Violator
Depeche Mode
1990
I sincerely have no idea whether I should feel bad for missing this one for the first three and a half decades. It almost feels like maybe this was a band that was popular but not critically respected, and then since their peak there's been a critical reevaluation, and now it is acknowledged that they were popular but also important and influential. I could even see there being a class of music listeners who scoffed at this shit back in the late '80s and early '90s and is not flabbergasted and disgusted at the idea of that music coming back around into popular culture. Am I making all this up? Possibly. The music does seem to want to feel mysterious, so why not the blog post too.
There is a subset of albums that end up on the Blind Spots list because I know the name and literally nothing else. Depeche Mode was one of those bands, to the point that Pam had to correct me on the pronunciation of the name (it's "dee-PESH," not "dee-PESH-ee"). I thought that maybe they were a cult-level band, but then I discover that this album had TWO alt-rock #1 hits (not that they were the straight-up most popular songs in the country, but being the most popular rock, or "rock," songs in the country is nothing to sneeze at either). And I listen thinking that this is gonna be a brand new experience for me, but then quickly realize that I know one of the songs really well. "Personal Jesus." No idea how, but I do, which means it was or is ubiquitous. And "Personal Jesus" wasn't even one of the aforementioned #1 hits!
"Personal Jesus" hit me all wrong. At first, it was kinda the same way I felt about slugs—like, I know that I probably had a really traumatic incident with slugs at some point in my childhood, and I'm scared of them even though I don't remember any such incident. But all I had to do was look it up, and the answer is that Johnny Cash covered it, and I hate Cash's music, but more importantly, Marilyn Manson covered it and had a popular version of it in my youth, and Brian Hugh Warner is an abusive piece of shit. So maybe I was thinking of his version? I don't know. It doesn't matter. "Personal Jesus" is not a song we need to talk about in this context or any other context.
The other eight songs are good enough to carry the water. "Enjoy the Silence" and "Policy of Truth," the two songs that hit #1, are fantastic. Not sure that I was familiar with them before this, which makes it even better. The former is dark synthpop mixed with widescreen disco. The latter is slinky and has a crunchy synth line that has stayed with me all week. The other songs find space in between those two poles—light and dark but mostly dark and weird and heavy and mysterious. That Depeche Mode was able to convince people that this was popular music to be consumed by the masses is one incredible trick.
I guess that's where my head is at this week. What is popular, does popularity matter, and so on. I know it's not important. Text is more important than context. But I can't help but think I only love this music because it has, since 1990, become vastly less popular. If someone had told me when I was one year old that "Enjoy the Silence" was the song of the summer, I would've scoffed, accused it of being artless swill, ya know, all the snobby bullshit your typical one-year-old music critic might indulge in. But here I am, listening to the art, able to strip away any undue context, and just enjoy the music.
It really is fun, listening to this. I could imagine thinking that this is try-hard shit, that the dark goth sound is a guise to sell records. Let's forget all that. I begrudge them no more than I would their only late-'80s mainstream peers, the Cure, who made music of a similar aesthetic if not necessarily structure (Cure is more theatrical, and more indebted to rock 'n' roll, whereas Depeche Mode feel like the weirdo art kids in the back of the class, content to stay in the shadows). Hit me with those swirling synths, the brooding vocals, the shuffling rhythms, the how-can-it-be-sad-when-we're-all-sad-together lyrics. Don't tell me if other people like this. Let me just like it on my own. It's more fun that way.

No comments:
Post a Comment