****SPOILERS****
The Boys/Beers/Breakfast/Book Club is celebrating its five-year anniversary right now, as we discuss our 21st book. We meet quarterly, and are open to any literate person who identifies as male or non-binary. I've made it an infrequent habit to write a review and list some discussion questions in this blog space in the past, but consider this a commitment to make it a regular task. And if you're are interested in joining our book club and are eligible and you are somehow reading this blog post without also having had any conversations with me prior to this in which I attempt to force you to join our book club, then hit me up!
I'll say first that reading a book for a book club changes one's interactions with the book in question. Not that it's easier or harder to enjoy it, nothing like that. It's just that the impetus becomes that it is a well-written book, and not just a great story presented in humdrum fashion. I'll cop to loving Bad Blood, but I think it presents an extreme version of "amazing tale, written adequately." A book like this makes me fear that book club will turn into a big discussion about the thing that happened, while completely eschewing the way in which that thing was presented. No!
I'm not saying that John Carreyrou is a shitty writer, either. He's a journalist, at the time for The Wall Street Journal. He's won the Pulitzer Prize twice. He's a good writer! But here, he's not a good author. If that makes sense. The story of Theranos is fucking bonkers, and you can tell that Carreyrou did extensive research. But the whole fucking book is a series of "and then this happened, and then this happened." Which works fine if you're just trying to tell a good story. This is a great fucking story. But there's nothing here that makes it a good book. There is no decision that John Carreyrou makes throughout this process that makes me think differently about life. There's nothing that the author wrote that made me think "goddamn, good job, John Carreyrou."
Which is really interesting and maybe even slightly ironic, because eventually, due to the nature of the story and how it played out, Carreyrou eventually is forced to insert himself into the story. That's the type of meta shit that typically gets my pulse going at a great pace, but it fell a little flat here after the initial realization. I want what the author writes to be the most exciting aspect to any book. That sounds too obvious when I type it out, but not when you read a book like Bad Blood.
Which is really interesting and maybe even slightly ironic, because eventually, due to the nature of the story and how it played out, Carreyrou eventually is forced to insert himself into the story. That's the type of meta shit that typically gets my pulse going at a great pace, but it fell a little flat here after the initial realization. I want what the author writes to be the most exciting aspect to any book. That sounds too obvious when I type it out, but not when you read a book like Bad Blood.
I know that there is going to be ample discussion today about the follow-up podcast bullshit and the tabloids and the fucking Amanda Seyfried portrayal of Elizabeth Holmes (though I guess the fact that Ebon Moss-Bachrach plays Carreyrou goes a long way in convincing me that The Dropout might be worth the watch), but I am going to do my best to stay focused on the book, and what it means to read this book, and what we can get from the words on the motherfucking page, both literally and emotionally.
Great book, but only because of the great story. I would've liked a little more creativity embedded in the process of writing about that story, but so it goes.
Great book, but only because of the great story. I would've liked a little more creativity embedded in the process of writing about that story, but so it goes.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
BOOK CLUB DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
BOOK CLUB DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
1. As far as I can tell, the book immediately presents Elizabeth as a villain. I can't tell if it's on the page or in-between the lines due to previous knowledge of the subject, but it's there. Is this good storytelling? Are too many cards revealed at an early juncture regarding Elizabeth's character and motivation?
2. Many of the characters state that there are shady practices all over Silicon Valley, but that this case is different, because it's medicine, and there are lives at stake. Is that different? Or is unethical behavior unethical regardless of the who or the why?
3. It's stated that Carreyrou interviewed around 150 people for this project. What I found interesting was how obvious it was that a lot of what was told to Carreyrou became the text. It would be like "So-and-so was a blowhard asshole around the office around that time," but at no point are we to assume that Carreyrou himself is making that judgment. He heard that assessment from someone else. But he presents it as "fact," more or less. Is this an effective storytelling method?
4. Was humor used effectively throughout this book? There seemed to be certain stories designed to get a laugh, and I think it was mostly successful. Thinking about Elizabeth saying "I'm not afraid of anything... except needles." Also thinking about Sunny yelling "He stole property of the mind!" at the cops.
5. It's interesting how the Elizabeth Holmes story is originally presented as "tech's first female billionaire" and how everyone is like "see, girls, you can be whatever you want to be when you grow up!" which are excellent and important lessons for young women, but then the rug is pulled out from everyone's feet, like, fuck, the first and best female in this specific field is actually a total fucking fraud. I wonder if there are legs on the idea that Carreyrou didn't do enough to say "Yes, but..." Like, maybe say that just because Holmes is a crook doesn't mean a woman can't succeed in this business or in the career of her choosing.
6. Also wondering if there wasn't enough underlining of the fact that basically no one associated with Elizabeth faced any consequences. E.g. Mattis getting hoodwinked and then eventually being a trump cabinet member, or e.g. Joe Biden getting hoodwinked and eventually being elected President. Hundreds of people under her spell, and able to walk away when shit came to light. Is this how life works?
7. Was the story of Ian Gibbons handled appropriately?
8. Curious if the various Philly connections made an impact on anyone in book club. That South Philly dude at the ad agency! It was never specified South Philly, but c'mon, we all knew. And Elizabeth Holmes securing her downfall at the Philadelphia Convention Center. Pretty cool, and probably some thematic relevance to be wrung from this.
9. Similar to #5—some of the men of power who were hoodwinked by Holmes were so willing to buy into the facade because they considered themselves "men of science." As someone who considers himself a man of science, that kind of hit hard. Completely undercuts the holier-than-thou attitude that someone like me can sometimes take on in that regard, in a very healthy and humbling way. Does the book do enough to discuss this idea?
10. I appreciated how the end of the book presents a theory that Sunny is the true evil mastermind here, but then prove that theory wrong. Sunny is comically evil, but the focus here is definitely Elizabeth Holmes, one of the great enigmatic villains of our age. Is that focus worth an entire book written about it, though?

No comments:
Post a Comment