Thursday, September 8, 2022

Never Seen It, #86 of 200: It Follows

Sexed up and chloroformed by a list of 200 movies I've never seen before; now they won't stop chasing me.


It Follows
2014
David Robert Mitchell

It is my pleasure to bring back friend of the blog Fisher for another movie discussion. Over the past couple of weeks, we exchanged some emails about the 2014 horror film It Follows. Like I did for Harold and Maude, I chopped up the exchanges and tried to group some of our thoughts together into specific topics to improve coherence and flow.

~~~~~~~~~

JOE: I think the questions of "Was this a good movie?" and "Was this scary?" are two different questions (though I'd be curious to know if you disagree). In answer to the first question, I'd say unequivocally yes. I have to imagine that it's difficult make a horror movie in the 21st century and still be as creative as the filmmakers were here. (I'll talk about the second question at some other point, unless you would like to begin that conversation.)

I doubt that you would have requested to discuss this particular movie if you felt differently. In my experience, people request to talk about things they like. Or maybe not, maybe you intensely dislike it or something. So, the standard two-part introductory question for these blog things: one, why did you want to discuss It Follows, and two, what do you think about the film?

FISHER: So before my rewatch, I might have been a D+, but now I'd say I'm a B. My main complaint then is the same now: I cannot buy these characters, and particularly I don't *love* the quirky mechanics. But I realize I have plenty of love for similar movies that have endeavored in this vain. As the director clearly is a student/obsessor of the genre it follows (Leo meme) that he would make such a piece. I wanted to discuss it because I had that smidge of, "Oh, I don't like this as much as everyone else" pride. But now I can more easily join the chorus.

Being raised on '80s and '90s horror exposed me to so much schlocky: acting, tone, writing, etc. It's probably that I give them a pass per nostalgia. I find I favor more realism as I age. And I'm allowed to do that. Having more exposure to Maika Monroe made me appreciate her performance more. She's become a solid scream queen. And it helps that she's a pretty lady. And it helps that I checked if she was old enough during filming for me to say that. And it helps that yes she was. And it helps that you don't judge me.

Despite my beef, I didn't really hate any character. None of her friends were annoying. With everything and everyone being so understated you don't have room for obnoxious behavior. I respected Paul the Simp's hustle but bro you gotta draw the line somewhere. This is demons. Come on. And of course the genre-appropriate heels: the jock-lookin' bad guy who ruins her life, the Judd Nelson-lookin' neighbor who suffers a ROUGH end. Don't want anyone bangin' me to death. Least of all her.

Was it a good movie? Was it scary? Given the work at hand, scary is a necessity for good. A tension-plus-jump-scare movie MUST deliver on the punchline, with precious few misses, in order to be good in the book of Me. And on this rewatch, I was pleasantly surprised by the quantity and quality of the spook-'ems. All attempts were effective. I always appreciate when a horror movie starts with a "This is why you bought the ticket" scene. The score was phenomenal. Fantastic sound mixing. I can't speak so intelligently on these things but by now we understand what a score can lend to a film.

JOE: Ah, very interesting that you wanted to talk about It Follows because you did NOT like it. I assumed that you loved it, and I was going to be playing the part of horror movie skeptic in this exchange. But now I feel the strange urge to defend this movie. Funny how that works.

~~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: I think the key thing that you said is "I favor realism," which is a really interesting thing to say about horror films in general, because they usually attempt to take us out of reality. Or am I off base here? I usually think, "Okay, here's the supernatural monster" and judge the movie based on how effective the film was at being fun in showing how that fictional creature operates. At no point am I ever like "Oh man I'm scared because this monster might be REAL." So I'm less interested in how "scared" I was while watching this movie, and I'm much less interested in whether this was some kind of allegory about STIs or something shit like that (though I am interested to hear your opinion on that one). I mostly interested in whether this was a well-made movie, given the constraints of the horror genre. And I'd argue that it was!

FISHER: I was too vague in saying "I favor realism." I'm right there with you in your whole paragraph. The realism I want is from a character perspective. Because of the dialogue and general monotone of everyone I couldn't invest in them. So I couldn't fear for them. At that rate I'm praying on the application of craft, which was top notch all the way through.

I couldn't agree more about the supposed STI theme. It's exceedingly rare that I extol a movie's themes. That kind of deep dive doesn't usually interest me.

JOE: I wonder why this was the thing that I was told about It Follows multiple times, and yet I definitely didn't get the sense that this movie was even trying to make the allegory at all. I just wonder why people latch onto these "the film is ACTUALLY about this" kind of ideas. It seems silly to me. Not everything has to actually mean something completely different. A fun horror movie can just be a fun horror movie. It doesn't have to be a lesson or something.

FISHER: They debate these things because they think they should. It's hip to be intellectually square (have you seen American Psycho?). Hell yeah, everything doesn't need meaning. Just have fun, you creeps.

~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: I want to hear more about your thoughts about the "quirky mechanics." I assume you are talking about some of the camera movements? I loved those times when the camera slowly panned the full 360 degrees and shows a lot of mundane activity and also oh yeah at 270 degrees you could see the ghost walking toward you HOLY SHIT. I thought it felt a lot more artsy than a horror film typical is, but that could just be a horror noob speaking.

FISHER: The quirky mechanics are the things used to establish that this is reality-adjacent: the old TVs, only old TV programs/news playing, the clamshell/Kindle device. They didn't add to the proceedings for me, but to each their own. You're probably on point with your "more artsy" assessment right up until the past eight or so years. There's been an art house horror boom, and now more than ever we're seeing some fun cinematography and narrative choices in the genre. Not that they were always absent, just lost amidst all the low-effort entries.

~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: I love your description of the stock characters, "Simp" and "Judd Nelson." Perfect. You're right that the characters weren't annoying. I'm always a little sensitive about whether characters are "too stupid" to be feel real, but I didn't feel that way here. I think that the arc from skepticism to hatching an elaborate pool electrocution scheme was well played.

FISHER: Stupid characters are a plague in horror, a rightfully lampooned trope. I, too, appreciate the arc they took. I also appreciate how it didn't take long for the friends to be given concrete evidence of It's existence. "Nobody believes me am I going crazy?!" is quite trite.

JOE: Not only that, but there actually was a character who "didn't believe the main character." And he was brutally murdered by his sexy ghost mother. It felt to me like the film making a statement: "No stupid characters here, or else."

FISHER: And I like 'at approach.

~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: I think I might be making this up, but I'm almost positive that I've seen Jake Weary (Hugh) on commercials for a soap opera on doctors office waiting room televisions before.

FISHER: Haha, I wouldn't doubt it. The man IS pretty. Thought he looked like a broke-ass Joshua Jackson.

JOE: Ha! He does look like Joshua Jackson. Holy shit.

~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: And agreed that Maika Monroe makes it work. I am interested in the term "scream queen." I'm familiar with the term, but I guess I never thought about it. Is there something about certain actors that makes them well-suited for a horror movie? Or is it just a coincidence in what roles you're offered?

FISHER: A "Scream Queen" is an actress who gets her start with a handful of horror films, Jamie Lee Curtis being the OG. I've seen Maika in three horror/thriller movies by now and she's got the goods. I'll wager my socks that certain actors are better suited for horror, but what determines that is beyond me. I doubt it's coincidence. Plenty of actors that blew up with a role will have countless, near identical, offers sent to them. But given the history of Hollywood, I doubt the Scream Queens had much say in what roles they could get.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: Big fan of the music in this one. I like how a lot of it was this light, tinny, almost 8-bit sound, but then when shit got serious, these huge booming basses would pound you. It was a really nice contrast. I guess it almost equates to another type of jump scare, like you were saying.

Which is definitely something I want to ask about. I like your thoughts on the subject. Honestly, I came to this conversation thinking that jump scares are cheap and secondary to any pervading sense of terror that a film is trying to convey. But I think it's refreshing to think of jump scares as legitimate, because then you can talk about how some are more effective than others. Are jump scares necessary?

FISHER: A jump scare's necessity depends entirely on the movie. The Exorcist has one, MAYBE two in the theatrical cut. Eliminate both and the movie is the same. But eliminate jump scares from The Conjuring and you've got bupkis. I love both movies. But they absolutely can be SO cheap. If they're just parachuted in at random times then it doesn't work. The definition of a gimmick. But in a James Wan, film the tension leading up to the "BOO!" is like five goddamn minutes long. Your stomach is in a knot until it's released in an unexpected moment. And I goddamn love that shit. You really have to earn the jump scare, which is why so few bother to pull it off. Or can, for that matter.

