Tuesday, January 23, 2024

Never Seen It, #132 of 200: Primer

What's worse? Thinking you're being paranoid, or knowing you should be? Or watching 200 films on a damn list that you made four years ago?


Primer
2004
Shane Carruth

Approximately one thousand years ago, Stephan indicated in a Facebook comment that he would eventually be interested in writing about Primer, when I eventually got to it on the list. No need for a time machine—the time is now, and here are Stephan's thoughts about the movie (and mine, below it).

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Stephan

Shane Carruth's 2004 sci-fi flick, Primer, is the story of two engineers, Aaron and Abe, who accidentally create a time machine. The film focuses on the two friends' relationship and the impact of their unintentional discovery. This low-budget ($7000), independently produced movie is very good, and one that I would recommend for anyone interested in a no-frill, complex, cerebral thriller. The actors' performances are solid and make the characters seem authentic and grounded. Often, science fiction stories—time travel stories in particular—create characters and worlds that are so far outside of reality that they feel entirely implausible. The difference with Primer is that the characters speak and behave in ways that are true to life. Carruth, who plays Aaron, and is the movie's writer, director, and producer, writes dialogue that does not water down the mathematical and scientific jargon. Though it's a bit of a pain and not always easy to understand, this makes the representation of the engineers feel genuine. Practical props further contribute to the believability of the world that has been constructed.

Another strength of this film is its short runtime. Clocking in at 77 minutes, it manages to provide an intriguing and challenging experience unlike any other in this genre. With all the complicated scientific language, the complicated time travel plot, and the many philosophical and ethical themes presented, this film would have been way too much to process, and not worth the time investment (or additional watches), if it were any longer. Movies like Christopher Nolan's Tenet and Interstellar are great films and are among personal favorites. They are well-acted, well-written, and highly entertaining, but they lack re-watchability, because they are so mentally taxing in addition to being incredibly long. While there are moments in Primer that could benefit from further exploration, this makes for a good film to debate, analyze, and obsess over well after the film has ended.

Primer's mechanics of time travel are very complicated, but unique and interesting enough to stay engaged and invested. The film manages to overcome some of the common pitfalls associated with time travel narratives, like paradoxical loops and a predictable plot, by centering around the physical and emotional toll of time travel on the main characters. That said, it's not all perfect, as Causality is sometimes an issue. The interactions between Aaron and Abe with both past and future versions of themselves and others, at times, results in varying, inconsistent consequences, which makes the inner workings of time travel less than clear. As Aaron reiterates in the film, "It's unknowable." It's a bit of a copout answer, but forgivable as the vagueness kind of adds to the film's mystique and charm.

It may not be a perfect movie by traditional, blockbuster movie standards, but it is an essential watch for any fan of the genre or anyone looking for a challenging, yet worthwhile, independent film.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

Full disclosure: I've Seen It Before. But I haven't seen it, if you feel what I'm trying to say. I promised you after we discussed Broken Flowers that this would never happen again. Sorry, I lied. Back around the time that Netflix was brand new and DVD-mail-order only, I rented a copy of Primer, and attempted to watch it. As the credits rolled, I reflected on the fact that I had just watched a film that I literally did not understand AT ALL, which was a new feeling for me. This wasn't like Broken Flowers, in which just the ending baffled me. The entire 77 minutes of Primer was, at the moment, for me, an unknowable mystery. I put it aside.

And now I am returning to it, approximately fifteen years later, to see what's changed. Primer hasn't changed, of course. I've changed. Any additional understanding that I have of this film the second time around will mark change and growth within me and on my own film journey. That's the reason this movie that I've already technically seen ended up on my Never Seen It list. If you watch a movie but don't understand any of it, does that even count as "seeing it"? I'd argue no. And here is an opportunity to change it.

I don't bear any ill will toward my former self for not understanding Primer. It's a dense and jargon-heavy movie. The creator (producer, writer, director, star) Shane Carruth, who had a degree in mathematics and worked as an engineer prior to making the film, kept the scientific language in the script to make it feel more realistic. It felt like a challenge, to be honest. I love hearing experts talk about the subject they are knowledgeable about, but only when there are no stakes. Here, you have to try to understand what they are talking about, or else you're lost.

And all these years later, I still don't really know if I understand the science behind the device the two characters (Carruth's Aaron and David Sullivan's Abe) create. Maybe you don't have to know too much about it. You do have to understand time travel theory. Luckily, Harry Potter put me on the road to thinking about this subject a while ago (though I am no expert on it, I hope it goes without saying). PoYB readers have long been schooled on the different time travel theories, how Marty McFly changed the past to the detriment of the future, but Harry and Hermione simply played their part in the established loop.

What's interesting is that Aaron and Abe know that they discovered time travel, but in that moment, they have no idea what type of time travel it is. They don't know how large of an affect their actions will have on the timeline. What's important is that they are scientists, and gradually begin to test more and more intense hypotheses the more times they go back in time. First, Abe refuses to leave the hotel room just in case he accidentally alters the future. Eventually, Abe and Aaron are going back in time by weeks to stop a violent shooter at a party. At a certain point, Primer starts to feel like a horror movie, in the way that Aaron and (to a lesser extent) Abe are so willing to plunge into the complete unknown.

I'd be lying if I said that I didn't have to check out Wikipedia after watching to nail down some of the finer details (I guess it's implied that Aaron is building a large-scale time machine at the very end there?). But in general, this time around, as a grown adult with a functioning brain that's not completely washed by hormones and alcohol, I found my viewing to be a much more satisfactory experience. I was able to appreciate the lo-fi sci-fi mastery without having to worry about what in the fuck was even happening. For real, mastery! It's a wonder that a movie that basically consists of two dudes talking about science could be THIS thrilling.

I regret being so obtuse about film in the '00s that all these important films went completely over my head... but I don't regret it too much. It happened and so all I can do now is appreciate that it happened. That's kinda the underlining point of the plot of this movie, right? That some things just shouldn't be fucked with. If I had a time machine, I'd be afraid to use it. Maybe my misunderstanding of Primer in 2009ish was essential somehow to who I am today. In any case, it led me here, to this place, right now, and here in this moment, as I type these words, words that surely wouldn't exist if I altered my past, I find myself to be quite happy. I am in the right timeline, watching the right movie, again but for real this time, watching it at the exact right time.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Here comes another sports movie, The Program, that I placed on this list for a very superficial reason, one that I'm going to have to dance around next week, for reasons that I'll explain then.

No comments: