Wednesday, January 31, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge Monthly Roundup: JANUARY 2024


This is Joe with some thoughts about the songs and the write-ups and the general experience of Yearlong Song Challenge in its first month.
 
—We had 26 different writers participate in YSC throughout the month. Sixteen people submitted a song for every single prompt. Seven people either missed a few or dropped out at some point. Three more people joined us for a quick one-off appearance (Dave, Stephan, and Josh Terry... I'm not including Robot John Lennon in this count). Participation has been even better than I could've ever imagined when this thing was cooked up, so thanks to all those who are here and who are listening and writing and responding.

—Hopefully everyone is cool with the "late submissions" system we have going here. The worst part about Summer Song Challenge last year was having to retroactively post late songs and then edit everything else in kind (the playlists, the landing page's list, etc.). Pain in the ass, especially since all of that was usually happening during my work day, and I couldn't always get to it in a timely manner. I like it a lot better to just tack 'em on at the beginning of the following prompt day's list, and then shove 'em on a list down at the bottom of the landing page. Has this encouraged people to be more timely with their submissions? I have no idea. But it's working for me to have a strict deadline, and hopefully it's working for you.

—I had intended Day 1's prompt, "starting over," to be about starting over on a new blog project. But I love how most of the entries were about starting over in the new year. I mean, that totally makes more sense, and I feel stupid for not even thinking about it that way until the day had arrived. Lots of great, heartfelt write-ups on Day 1 (a little further down in this blog post, I will try to highlight some of the best write-ups we've had so far).

—And I loved the idea of setting expectations right at the beginning with the string of "best song" ---> "worst song" ---> "song in between." It gives everyone a good sense of each author's individual sensibilities, as it allows for easy comparison to your own tastes. From my vantage point, there were a few "worst songs" that were better than that author's "best song." There were even more "in-between songs" that fell outside the range set by that author's best and worst. For a few of 'em, the "in-between" was a lot closer to "best," and for others, the "in-between" was A LOT closer to "worst." Not that my opinion means fucking anything to anyone except me; I'm just saying that I was personally able to regulate my own expectations about certain participators' song choices. E.g. if someone whose best and worst and in-between songs were all pretty bad (in my opinion), then the day they choose a GREAT song is gonna feel even better than it would have otherwise.
 
—I'm trying to hold back on commenting A LOT on these posts. I mean, I know I comment a good amount, but this is me holding back. I could comment "this song is great" and "this song fucking blows" on most of the posts, but my thinking is that I should save most of those opinions for these monthly write-ups (yes, further down on this post I will also list some of my favorite and least favorite songs).
 
—I thought about making a map for all the geographical locations for Day 5, but I'm too lazy for that. Everyone nailed the task, though. All geographical points, no mistakes. There weren't even any repeats! Though Detroit is in Michigan, and Point Breeze is in Philadelphia, and Strawberry Fields is in London (but not South London, and not in London at all if you're considering it to be the NY Strawberry Fields memorial).
 
—But I'm saying "repeats" there in a lighthearted way there. Having repeat songs on the same day is always pretty funny, and more of a mark of my uncreative prompts than anything else (though that Billy Ocean repeat on Day 6 was pretty wild and unlikely!). In this case, it would've been even funnier to have the same geographical locations but for different songs. In my mind, such coincidences are a sign that music is fun and special and it's all connected, baby.
 
—There haven't been any repeats of songs on different days, however, and I'd argue that that is a good thing. In fact, I'm not going to allow it. Despite what Erin argued, there ARE enough songs that you could easily fit 3000 unique songs into this Song Challenge throughout the year. If you send me a song that has already been chosen and published, then I will not accept it. (The important distinction here is "chosen and published." There is a repeat coming up on Saturday, but its author sent me the email before the write-up for the repeated song was published. Some people are working well in advance, there's nothing we can do about that.)

—Also, I've said this to a few people individually already, but it bears repeating: I am not the judge and jury of song choices. Yes, I obviously have opinions about which songs are "correct" and which songs are "incorrect" for certain prompts, but as editor, I will NEVER tell you "you can't do this because it doesn't follow the prompt." It's all up to individual interpretation. Now, I might tell you my opinion after you publish it, but that's a different story.

—So have there been any so far that haven't done exactly what the prompt asked them to do (according to my own opinion and no one else's)? Absolutely. Day 6's "non-geographical location" was a good showcase for prompts that are clearly defined but that I have opinions about anyway. I thought that the prompts answers of "yesterday" and "block list" were iffy, and I think I'd ultimately argue that they did not fit the prompt. Those are more, like, figurative locations than actual locations. Other ones I had to think about but ultimately agreed with: "hell" (also fictional, but definitely a place), "ceiling fan" (more of an item, but the title indicates that something is in it, and so it's a location), "under the sun" (feels kinda broad but technically works), or "the bathroom window" (she came through it, so it's a location).

—Now something like Day 7's "first song you ever heard" is practically impossible to actually get the correct answer for, so it was one of those days when neither I nor anyone else would have any right or reason to say "this doesn't meet the prompt criteria." In fact, it's the opposite—because the prompt is more or less impossible, what do you, as the author, do about it? So it was cool seeing the different directions that people took with it.

—I'm kinda shocked that Day 8's "last song an artist made before dying" prompt didn't result in any repeat songs. Thought for sure we'd get like seven Notorious B.I.G. songs or something. Only one repeat artist, David Bowie, and the folks who chose that artist picked different songs. Which I guess technically means that one of those songs is incorrect, right? Not necessarily! What song Bowie actually worked on last might not be any one song. Maybe he was pecking away at a bunch of songs off of Blackstar toward the end of the recording sessions. Only David Bowie knows, and he is dead.

—I liked Sara's observation about Day 9's "cigarettes": "All I’ve gathered from todays YSC prompt is that smoking is cool." See, this is another reason I love this project. It turns up some interesting sociological truths that we would have never known otherwise. Are cigarettes actually cool? Probably not. But isn't it fascinating that so many people wrote about them being cool?

—As to the "wrong" song choice on Day 10 ("no letters")—I have no doubt that the chooser of "867-5309/Jenny" by Tommy Tutone had no idea that the word "Jenny" was an official part of the title. I have no qualms about adding the official title to the write-ups even if that means it's made clear that the song was chosen incorrectly. I am committed to getting the spelling and grammar and capitalization of these titles correct, even at the risk of calling someone out for making a mistake. (Did I quadruple-check it before I hit "publish" because of that? Absolutely.)

—A full list of crushes from Day 11: Aaron Cohen, Lauren, a fictional "Ash," Patrick Luccini, Arthur Fonzarelli, the girl who accompanied Mr. Best Legs, Kyle, Kristen Kreuk, the Ambler dance partner, Adam (possibly Adam Klein?), New Life Glenside Church girl, Abington MySpace girl, Laura, Jared Jackson, Not Jim Cherry, and Brian.

—At least four songs on Day 12 that aren't technically "title tracks." I would define a "title track" to be a song that has the exact same title as the album itself. So "Norman Fucking Rockwell" (album title has an exclamation point, song doesn't), "Welcome to the Black Parade" (album is just The Black Parade), and "YAK" (album title is YAK: A Collection of Truck Songs) would all probably be described as a "quasi-title track," if I were describing them in a review or whatever. And, of course, "Can You Feel My Heart" by Bring Me the Horizon is definitively not the title track to their album Sempiternal.

—I will publish anything (within reason), even political shit that I don't believe (though expect me to then meet you in the comment section). But let's just go ahead and say that I give my full approval to anyone who wants to disparage or criticize antivaxxers, especially but not limited to those who are running for president.

—I laughed at a lot of Day 13's prompt responses. Good work, everyone. Though I am curious as to whether there are any songs here that really are actually about sex, and the artist has just never articulated their "true intentions." E.g. Gilson might be on to something that "Da Biggest Bird" was legitimately about having a huge dick. But how could we know for sure? That matter is between SAINT MERCAT∅R and his god.

—Shoutout to Nate for sticking with his restrictive "only songs from 2020-2024" gambit. I'll be interested in how he deals with some of the really specific prompts, and whether he manages to sidestep them like he did with the "first song you ever heard" prompt. (P.S. We're all still waiting for Big Eddie to make another appearance in the text! Don't leave the Peaquadrophenia fans hanging!!)

—In general, I appreciate how the prompts, and the Yearlong Song Challenge itself, manages to make bad songs bearable or interesting. Day 14 had a few songs that we're just really fucking bad. That was by design! Those songs fit the prompt, because the author literally had just heard the song! So, e.g., would I have listened to the obviously fabricated sounds of Tate McRae's voice outside of this context? No (not even because the video is almost inappropriately hot). But here I am, laughing at the absurdity of cookie-cutter pop, and enjoying it in the moment, because of YSC.

