Tuesday, November 26, 2024

Never Seen It, #177 of 200: The Tree of Life

"Where were you when I laid the foundations of the Earth, when the morning stars sang together, when I watched 200 movies I've never seen before, and all the sons of God shouted for joy?" —Job 38:4,7


The Tree of Life
2011
Terrence Malick

Consummate Never Seen It shaman Frank is back to trade a few questions back and forth yours truly. We each sent three questions to one another, and then separately answered them. I've spliced up our emails and pasted them below.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

JOE: How do we feel about the big gambit of including the big bang, asteroids, protozoa, dinosaurs, all kinds of primordial shit at the beginning of this film? I imagine that it's polarizing. On the one hand, it underlines the epic nature of the film—it's not just the story of one family, but it's the story of EVERYTHING. On the other hand, could you make the same movie and have it start at the birth of the O'Briens' first child? Maybe. Or maybe it wouldn't be as memorable. Tell me your thoughts on this.

FRANK: I think it HAS to be about everything. Of course, it could start with the baby being born, and just be about a small family but I think it would change the answer to the three central questions of the movie: A) Mr. O'Brien's questioning why he isn't more important / more able to use his real talents and interests, B) Mrs. O'Brien's questions of why God would allow R.L to die, and C) Jack questioning the point of existence. The movie provides a massive answer that I think is impressive in its optimism. It is easy to feel unimportant when considering the vast history and expansion of the cosmos: the millions of years that come before us, the millions that come after. In the long run, our existence is insignificant. I think the movie is saying isn't it incredible that with all that insignificance, we can matter so much? We matter in the immediate, as crucial cogs of history, part of a larger tapestry. Death and pain and extinction are part of it, but so are small moments of joy and grace. What a miracle to be alive.



FRANK: Similar to your first question: What do you think this movie is about? WHY does it need to be (if it does need to be) the story of Everything?

JOE: The most striking moments for me were the long scenes that were content to just follow these young boys causing trouble. From the wrong light, one might view those scenes as padding. Sure, eventually Jack acts out and gets in trouble with mom and that causes conflict with his father who wasn't around to punish him, etc. But I liked it because it felt innocent. Just little fucking kids, fucking around in the suburbs. But the camera was also content, during those moments, to linger on Jack's face, and he always had this look that was almost... confused? Like he knew something else was happening here, past the shit talk and rocks through windows.

It was clear that he, in those moments, felt that something IMPORTANT was happening, even though he was too young to understand that feeling or put it in words. I would normally be quick to say something along the lines of "he's thinking about how when he gets older, it won't be like this," but in this specific film, it's more than that. It's—as you've said before—that everything has led up to this moment. Everything that's ever happened resulted in this. Even if "this" is a bunch of kids fucking around, it's still true. And even if "this" eventually means that his brother dies, maybe then it's more important than ever. The immense weight of history presses down upon every random-ass occurrence in our lives. Through that we find meaning, even if we can't say what that meaning is out loud.

If I had to guess, I'd say that's what the movie is about. Though, again, that's probably just my own interests filtering the movie to suit my needs, which doesn't make it true for anyone else.



JOE: This felt pretty unique stylistically. I don't have the film knowledge to be able to give names to what they were doing here, but I noticed a lot of film shakiness (handheld cameras, I guess), and a LOT of quick cuts. Like, sometimes we'd be close up on Jack's face, and it would technically cut, but it would cut away to that same face, just from a slightly different angle. And then, of course, all the cuts to the beauty of the universe, just so, so many. Not sure if you saw the first episode of Season 3 of The Bear, but my immediate thought it that the episode drew a lot stylistically from Tree of Life.

FRANK: I think that different directors have different strengths, and Terrence Malick's is how he seems to almost view movies as paintings. He is definitely more interested in how the movie looks and how camera movements make us feel than narrative clarity. This is the most polarizing part of his work, because sometimes the plot and characterizations can get lost under the weight of his art, but when it works, it elicits emotions and conversation, which is what he wants. He clearly is an intense guy (he went twenty years in between making movies at one point), but worth it. If you liked this, check out Days of Heaven by him too. 

And I absolutely see some of that "use the camera cuts to generate emotions" in The Bear, which rocks.



FRANK: Is Sean Penn good in this?

JOE: Something interesting and kinda perplexing that I found in looking through the Wikipedia page for this film was that there is an alternate cut to this film that features a lot more of Sean Penn and his wife and sidepiece and teenage son? This is the "Extended Edition," and I suppose I saw the "Theatrical Edition." "Malick maintains that the theatrical edition is the official director's cut" says Wikipedia as well, so I'm not too cut up about it. I saw the official version. But it's strange to think that someone is watching this film and walking away with questions about Sean Penn, since I walked away thinking he was kind of a nothing of a character. I'm assuming by your question that you saw the Extended Edition.

