1951
Elia Kazan
I like thinking about A Streetcar Named Desire as a Rorschach test. You see in these characters what you want to see. The genius of the film (and the play before it, I assume) is that there really is no right answer in terms of who is right and who is wrong, who is acting reasonably under the circumstances and who is acting insane, who is the hero and who is the villain. All four main characters are both sides of each coin. That's what makes them deep, real, human. But the other thing is that humans are watching the film too, and we're flawed, and we don't have the capability to see an entire person, all at once. And so we pick and choose.
The discussion begins and ends with Marlon Brando and his portrayal of Stanley. I didn't know anything about this film going into it, but I did vaguely know (extrapolating backward from On the Waterfront) that Brando became a sex symbol after starring in Streetcar. So the assumption, I guess, is that Stanley is going to be the hero, perhaps a complicated one. Not so. Complicated, yes, but hero? Impossible to describe him as such. The character is abusive, abrasive, toxic, manipulative, violent. Brando's acting is a black hole, sucking up everything else in the scene. Maybe it's the acting, so visceral and real and raw, that makes us try so hard to find anything redemptive in this guy. It can't be done, though. But we try anyway, and that's what makes it a special performance. I just can't stop thinking about Brando performing with a mouth full of food, ya know? You cannot watch this film in 2024 and think that this dude is anything but a horror film villain, and yet Brando's performance was so explosive that it changed Hollywood forever. Shit, man, the tension between those two truths. Wild.
The discussion begins and ends with Marlon Brando and his portrayal of Stanley. I didn't know anything about this film going into it, but I did vaguely know (extrapolating backward from On the Waterfront) that Brando became a sex symbol after starring in Streetcar. So the assumption, I guess, is that Stanley is going to be the hero, perhaps a complicated one. Not so. Complicated, yes, but hero? Impossible to describe him as such. The character is abusive, abrasive, toxic, manipulative, violent. Brando's acting is a black hole, sucking up everything else in the scene. Maybe it's the acting, so visceral and real and raw, that makes us try so hard to find anything redemptive in this guy. It can't be done, though. But we try anyway, and that's what makes it a special performance. I just can't stop thinking about Brando performing with a mouth full of food, ya know? You cannot watch this film in 2024 and think that this dude is anything but a horror film villain, and yet Brando's performance was so explosive that it changed Hollywood forever. Shit, man, the tension between those two truths. Wild.
That's not to take away from the fascinating performance of Vivien Leigh as Blanche. We last saw Leigh in Gone with the Wind, and Blanche almost feels like a parody of that refined manner (I am avoiding saying "demure" because I don't want any Gen Z kids to misinterpret their new buzz word as some sort of dogwhistle). She is prim and proper to the point of literal mental illness. Maybe. Does Blanche actually suffer from illness, or has she been manipulated into the asylum by her insidious brother-in-law? Let's leave that question to high school English classes, and let's focus on the fact that we can ask that question with a straight face because Leigh so nimbly straddles that fence. There's a reading that Blanche is the true manipulator here. That reading was probably a lot stronger in 1951, and would feel tinged with misogyny as presented in 2024. All depends on how you want to (or need to) view the character. Does she lie by omission because she is trying to gain the advantage in the household, or does she lie to protect herself from the monster that she finds herself locked in battle with?
Kim Hunter's Stella and Karl Malden's Mitch are supporting characters (and indeed, both actors won their respective Best Supporting Actor Oscars), but even they bring nuance to the roles they play, forcing the audience to consider their entireties, and not just see what we want to see. Stella's choice to return to Stanley halfway through the film is devastating, but you can also empathize with the complexity of a domestic violence-type situation. And it makes her decision at the end all the sweeter (hard to believe that the theater version finds Stella choosing to stay). And Mitch takes a journey from compassion to cruelty, and I wonder how much of that change is informed by my modern sensibilities. Seems like Blanche's "body count" (as the kids are referring to it now) would be less of a issue for a 2024 Mitch type than it was in 1951. Still, his cruelty is logical in the context, if not necessarily sympathetic.
I choose to believe that it is for these reasons that A Streetcar Named Desire felt like a slippery film, difficult to hold onto, almost like a nightmare that you grapple with the morning after as it gradually fades away. I feel this way because there are no firm answers presented, and we are forced to consider what we really think about each character, and what our choice says about us, etc. It's hard work, and makes for a somewhat grueling film-watching experience, honestly. It also probably didn't help that we watched it over the course of two different nights, two days apart, sleepy both nights, and plus the night in between featuring a viewing of a debate involving a disgusting human being with all of Stanley's sexism-tinged violent tendencies and brutishness and exactly zero of Brando's strange magnetism
What I'm trying to say is that I don't know if I can say that I enjoyed watching A Streetcar Named Desire, under any of these circumstances. But I sure do enjoy turning it over in my head, and letting it consume my waking thoughts. 164 movies into this project, and I still haven't decided if that means that this was a good film or a bad film. Or both. Or neither. Let's split the difference.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
STRAY THOUGHTS:
NEXT TIME: We take a quick break between Elia Kazan films with a sojourn at the critically-reviled Suicide Squad. [EDIT: nevermind, the one after next is a Billy Wilder, not an Elia Kazan.]
Kim Hunter's Stella and Karl Malden's Mitch are supporting characters (and indeed, both actors won their respective Best Supporting Actor Oscars), but even they bring nuance to the roles they play, forcing the audience to consider their entireties, and not just see what we want to see. Stella's choice to return to Stanley halfway through the film is devastating, but you can also empathize with the complexity of a domestic violence-type situation. And it makes her decision at the end all the sweeter (hard to believe that the theater version finds Stella choosing to stay). And Mitch takes a journey from compassion to cruelty, and I wonder how much of that change is informed by my modern sensibilities. Seems like Blanche's "body count" (as the kids are referring to it now) would be less of a issue for a 2024 Mitch type than it was in 1951. Still, his cruelty is logical in the context, if not necessarily sympathetic.
I choose to believe that it is for these reasons that A Streetcar Named Desire felt like a slippery film, difficult to hold onto, almost like a nightmare that you grapple with the morning after as it gradually fades away. I feel this way because there are no firm answers presented, and we are forced to consider what we really think about each character, and what our choice says about us, etc. It's hard work, and makes for a somewhat grueling film-watching experience, honestly. It also probably didn't help that we watched it over the course of two different nights, two days apart, sleepy both nights, and plus the night in between featuring a viewing of a debate involving a disgusting human being with all of Stanley's sexism-tinged violent tendencies and brutishness and exactly zero of Brando's strange magnetism
What I'm trying to say is that I don't know if I can say that I enjoyed watching A Streetcar Named Desire, under any of these circumstances. But I sure do enjoy turning it over in my head, and letting it consume my waking thoughts. 164 movies into this project, and I still haven't decided if that means that this was a good film or a bad film. Or both. Or neither. Let's split the difference.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
STRAY THOUGHTS:
- I didn't mention "method acting" because I already said my piece regarding Brando's acting in this context with On the Waterfront. It's still worth being mesmerized over, though.
- I also wasn't able to fit in the two immortally famous quotes from this film—"Stella!" and "I have always depended on the kindness of strangers." We already touched on the phenomenon of knowing a famous quote before finally hearing it in the movie it came from when we discussed Jerry Maguire. I can confirm that I still felt that little click in my head when I put 'em together. And I was also kinda shocked that "Stella!" entered the canon at all, based on the fact that it happens halfway through the film and didn't seem to me all that distinctive from the rest of the bellowing that Brando does throughout the rest of the film.
- I still maintain that Karl Malden should've won his acting Oscar for On the Waterfront instead of this one, but, ya know, that's the Academy for you. Absolutely astonishing that the only major acting award that Streetcar didn't win was for Best Lead Actor for Brando. Was there a bigger upset in Oscar history? I mean, probably, that's just my recency bias talking. I would also have to see winner Humphrey Bogart in The African Queen to say for sure.
- I didn't mention La Salle University's performance of the play A Streetcar Named Desire, since I already used that hook for my The Philadelphia Story write-up, and also, I didn't actually see their play. But I should have! Two years after I graduated, it still features a bunch of my friends, and I know now that they are all so goddamn perfectly casted, it's incredible. I'll have to ask the PoYB Contributors from that show if they have a recording of it or something.
- I am told that cuts were made to this film without the director's or the writer's permission, which is fucked up. Tale as old as time in Hollywood, though. I'm glad that the cuts were reinstated at some point over the last 70 years, and that I was able to see the vision as it was intended. Because, like, there were already changes made from stage to screen, right? The rape was apparently more explicit, and the background info on Blanche's husband was that he killed himself because he was outed as gay.
- Actually, I read a theory somewhere (there were a surprising number of amateur essays on this film hosted by Blogger scattered around the web) that the character of Blanche is supposed to represent a gay man and that this is why Stanley is so vindictive and violent, because of his self-loathing for his own homosexual tendencies. I wonder if there is room for a modern-day Streetcar adaptation in which Blanche is trans.
- Given my staunch views on domestic violence and abuse, I wonder how many of you arrived at this blog post thinking that this was going to be the thesis. I do think that Streetcar gives a pretty striking view of how normalized domestic violence was in the 1950s, and, though we have obviously come a long way in the seven decades since, it's worth considering if there are any similarities, still, between then and now. Consider that a 2024 adaptation would probably still require a sex-symbol actor to play Stanley, and that people would still willfully misinterpret the motivations of the character based on this.
NEXT TIME: We take a quick break between Elia Kazan films with a sojourn at the critically-reviled Suicide Squad. [EDIT: nevermind, the one after next is a Billy Wilder, not an Elia Kazan.]

No comments:
Post a Comment