Monday, November 18, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 161: Joe

Prompt: "A song with a formal title in its, um, title"

Selected by Joe


"Mr. Tangerine Man"
Wesley Stace
30 Days, 30 Songs, 2016

Alright so it's been what, like 87 days since Election Day, and I'm still working out my thoughts in real time, since, ya know, I was stupid enough to be baselessly optimistic about the outcome of the votes, and didn't prepare, emotionally, for what actually happened, and now my brain and my heart are struggling to catch up, and I've said some thoughts out loud and I think I mean them but I'm fine-tuning those thoughts as I say 'em, and—what's that? It's only been thirteen days? Oh lordy. What is happening.

My general thought process has led me to believe that I need to shut up about all this. But I don't know if that reaction is borne of cowardice. Like, okay, say I find out that a close relative voted for trump. I applaud all those women who are divorcing their maga husbands, I think it's great that people are cancelling Thanksgiving because they don't want that trash in their homes, etc. I think that's great but I don't necessarily think that's the way I'm gonna go with it. I'm in a position where most of the people I associate with regularly are not maga, so I'm lucky in that regard, but say there were a few. There is, but let's just make this point in the hypothetical. I don't think that I am going to completely shut 'em out of my life, at least not right now. I am trying to look at it from a cost/benefits perspective. The cost of right this second completely exiting from the lives of the few maga people in my life is that creates a lot of drama, and the benefit is...? I don't know, self-righteousness? That doesn't seem worth it. I feel like it might be more beneficial to hold my cards close to my chest, for now. Know fully who is on our side and who isn't, and then just shut up until the trigger-pull is absolutely necessary. That day will come, and I plan on being prepared for that time (up to and including deleting this blog post and maybe even the whole blog). There will come a time when the benefits will outweigh the costs.

But okay, or is that just me being a coward? I don't know. It's not right to give a maga person a pass in this moment (and I'd even argue lumping in third-party voters and both-sides morons into this category with the maga), but I think I'm willing to sacrifice being right RIGHT NOW so that I can position myself to be right when it is absolutely necessary. I know it's cliché to think about the Holocaust but I do sometimes, regarding this current mess we're in. You always hear about the people who were in a position to smuggle out like 100 Jewish kids out of Germany, saving them from certain death. You think the people doing the smuggling were also out there in the street with megaphones hollering about how Hitler was a ratched-ass bitch? No, they weren't. They were quietly doing the right thing when it mattered most. Some people were using their position to plant bombs and rescue babies. They did that in secret.

I think then reason I keep writing about it in this way (seriously, this is like the third time I've tried to explain it on this blog in the past thirteen days) is that I'm also scared that this is going to result in either me looking like a coward or me actually legitimately being a coward. There is still a part of me who believes that I need to be doing something right now. That I need to once again don the pink hat and march down the Parkway and feel good about myself, that I'm actually doing something, instead of just sitting back and watching it happen.

And then I remember the Muslim ban. Do you remember this? Of course you do, eight years isn't that long. In the early days of the first (oh god oh god) trump presidency, he signed an executive order that banned people from six Muslim-majority nations from entering the U.S., including refugees. Which is fucked up in a bunch of different ways! And people reacted in kind. People rushed to the airports to protest! I have a distinct memory of a picture of then- (oh god oh god) Senator Bob Casey at the airport in a tux, rushing there from some swanky event or whatever. The people were coming together to stop one of the first heinous acts from a heinous man!

Except... then he just brought it to the Supreme Court, they said it was okay, and then the government started to enforce the order. And they enforced it until the next president came in, Joe Biden, who dutifully reversed the order, until... until, until. You see that the protests didn't do shit. They didn't do shit except make people feel real fucking good about themselves. But they didn't do shit for the policy. It still happened. I don't fault anyone for trying, I really don't. I think it's amazing that there are people out there so willing to put their bodies on the line like that (especially now that police are gonna be able to kill protestors without consequence). But look at the cost vs. benefits here. What was the cost? A bunch of shit, from big to small. What was the benefit? Fucking nothing. 

I think this means I've lost hope. Which is a reality a lot of people are facing right now, and it's an understandable one. We're all headed off the cliff, possibly in slow motion, and there ain't a protest in the whole goddamn universe that can save us.

And what I don't want—an idea that makes me fucking ill, to be honest—is to spend the next four years hemming and hawing about each individual slight, each little fracture that trump chips away in the glass of the democracy. I don't want to hear about every little grievance, because there ain't fucking nothing we can fucking do about it! I saw Elizabeth Warren chirping the other day about how trump didn't sign some ethical contract and how it was illegal that he didn't and whatever and whatever, and it's like, fucking so? Fucking Elizabeth Warren is gonna sit here and bitch in a tweet about how the incoming president is breaking the law, fucking again, and so what? What the fuck can she do about it? What the fuck can anyone do about it? What benefit would it be for me to march down to Washington right now and get harpooned by some fucking loser cop over it? What benefit would it be for me to fight with my uncle about it at the next First Holy Communion party about it? None! Fucking none!

If that isn't worth it, then I'll tell you something that also isn't worth it—listening to the dumb fucking protest songs that are going to come about again. I hated this shit when it was happening in 2017, and I hate the idea of it happening now. You heard the song that I embedded above, right? How fucking smarmy, self-righteous, and unhelpful is that shit? All those fucking people giggling along to some tired fucking jokes about small hands, it makes me fucking sick. As if these fucking asinine cracks at trump are going to move the needle one fucking micrometer. Make fun of his toupee all you want, you fucks. It makes no difference to the fucking ghouls who are out there making executive orders that are gonna kill your wives, your daughters.

I'm ashamed to say that this was one of the first maybe ten reactions that I had on election morning. I.e. how many fucking dumb fucking songs from fucking Tim Heidecker about trump taking a shit on a gold toilet am I going to have to endure this time around? Luckily, I saw YSC Villain Steve Hyden fishing for just such a question on his Twitter, days before I quit Twitter in disgust (years too late, I suppose), and—perhaps in a perverse bit of closure for this running bit in my YSC ghost rivalry with Hyden—Joe from Philadelphia had his third Ask a Music Critic question answered. Take a break from this too-long blog post and read the question(s) and the answer(s).

Not sure there's much else to say in this regard, besides that maybe it's finally a good time to give Pure Comedy another shot. And also, I think I am taking this as my cue to have more grace for musicians at this time. Grace for those who are choosing to not take a political position, since I am all of a sudden saying that I too will not be publicly taking a position for a while, and so now I see the lane for empathy that opens up in that regard. But grace, too, for the musicians who choose to make an absolutely terrible fucking song about how Orange Man Is Bad. I understand the urge to do something, fucking anything, and I understand why doing nothing seems like you are failing yourself. I truly do get it. It feels like a coward's move.

But I'm asking you to have some grace for me, the humble blogger, who will not, I promise you now, beat you over the head about this point from this point forward, especially since that would be counterintuitive to what I'm trying to achieve here. If I continue to squawk about how I need to shut up, well, then I'm not actually shutting up, am I? And so this is it. I promise. You wanna talk about this with me from here on out, then we can meet up in person, possibly in the shadows. Because that's where we're gonna need to start from when the shit really starts raining down.

8 comments:

Zach said...

Couldn't agree more about the dumb songs.

Nate said...

Sounds good, looking forward to reading more on this tomorrow.

Joe K said...

Hey Nate Dogg, what's your gym routine??????

brocarthy said...

you have more in common with a "third party voter" than a maga cousin so lumping the two together is unfair to say the least. it's good to be frustrated, and it's nice to know where people stand, so keep those fingertips nice and calloused and keep typing :) also check this out https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xo1VInw-SKc

Joe K said...

I get what you're trying to saying, and I appreciate you taking me to task for what I wrote. But I think I was speaking less ideologically (which, yeah, I could probably find candidates closer to where I am on the far left, far from Kamala Harris), and more realistically (voting for anyone but Harris was a vote for trump, and if I can't trust third party voters to know that, then I cannot trust them when the shit hits the fan).

brocarthy said...

i didn't vote for kamala i didn't vote for trump i wrote you in and included the URL

Joe K said...

Only 100k more votes and we could've tied the brain worm guy.

Anonymous said...

im anonymous :)