In attempt to answer your question, I guess the scene that I remember is the shaky scene where he (Jack) is apparently speaking to his dad on the phone, and it's about his brother dying. And this scene is happening decades later, so that informs us about the father character, and how he never really got over his son's death, maybe even to his other sons' detriment. Jack says something like "yeah, dad, I think about him every day!", and that reaction read as sincere and well-acted by Sean Penn. Just that mix of frustration, sadness, and sincerity, it was well-handled.

But that's really all I remember, beyond Sean Penn wandering around looking tired and lost. I can't ask you the same question due to the limitations of this chosen blogging format, but maybe you (Frank) can hop in the comments and tell me about the Extended Edition. 



FRANK: The reason why I wanted to talk with you about this is because this movie made me really think about breaking away from not just the binary of "was this movie good/bad," but also the binary of "did I like this movie / not like it." Saying I liked this movie wouldn't accurately describe it. Saying I didn't like it wouldn't either. I struggled with this movie, and it has stuck in my craw. I think it changed my perspective of what movies can be. And for a movie that I don't think hit me in the heart on first viewing, it's bizarre how often I think about it. Do you have thoughts on widening the spectrum/vocabulary on how we talk about movies?

JOE: Do I have THOUGHTS? Oh boy, do I have the perfect blog to show you. My thoughts, since you asked are: yeah, sure, the binary sucks. It sucks because it's limiting. Too many people are out there just saying "good movie" or "bad movie" and being content with that. There needs to be a WHY. Why was it good? And then, my favorite tertiary question: what does the "why" say about you? Everyone is unique, everyone can have a different experience with a movie, as it is filtered through their own experience. Looks like Ebert had a good time with this one because he saw childhood self in the young characters on the screen in that particular Texan small town. The reason those WHYs are important is that, eventually, you can disregard the good/bad and just focus on the why. "It is good in some ways and bad in other ways, but I feel THIS way about the film and here is WHY." People who don't do this are too afraid to examine the self, or maybe just don't know how.

So okay, practicing what I preach. Did I like this film? Yes, I did. WHY? It felt big. It felt extra. Like, the extended sequence about the beginning of the universe, complete with dinosaur fable by the creekside? Incredible. Unnecessary and incredible. Incredible because it's unnecessary. I am a fan of "doing extra." I am the type of person to think that really fucking going for it and doing extra is a ballsy pursuit, and elevates the art. But that's just me. What does that say about me? I don't know. That I get bored easily? Which is a flaw, but it's a flaw I acknowledge, and actively work to address, e.g. through Never Seen It, and watching provocative films.



JOE: I get the feeling that there was a lot of PHILOSOPHY happening in this film that I didn't completely pick up on, and I'll be excited to read about that and hear your thoughts. E.g. a lot of what the mom was whispering into the cosmos felt like it was out of my reach. At the same time, I thought that maybe the parts of the story spent here on the ground (and not in the stars) was poignant enough that I appreciated it even without knowing what religion they practiced or whatever. Like: man, I have a lot of thoughts about the parenting styles presented here! I guess that's the burden of being a parent, watching a film about parents.

FRANK: I too feel like the grounded parts are relatable. It's like philosophy (see my previous answer) is there, but philosophy is theoretical. Living is practical. The crux of the movie I THINK is two parents with different viewpoints on how to make life good for their children, a very relatable adult child who has struggled with both styles and how it's affected his adulthood, and also making peace with your parents as humans that were trying their best. I don't think it is letting parents off the hook for the abuses they put on us, or not holding them accountable. It's viewing them as people too. I think the ending is him forgiving his parents. I think it's crucial also to know that Terrence Malick's brother allegedly committed suicide after feeling like he didn't live up to his parents' expectations of excellence. So this movie is personal.



JOE: BONUS: Let us give Sunny his due for including a reference to this movie in his post today, as an obvious attempt to get mentioned in the Tree of Life PoYB post.

FRANK: Sunny is a scholar and a gentleman. No notes.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

JOE'S GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Everything in human history has led to the moment that I start watching Three Men and a Baby.

1 comment:

Frank said...

I don't think I've seen the extended edition either. I guess I asked the question in bad faith. He may have been asked to do a ton more and then it all hit the cutting room floor, something Malick is notorious for. (The Thin Red Line originally had Adrien Brody as the lead in the script, and he showed up to the premiere and discovered while watching the movie his part had been cut in the editing room). In my head you can get anyone to walk around and look tired, why use Sean Penn? Jessica Chastain and Brad Pitt are very good in this, and it jarred me how little Sean Penn was used and got second billing. Give the kids top billing!! But that's not how Hollywood works. None of this is actually Sean Penn's fault. It's my own personal voice saying "why is he in this?!"