JOE: Yeah man, I don't know. I think I agree with you that there can be a successful one, but I feel like the scales are weighed too heavily toward the "cheap scares" side. Even the jump scare in this movie when the wall of the closet suddenly blew apart and it was just the friend on the other side. Felt cheap to me! I'm way more invested and, frankly, more scared when the monster is subtly in the background, slowly walking toward the protagonist. That felt earned.

FISHER: Yo but when the no-eyed tall dude barged into her bedroom. So good.

JOE: Was there a "scariest" part for you? If that's an adjective you would even use.

FISHER: Probably Tall No-Eyed Dude

JOE: Glad you mentioned the tall dude. That was freaky when he walked in. Something about the fact that he had to duck to get in there and then walk around the human who walked in first added up to more than your average scare. I think the part I would argue is over whether it was a "jump scare" or not. I will defer to your definition of it, but to me, it was so scary because it didn't make me "jump" per se. Like, it wasn't the camera suddenly finding a creep dude while he yelled "Boo!" It was just two people walking into a room at a normal pace, and one of them happened to be a tall creepy man. The mundaneness of the movement was what scared me.

FISHER: Whatever we wanna call it: hell yeah, it rocked.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: What do we make of the runner of the one character reading The Idiot throughout the film? I have to read the Wikipedia page on the book, but I want to throw it to you first so I have time to gather my thoughts, haha.

FISHER: I would also have to learn what it is. But like themes, these Easter Eggs only tickle me so much.

JOE: Here's a one-sentence description from Wiki: "The title is an ironic reference to the central character of the novel, Prince Lev Nikolayevich Myshkin, a young man whose goodness, open-hearted simplicity, and guilelessness lead many of the more worldly characters he encounters to mistakenly assume that he lacks intelligence and insight."

What's the connection? My best guess, having never read the book and only basing my guess on this description, is that this is some sort of commentary on the typical horror movie character that you talked about elsewhere? That maybe they aren't idiots who don't believe in monsters until it's too late. Maybe your typical stock teen characters is just too open-hearted and simple to accept the fact that evil exists in this world and it's chasing you into a basement?

FISHER: Maybe the director put a lot of himself into Paul. Like too much. And he has a chip on his shoulder because he was always the odd-numbered wheel and he wanted to throw a bone to the Nice Guys of the world. That's 90% a joke and I do hope it's wrong.

JOE: I guess the quote from The Idiot at the end is more obvious: "When there is torture there is pain and wounds, physical agony, and all this distracts the mind from mental suffering, so that one is tormented only by the wounds until the moment of death. But the most terrible agony may not be in the wounds themselves but in knowing for certain that within an hour, then within ten minutes, then within half a minute, now at this very instant—your soul will leave your body and you will no longer be a person, and that is certain; the worst thing is that it is certain." Basically explaining why we try to avoid physical pain—because it translates to mental pain, and that is the true agony—and that explains why these characters keep running, keep trying to get away from a monster that will never stop chasing.

FISHER: I'm not seeing this take but that's why there's north of fifteen billion eyeballs in the world. I don't know if the novel's context beforehand implies masochism or a literally tortured-to-death scenario, but I figure it's a stab at the root of the biggest fear of death. The fact THAT you're a fact is called into question at your death. Ew that grosses me out. Ultimately I'm not seeing a big connecksh to the film. But who gives a shit.

~~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: Do you think that the reveal of the monster taking the form of Jay's dead father (that was her father, right?) had the intended impact? I'm on the fence.

FISHER: That's a good call, and I'm landing on "no." Did they establish any sentiment toward the father throughout the film? I don't think so. I don't think it worked. But I'm not angry.

JOE: Thank you for confirming. I didn't even realize it was her father until I read about the movie afterward. Like, even when they zoomed in on the pic of her family, I still didn't really understand. I know Josh Jackson said "sometimes they take the form of loved ones to fuck with you!!" but as you said, I don't think they did any work to make it known why seeing her father would have any more of an impact on her than any other loved one.

