About halfway down I saw the following title: S5 E08 Grannies Gone Wild.mp4.
I guess I downloaded it at some point in the last year. I don't know when. I don't know why. I never watched it. Maybe I was frustrated enough at work to read the GGW columns with zero context at some point and decided to hit download. I really have very little memory of this.
But I know it was recently Veterans Day. For some reason, that means Joe watched this show. And I know he's watched it many times. And I have no Netflix password, no Prime account, no way to watch anything except on my roommate's TV, and I don't want to do that. I'm hungry for content.
Reba it is!
So, at 10:15 PM on a Thursday night in November, I started watching this episode.
Snap reactions without remembering much of what Joe's written about it:
- Van sucks. I know this can't possibly be a hot take. But, like, he really sucks. He sucks as a person, but he also sucks as a written character. Why do they keep going to the "weird face" joke? I want to throw a tomato at the computer.
- Reba herself is not compelling. She's an empty vessel with an accent. And I find that fascinating. The show is named after her, but she's so clearly a meaningless character who does nothing? She's not even a foil for the other characters. What does that mean for our show, for its core?
- Is the actor playing the judge famous from other things?
- "I'm foreman! I call it!" made me laugh.
- When the grandmas all come out dressed up, is that supposed to be a big punchline or reveal? I don't understand why it's so objectionable.
- I've read enough about Errol Flynn to know through osmosis that Joe hates that line.
- If this show were actually dark, the dark humor about being dead would be earned. But it's not dark. Or maybe it's way darker than I realize. I don't know what's happening.
- "You don't think she's got a thong under there, do you?"—I can tell the actor himself is cringing while saying this line.
- Elder abuse is funny for these horrible people!
- The judge regretting his whole career is... not convincing.
- Actually Ms. Hart is a great actor.
- "My boob just popped out of my lucky bra" is not a line that would appear on television today.
- "Bailiff Ron" is a line I am sure Joe hates by now.
- I laughed at Mother Teresa being declared a loser but I think it's because the line is delivered and acted so poorly. A little bit of The Room vibes.
- Man, Reba SUCKS as a character. I think I'm most mad about this. Something about her orange blouse makes me angry, too.
- If Cheyenne doesn't divorce Van on the spot I will be angrier.
- Actually I will give the show credit for shining light on Van's vulnerability. It just doesn't jive with the "hot and ditzy" comment that he made a minute ago that was grounds for divorce.
- The 80th birthday scene feels like something a first-time director in a freshman year course at art school would have put together.
- Did Van really hate him that much to gloat over his death?
- The death scenes feel like the way Andy Samberg and Bill Hader and Kirsten Wiig and Shia LeBoeuf die in the "Dear Sister" SNL O.C. parody.
- Clever thermometer ending, a twist I did not see coming that was set up at the beginning.
- What was the point of the jury duty plot? Did I miss something?
- I feel dirty right now after watching that. Not uplifted, and not happy, and not feeling good about life.

3 comments:
I am sorry to say that you are now obligated to watch it at least 99 more times.
For posterity: as Melissa Peterman explained directly to Puke on Your Birthday, the jury subplot was a work-around for a pregnant Melissa Peterman to be able to shoot her disconnected scenes very quickly, for a few different episodes all at once, before she went into labor.
Sounds like a pretty classic first viewing reaction. Welcome to the fold.
Post a Comment