This is a weekly space for creative writing. Please check out the landing page
if you're interested in what we've written already, or if you yourself
are interested in writing creatively. Feel free to comment below
(according to the request feedback level) with any comments or
suggestions!
Requested feedback: Harshest critic—give me your worst
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"Suspenders"
I've always thought suspenders were silly. Is it a fashion idea or is it a way for pants not to fall down? As an overweight youth I loathed them. I just assumed they were made because I had to buy pants that were way too big. And so I forever hated the idea.
My entire vision of what suspenders are comes from the likes of Urkel and Larry King. And for some reason I picture the guy from The Honeymooners and Archie from All in the Family. It's tough to get more lame than that.
"Cool" is just a vibe. It's something we can feel or is told to us by someone else. You're cool if you wear this. You're a dork if you wear that. Little did I know that suspenders are probably the coolest thing you could wear.
Take this kid for example. He's just trying to enjoy his time. He's probably eating some food and wondering when his next nap will be. Literally everything I dream of now, AND he looks cool doing it. Why? Suspenders.
They are magical. They make the handsome into models. They are as sexy as it gets. And, yes, they still assist in holding up pants.
Now this dad bod has seen some stuff. But next time there is an event, you'll see me rocking them. Holding up my jeans. Looking as attractive as it gets. And hopefully, hopefully being as cool as this little guy.


1 comment:
Gary! Thanks a lot for doing this! I know you asked for "harshest critic," but I think it's worth first stepping back and appreciating what you did here. You created something out of nothing. That's not easy! I've always appreciated your willingness to get out there and write your truth. I saw it all last year in RC. That club misses you for that reason.
I really liked your treatise on suspender pants. It's honestly a subject I've never given any thought to at all, ever, and so it caught me off guard when it was the suspenders on the child in the picture that inspired your work. I like the off-beat choice. I appreciate it. The creative prompts are meant to inspire in that way, and I think you nailed it.
If I had to give criticism, I think it would look like this: there was change of heart here, right? The protagonist (you, I presume? or based on a true story?) thought before that suspenders were lame, but now he thinks they are cool. Both sides of the argument are given examples, but we don't get to see that change, that flip, and I think that is to this story's detriment. What is the cause of that change? It can't be the picture of the old-soul kid, because that's listed as an example of "cool suspenders." So what the heck happened here?
I think describing a character's motivation is really difficult. I feel like I struggle with that too. Especially when the character is based on the author. It's like, you already know your own motivation, and what makes you tick. The trick is conveying that to the reader. Coming away from this story, I do not doubt for a fucking SECOND that I'm going to see Gary rocking the suspenders next wedding we're at together. But I want to know the why. That's all.
Otherwise, I'll say that reading your stuff is always a joy. I think we always get a very real sense of how you're feeling in the moment, and that's valuable to the reader. If there was something I wanted from your writing, it's for you to DIG DEEPER.
Thanks again for writing, my friend. Looking forward to seeing what else you can come up with on the blog in the future.
Post a Comment