Thursday, December 19, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 174: Zach

Prompt: "A song that you know for sure makes someone else think of you when they hear it"

Selected by Zach


"Ways to Go"
GROUPLOVE
Spreading Rumours, 2013

Last night, I was having dinner with someone special.

"What bands do you like?" she asked me.

And I rattled off a few bands. Anyone reading this could probably guess a few of the bands I named (what a cool thing about YSC, for people to know you and your music taste so well after a year of seeing your choices). We agreed on some (Guster chief among them). I asked her who she liked.

"I love GROUPLOVE," she said.

The only GROUPLOVE song I could remember is "Ways to Go." I started singing it. I referenced its appearance on a Girls promo for Season 3 (side note: how fucking good was Girls? The further I get away from watching it, and the more I realize I haven't heard about Lena Dunham in a while, the more I appreciate it). As we were walking home, she turned to me. "Now I'm singing GROUPLOVE," she said. So I know for sure that if she were to hear "Ways to Go" at this moment, she would think of me.

But that's not the point of this post. I want to tell you more about S. 

S and I went on our first date on November 12. But we met well before that. 

Late April 2021, Yom Haatzmaut (Israel's Independence Day). My friend organized a camping night on the outskirts of Jerusalem. I went. I was new to Israel then, but I knew a bunch of people there. A high school friend who lived in Tel Aviv, people I knew from America, others I'd picked up along the way. I brought the person who I was dating at the time. And S. S was there, and was one of the people I'd never met.

Somehow the person I was dating, me, and S ended up sitting on the same side of the campfire. I don't remember exactly what we talked about. But I do remember thinking S was awesome. 

I had mixed feelings about the person I was dating at the time. Either way, I definitely liked S. She had talked about how she was into hiking and meditation and was on a real religious journey—all things I very much connected to. I loved that.

The person I was dating didn't stay the night. We all went to sleep. The next day we all did a hike together, and S was there. We chatted a bit, and my affinity for her grew, which was complicated, of course, I was dating someone, someone who my gut told me probably wasn't the one. 

Later that night, I hosted Shabbat dinner. I debated—should I invite her? Is that too much? I barely know her. But it's not weird to invite people you barely know to Shabbat dinner, and so I did. She came, along with a few others from the camping trip. It was nice. I told the person I was dating that I invited her. She agreed that S was awesome—after all, the three of us had spent the camping night hanging together. Everything was good and above board and nothing was inappropriate.

That person and I broke up soon after. I dated someone else right afterward. It was a very volatile month-long relationship. I was pretty upset when that one ended. S had been on my mind. I texted her the next day. "Would you want to get coffee sometime? You can let me know!" She wrote back that she was visiting her family in the US, that she'd get back to me when she was back. 

I never heard from her after that. I never really knew why, but I wasn't in a place where I was going to wait for her. I started dating someone else right around that time, a six-to-seven-month-long relationship that ended early 2022. Then I started dating the person from Chicago. Right as that relationship was beginning, I went to my friend's house for Shabbat dinner. He didn't know I knew S, and I didn't know he knew her.

"My friend called me today," he said. "He got engaged! To someone named [S]!"

Cool, I thought. Nice! It had been many months since I had asked S out, and I had kind of written it off, and I had started dating someone. I honestly didn't think much of it.

A little more than a year later I was voice noting with a friend from the US. He told me he had spent the weekend in Denver on a trip from New York.

He told me he had been at a Shabbat dinner in Denver, where he was sitting with his friend and two women who he met at the dinner. He and I had once taken a different trip to Denver, and one of the women told him she was back and forth between her hometown of Minneapolis and Israel. So he brought up my name. "I know him!" she apparently told him. And mentioned the Shabbat dinner I had hosted her at, two plus years prior. He shared her name with me. It was S.

S is from Minnesota. And as far as I knew, she was married and living in Israel. 

