Urban Hymns
The Verve
1997
"Bitter Sweet Symphony" is worth the price of admission. The price: another 70 minutes of nondescript Britpop. I don't hate it, but a lot of this album blurs into one another, with "Bitter Sweet Symphony" providing the only oasis on here, smooth suede against the rough pulp. I understand a lot of people find this album to be an important one; I also understand that most of those people live an ocean away. Still, "Bitter Sweet Symphony"... man, what a fucking jam.
That whole movement over there, all the young Brits playing alt-rock with passion and drugs in the mid-'90s, all of that seems to be overcompensating for something. I don't know what, and it all happened about a decade before I became conscious of "music" in an artistic way, but I've always been suspicious of this shit. Like all the bands like the Verve and their ilk were playing off a young audience's willingness to perform 20/Twenty Vision in real time. I'm not saying its bad—and for real, the song on here that still plays on alt-rock radio to this day is an amazing fucking song—I'm just saying that it doesn't really seem all that special to me. Could never get into Oasis, and I'm having the same trouble now with the Verve.
The story is interesting, if you don't obsess over it too much. The Verve were, in fact, broken up before they ever made "Bitter Sweet Symphony." Their only true hit was actually a comeback. And then, having reformed and then conquered, their only true hit became an essential piece of their downfall as well. The song utilized a sample from an orchestral version of the Rolling Stones' "The Last Time" (performed by the Andrew Oldham Orchestra), and the Verve cleared it with the Stones' copyright holder at the time, Decca Records, but didn't realize that the copyright pre-1970 still belonged to former Stones manager Alan Klein, who sued the Verve. The courts forced the songwriting credits to be transferred to Mick Jagger and Keith Richards. The stress of that whole thing more or less broke the Verve again, and they didn't reach any commercial or critical success after this. (Somewhat optimistic postscript: when Alan Klein died in 2019, Jagger and Richards and Klein's son agreed to transfer the song's rights back to Verve songwriter Richard Ashcroft, so that's cool.)
No theft, just a financially catastrophic misunderstanding. Didn't we just do this last week? Talk about how sampling is still pure art when intentions are similarly pure? It's fascinating to me how someone (Ashcroft, in this case) heard what would otherwise be a completely forgotten orchestral cover version of a Stones song and took a piece of it and turned it into one of the defining songs of a generation. It's a lot more fascinating to think about while you're listening to "Bitter Sweet Symphony" fifteen times in a row than dredging through the rest of the deep cuts, in any case.
No theft, just a financially catastrophic misunderstanding. Didn't we just do this last week? Talk about how sampling is still pure art when intentions are similarly pure? It's fascinating to me how someone (Ashcroft, in this case) heard what would otherwise be a completely forgotten orchestral cover version of a Stones song and took a piece of it and turned it into one of the defining songs of a generation. It's a lot more fascinating to think about while you're listening to "Bitter Sweet Symphony" fifteen times in a row than dredging through the rest of the deep cuts, in any case.
From Track 2 through the end, you'd be forgiven if you thought you were listening to U2. This is the best way I can describe it. That's not a criticism. Not really. I like U2 as well. I like their hits (though I'd say that I like "Bitter Sweet Symphony" better than any U2 hit, even if that's an unfair comparison), and I more or less tolerate the deep cuts I'm familiar with. But I guess this is my way of saying that I don't really hear anything new throughout the rest of Urban Hymns, nothing that I haven't heard before. Probably the only one that stands out is "Lucky Man." I would've told you that I like this one because it's the other one that has an orchestral loop in it (not stolen this time). But I found this on the song's Wikipedia page, and it's fucking hilarious: "U2's Bono listed the song as one of six songs released between 1986 and 2006 that he wished he'd written." That makes sense! It's the one non-"Bittersweet" song on here that doesn't sound like Bono already wrote it!
Still, it doesn't really matter. Urban Hymns will be known as one of the best albums of the '90s whether I agree with it or not (or whether I give it more time to sprout wings or not), and we'll always have that one song from the album that will live on. That's enough for me this week.

No comments:
Post a Comment