Andrew Bird
Week 46: December 15-21, 2019
The fucked-up thing is that the HARK! EP doesn't even exist anymore. Total fucking Record Club erasure (but not Erasure). In 2019, I didn't do much research, and accidentally allowed an EP onto the inaugural holiday poll, even though EPs aren't technically allowed (a compilation was on there too, also retroactively disqualified). But when it won, we covered it anyway, because who gives a shit. The only problem is, but the following year, 2020, Bird had rereleased a full HARK! LP, this one with thirteen tracks, including the six from the EP. So now, if you wanna listen to the EP that Record Club listened to for its first Christmas together, you gotta turn to unofficial YouTube playlists and fucking weirdos who still use iPods (I actually don't keep Christmas albums on my iPod, so I used YouTube today).
There's literally nothing to say here in this space about the album from five years ago and its Christmas music within that I am not repeating for the sixth time in any of the album reviews published. There's only so much you can say about Christmas music. It's a frustratingly limited subject matter! At least when approached from a music criticism perspective. This probably begs the question: how many more years can we put up with this? The reviews for Andrew Bird's HARK! EP all sure made it seem like that was going to be the only time we'd have the space to talk about Christmas music. And yet here we are, six more Christmas albums later, still squeezing blood from that stone. I don't know how long it's gonna last, the holiday poll. Maybe I'll put more of an effort into finding weird, non-Christmas-y Christmas albums next year, to mix it up a little. Or maybe we just keep bashing our heads against the wall because that's the true spirit of the holiday.
One more unconnected thought before I wrap it up for today (there's a lot more to get to, no sense wasting time in an RC@5 post). I think it's kinda interesting to think about certain artists becoming "Record Club Alumni" because we covered their Christmas album. And then having to follow up with that artist over the years and somehow compare their later, secular work to the holiday album we originally examined. Andrew Bird's done a lot in the past five years, and none of it had anything to do with Christmas (at least after that expanded HARK! release, anyway). And HARK! is certainly not the reason Andrew Bird came into my life. And yet, within these confines, as rigid as they are here in this music club for friends, Andrew Bird is and forever will be a Christmas Artist. Fucking weird, man.
Enjoy the rest of the Christmas music nonsense today!

No comments:
Post a Comment