She was apparently in Denver for a hiking trip, as was he. "Wait, but isn't she married or something?" I asked. He said it really didn't seem like it. I didn't understand what happened, or why she was in the US, or anything. 

"I don't know what your deal is," my friend told me. "But anyone would be lucky to be with her."

So it seemed like her engagement hadn't worked out. But she was in the US. I didn't know what was happening with her. And I didn't text her, didn't pursue anything. After my Chicago experience I was very wary of reaching out to anyone in the US for dating.

And another year went by, with all the things that happen in a year. By then, the volatile relationship person was married. Chicago person was engaged (she's getting married on Sunday). Denver friend was married. Things change in a year. It was Yom Kippur, and I was leaving the morning services, for an hour break before I had to go back for the afternoon prayer. As I was walking out of the synagogue, someone caught my eye. 

I didn't recognize her at first. It was three plus years since I had seen her. Then it clicked. I went up to her.

"S?" I said. 

And it was her. She had just moved to Tel Aviv, for an internship in social work. I couldn't believe she was living in Tel Aviv. Tel Aviv doesn't generally attract hippies. But there she was, right in front of me.

(I've since learned that her engagement didn't work out and she's very grateful for that, that she had moved around Israel a bit, had spent time in the US, and decided to totally change her career and pursue social work, which she couldn't be happier about. She did just come back to Israel with the intention of staying.)

Yom Kippur ended, and I moved on. I was on a break from dating, and even though my crush on S had never fully been extinguished, I wasn't sure what to do with the information that we now lived in the same city. There were also other things going on, other dating ideas that had been percolating. 

I ran into A #2 and asked her out, and she said yes (I wrote about that somewhere in YSC). The day she said yes, I went to Shabbat dinner (are you sensing a theme here?) at a couple who I'd never been to before, about two weeks after Yom Kippur.

I walked in, and there was S.

It wasn't a total shock. We're all part of the same community. But it was a small meal—the couple hosting, another couple, and me and S, and that was all.

We talked at the meal. The crush was there, 100%. I was supposed to go on a date with A #2, though, and I didn't want to mess around.

When A #2 told me that she had started dating someone else and couldn't go out with me a couple days after that meal, I was relieved. It opened the door for me to ask out S.

I still wasn't 100% sure. She had just moved to Tel Aviv, wasn't her life crazy? What if she wasn't interested? What if she said no, and I had to see her around all the time now?

I talked to my therapist. Afterward, I drafted a text. I sent it to my friend. She vetted it, and gave me some feedback. It was a Wednesday, and I woke up with a fever of 100.4F. I took a sick day. That morning I made the final edits to the text and, after taking a deep breath, hit send. I scrolled through my roommate's movie selection and decided on Manchester by the Sea after realizing I didn't have the patience to get through Killers of the Flower Moon. I waited all day.

The next morning, I saw she had sent me a voice note. As a defense mechanism, I convinced myself that she would say no. 

"Hey Zach," she said. "I was also thinking about how we should date. I want to go out. I'm busy for the next two weeks—I'm moving, I'm starting an internship, my life is insane. Can I get back to you when I'm free?"

So it was a yes! I celebrated, with an asterisk. Because it's happened to me more than once that when someone says they'll get back to you, it doesn't always happen. 

I told her that was cool. I asked how long it might be. She said two weeks. And I immediately lowered my expectations.

But a week and a half later I heard from her. She was ready to meet up. Pleasantly surprised with how quickly she had gotten back to me, we made plans to get a drink. That was November 12.

Since then we've gone out eleven times. I have to say it's going very, very well.

Typically I'm full of anxieties about the other person when it comes to dating. It's my own stuff, sure, but it's also my gut telling me something's not right. I don't trust my gut often enough. It's why I'm still at my job. But with her I don't feel all those familiar anxieties, and I kind of can't believe it.

