Saturday, November 16, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 160: Allison

Prompt: "Your least favorite holiday song, played waaaaay too early in the year"

Selected by Allison


"God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen"
Pentatonix
A Pentatonix Christmas, 2016

God, I hate Pentatonix. It's surprising, given my fondness for a cappella music in middle and high school; maybe it's an overcorrection. This thing I used to like is now popular; I guess I can't like it anymore. I don't know why I'm like that, but I can't fucking stand them.

I'm not one of those over-eager Christmas people. I like to put my tree up and watch Muppet Christmas Carol, but there is a time and a place. Christmas starts after Thanksgiving. That's the way it's always been. For years, my Aunt Louise would host family dinners. My dad's oldest sister, the matriarch in training. Her kitchen, renovated in the '80s and never again, would be flush with humidity from the massive turkey meant to feed a small army. Once the appetizers were picked over and the kitchen overcrowded, the cousins would retreat outside, regardless of the temperature, to throw a football around, practice wrestling moves, or sneak a sneaky cigarette.

For all the time and effort she put into the meal, meant to be the main event, it was just a hurdle on the way to dessert. Kind of bland, kind of beige; standard Thanksgiving fare. I didn't know mac and cheese could belong on a Thanksgiving table until I met my husband's family.  

After dinner, the aunts would clear the table, and grandma would hold court in the dining room over coffee and pie. The kids would gorge themselves on Louise's famous butter cookies and pile into the den to watch National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation. Fifteen cousins and a handful of unhelpful uncles vying for a space to sprawl out. Overlapping on the couch, two to a recliner, the carpeted floor littered with pillows and food-drunk family. Year after year, this tradition held strong. This was the demarcation between Thanksgiving and Christmas. Once the movie was on, it was officially Christmas. We could have played the movie on mute. "WHY is the carpet all wet, Todd?" "I don't KNOW, Margo!"

I don't know if I miss it. It was fun but always loud, chaotic, and overwhelming. As we got older, the rifts got wider. I haven't talked to some of my cousins in years. I remember them as kids, but I don't know them as adults. And I would not be friends with the ones I do know as adults. There are close to fifteen second cousins now; we've nearly doubled our ranks. Aunt Louise's house hasn't been able to fit us all in at least ten years. My dad says the house is falling apart. She's 74. I should visit.

Thanksgiving will be spent at home this year—just the two of us and the dog. Everyone else's family is growing, but I feel mine shrinking. Maybe I'll bake a batch of butter cookies and see what nostalgia tastes like.

1 comment:

Joe K said...

Thanks for writing this. I have similarly mixed feelings about the cousins I no longer see all that much of, so it's nice to hear I'm not the only one.

The opposite of thanks for choosing this song, which, I'm sorry to report, is sung by the Whos in the 2018 animated Grinch remake, and I'm just being told now that it's Pentatonix who voice those Whos.