's technically true! I really do think that writing about music offsets the cost of stealing music!

It's been more than two decades since System of a Down implored you to steal their album (a wink wink nudge nudge toward piracy), and a lot has changed since then. In many ways, System of a Down lost this particular battle, and the corporate vampires won. There was a motivation at the turn of the century to steal music, and instead of trying to stop people from following that motivation, they just removed the motivation altogether. It's a lot easier to pay $10 per month in perpetuity to some fucking asshole than have to worry about obtaining and documenting and caring for music. There are so few of us now who are still motivated to do this through increasingly byzantine and convoluted ways that I get laughed at while I'm driving late on a Thursday night through fucking Ambler, PA.

We keep fighting this fight. We keep breaking the rules. We care so much about music that we're gonna schlep that music around on a badass iPod that functions the same way that these iPods have functioned in my possession since I was gifted a (free! technically stolen!) iPod for my eighteenth birthday. Fuck all the naysayers. Go listen to your robot-made, corporate-funded Spotify algorithm, ya jabronis.

2 comments:

Nate said...

Everyone should be forced to listen to music on BANDCAMP, the number-one resource for some great music, and an absolute deluge of stuff that sucks out loud. Just yesterday I paid some weird kid from Connecticut $4 for 10 great songs. Seems like a good deal to me.

Joe K said...

"There are those who have found better but still financially inconvenient ways to support the artist." That was definitely a reference to the PoYB contributor who gives a lot of money to Bandcamp. For the record, this is probably the BEST way to support the artist. Unfortunately, it's just not doable for me at this time, financially speaking. Hence the tough choice.