She's smart. She's adventurous. Looking into her eyes is like looking into the depths of the ocean. She doesn't care that I'm not sure about my job situation—she embraces the excitement of it. When I told her that I feel weird that I don't exactly know where my career is going and how I can be a provider, she laughed. "Yeah, I've always wanted to date a guy who hated his life and made tons of money," she said, with just the right dose of sarcasm. It made me feel so good when she said that, and I felt so supported by her. She loves the outdoors and wants to do long backpacking trips. She has an incredible smile. Religiously, we're pretty much on the same page, which is not a given for me. She loves Israel and wants to live here. She's incredibly close with her family. She's been through her fair share of challenges in life. She's a meditator, someone who goes off on two-month long silent meditation retreats and doesn't look at her phone or communicate with the outside world for that entire time. We vibe. We get along. She's so pleasant to be around. It's like a burst of light when she comes into the room. I like just listening to her talk—about anything, about her day, about whatever. She's so easygoing, and lets me be me. I've had to negotiate roommate politics when having her over to my house, but the way she's handled my anxieties about how those politics could affect her has been nothing but calming and affirming. I feel so lucky to be dating her. I want her to be happy.

And I'm scared, too. I don't want more heartbreak. I've had enough. Neither does she. I think we're both holding back, just a little bit, because we're scared of that. It's also only been a month plus. I'm trying to take things as they come, to let them happen, rather than artificially move them along. But we've had some of the big conversations already and they've felt like they've come at the right time. They've just been integrated into the fabric of our regular time together, rather than being talked about as "issues that NEED to be brought up." I'm still scared. Sometimes I feel like I have to be perfect, that if I make one mistake she'll run away. This isn't healthy. There's humanity in the imperfection. We're not God, we're not angels. I've talked about this with S. "What if the imperfections are the things to celebrate?" she asked. It's true. And yet. 

But these are my own anxieties, things I'm going to have to work through on my own. They don't have to do with her—they'd come up no matter who I was dating. It's a new experience to not have anxieties about her, if she's right, if we should or shouldn't keep dating. I just feel really good about how it's going right now. And I want to continue. I have no doubt about that. Because of that (and S and I have talked about this, and she feels the same way), there's all this extra space around us. That space isn't taken up by anxiety. It's just there. I kind of can't believe it. That's what I've been wanting. And yet—what do I do with that space?

I'm trying to let go of the fear. I recently read an incredible list of life lessons that I really connected to, by someone named Nabeel S. Qureshi. Number 5: "Later, you'll be nostalgic for right now." 

This is the good stuff, right now. The excitement of meeting someone new, of not being sure where it will go. 

Yeah, it's scary. Yeah, I don't know the answers. Yeah, I have my own things I'm working through. Yeah, I want to meet someone and start a family and S seems like someone who I could potentially do that with. Yeah, I don't want to get hurt, and I don't want to get my hopes up too much.

That's all true. It's all true.

But right now all I have is me, and her. And we're here, and we're spending time together. Things are unfolding, because that's how life works. Things will continue to unfold, however they will. I have no control, really. 

What do I do with all this extra space? Enjoy it. Enjoy the hell out of it. Because it'll never come again, and I'll miss it when it's gone, no matter what direction it goes.

Right now S is somewhere in Tel Aviv, and I'm standing in my office in Neve Ilan. She's on my heart. I'll see her soon, maybe today, maybe tomorrow, maybe next week. I'll see her, and we'll say hi, and we'll smile at one another, because we're just happy to be together in that moment.

That's all I know, and that's all that matters.

4 comments:

Joe K said...

After everything you've written on this subject in 2024, if this is how your YSC story ends, I will be so happy.

sunny said...

An incredible level of closure and catharsis happening in the blogodome here

Sara said...

Sending good vibes for S! We’ll need a column next year. (Also 11 dates in 1 month is a wildly good number of times to hang out!)

Zach said...

Thanks!! Curious what that column would be, other than 'Zach's dating life?' You tell me and we'll get it to the EiC.