1996
Cameron Crowe
This is a list of 200 movies I've never seen before, but that doesn't mean I don't know anything about any of the movies on the list. In fact, my knowing at least one aspect of them may have originally guaranteed their placement on the list in the first place. Sometimes, films are so ingrained in the pop culture public consciousness that it would be impossible for me to come in with zero knowledge of that movie.
For the most part, I'm talking about famous quotes from the movie. Occasionally, for whatever reason, a certain quote from a certain movie will become "well known." Meaning that people are quoting it outside of the context of describing the movie. The biggest example recently in this Never Seen It column has been A Few Good Men, whose immortal line "You can't handle the truth!" I was already familiar with. It would have been impossible to function as a person who consumes pop culture art to not know about that line at the age of 33.
But so the question became, why do they say that line in the movie? Who can't handle the truth? The truth about what? Why can't they handle it? I needed to know. And so I placed A Few Good Men on a list of movies and forced myself to watch it to find out. The fun part was finally putting the quote into its original context. And the judgment became, did the film do a good job with that quote? More importantly, was its stature in pop culture justified by its usage in the movie?
Today's film—which I swear we're going to talk about—is Jerry Maguire, and it is one of seven movies to have multiple quotes listed on AFI's Top 100 Movie Quotes list. I knew that "Show me the money!" was from this movie. I did not know (or forgot?) that "You had me at 'hello.'" was in it as well. After watching Jerry Maguire, and hearing the famous quotes in their natural habit, I can now say that they were... okay, I guess.
"Show me the money!" comes pretty early in the movie. Jerry Maguire is almost two movies in one. Tom Cruise plays a sports agent who tries to revitalize his passion for his work by becoming more client-focused, and is fired for his efforts. That's the first half of the movie. The other half is a rom-com with Renée Zellweger, which we'll get to. But back in the first half, Jerry is trying desperately to hang onto as many clients as he can after getting the boot, and the only one he manages to keep is Cuba Gooding Jr.'s Rod Tidwell.
Tidwell makes one thing clear—he believes he is worth a lot of money—and so he makes sure that Jerry Maguire is on the same page. He implores his current and future sports agent to thus "Show [him] the money." He yells the phrase on the phone to Jerry Maguire multiple times, and even makes Jerry yell it back at him. Simple, and yet effective—Cuba Gooding Jr. won an Oscar for this role.
It didn't feel like a momentous line, no culmination of plotlines or character decisions or anything, just a funny little line that comes about one-third of the way into the film. It doesn't feel to me like the 25th best movie quote of all time. But I have at least three theories as to how it could've ended up in such a spot.
One is that it unintentionally touches on the American public's uncomfortable relationship with capitalism. We are meant to see Jerry Maguire as a hero for wanting to eschew monetary success in favor of intimate relationship building with his clients, i.e. happiness, and yet here is his one and only client rebuking that mindset, saying that happiness doesn't matter unless you have money, and lots of it. He forces Jerry Maguire to repeat the phrase over and over, much to Jerry's embarrassment. He's embarrassed because he is being forced to admit that he is wrong. He can write as many manifestos as he wants, but the truth remains: he will be a slave to capitalism forever.
The second theory is related to the fact that Jerry is himself forced to yell "Show me the money!" multiple times. I'd argue that the fact that it is Tom Cruise yelling this phrase and making a fool of himself really had an effect on an American public who was used to see Tom Cruise as the most unflappably cool screen actor of his time. He is a larger-than-life persona, otherworldly. Just a few months earlier, he was seen on the big screen in Mission Impossible (which we'll get to by early next year). I'm thinking that maybe there was some unconscious itch to see this guy taken down a peg, and Jerry Maguire fulfilled that unconscious desire by debasing its title character and making him eat shit just to pay the rent. Not that anyone dislikes Tom Cruise, it's just uncomfortable seeing someone's star shine as bright as his. Maybe "Show me the money!" was a way to dim it slightly.
The third theory plays with Occam's razor, because it is the simplest and thus the most likely to be true. Maybe moviegoers just like stupid phrases yelled over and over in funny ways. Maybe the words means less than the way big-name actors yell them. Maybe Cuba Gooding Jr. could have yelled "Bake mom some pretzels!" over and over, and "Bake mom some pretzels!" would have ended up as the 25th-best movie quote of all time. Does it even matter?
Regardless of which theory is correct, I'd argue that the quote left a little to be desired when it finally hit, after a lifetime of hearing it repeated in public. Which is fine! That's on me for isolating the phrase from the rest of the movie, and expecting it to still stand. One specific line of dialogue probably shouldn't be the end-all-be-all of a movie. Still, the fact that everyone knows the line, including me, who had never seen the movie before, told me that it was going to hit hard when it finally popped up. The fact that it didn't was disappointing.
But hey, at least that one actually makes sense, unlike the other one. "You had me at 'hello'" is perplexing. The context is that Jerry is finally making his big profession of love for Zellweger's Dorothy Boyd (so we're in the other half of the movie from the sports agent stuff). He gives this long-winded speech about his love for Dorothy, but she eventually says that the speech (his grand gesture) was completely unnecessary, because: "You had me at 'hello.'"
This is me being stupid, probably, but I didn't get it when she first said it. I get what she meant—she's loved him since she first met him, and she doesn't need him to profess his love now, after their love has already been well established—but it's the details that confuse me. Specifically, the fact that she calls it "hello," when Jerry Maguire doesn't say "hello" to her in this scene at all. And "hello" is not even the first thing he says to Dorothy when they first meet at the airport (it's "Excuse me, can I help you?").
Okay, fine, he does say "hello" to the other women when he enters the scene, but it's a tossed-off "hello," and I don't understand why Dorothy would specifically refer to this "hello" as the moment when she knew their love was meant to be. I'd almost be inclined to argue that this "hello" was added to the script, or ad-libbed by Cruise, when everyone realized that "You had me at 'hello'" makes no goddamn sense otherwise.
No, that's too strong. Again, I know it makes sense as a declaration of undying love. I'm just saying that the details are too strange to me that I can't seem to wrap my head around its popularity. (I'm not the only one—Zellweger was so confused by the line in the script that she thought it was a typo at first.) And to say that this is the 52nd-best movie quote of all time seems insane to me.
But this is what the American public has chosen, and who the fuck am I to say otherwise? I'm just some asshole who's watching some movies. I'm only one man. There is nothing I can do to change what the general pop culture populace has chosen as their mottos. All I can do is consume, comment, and then move on.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: Pretty much every filmography I've ever looked up has a credit for JFK, so we'll see next time just how many major Hollywood stars one political drama can fit into three hours.

5 comments:
And "you complete me"
You got me. Shame on AFI for not agreeing with you that this is a famous quote. My own personal experience with the quote is when Dr. Evil gives the line to Mini Me. I don't know who looks worse in that context, me or Dr. Evil.
All the best blog posts/comments have a Dr Evil reference. You're good.
Hey “You complete me” is famous from Dark Knight
I think we all know the most famous part of Dark Knight.
Post a Comment