Sunday, September 4, 2022

The Record Club Final Word: Pam on Little Earthquakes

If you pick an album for Record Club, you will get an "exit survey" on Friday morning, after the reviews have been published. This isn't to add more to your workload; I instead just want to provide space for the album picker to have the final say, if they feel like they need some sort of closure on the week. It's totally and completely optional. But I love when Pam writes, and I'm glad she chose to do the exit survey this week. The truth is that Pam is one of the best writers I know, but for some reason she refuses to believe it. It's frustrating! She should acknowledge her skill and talent! C'mon!

~~~~~~~~~~~


1. Was there anyone who convinced you to consider a different opinion regarding the album itself?

I'll consider the opinion of Joe who had a hard time getting past the lack of drums, but I don't agree with it. Otherwise, I think Sunny and I had pretty similar opinions of the album

2. Was there anyone who you felt did a good/bad job at presenting their own views, regardless of whether you agreed with said views?

Both reviewers did a good job at presenting their own views. I was honestly a little surprised at myself for not referencing any witchy-ness that Tori Amos gave off. 

3. Were the reviews varied, or did this album elicit same-y opinions? What about that album made that true? Or do you think that this answer is reviewer-dependent and not album-dependent?

I think albums from someone like Tori Amos can be a little reviewer-dependent. A lot of her songs are female-centered, which, of course, would elicit a different type of feeling from me, as compared with Joe and Sunny. Different experiences make for different feelings and reactions to art. That being said, I think the music was appreciated similarly among me and Sunny. And Joe did his best even though there were no drums. 

4. Did the variety of reviews justify the album choice? Would you choose a different album (yes/no) based on the reviews received?

Absolutely. I think this was an album that has the power to challenge listeners. I would choose it again even though the reviews were low in numbers. 

5. What can Record Club do differently to make your RC experience (especially as a weekly captain) a worthwhile one?

Nothing. This was one of my favorite weeks and definitely one of my favorite albums picked by me. I can almost taste those chicken chalupas. 

6. Any other takeaways you have from this experience?

It feels good to at least be attempting to break generational cycles in how I personally listen to this type of female artist.

No comments: