I get annoyed and sometimes even angry at the vast majority of Christmas music that I hear. There's no winning with this shit. It's either bad because I've heard it a billion times, or it's bad because it's new and sounds nothing like the Christmas music I'm already familiar with. And if I am grumpy enough to believe that all of it is bad, then this is simply gonna be a time of year when I'm annoyed and/or angry when I hear the music, since society has deemed it the time of year when we MUST listen to Christmas music, which, again, all sucks.
One of the more fascinating things about Christmas music—to me, anyway, though I understand that I probably give this kind of thing way too much thought—is that it's so hard to make a new, original Christmas song that eventually enters the canon of "classic Christmas songs." Listen to B101 for seven hours straight. How many songs released in the 2020s are you going to hear during that time? Maybe one, at most? The vast majority of the holiday music you hear is the same music you've heard your entire life. That's just how it is. Someone like Kelly Clarkson or Dolly Parton releases a brand-new Christmas song, and by the very next season, it's gone, completely forgotten about, forever.
For the longest time, I've blamed the commercialization of Christmas, and how there's more money to be made hawking a 65-year-old Brenda Lee song than there is wasting your time with a two-month-old Andrew Bird song. And so I picture the shadowy forces who control the universe keeping the same songs in rotation year after year after year, to the point where I literally cannot stand to hear Nat King fucking Cole one more goddamn time or else I'll fucking explode.
But who's fault is this, really? Lately, I've been blaming myself, and us, the audience. There's new music out there, new Christmas music every single fucking year, but we're not doing the work to sift through it and find the gold. Furthermore, if there happens to be a good song in there somewhere, then repetition is required to embed it in the culture that we build, year after year. We gotta hold on tight to the good ones, instead of casually disposing of them like a cheap toy in January. We have to acknowledge which ones are worth keeping, and then actually keep it.
This is why my mom knows Sufjan's Christmas music. This is why Jason Kelce's "Santa Claus Is Coming to Town" gets played every year now regardless of what the Eagles' season record is at that point. This is why Pam is officially claiming these days that the Goo Goo Dolls' 2020 Christmas album, It's Christmas All Over, is, and I quote, "the only Christmas album that matters." It doesn't have to be the best music. It doesn't have to compete with the music you know and love from Jan. through Oct. It just has to be good enough to try to remember the following year, and then you gotta give it space—literally years of time required—to let it sink in, allow it to start to slowly but surely soundtrack the holidays for you, every year, at this time of year.
There is a lot of new music on Ben Folds' immaculately named Christmas album, Sleigher. Not all of it is good, and not all of it is memorable. Some of it, like the A.I. song, is so bad that it becomes good again, in winking fashion. A lot of it is inessential, like the piano talent show-grade time-fillers. I recognized one song as a cover, and it's pretty good but obviously will never supplant the Nat King Cole version, whose roots are too deep to pull out at this point, for better or worse (worse). Much of the music is CILO (Christmas in Lyrics Only), which is totally fine.
It's fine, because EVERY song is CILO at the beginning of its life. It only becomes Christmas-y as it starts to engrain itself in the Christmas tradition. If you played A Day to Remember's "The Downfall of Us All" every Christmas Eve for 25 minutes straight every year for the next ten years, then by 2034 you'd sure as shit consider "The Downfall of Us All" to be a Christmas song.
So then it becomes: what do you want? Do you like any of these songs enough that you're going to play them next year in mid-December? Do you want any of these songs to become "Christmas songs" for you? It's really up to you. Seriously. This isn't that deep. If you are like me and listening to music is important to you and hearing the same old fucking BULLSHIT every Christmastime is something that pisses you off enough that you write way too many words about it on some blog that still exists, then you owe it to yourself to at least try.
I'm going to try with "Christmas Time Rhyme." There's enough in this song to convince me that it's the best new Christmas song of 2024—really low bar to clear, but I want it to also clear the really high bar of "song I'm excited to hear again next Black Friday." There's a lot of dorky Ben Folds fun here (the "oh yeah!" being about as cool and natural and totally not forced as "MUSTARD!" from a few weeks back). The jazzy rhythms feel old-school Christmas-y without outright stealing any of it. And the lyrics read true. There's the poignant line about family ("Listen, you're all fuckin' freaks, but we're family"), and the lines with simple yet relatable imagery ("Gifts wrapped in newspaper / Ringing the bell of my grandmother's door"). Most importantly, the line about just making it to Christmas: "What a wonderful, bittersweet holiday / We arrive half alive / From the last weird trip round the sun."
The best part about Christmas is the way that it inspires us to do some reflecting on the year we just had. I feel it more this year than I have in many, many years, those "half-alive" and "weird" descriptors. It was a weird and wild year, and I am very tired. Tired for both good reasons and bad (mainly: physically tired for the good, and mentally tired for the bad). Christmas has felt small this year, simply because the rest of my life outside of that has felt so big, comparatively speaking. Tough to get excited about Christmas when I'm spending so much of my time needlessly commuting. Tough to remember to buy Christmas gifts when you exchange small gifts of love all year 'round. Tough to remember the joy of the holiday when it feels like the world is otherwise burning to the ground. Tough to remember to celebrate with someone who didn't vote! Tough to participate in the buying culture, the commercialization of this bullshit, the needless spending on useless bullshit, the way it's designed to hurt your wallet so that we can pad the billionaire's pocket more and more. And on and on.
I feel that chorus, man. Ben Folds fucking nailed it. So many emotions packed into that one little line "We arrive half alive from the last weird trip round the sun." I think there's grace in that sentiment, an understanding that we are not alone in feeling this tired. We are together, we are one, we are all feeling the burnout and we're all very tired and we're all trying desperately to find that classic Christmas merriment and joy and childlike glee but it doesn't come often, and that's okay! "Christmas Time Rhyme" gets it. Ben Folds gets it. I want to get it again next year. I want to remember. I want to hold onto this song. I want it to become a part of the canon, because I'm going to need it next year, because shit sure ain't getting better by any reasonable metric.
Sleigher is the best Christmas album we've ever reviewed here during Record Club's relatively short existence on this earth. That's not because it has the best music, or kowtows to your need for comforting well-known tunes, or because it's popular, or because it's the shiniest, happiest package. It's the best because it's the only one so far that feels real, man. There is shiny, happy music here, but it feels self-aware too. It feels like it was made by a normal person who understands the mixed emotions that come part and parcel with the so-called "happiest season of all" for people like us.
It annoyed the hell out of me, because it is Christmas music. But it didn't annoy me by being fake. This shit was real. And on our next trip around the sun, when we make it to the next holiday season and it's time to pull last year's songs out from their mothball storage containers, I hope I'll find "Christmas Time Rhyme" waiting there for me, so that I can remember once again what it really means to feel Christmas-y. It feels weird. It feels like we're half-alive.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment