Friday, September 13, 2024

The Black Parade, Dave


A pretentious trait of music fandom, especially prevalent in the punk scene, is abandoning bands upon "selling out." I hate it. It's gross. Sixteen-year-old me is guilty of it. I'm not going to relitigate the term "selling out," but The Black Parade is a prime example of a band selling out, and it worked out beautifully.

I remember the first time I heard My Chemical Romance. It was the fall of 2003 on John McCafferty's headphones in the Judge cafeteria somewhere in the 7:00 AM hour. The song was "Drowning Lessons." It's a fun and catchy tune, contrasted by lyrics about murdering a love interest, an element trademarked by the emo genre. What struck me, though, was the rawness of the song and the ensuing album, which I had a friend burn for me shortly thereafter. The album, I Brought You My Bullets, You Brought Me Your Love, sounds like it was recorded during a basement show. That's not a bad thing. It's endearing and makes the band relatable. Their sophomore effort, Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge, is a bit more polished, but still contains the raw component.

By the time The Black Parade came out, MCR was no longer an edgy post-hardcore band from suburban North Jersey. They were a rock band who acted like they've been there before.

The Black Parade is a concept album about a cancer patient, and opens with the sound of a beeping hospital monitor. We've all heard that sound firsthand, and it immediately grabs your attention after you hit play. The album is pretty aggressive from the outset, with catchy hooks and Ray Toro's signature guitar workings. The band slows things down midway through with "Cancer," which is an incredibly morbid song written from the perspective of the dying patient who is both protagonist and antagonist of the album. This is not the slow song that most fans will skip over. It's a must listen.

The most interesting song on the album, and potentially MCR's entire catalog, is "Mama." A scathing letter written by the patient to his mother, "Mama" toes the line of parody, but keeps the mood so dark. The patient is very much an unreliable narrator, which brings a certain appeal to both this song and the entire album. This is some of Gerard Way's best work as a writer.

Musically, this album is on par with MCR. However, it's more produced than anything they've released. While that may turn some fans off, MCR makes it work. The well-placed sound effects and orchestra cuts complement the eerie nature of the album's concept. If this is selling out, then I hope all of my favorite bands sell out.

3 comments:

Maeve said...

I love this album so much.

Joe K said...

As Dave has proven today, it is never too late to write your Record Club review for the album!

Bridget said...

Perfect review!!!!