Monday, January 15, 2024

A Year of Blind Spots: Donuts


Donuts
J Dilla
2006

Once again, for those in the peanut gallery: this is not expert testimony. By design, I'm approaching these "blind spot" albums with ignorance. If I knew anything about them then I wouldn't be "blind." So it is with grace and with a total commitment to understanding eventually that I sometimes react to a hitherto "blind spot" album with the following phrase: "What the fuck is this?"

That's totally okay, assuming that this reaction does not immediately lead to dismissal (I will have to reckon with past failures in this regard when I eventually revisit Suicide in sobriety). It didn't here, obviously, but I was still taken aback, because this is not what I expected. Donuts is labeled as "hip hop," but it was missing what I had previously thought was an essential piece of the genre—any rapping whatsoever. And I just didn't really know what to do with that.

In times like this, it's okay to reach out to an expert. For Donuts, I read the ten-year anniversary piece by Collin Robinson on Stereogum. I just want the context. It's okay that these pieces are usually written by fanboys, because the way I see it, if someone loves something, then they are extra motivated to convince someone else why they love it and why the other person should love it too. The love translates into a really well-written article. I got exactly what I needed.

The story I found seemed to look like the convergence of three separate storylines that seem to run through a lot of the music writing that we do on this blog. One is the concept of samples, and generally how sampling is one way that musicians take music that already exists, and shapes it into something new. There was a time, long ago, when I was suspicious of the concept, that maybe I felt that music needed to be completely original at all times. I still think that some pop artists take the idea too far, and basically repeat a song that already exists, but that's not really a big concern for me at this point. There are far more artists who are talented enough to take songs and completely refashion them into something that does indeed become wholly original.

There's a lot of that here. The whole album is samples, and that's good. It's unique. It was be ignorant to sit here and say "well all he's doing is taking old songs and smashing them together." That's not even true, and Robinson's Stereogum piece went a long way in describing why it's not true. It's not just a matter of cutting and pasting. There's warping, flipping, tempo-changing, juxtaposing, segueing, plus the paramount idea of choosing samples that thematically fit into the soundscape that you're trying to create. I don't know if I necessarily understand the science behind how J Dilla does it, but I can see and hear why he is considered good at it.

The second through line here is the idea of death, and how the finality of an artist's work does something to change and heighten our perception of that work. Donuts was released on J Dilla's 32nd birthday, and he died three days later. It wasn't sudden—Dilla suffered from a rare blood disease, and he made Donuts on his literal deathbed. Here was a man who knew he was at the end and decided to spend his final days making one more artistic statement. That idea brings immense weight to the proceedings. This goes beyond some of the work we've considered on the blog recently from artists who passed away too young. Janis Joplin and jaimie branch died suddenly, and their art only grows in retrospect. J Dilla knew exactly what was going to happen, but he made the album anyway. There sadness in all of it, but there's courage in this album, specifically. And beauty, too—not sure if I would've gotten to the whole "donut is a circle, as in circle of life" thing without Robinson's help, but there you go.

And then the third thing is minor in terms of the blog, but major in terms of J Dilla's legacy. Donuts is a hip hop album sans rapping, yes, but that means that it's ripe for the taking. Cyclical: just like Dilla spun samples into songs, so too can rappers take his songs and use them to rap. Make something new. This album can act as both a work of art unto itself and also a springboard for more art to be created in J Dilla's name. That's a legacy, man.

Donuts was not what I expected, and it's probably not in my wheelhouse, so to speak. But it's one of those albums that is impossible to ignore, given what it took to be made, where it's going after he's gone, and what it means to the people that were left behind. What the fuck is this? I wouldn't know how to answer that question, personally. It's like life. I don't know what life is either. But we live with the unknowns, and we try to find peace.


No comments: