Monday, December 16, 2024

2024 in Review: Every Movie, Ranked

Every popcorn kernel of 2024, ranked

I'll consider it a good year if I get to watch more than 100 movies. This year, I saw 124. Not all of them were great, but all of them were helpful in my slow, decades-long journey toward being a "film buff." It was a good year.

My "pop culture year" is shifted by one month to make room for EOY lists in December, so these are actually the movies that I saw from 12/1/23 through 11/30/24. This means that there is a really weird mix of Oscar films from this year and last year, Never Seen It films from letters P through T, kids' movies that we watch on Friday nights, and other random shit. I like the chaos.

As I've done the past couple years, I'm just copying and pasting from PoYB's Letterboxd account. I don't sweat over the reviews on there, but it does take a non-zero amount of time, and so why not take shit that I already wrote and place it on the blog? That's one of the reasons we're here. I'm not going to link to anything I've previously written about any of these movies, but if you want to know more, you can find a lot of them on the NSI landing page and through the Oscars tag.

First, the films that I saw in 2024 but it wasn't the first time:

13. Labyrinth

Everyone gets to absolutely fucking despise exactly one pop culture entertainment thing that their spouse adores, and this is mine. Terrible film. TERRIBLE. Visually intriguing, with a plot that makes zero fucking sense. Fuck David Bowie forever.

12. Idiocracy

We're not getting more stupid as a society because of genetics. We're getting more stupid because the ruling class is specifically designing it that way, so that they can preserve their power. I really wish I would stop seeing liberals smugly chortling about this bullshit on reddit.

Anyways, it's also very funny to hear Dax Shepard mumbling about masturbation.

11. Space Jam

It somehow doesn't ruin the movie, but it still needs to be said: Michael Jordan gives one of the worst performances of any actor in literally any film in movie history. If he wasn't the best basketball player of all time, I'd almost feel bad for him.

It's possible that maybe the performance was bad on purpose and that it's trying to say something in a meta way—like maybe it's a commentary on the artificial construct of cartoon movies themselves—but let's not go overboard here. A fun nostalgia trip, but yeah, man, a legendary performance by MJ, in a bad way.

10. Monsters Inc.

Watching this a few days before going to Disney World and seeing the Monsters Laugh Factory comedy show was pretty helpful, since they kept showing my niece on the screen, labeled "Boo," and it was so fucking accurate, and I don't think the joke would've landed with my kids if we hadn't watched this one. So here you go. Billy Crystal's comedy shtick is 1000 years old.

9. Honey, I Shrunk the Kids

This dude is the worst fucking scientist. You shrink the kids and speculate that they are in the backyard and waste like twelve hours of your day just randomly spinning your huge body over random patches of grass with a fucking magnifying glass? Bro, there are so many smarter ways to go about this.

First, stay in one place. You fucking buffoon. Next, keep talking. They can hear you, numbnuts. Let them know your plan. Let them always be aware of where you are, and where they need to start walking to. And that's just the start. Next.....

8. Matilda

For decades, the memory in my mind of this movie was Matilda making all the objects in her house float midair and dance around above her head to the sound of Rusted Root's "Send Me on My Way." But I rewatched it with my kids, and the scene is actually set to Thurston Harris' "Little Bitty Pretty One." Our brains are imperfect machines, and I do not know how anyone could trust anyone who takes the stand in a murder trial.

My kids also enjoyed seeing Danny DeVito eating a Jersey Mike's hoagie on a billboard the day after we watched this.

Should go without saying, but: 10000x better than the dumb fucking musical version of this shit.

7. Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

The only reason I can't say that I think every superhero film is a piece of shit.

6. Angels in the Outfield

The only thing I remembered from my first viewing of this film, probably 28ish years ago, was the final batter being a big fat guy who spit a nasty wad of tobacco on the mound before he's struck out. That was still a good moment. The rest of it is pretty good too.

Other important notes: god does not exist; the child welfare system is irrevocably broken.

5. Fantastic Mr. Fox

Read something that they recorded the voice parts outside instead of in a studio, and at one point they got a best take as a boat was speeding by on a lake. Instead of using a worse take, Wes Anderson just added a plane into the scene to explain the noise.

I don't know how this anecdote explains my love of this movie, but it does.

4. The Sandlot

Movie magic is watching the film with your kids and having them go fucking BONKERS during the dog chase scene.

3. Jack

I was gonna write the review like this—

"Do we think Jack masturbates?"

—but then the ending got me. Probably even more so now that I'm that much closer to death.

2. Miracle on 34th Street

Yup, confirmed: this movie fucking rocks, regardless of whether you watch it before Christmas or after Christmas.

A flaw I noticed this time was that I do not like how the final line of the movie is a sarcastic statement from Fred Gailey. If the film had just ended when he and Doris see Santa's cane and they look at each other in bewilderment, it would've been the perfect movie. As it stands now, only the first 95 minutes and 50 seconds are perfect.

1. Whiplash

I could watch the last ten minutes of this film 100 times and come away with a different interpretation each time. I could watch the last ten minutes of this film 100 times and my heart would explode every single time.


We're still doing Family Movie Night, and I'm keeping records on which movies we're watching when. All of those movies (at least from the date we started, 3/1/24, till 11/30/24) are on a list on my phone. I'll spare you that separate list. You can probably figure out which of these films were seen by young eyes too.

Okay, here are the 111 films that I saw for the first time in 2024, ranked from worst to best. I wouldn't take the rankings too seriously, because I didn't.

111. IF

I have so many questions about the logistics of this world, but no time to consider any of them because of that nagging question that is suppressing all other thoughts: who the fuck gave Jim from The Office money to make this shit?

110. Woody Woodpecker Goes to Camp

Boy, this Woody Woodpecker guy is starting to seem like a real jerk.

109. Trolls Band Together

This would have been zero stars if 1) Letterboxd let you give zero stars, but more importantly, 2) if James Corden had reprised his role as Biggie. I've been saying that I hate James Corden even before it was cool to hate James Corden. I'm always glad to watch a movie that doesn't feature the punchable voice of James Corden.

108. A Christmas Story Christmas

There is a kernel of a good idea in here. Had this sequel really leaned into the concept of "adult Ralphie trying to emulate child Ralphie had" we could've had a fun meta exercise on our hands. Alas.

Peter Billingsley is not a good actor, but I guess I can't blame him for squeezing another paycheck out of the thing he did when he was six. I think the problem here is that Jean Shepherd's words are literally the only thing that make the original film special, and they are almost completely absent here.

I will say that, perhaps due to some combination of it being two days before Christmas and the baby being up literally the entire night due to reasons the doctor will have to tell me about after I write this review, I found the ending to be kinda sweet.

107. Sonic the Hedgehog 2

I hate, hate, hate, hate, hate how inconsistent Sonic's top speeds are in these movies. That bar scene in the first movie ruined it for me. You can travel pretty much at the speed of light to fuck with some redneck bar patrons, but then you have trouble going more than like 60 mph when Dr. Robotnik is chasing you? It just doesn't make sense. I hate it.

106. Unfrosted

I guess I am TOO WOKE to find this funny.

105. Wish

No good! I have the same problem with Wish that I did with Frozen II, and that I do with a lot of kids' films—the world's rules are made up to fit the plot as needed, and not the other way around. I am a grown-ass man with a master's degree, and I have no fucking clue what is happening in this kingdom. People give wishes? But the king doesn't want to grant the wishes? And some anthropomorphic star comes down and is stealing the wishes back? Seriously, what a lazy fucking movie. The music is weak too.

The references to other Disney movies were a little much overall, but that Zootopia joke at the end was so egregious that it made me a little nauseous.

104. Shark Tale

Martin Scorsese as a voice role is the best worst stunt casting of all time.

103. Sonic the Hedgehog

I don't understand why the James Marsden cop character clocks Sonic as going 300 mph at top speed, but then it's shown that Sonic can basically travel at the speed of light. Like, if this movie is going to do the same exact scene as the Quicksilver scenes in those X-Men movies, then obviously he's moving faster than 300 mph. But then he has trouble outrunning Dr. Robotnik when he's chasing Sonic through the city with explosives? What, Sonic can only freeze time while in a bar fight? He can't freeze time when Robotnik is trying to kill him? Can't he run to the gun store, steal a gun, put it in Robotnik's mouth, and pull the trigger, all within the space of less than a second? Or should we all just admit now that this was a kids' movie that doesn't really care about this kind of shit? Well I do, Sonic. I do.

Way better than that fucking Mario movie, though.

102. Beetlejuice Beetlejuice

Not good, folks. Don't bring shit back from the dead like this. It's never worth it. Feels like there should be a movie about that lesson.

101. The Internship

It was 3 AM and I was doing the semi-regular "watch a movie with a baby who refuses to sleep" and I put this one on and about 45 minutes into it I was like "where the FUCK is Anne Hathaway?!" and I then realized that I had put on the wrong movie. That's The Intern, not The Internship. The latter, i.e. the one I watched accidentally, was very, very bad. Vince Vaughn and Owen Wilson are fucking insufferable.

100. Suicide Squad

Should've named it Suicide Watch for what I needed after having to watch this terrible three-hour superhero mess.

I'm sorry, someone has probably already made that joke before about this movie. It's not even that good of a joke.

99. Lyle, Lyle, Crocodile

Friday Family Movie Night is going swimmingly. Occasionally, we watch a great movie. Occasionally, we sit through middling children's fare like this singing crocodile movie. My biggest takeaways are that Winslow Fegley is the sweatiest child actor in Hollywood today, that I'd punch Shawn Mendez in the face if I ever met him no questions asked, and that no child should let their parents put a tracking device on them.

98. The Sound of Music

Would have probably been a lot better if the sounds were not of music. The songs STINK!!!

97. Taken

I liked the over-the-top action, but I take issue with the premise. Taken, the movie, is attempting to tell me that the world really is a dangerous place, and that paranoia is always justified. We do not agree, Taken and I.

96. The Color Purple

We're only here again because there's music this time, right? So why was the music so forgettable?

I also hate H.E.R. with a burning passion, and even in the nothing role she had here, I hated it.

Some good acting otherwise. I like Danielle Brooks a lot. Probably could've stood to see Jon Batiste on the receiving end of some of those slaps though.

95. Migration

I hate the kids' movies that don't try to tell one coherent story, but instead have the main protagonists move through a series of separate trials and tribulations, each of them starring a different voice actor. I thought Migration was overall fine but did too much of this. Like, it wasn't necessary to have the duck family meet a crane voiced by Carol Kane. The crane didn't factor into anything else throughout the movie. It's just an excuse to hear Carol Kane. I love Carol Kane, but that shit mostly annoys me. We've seen worse movies on Friday Family Movie Night (and Danny DeVito made it so that there's no way this movie is devoid of laughter), but it was just okay.

94. ParaNorman

Better than your average kiddie flick by far, but probably didn't do enough to make me enamored in any significant way. I liked the animation, there were plenty of good jokes, and ultimately, the message was a sound one for the little ones—be kind, be patient, believe in the best in people, all that good stuff.

93. Jungle Cruise

I was all ready to say "hey, this wasn't nearly as bad as I would've guessed it'd be!!!" but then I waited too long to write this, and the Rock came out as Republican, and now I feel compelled to say "this movie sucks!!!"

92. Leo

As far as children's movies about talking lizards voiced by Adam Sandler giving life lessons to little kids go, this one was pretty good.

91. Police Academy 3: Back in Training

why

90. The Program

Boy oh boy... one of the worst football movies I've ever seen. But you know what? I'm getting down on my knees and thanking the god I don't even believe in, every day from here on out, that this movie wasn't any good or any more popular than it was. Because: check out the quarterback's name. Can you imagine how shitty my life would be if this was an all-timer or billion-dollar-earner?

89. Predator

Pretty good! That it wasn't "great" either means I'm not a real man or I'm not twelve years old anymore.

88. Splendor in the Grass

Watched during a 2 AM - 4 AM zombie session with a cranky one-year-old, so maybe I'm missing something. But is the movie trying to justify the overly zealous parents who basically drive Natalie Wood to suicide, so afraid are they of teenage sex? I think it is, but I'm not 100% sure, is the thing. A very bad movie in which the very good last five minutes justify its existence, somehow, against all odds.

87. World's Greatest Dad

I cannot believe that this movie exists. No, actually: I cannot believe that Dear Evan Hansen was able to steal this plot wholesale and get away with it.

An extra half-star for the Bruce Hornsby subplot.

86. The Jungle Book

Two immaculate songs surrounding by a bunch of well-meaning but ultimately lackluster '60s cartoon bullshit. "Bear Necessities" and especially "I Wanna Be like You" would be worth the price of admission for movies way worse than this though.

85. Rashomon

Ends up being a better idea than an actual good film. It was fine. The idea, i.e. the narrative structure, is so fucking good, though, that I know there are probably a handful of movies already in existence that use that idea to better ends. Also, it's like 75 years old, so I am a bit more patient with its shortcomings.

84. Don't Worry Darling

The coverage of this movie on its site is what made me finally stop visiting AVClub for good. All of that was very annoying, and I was very happy during the year after I forgot that this fucking thing even existed. But then I watched it, and found that it wasn't that bad! Extremely silly, but beautifully shot. Also: an extra star awarded for hitting Nick Kroll with a car. May that man be hit in every car in every movie he stars in from now until the end of time.

83. FernGully: The Last Rainforest

The only thing I knew going in was that Avatar basically stole the plot from FernGully. Afterward, I can officially confirm that FernGully was better in basically every way, but mostly because it's like 1/3rd of the length.

82. Coraline

Meh. I appreciate that it was a kids' film that pulled no punches and wasn't afraid to get dark. But I also felt like it went on way too long and leaned way too hard on the "goth-emo aesthetic" that was popular with a certain type of person when we were growing up.

81. The Secret of Kels

The animation is stunning. The plot was a bit of a reach. Overall, just really nice to spend time in this film, even if a lot of it didn't really make sense.

I think it was a good one for the kids, is basically what I'm saying. They need more art that just exists to be creative and whimsical, as opposed to every goddamn thing they ingest being a strict A-B-C plot with a Explain Everything style.

80. The Willoughbys

Needs to be more cohesive, but honestly, my kids didn't give a shit about cohesiveness. Low bar to clear, but this was the best family movie night film we've seen in a while.

The bad guys are Child Services, and I didn't bother trying to explain that one to my kids.

79. Rustin

Colman Domingo plays an outsized character with deft skill and subtle nuance. That was surprising—not that Domingo hasn't already proven himself as a fantastic actor, but more so that they allowed this character to be this grounded as opposed to the flamboyant caricature that Netflix no doubt wanted him to be. So that was surprising. Unsurprising was literally everything else about this movie. Still decent.

78. Superman

The first rescue—ripping open the shirt to reveal the logo, catching Lois, Lois exclaiming "who's got you?!"—is more than worth the price of admission. That price being that this is basically as mediocre as most other superhero movies otherwise.

77. The Lion King 1 1/2

Big fan of meta concepts, but I wish they would've taken this one even further. Still, props for doing something different. I'll watch this one a thousand times before I watch even two minutes of some cash-in bullshit like The Lion King 2.

[Editor's note: coincidence that there's sort of a The Lion King 0 1/2 coming out soon, with the same premise? Despite my kind words above, I'm not going to see it.]

76. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

I'm not going to click the "I've watched this film before" button even though I've probably watched this film before. If I did, it was when I was like six years old. Doesn't count. Watching as a 35-year-old, I was impressed with how engaging it was, despite the fact that a lot of the sequences felt like they were put in there just so that the movie didn't end up being like 20 minutes long. I can also see why, a century later, Disney tries too hard to make their female protagonists fully engaging and quirky and detailed—they are overcompensating for the fact that their first Disney Princess was a xerox of a facsimile of a sketch of a character.

75. Rush Hour

I almost can't believe Chris Tucker even exists, so preposterous is his squeaky-voiced shtick, let alone star in a goddamn action movie. Racist? Probably yes. Excellent fight sequences? Also probably yes. Will I see Rush Hour 2, or 3, or 4? Probably not.

74. Crazy, Stupid, Love.

If someone had revealed the twist to me prior to watching, I would've dropped at least a full star off the rating. That was good. That got me. Otherwise, I liked Steve Carrell toning it down and Ryan Gosling turning it up and Emma Stone being so goddamn charming and Julianne Moore holding shit down, but not much revelatory here in romcom land.

73. Point Break

Look, I get that most, if not all, cops are some of the dumbest people on earth, but even real-life cops aren't this dumb. Call for backup! It's not that hard! That being said...... if you're able to ignore the stupidity of this film, you'll find an emotionally affecting core, one that makes it well worth the watch.

72. The Ten Commandments

The nuts and bolts were a little rusty, but the overall sense of epic scope held together well. I'm a big fan of the director appearing on stage at the beginning of the film to explain what the movie is about. More filmmakers should do that.

71. The 'Burbs

LOL, imagine being a QAnon dude watching this film and believing that its lead actor was actually killing people in his basement in real life. That actually might be the one time that believing in heinous conspiracy theory Republican shit might actually ENHANCE your appreciation for a film. Unfortunately, I am not a batshit crazy moron, and so all I saw was a pretty quirky and pretty funny cult comedy.

70. Taxi Driver

It was disturbing watching Travis Bickle, and it was disturbing thinking about how many Travis Bickles are out there right now, looking around at their fellow human beings, and hating them enough to, I dunno, vote for trump, basically. I know that's reductive, and unfair to a really great film and a really incredibly performance by De Niro. But that's what I think about when I watch this. I just feel sad, and a little helpless, because, like, what can you do for someone like Travis Bickle?

69. Sophie's Choice

I'm glad I didn't know this was a Holocaust movie because I would've come with higher expectations that it did not meet. But I had no idea what it was about, so that means I had the space to be blown away by Meryl Streep, and by the scene in which she makes the titular choice. Both were more than worth the price of admission otherwise.

68. Holes

It's been about 24 years since I've read the book, but it was my favorite book in fifth grade, and from what I remember and from what I saw during family movie night, I can say that this was a faithful adaptation. Maybe kids' movies are easier to adapt? I don't know. What ever happened to Louis Sachar, anyway?

67. Se7en

Hey Mike L****, thanks for ruining the ending of this movie for me back on Halloween 2016, you ASSHOLE.

66. Purple Rain

Not completely sold on this Prince character. The other one, though—Morris Day, of Morris Day and the Time? Yeah, I have a good feeling that that kid is gonna go far.

65. Maestro

I'm not going to be the only one who mentions this, I can't be, but that brief inclusion of the "Leonard Bernstein" line from the R.E.M. song was so ridiculously bad and cringe that it took me out of it.

Otherwise, pretty good biopic.

64. Team America: World Police

I'm hit or miss on the edgy humor of ironic racism and doll-fucking—though the ratio was skewed more toward "hit" than I would've guessed it'd be—but I'm big on the humor of "this is funny because it's puppets." It really was funny because of the puppets!

63. Pretty Woman

Julia Roberts is pristine as usual. Richard Gere was surprisingly flat. The sexual politics held up pretty well, all things considered. I enjoyed this, despite the Big Romantic Gesture at the end. Knew it was coming, still hated it.

62. BlackBerry

Felt like it hit all the standard notes for this kind of tech bullshit wild-but-true-story film. The difference was that all those other dumb movies don't have a bald Dennis Reynolds playing his usual rage shtick for gasps instead of laughs. Big fan.

61. Rebel Without a Cause

Everything that you've ever heard about this film is true: that it's important, that it's well-acted, that its plot makes close to zero sense, that parents in the '50s must've lost their fucking shit. I've never loved a movie with this many plot holes this much.

60. Scarface

Great movie. Thrilling. Well-made. Funny and sad and violent in all the right places.

Hanging a Scarface poster on your dorm room wall is pretty much the same as hanging a confederate flag.

59. Meet the Parents

The plot machine I hate the most is the "we could've solved all our issues with open communication about our feelings, but that would kill the entire premise." Listen, my father-in-law is not a walk in the park, but he's never done any fucked up shit like DeNiro does here. And more importantly, if he DID, then I'd just... talk to my wife about it? Voice my concerns to my best friend? And would probably divorce if she was like "eh, ya know, that's just how he is, can you try to forget about it?" But yeah, sure, sure, the tension created because of our willingness to accept the absurdity of the situation is what makes it funny. I laughed. But there's gotta be a better movie in here somewhere. I just know it. One more true to life, while still being just as funny.

58. Saltburn

Definitely the type of movie that made me wish that I didn't spend so much time on the internet. Not nearly as bad as the smart alecks online want you to believe. Also probably not as great as Emerald Fennell was gunning for. The "twist," I think, is what made a lot of what came before it not really work. Lots of provocative scenes for the sake of being provocative. Still, I mostly liked it! Felt like I was drawn in despite myself. May Barry Keoghan's penis earn all the memes the film so clearly believes it deserves.

57. Primer

Helps if you understand it. If you can get there (and I just barely did, trust me), then you can pull back and marvel at how much of a punch this one packed into such a small frame.

56. Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs

I didn't realize who made this film while watching it, so when I saw "Phil Lord and Christopher Miller" flash on the screen at the top of the end credits, nothing has ever made more sense to me in my entire life. So many of these jokes landed, and so much of the plot was unnecessary. Classic Lord and Miller. Andy Samberg is annoying, as usual.

55. Hercules

How come no one told me that Danny DeVito had his own Disney song?

...Okay, this observation is hiding under the Danny DeVito quip, hopefully you don't think too much about this, but: Megara immediately jumps to the top of the list of cartoon characters I would absolutely have sex with, if given the chance.

54. DogMan

I've found that it's more fun to just lean into silly/over-the-top films instead of nitpicking. Movie magic can still exist even if the movie is so dumb that it takes you out of it a little bit. I would recommend DogMan to anyone who feels that they too can overlook some dumb bullshit and just have fun.

53. The Shining

I've never read the book, but I know that the book was better.

Still very good. And creepy in all the right ways. I'm just not a "creepy movie" kinda guy I guess.

52. WolfWalkers

The perfect Family Movie Night film—interesting, inventive, not too complex of a plot, vivid time and place, joyful and thrilling, fun for all ages, yadda yadda yadda. I like Soul more than most, but this probably should've taken the Oscar.

51. Ron's Gone Wrong

There was a dark heart to this one, with a bleak message that I don't think my kids fully comprehended during family movie night, but they will, eventually, when they're older and they are dependent on their phones and they realize that Ron's Gone Wrong tried to warn them all those many years ago.

50. Meatballs

A simple film that I really enjoyed, and probably would've enjoyed more if I had seen it three months or possibly seventeen years prior. I'm talking about the palpable sense of innocence here that I really would've latched onto decades ago, and from this angle can only appreciate from afar.

Sidenote: Bill Murray excels at playing characters that are always "on," to the point that it's completely unrealistic that any other character would ever date them. I gotta imagine it's fucking exhausting to date someone like that. Not his fault or the movie's fault, not even really anything bad, just a stray thought.

49. Oppenheimer

This was great, but great in a way that I expected, and was unsurprised by. Definitely a film that would've been cooler to see in theaters, what with the pivotal test explosion scene being powerful even on the medium-sized TV screen. Also a little weird that the "hey this congressman is an asshole" plot held the same weight as the "man vs. god re: nuclear devices" plot, but I was fine to go along for the ride anyway.

Here's something that really bothered me. I don't even know if I should mention this. I don't want to ruin the experience for anyone else. Don't read ahead if you want to be able to watch Oppenheimer again without thinking about this constantly over the course of three hours. Okay, here you go:

Cillian Murphy sounds EXACTLY like Robin Williams in this film. Fucking exactly. You can't unhear it once you realize it. I am so sorry.

48. First Blood

Wow... the reputation of the film series as a whole really tricked me into thinking that this first film was going to be dumb loud explosions. There was a lot of that, but I was shocked and delighted to find that the explosions had a purpose. There was nuance here. The quiet moments in between were honestly kinda beautiful. Also: ACAB (Rambo agrees).

47. Puss in Boots: The Last Wish

This might be a matter of low expectations begetting high reward, but I really liked this thing. Genuinely funny throwaways lines mixed with a mature take on "grappling with death," at least for an ostensible kids' film.

I'm trying to start a new thing where my older daughters are allowed to stay up late on Friday night if they watch a movie that neither one of them has ever seen before. Trying to build a love of cinema, or whatever. The goal for me is to actively watch it with them. This was Friday #2 (last Friday was the new Trolls stinker, and I know they're not all gonna be winners, and that's okay). So maybe I'm overrating it in that regard too—a movie that I can share with my daughters is gonna boost the grade maybe a half a star. But still. Still! Really good movie!

46. Raising Arizona

Kinda nice sitting down and already being acquainted with the general style and tropes of a particular director (or directors). I liked this one. Laughed a lot. Probably had something sneaky to say about parenthood too that I'm not sure is annoying for me to bring up.

45. Punch-Drunk Love

The hullabaloo over Adam Sandler's first non-Adam-Sandler-type role is not overhyped. There is more comedic tension found in one scene of this overstimulating film than a thousand Billy Madisons or Happy Gilmores could ever hope to reproduce.

44. Rain Man

Mainly just relieved to find that it hasn't aged poorly overly the last 35 years. But otherwise taken by the kind and gentle portrayal of Raymond (pit stop in Las Vegas notwithstanding).

43. Psycho

One of my favorite things about exploring classic films that I've never seen before is the idea that there's one scene that's become so famous that everyone knows about it, even if they've never seen the film in question, and even if that film is over 60 years old, and then you end up watching the film and realizing how truly insignificant that famous scene is in the general scope of the film's plot. So: obviously I knew about the shower scene. But I was extremely tickled by the fact that it happens halfway through and ushers in a completely new back half of the film. Fun stuff.

42. Quadrophenia

Oh damn, that whole split-personality thing on the Who's best rock opera was actually a metaphor? Holy shit.

Good film. Kind of like a slice-of-life thing going here. Lots of scenes that were content to just sit back and view the action in long, uncut sequences. I liked it.

41. Bernie

Minor Linklater, but still worth your time. More emphasis on fun and less emphasis on the philosophical. I'm usually coming to this dude's movies for the latter, but the former is fine too. But, like, there was totally an opportunity to lean into the philosophy of it all too, ya know? Maybe I'm just missing something. Maybe the talking heads of the local yokels is supposed to count as ironically high-minded? Could be. Shit, though, I had fun.

40. Inside Out 2

The premise is one that I still think about all the time. It's reductive, to think about your emotions like little colorful creatures who talk like the best part about Stranger Things and the worst part about Parks and Rec, but it's helpful too. Pixar usually nails the ending to these things, and they nailed it here, so that's helpful too.

39. A Streetcar Named Desire

A tough watch. I know it was designed that way, like, that's the whole point. Doesn't make it any easier. Honestly, I shoulda just schlepped myself over to La Salle University in April 2013 to see their version instead.

38. High Fidelity

The trick is to not be like these people. Music is great, but you don't have to be obnoxious about it or overly protective of it. Cuasck is fucking bonkers good in this. That anyone would accuse me of being like Rob is a sign that I'm doing something wrong.

37. Tommy Boy

Pretty stunned to find that Chris Farley was not annoying at all in this. I was conditioned to think otherwise, probably from the dozens and dozens of '90s and '00s comedies featuring annoying men (most of them alumni of SNL). Would they have taken after Farley from Tommy Boy, and so much pain could have been avoided.

36. Sunset Boulevard

Totally makes sense that this would be ranked high on All-Time lists, since it's a movie about movies and a sad movie about how sad making movies is. Totally makes sense that the final line is as well-known as it is—it's a good one! All of it totally makes sense, and adds up to making sense that I would like it a lot.

35. Some Like It Hot

Marilyn Monroe is resplendent in her pilled-out brilliance. Takes a lot for humor to translate 65 years after the fact, so the fact that this was still funny says a lot.

34. Sliding Doors

The concept of this film (forking the narrative at one specifically place and then telling both versions simultaneously) will outlive the plot of this film (Goop Gwyneth finds love) by 1000 years.

33. Traffic

Pretty much exactly what I expected, but that's not to its detriment. Yes, the country has a drug problem, and yes, it's complicated. Doesn't mean that the film itself can't work the shit out of those simple ideas. Good acting and good plotting abound.

32. Fallen Leaves

Might seem like a sad film—and it's certainly acted like it's one—but I see a very dim and slightly grim message of hope here. There is a lot of pain in the world, but it feels better to hang out with people who understand that pain.

31. Spirited Away

I couldn't look away during, but walked away from the experience mostly unchanged. I think I maybe didn't allow myself to adjust to the weird rhythms of this film. I also think that a lot of the plot was either bullshit or just culturally different and thus inscrutable. Overall, slightly overrated, but still interesting enough that I want to watch everything else Hayao Miyazaki has ever done.

30. Saving Silverman

I don't think I've ever been so charmed by a film so dumb. This is the kind of film I wish I would've seen when I was drunk on Hurricanes in St. Basils 249 while skipping world history class.

29. Requiem for a Dream

If a film is to be judged on how much it makes you "feel something," then this one goes above and beyond. No idea how people do drugs after watching this. No idea how people eat sugar after watching this. No idea how people go ass-to-ass after watching this.

28. The Texas Chain Saw Massacre

Shit like this makes me wonder why any horror movie needs a budget greater than like $2000. Grab a couple masks, AirBnB a farmhouse, and then just add some movie magic, and there you go. Fucking classic.

27. Shogun Assassin

I am here because of GZA's Liquid Swords. One of the most badass movies I've ever seen in my life.

26. The Iron Claw

A pretty simple but extremely affecting portrait of sadness and grief as told through the ridiculous context of professional wrestling. Zac Efron fucking did it! I'm proud of him! Dude made me cry at the end of his movie!

25. May December

I loved how it didn't necessarily ask you to judge any of the characters, even the child molester. The judgment is implicit. Instead, May December wants you to examine we respond to such stories. The judgment is directed toward the self, if anything. Yes, it's fucked up what happened, but isn't it just as fucked up that we're indulging ourselves with a dramatic movie about it?

24. Kung Fu Panda

I know this is the dumbest and most simplistic takeaway from this movie, almost insultingly so, but here it is anyway: I gotta watch more kung fu movies. This was a generic kids movie, yes, but even so, the fight sequences really got me going! I need to see that kind of shit more in adult contexts. (Sidenote: Dustin Hoffman in this film? Really fucking good!)

23. The Terminator

Possibly the only movie I've ever seen in my life that made me say during the credits "I have to see the sequel!" Wait, is that true? I don't know. I can't remember. This was awesome.

22. Election

I can't explain why, but it makes perfect sense that this was written by the guy who wrote The Leftovers (the book) and directed by the guy who directed The Holdovers. An insane combo on the face of it, but emotionally true.

Kinda insane to see an only-25-year-old film treat institutional rape as a sort of joke, but I think there's a lot to learn from how societal views Tracy Flick in '99 and then how that's different in '24.

21. Singin' in the Rain

The classic songs hit HARD. Holy hell. I think that, by and large, musicals are stupid because they prioritize the musical numbers over the needs of the plot. But I almost don't even give a shit when the musical numbers are as full of pure fucking movie magic as these were. On the other hand... this fucker goes completely off the rails with 30 minutes left. Does anyone talk about that? I haven't looked it up yet.

20. Rocky II

I expected it to be Rocky I on steroids, and it mostly was. I did not expect "Rocky I on steroids" to still be so fucking exciting. I wish I was born twenty years earlier so I could've been one of those kids running with Rocky down Ben Franklin Parkway.

19. Rushmore

Instantly became my favorite Wes Anderson movie, for reasons that I'm still putting together. It felt... really BIG, is the only way I can describe it. And that's a funny way to put it, because if you examine each individual piece, it feels small, right? Deadpan acting, minimal set pieces, no explicit action. Put it all together, though... and it feels fucking immense.

18. The Tree of Life

I've more or less thought about this film every day since I've watched it, so that's something.

17. Spartacus

Went down well during a rough day at work. Fuck jobs, Spartacus has convinced me that we should all UNIONIZE.

16. Saving Private Ryan

One of those movies that is so well made that you can't help but get distracted with thinking about what it must have taken to make it. Steven Spielberg is just too good, I guess. Shame on him.

15. Orion and the Dark

Absolutely flabbergasted to discover the "classic Pixar-type children's movie except written by Charlie Kaufman" film in existence. Less flabbergasted after knowing it was a Kaufman film to find that I loved it. This is right up my fucking alleyway. "A story about storytelling," if you will. If Kaufman wrote a screenplay for every children's film, I'd never watch a film for people my own age again.

14. Snowpiercer

A generic thriller would give you a brief flash of the cockroaches getting grinded up into protein bars. Snowpiercer lingers on that shit for a few extra seconds. A lesser film would explain why the axes had to be dipped in fish blood before battle. Snowpiercer not only doesn't explain it, but has a comedic pratfall right afterward when the main character slips on the fish. I could go on and on about why this film is weird and different, but it all adds up to the fact that I can't seem to get it out of my head. That's a good thing. Great film.

13. Anatomy of a Fall

Count me in for a talky film. We get the opening incident, and then we get two hours of people talking about that opening incident, and I'm all for it. I appreciate the restraint of the film to never actually reveal the truth, so to underline the fact that the only truth is that we can never actually know what is true. See, I can talk out of my ass about this shit too!!!

12. Poor Things

The funny thing about the Margo Robbie snub (which, sure, okay, she deserved to be nominated) was that the uproar completely ignored the fact that there were plenty of worthy performances that were nominated. Emma Stone was fucking fantastic here. Totally deserves the nom. Might even deserve the award. I didn't expect to laugh as much as I did for this film. Great shit.

11. Steel Magnolias

I've never felt like more of an interloper than I did watching this film. As far as I'm concerned, these are real people, and this shit really did happen, and I'm just a ghost, watching and appreciating as I stand there, invisible, for three years, so goddamn proud of these ladies.

10. Asteroid City

I hate to say it, just because there's a good chance that this is recency bias, but I honestly enjoyed this more than any other Wes Anderson movie I've ever seen. And that's a high bar! I really like his movies! The brilliant structure of this film, the constant fourth-wall-breaking, is what ultimately puts it over the top for me.

9. Killers of the Flower Moon

The central conflict was obvious, but I think that was the point. The film went out of its way to make it obvious. It broke the fucking fourth wall with the director himself telling you to your face that it was obvious!

And you know what? That's okay. I like it. I also liked a lot of the supporting characters and weird shit happening around the edges. I was so ready to blast this shit for being 3.5 hours, but I think at this point I could've done this for a few more hours.

8. Sing Sing

I didn't know all those characters were actual Sing Sing prisoners playing themselves. Makes sense, in retrospect, that I'd walk away from this film thinking it was one of the realest movies I'd ever seen. Every performance was so goddamn honest that it was sincerely shocking and thrilling to see. I love movies where there is no villain; this might be the best of its kind.

7. The Holdovers

Aesthetically, it felt like Harold and Maude. Scenically, it felt like Dead Poets Society. Plot-wise, it felt like the beats were well-worn, but the three main actors had a way of pulling you in anyway. I wouldn't mind watching this thing every Christmastime from here on out.

6. Terms of Endearment

If you told me I could make out with one 1983 Oscar nominee, either Debra Winger or Shirley MacLaine, I think I'd have to just choose John Lithgow so I don't end up hurting myself.

5. Kiki's Delivery Service

A beautiful fucking film that is immediately comforting. I love how there's no villain here, just a young girl trying to find herself. The story is so small that it's almost unbelievable that this film got made at all. What happens? Nothing really. But you get to watch the beauty unfold anyway. Big fan of the good feelings from this one. Kids liked it too (didn't hurt that Kiki's cat looks exactly like ours).

4. The Wild Robot

This won't win Best Picture, but it should. "Kindness can be a survival skill" is a line that will live with me until I die.

3. American Fiction

I haven't felt this specific way about a film since watching Ratatouille. The specific focus is the role of race in art, but if you zoom out, then you find that the general focus here is like the flipside of the coin in Anton Ego's monologue: yes, good art can come from anywhere, but that doesn't mean that art from anywhere is always good. Equity means equal opportunity, but that equal opportunity does not automatically mean equal quality. I don't know, it's fucking complicated... clearly I don't have a good grasp on it, and I'm fumbling around with my thoughts in a fucking Letterboxd review for some reason... suffice it to say that if a film has me this excited to be perplexed about my thoughts about art and my reaction to a film that is reacting to art, and so on, then I'm assuming that this is one of the best films I've seen in a while.

2. The Zone of Interest

An absolutely insane movie that I can't stop thinking about. Like, if this were just a regular Holocaust movie that overwhelmed you with the sheer scale of the atrocities committed, then that would be one thing. But presenting it as mundane... shit's got me haunted.

Sidenote: I had the audacity to chuckle just a little bit at the brief scene where the baby wouldn't stop crying in the middle of the night. I know it was in the movie too indicate that the baby was suffering trauma from her proximity to all that pain and death. I only chuckled because I'm so goddamn tired all the time and I'm like that because of my own baby. I am now being punished. Writing this review at 2 in the morning. Baby won't sleep. She knows I deserve this. We're sitting here in the dark, and I am obsessively thinking about Zone of Interest, and how the craziest Holocaust movie I'll ever see in my life consists 90% of household chores.

1. Robot Dreams

Sorry if this feels like an exaggeration, but: Robot Dreams is the perfect film. YMMV, I guess, since there is no dialogue, but I don't need dialogue to know what these characters are saying. And what they have to say, or don't, is fucking stunning. It's basically Past Lives for the whole family.

Me and the six-year-old and the four-year-old watched it together, and it's probably the only film of our lives together—so far!—that left all three of us stunned. How rare, man, to have something like this to share.

3 comments:

Nate said...

"57. Primer
56. Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballls"

This is when I turned into the Joker reading this.

Joe K said...

Sorry, I should have explicitly noted that I design these rankings to make Nate angry when he reads it, and no other reason.

Nate said...

We can find community in a shared appreciation of Kung Fu Panda, if nothing else.