Wednesday, November 20, 2024

Song of the Evening: "Impossible Soul"

I promised you, about a year and a half ago, that I would make sure that PoYB had at least two blog posts every weekday, Monday through Friday, and I intend to hold to that promise as long as I possibly can. But so now I'm on the bus home on Wednesday afternoon and realizing that I only had one for today, so here's an emergency post that I wrote on my phone. I will publish as soon as I can when I get home. Check out the rest of the Songs of the Whatever HERE.


"Impossible Soul"
Sufjan Stevens
from The Age of Adz
2010

The question of "favorite song" is so subjective that it's almost not even worth asking. If you got 100 people together and asked them to list their top 100 songs of all time, you'd probably get around 10,000 different songs. A favorite song is more reflective of the listener than the artist, and every listener is different. If I ever decide to stupidly and for no good reason whatsoever get together my own personal list of Top 100 Songs All Time, I really how I don't forget "Impossible Soul."

Because it's such an interesting test subject! All 25 minutes of this behemoth are worth your time, but if you divide it up into its (possibly) intended five sections, you get almost five entirely separate songs. And then, if that middle song is the best song of all time, and the two songs on either side are like B+ for your average artist and like B- for Sufjan Stevens, then what? Where do you put the song on your list? (Again, assuming you remember it at all.)

I think the "it's not so impossible!" middle section sincerely is my favorite piece of music that's ever existed, even if I can't technically call it a "song" due to the circumstances. It's such an explosive mix of bombast and heart, a treatise on life and love that also sounds like the romantic climax scene in a grand sci-fi space epic. If I were to ever get a tattoo of a lyric, "In the right light / it's a miracle" might be in the running.

But anyone who even suggests to me that I remove this section of the song from the rest of "Impossible Soul" so that I can listen to it in isolation should be locked up on felony charges. A crime against art! I will sacrifice its placement atop a theoretical Top 100 Songs list if it means being honest and true with my engagement with art. The honesty is more important than the hosannas.

So who knows where "Impossible Soul" would end up on such a list, were I ever to make one. Who knows if I'd even remember it at all. Since I am, in fact, a moron.

3 comments:

Zach said...

I love Sufjan, but when I say I love Sufjan, I really mean I love Illinois and I love Michigan and I kind of like Carrie & Lowell. Listening to this makes me realize there's a whole trove of Sufjan material I haven't yet experienced that is just waiting for me, and that's awesome. This song is wild and great.

Zach said...

theoretical

Joe K said...

Ya caught me!

Check out the All Delighted People EP (at 59 minutes, only nominally an EP) if you want a stepping stone from his folky stuff to the electro freakouts of The Age of Adz.