~~~~~~~

JOE: Do the logistics of "it will follow you unless you fuck someone else" hold up?

FISHER: I think so. Before it killed Judd Nelson it looked over at her, then back to the target. I respect that it has rules.

JOE: I don't know. I've been thinking about this a lot. I think the part that gets me is that Hugh (I forget the character's real name, Jeff I think?) passes it to Jay, but then says he's "still in danger." He's not, though, right? Unless Jay dies? Which clearly she's not dead. And if his safety depended on Jay's safety, why ditch her? Why not help her stay alive? You could also think about the "pass as fast as you can" strategy. But if you're gonna pass it to a hooker, then why not try to protect the hooker, or make sure she passes it real quick and then buy that john another hooker, put like as many people as you can in between you and the ghost in the shortest amount of time as you can. Can you loop it around?

FISHER: I think that would involve doing just about the same preventative measures you'd be doing solo. But instead you'd be tethering yourself to some rando(s). I think the best course of action is to: move far, Google Map the distance as the crow flies, and vacation to the opposite coast at intervals and for whatever length of time, the longer the better.

I wouldn't want the government to know that supernatural phenomena is real (who am I to say they don't?). However, and in a pinch, I would go to an FBI field office or the gates of an army base and perform a demonstration. Do some facsimile of tar and feathering to prove its existence. They'll get DARPA or some shit to build an MCU style prison box around it. Good to go. But that's a Pandora's Box. I've only ever put this into words once on Reddit. Thank you for the outlet. I've thought about this.

JOE: What if Paul and Jay had sex again? Would "It" be passed back to her? Can you pass it to two people? What if you die from natural causes when It is following you? Does it still reverse? I could keep going. I probably shouldn't.

FISHER: I suppose you could pass it back and forth. If you die of other causes then I suppose it just goes to the next living one in the line.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: I heard there was at one point potentially a sequel. I guess the characters were going to go the opposite way down the chain and try to figure out who had sex with whom enough times that they could trace the origins of the monsters. What do we think about this? Potential in the idea, or another dumb potential cash-in?

FISHER: Cash grab. Off my gut I doubt the director cares for a sequel. Though I've softened lately, I can be pretty "give me the damned explanation." But I don't need one here. Supernaturally evil force carrying out a task. I'm good.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: I liked the quote: "It's funny, I used to daydream about being old enough to go on dates and drive around with friends in their cars. I had this image of myself, holding hands with a really cute guy, listening to the radio, driving along some pretty road. Up north maybe. The trees start to change colors. It was never about going anywhere really. Just having some sort of freedom I guess. Now that we're old enough: where the hell do we go?”

Especially liked it juxtaposed with what happened right afterward, with Joshua Jackson chloroforming her. I'm not sure I have anything to add to it, it just kind of rang true. Felt like a "loss of innocence" speech right before her innocence is REALLY lost.

FISHER: I'm not sure I have anything to add to it, what you said is bang on.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: What is your favorite horror movie, and in what ways is it better (and/or worse) than It Follows?

FISHER: It's The Exorcist and it's better in every way. I could go on about this joint. It's a Top Five All-Timer. I respect and reject the "scariest movie of all time" moniker. It's subjective first and foremost. But its impact was undeniable. Its staying power is undeniable because it's played damn near documentary style. Ellen Burstyn's performance is so. easy. to buy. She is a real woman whose daughter is really possessed. The genre fair is exquisite, grounded, and played straight. Had a highly memorable experience (first time) seeing it in theaters in eighth grade. That movie occupies solid real estate in my heart.

JOE: Does it have anything to do with the idea of an "exorcism" being slightly more possible than the idea of monsters that haunt you after you have sex? I agree with you that it's a great movie. I always just wonder about the idea of fear and why people are afraid of some things and not others. "Afraid" being intertwined with "appreciating a movie as art" in this case, but the question remains the same.

FISHER: Could be that an exorcism is more "real." And it's the realism behind the subject matter, cinematography, and performances that give The Exorcist that extra umph. The whole thing is played DEAD serious. Despite having 360-degree revolving heads and impossible quantities of vomit. As for why people are afraid of X and not Y, I don't have the degree required to know. Figure it's all in the individual's nature/nurture soup.

~~~~~~~~~

JOE: What is it about horror movies that people like so much? in your opinion.

FISHER: I've heard multiple masters boil it down to: it allows us to face our fears in the safest way possible. I link it to my adoration of roller coasters. I love a good thrill.

JOE: I'm just trying to get to the root of "why do people like horror movies," which is something that I don't know that I quite "get" at this point in my life. There are horror movies I like, and horror movies I don't like, but to be a "fan of horror movies" is something I'm still seeking. I like your explanation of feeling unsafe while being actually safe is a thrill.

FISHER: What's at my rootiest horror root I'm unsure. By the end of my single digits I was exposed to: Child's Play, Poltergeist, Are You Afraid of the Dark?, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark (shouts out Mrs. K***), and Goosebumps. Something just clicked and never unclicked.

~~~~~~~~~

JOE'S GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Worst movie of all time? We'll see! It's Jack and Jill time!

No comments: