I've never seen a full episode of Lizzie McGuire but it's not really that hard to imagine what a typical one might entail. Hilary Duff as Lizzie, everygirl, dealing with the low-stakes drama that your average middle-schooler might empathize with. Gordo, her male best friend who eventual flowers into a love interest, a half step after the hormones kick in, when it occurs to the young protagonist teen that looks aren't everything, that it's what on the inside that counts, that the goofy-ass ugly-ass motherfucker you've been palling around with your whole life might also be boyfriend material, weirdly. Miranda, the best friend, who has her own interests but those are always adjacent to the protagonist's interests, with an alternative look to differentiate her from the everygirl protagonist, and she's kinda quirky but also cool too, in ways that complement the main star. A little brother, an ugly little annoying shit who eventually becomes more of a friendly rival then a villain, and as they get older, they understand that the sibling bond is deep, no matter what the age and gender differences do to keep them apart on a social level. Lizzie's parents, the level-headed mom, the good-hearted but embarrassingly lame dad. Probably a pet somewhere in there, one that doesn't require a significant budget for animal trainers on set, like an iguana or hamster or something. And there's a cartoon Lizzie too, and she's acting as the internal monologue, expressing in words what would otherwise be implied in an adult TV series, a voice for the kids watching who might feel voiceless at that age. Each week, minor conflict. Lizzie wants something, she is hamstrung by circumstances, she learns a lesson, and knows at the end of those 22 minutes what she actually wants, which is just slightly different than what she desired at the beginning, but in a significant way, in a way that shows that she's grown. I assume Miranda talks some sense into her, Gordo adds his offbeat two cents, the little brother causes a commotion that intersects with Lizzie's plot in a way that involves dramatic irony, the mom imparts a lesson, the dad does something silly that makes Lizzie glad she at the very least knows what's cool and what's not, and the hamster is there, spinning its little hamster wheel all the while.
Haven't thought about this show in a hot minute. It didn't take up too much headspace for me as a teenager either. I was graduating eighth grade when the movie came out, so I was around the right age, but like I said, I've never seen an episode. I will say that in high school, I heard more than once that I looked like Gordo. Having not seen the show, nor having the understanding of Disney Channel Original Series and the tropes that they'd traffic in, I never knew whether to take that as a compliment or as an insult. I think in retrospect, it was probably a compliment couched in an insult (emotions being like Russian nesting dolls, back when you're a teen). Like in a playful "ha ha I think this boy is cute but I don't know how to say it without sounding like an embarrassment so I'm going to tease him instead" sort of way. For the record, I don't think Gordo is an attractive person, but I say that as a heterosexual man, and I acknowledge that it's probably a self-hatred thing. You tell me. I think it was the dumb fucking hair, maybe?
Clearly my mind is in this headspace because this album, Hilary Duff's 2003 album Metamorphosis, is written for middle-schoolers. It is exactly what it's supposed to be. It is empty, it is slick, it is catchy as fuck, it is shallow, it is immature but strains to give the impression of maturity, it is sexless but doles out tiny little hints of sexiness that its intended audience would experience for themselves in the years ahead. This is not meant for a 35-year-old adult. Doesn't mean I can't put myself in someone else's shoes and see how it might feel if I wasn't me and it wasn't right now. Reviewing music that isn't meant for you is an exercise in empathy. Yes, I remember what it was like, back then.
Most importantly, I think, Metamorphosis is a product of a known face. This isn't just a shiny pop rock album from any ol' pretty anonymity. This is Hilary fucking Duff. I have literally never seen anything that she's ever been in (besides a bit role in one single episode of Community, I forgot about that), but I know who she is even still, and I understand why this album would be appealing to someone who loves this chick. I think she's a pretty bad singer. I have a feeling she's a pretty bad actor. I don't think any of that matters. She is a product on Metamorphosis, and she sells herself extremely well. A pretty bad album, overall, but gosh, is it memorable. Sometimes, that's all that matters.
It is, of course, catchy. Very catchy. If I was writing this album review in middle school, maybe there's a good chance that this would be the thesis of my review: it's catchy. It's catchy because it's designed in a lab to be catchy. Some fucking ugly dude is like "hey I have some hooks and I've made them into songs" and the songs are good enough that some other ugly dude is like "maybe we should get you in a room with Hilary Duff, because she is popular and well-known and if you work her really, really hard then maybe we can get a couple vocal takes out of her that don't sound like fucking dogshit." And so they make the album, the album that wouldn't exist if the songs weren't catchy to begin with. That's the whole goddamn point. This isn't something to celebrate. It's the baseline. Catchiness is the baseline. That doesn't make it special.
But it's catchy. I'd be a liar if I said that there weren't multiple choruses from this album stuck in my head throughout the week. For posterity's sake, I'll point out that "The Math" was my favorite, both in terms of catchiness and in terms of a specific appeal to me, a middle-schooler in a 35-year-old man's body, the knowing that the line "I am calling you back / This is star 69" was written to connect to the immature among us who hear that number and just let their minds go fucking bugnuts with possibility. 69!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
But I get it. It's catchy because it's supposed to be. It's literally impossible for you to find an album like this that isn't catchy. That's the fucking point. If we were listening to an album from a non-singer that didn't have catchy songs, we'd be like, well, what the fuck is the point?! It exists for this reason alone. We're listening to this stupid immature album from some has-been because it is CATCHY. I am not surprised. How could you be? C'mon. That would be like shooting up heroin and being surprised that it's addictive. That would be like, I dunno, listening to an album from the sister of a has-been and being surprised that it too is very catchy. Wait, we're already doing that? No. Let us learn from the mistakes of the past. Let us acknowledge that Metamorphosis is catchy, but let's not act like its catchiness makes it a worthy endeavor.
But I get it. It's catchy because it's supposed to be. It's literally impossible for you to find an album like this that isn't catchy. That's the fucking point. If we were listening to an album from a non-singer that didn't have catchy songs, we'd be like, well, what the fuck is the point?! It exists for this reason alone. We're listening to this stupid immature album from some has-been because it is CATCHY. I am not surprised. How could you be? C'mon. That would be like shooting up heroin and being surprised that it's addictive. That would be like, I dunno, listening to an album from the sister of a has-been and being surprised that it too is very catchy. Wait, we're already doing that? No. Let us learn from the mistakes of the past. Let us acknowledge that Metamorphosis is catchy, but let's not act like its catchiness makes it a worthy endeavor.
The little Gordo in me would have been so totally confused by this. I would've either completely dismissed it because it "wasn't cool" or I would have lacquered my appreciation in irony, so taken aback would I have been by the catchiness in the face of the total lack of coolness. I'm not Gordo anymore. I've gotten a haircut, and I am no longer confused when a girl says something ironically nice to me. I'm not Gordo and I know exactly where I stand with Lizzie McGuire I mean Hilary Duff. It's catchy. It's supposed to be. It's not for me.
And I'm assuming that the TV show is not worth watching at this point either, but that's for another day.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment