Monday, December 16, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 173: Zach

Prompt: "A song that has the same exact title as a song that was chosen already for Song Challenge, but is in fact a completely different song"

Selected by Zach

The same exact title as Nick's song from Day 5



"Amsterdam"
Keep It Together, 2003

This was one of the easiest picks for me. I've picked six Wilco songs, and this pick gives me six Guster songs. Sounds about right.

I'm guessing this is the second or third most famous Guster song, behind "Barrel of a Gun" and maybe "Fa Fa"? I'm mad they didn't have any songs on that XPN list, but eff XPN anyways. Guster is the most misunderstood band of the last 25 years. 

One of my recent delights has been to learn that comedian Alex Edelman is friends with Ryan Miller and the others from Guster, and performed "Happier" on stage with them during one of their concerts. Alex Edelman also unintentionally helped Ryan Miller become the writer for the musical Safety Not Guaranteed (Allison: as the musical expert of YSC, is it good?), as actor Nick Blaemire spotted Miller at the afterparty for the final night of Edelman's standup show and was inspired to ask him to write a musical adapted from the movie (Miller had already written two songs for that movie, which starred Mark Duplass and Aubrey Plaza, who I also both love). I also learned that Alex Edelman is friends with Regina Spektor, whose song "Human of the Year" is the theme song for his stand-up show, for which he won an Emmy (Writing for a Variety Special). A Guster, Alex Edelman, and Regina Spektor triangle is a perfect one for me. 

I have three specific ideas for posts I want to write before this whole thing is over. That means five other posts (including this one), plus one more I'm late on that will be fulfilled. Six posts that can be filled with anything at all. And I feel an urge to "make these posts good." Historically, I've been a big "make things big at the end" person. When, really, it's not about the ending at all. The best moment of your life does not happen on your deathbed unless you're already dead and you appear in a dream and you're in the movie Inception and you're finally telling your son that you love him, albeit indirectly.

So a post about Guster feels right for today. And about Wilco. Because "Impossible Germany" was #6 on the 885 song list, and I would not have predicted that.

6 comments:

Joe K said...

Proud of you for not choosing "Amsterdam" by Imagine Dragons or "Amsterdam" by Van Halen or "Amsterdam" by John Lennon and Yoko Ono ("Amsterdam" by Peter Bjorn and John is a good one though).

Joe K said...

In my mind, "Amsterdam" has always been the most well-known Guster song, but I am certainly not an expert on the matter.

Judging by Spotify, "Amsterdam" has the third-most plays (8.7 mil), behind "One Man Wrecking Machine" (9 mil) and "Satellite" (40 mil?!). Was "Satellite" in some Netflix rom-com or Grey's Anatomy or some shit like that?

Zach said...

Per Wikipedia: "The song is also featured in the 2007 film Martian Child." I don't think that vaulted it. Probably what did it was the fact that Guster was at its most well known in 2006. I still can't really explain 40 million plays for a song that is good but might not crack Guster's top 10.

Sara said...

ENOUGH of your XPN slander!!

Nate said...

As a guy who just went 29-for-90 to complete a 1,000 free throw challenge this morning, the idea of "I would like to finish strong but will perhaps have to settle for finishing" resonates very strongly with me.

Zach said...

A prayer: May your YSC finish be blessed to be akin to Reggie Miller, even if your free throw finish was more Bismack Biyombo.