—My rule is that if I am really excited for an upcoming album release, then I will actively avoid all the advanced singles for that album. Hence why I did not listen to that new Waxahatchee song, despite Maeve picking it for Day 14. I'm sure it's incredible though.

—Hope you have all enjoyed the blog-standard practice of making the "artist" the character name if the song is sung by a fictional person, say in a movie or play. Read my reasoning HERE.

—Most featured artist: Taylor Swift (5) and Simon & Garfunkel (4, but with more upcoming). I like Taylor Swift's music, and I mostly tolerate the obligatory discourse surrounding it. But I fucking despise Simon & Garfunkel.

SONG CHALLENGE MOVIE CLUB:
  • Jesus Christ Superstar
  • The Family Stone
  • Jacob's Ladder
  • The Royal Tenenbaums
  • Encanto
  • Cinderella
  • The Lion King
  • All Quiet on the Western Front
  • Shrek
  • Mary Poppins
  • Oppenheimer
  • It Follows
  • Homecoming

ALBUMS I DOWNLOADED OR AM GOING TO DOWNLOAD SOON BECAUSE OF SONG CHALLENGE

(In other words, these are the albums I'm not familiar with but that I'm interested in exploring more of, directly because of a song choice or a write-up or both. This is an important function of Song Challenge for me! Thank you to all those who gave me the recommendation!) (Also: some of the albums connected to the songs chosen are coincidentally upcoming for my Year of Blind Spots project. Those albums are not included here.)
  • Cloud Nine by George Harrison (Beth, Day 4)
  • Very Emergency by the Promise Ring (Gilson, Day 5)
  • Hounds Tooth EP by Dope Lemon (Brianna, Day 6)
  • Stay Where You Are by Saves the Day (Rachel, Day 6)
  • Give the People What They Want by Sharon Jones & the Dap-Kings (Allison, Day 8)
  • The Soul Album by Otis Redding (Bob, Day 9)
  • Dial M for Meds by Taking Meds (Nate, Day 9)
  • Crime in Stereo Is Dead by Crime in Stereo (Nick, Day 9)

SONGS I'M GOING TO DOWNLOAD SEPARATELY

(They were really good songs, but I'm not really interested in exploring the album their from, through no fault of the person who picked them of course.)
  • "Detroit Vs. Everybody" by Eminem et al.
  • "I Believe in a Thing Called Love" by the Darkness
  • "Einstein on the Beach" by Counting Crows
  • "Save Me" by Remy Zero
  • "Walking on Thin Ice" by Yoko Ono

BEST SONGS (THAT I WAS ALREADY FAMILIAR WITH)

(Also, should go without saying that the songs that I personally chose are disqualified from this list.)

WORST SONGS

(Obviously, some prompts call for a bad song. So, for many reasons, the songs aren't on this list because of anything the writer of the blog post did. Let us separate the song from the reason the song was chosen, and let us separate the song from otherwise excellent write-ups for that song. These are just bad fucking songs, period.)
 
The best write-up from each individual contributor (minimum five on-time submissions), along with a brief quote from each:
 
Bob — Religious experiences on Day 6: "It's important in life to be a part of something. To be involved. To be in a group, and that's why I get it. I get why religion pulls in so many  people."

Pat — Coining the now-PoYB-canon phrase "human laryngectomy" on Day 12: "What is to be gleaned from this? Dicky Barrett went from reasonably progressive in the mid-'90s to thinking Pfizer was out to kill him thirty years later. Is fame and wealth the ultimate corrupter? Or is this a case of diagonalism, a combining of left-wing and right-wing beliefs in which Barrett honestly believes all human beings are worthy of respect and therefore cannot be forced to consent to vaccines?"

Nate — A contemplation about death on Day 8: "None of it a complete composite of a person, all of it a fragment that becomes more valuable and rare than diamond. To have an entire recorded discography to leave behind is both a strong tab at immortality and a Monkey's Paw blessing for those who loved you. You can always visit your friend, but only as they were, never as they'll be."

Nick — Re: smoking on Day 9: "I don't think I've ever actually expressed that feeling before, either. Life is weird, and often needlessly hard to understand."

Brianna — On how youth's experiences can shape the present day, on Day 5: "From lessons learned from mistakes or from friends no longer present, to the things that brought you joy once upon a time, our youth is a beautiful guidebook to our next chapter in life. Whether it's South London or Philadelphia, I think we should all find a place from time to time to read it."

Rachel S. — I guess I didn't comment on the post about this, but I meant to, how this Day 4 write-up made me realize that Taylor Swift might be talking about substance abuse and sobriety in this song. Or maybe I'm just projecting. Still, the write-up made me really appreciate this song: "And you won't even notice it... but the best day is a few days later when it hits you. That feeling of realizing you've forgotten someone after they once held all your time and thoughts."

Allison — On the idea of a "place," Day 6: "The location may still exist in a physical sense. The acquaintances, friends, lovers may still have a presence in your life. In theory, you could visit that place together again, but you're not the same. They are not the same. You can never go back."

Boober — Much appreciated emotional vulnerability on the blog, Day 10: "I did my normal nightly routine and put my headphones on and this song came on some random playlist I was listening to and I sat on my couch, just me and my dogs. And I sat there taking in the views of a once loud, bustling, loving family home, and felt like a failure."

Beth — An astute psychological observation on Day 9: "This guy was a real strange dude, but he was also extremely hot and had great taste in music, so a win is a win I guess? I don't think he ever had to fully develop a personality because of these things, but I benefited from them so I can't really complain. To be honest, I sometimes used to randomly text him just for music recommendations after the fact."

Bridget — Proving the haters wrong before they even have a chance to protest, on Day 3: "You might be saying, wow Bridge, one of your best songs is Flo Rida, but your worst is a DJ remix that could be played back-to-back but hey, to me there is a huge difference. This song is a wannabe club banger that's primary goal is to be played while frat boys order bottle service using their dad's Amex. I actively want to go the rest of my life without hearing this stupid bad dumb song."

Maeve — Leaning on Song Challenge to aid in some change at the start of the New Year, Day 1: "It's not great, and leaning in allows it to become a self-fulfilling prophecy. I feel like my flame has been blown out, that I haven't been myself for months. Wow, depression, man. The point of this being that I'm really working on everything. It's not necessarily a New Year's resolution, but I'm really going to try and be a better person, have a better attitude and outlook, just overall, focusing on change."

Sunny — Using nostalgic to solidly defend and otherwise indefensible song, Day 4: "Is it fun or catchy? Yes, sort of, the 'SAIL!' hook is fun to shout. I have fond memories of b-school where me and my merry pranksters would yell this during parties both to annoy others and as a round-up call sign. Good times."

Pam — The sound of Pam breaking free from all creative limitations and really going for it, Day 9: "Hey, remember that time when we would only drink bacardi razz? Hey, remember that time when we would only drink at vodka from water bottles? Hey, remember that time when we would only drink franzia? Hey, remember that time when 40s of malt liquor were the cheapest? Hurricane. Hurricane."

Jeanine — I enjoyed a lot of the cutting cynicism employed by Jeanine so far, but here is the line that sticks with me, from Day 1: "I have always believed if you want or need to make a change in your life, you should just do it. I understand starting 'fresh' in a 'new year,' but hear me out—how about starting fresh at 5 PM on a Wednesday in June?"

Laura — A tale of love and loss from the first crush, Day 11: "Nothing was ever official, and things fizzled out when I went to college, but we still got together here and there. My crush finally came to an end a year or two into college after not seeing each other for awhile, busying myself with college things, and meeting tons of new people. But as Fall Out Boy would say, 'Thanks for memories.'"

Gilson — I really felt the uplifting and yet realistic message here at the start, Day 1: "Every single day is a battle with myself to not pick up a drink that day. Some days float by, and some days are more of a conscious decision to not give in. But it's the line in this song that plays through my head on those days: I'm not trying to say it's easy, but I'm trying to say it's fine. For me, every day is starting over. Every day is a new resolution. Because every day, I wake up and I decide that no matter how tough it's gonna get, I'm fine."

Sara — Oh man, this one made me laugh so hard, such specificity! Day 11: "He also said he wanted to be single over the summer, but gave me his puka shell necklace sprayed with Axe Body Spray to remind me of him. I wore it, I smelled it, I listened to 'Addicted' by Simple Plan probably 900 times thinking about him."

Galia — Some holiday melancholia on Day 5: "On our way home, we usually get back to Philly around 7/8 o'clock. During Christmastime, we arrive when it's dark out and the streets are quiet, as the city is awaiting New Year's Eve. This song plays through my head as we pull into our neighborhood and reacquaint ourselves with the Philly scenery after spending a week in the starkly different layout of Northeast Indiana suburbia."

Joe — I'm obviously in no position to say which of Joe's write-ups were "the best," since I am Joe, and that would just be weird and sad. But I will say instead that the write-up I am most proud of so far is: Day 2, or Day 9.

No comments: