Welcome to Highbrow/Lowbrow, where Rachel S. talks about all the culture she's consuming, from the thoughtful to the trashy and all things in between.
This Week's High: Oscar Nominations are Announced!
To start, let's just establish that the Oscars are my Super Bowl. You might think awards shows are frivolous, Hollywood is a sick cult (more on those later), and that winning an Oscar is because of popularity PR contests. You wouldn't be completely wrong.
But you have to understand, I came of age during the golden era of the little golden man, raised by a father who was a total movie buff. We're talking about the time when Billy Crystal hosted and opened with spectacular and genuinely funny opening numbers. When stars didn't have Instagram to build their "brand." When Cher won Best Actress for Moonstruck and wore THAT dress. It was a simpler time.
And much like my lifelong love of Saturday Night Live, I know the Oscars aren't at their best right now. But I still have to watch. It's like homework, almost. Homework that literally no one other than me is making me do. And watching awards shows is the only time I actually miss Twitter. Oh, to live tweet again!
I write all of this because later I am going to absolutely dunk on something I know a lot of people love. We have personal connections to pop culture. It's not all about having Criterion Collection taste. The films, TV shows, plays, and music we like has more to do with memories and our guts than rationality. I get that.
Without further adieu, here are my Oscars (likely not-so-hot) takes:
- Jimmy Kimmel is such a lame boring host.
- However, I am glad to be past the Ellen era where they did those weird "let's make celebrities interact with normies from the street" segments.
- There's a lot wrong with Greta Gerwig and Margot Robbie getting snubbed for their respective categories. Plenty of people have written ad nauseam about the sexism already. So I don't need to go much further. What I don't understand from the Academy's perspective is... do you not want viewership? Do you not want a younger audience to engage and care? The snobbery is just bad for business.
- However, I am not at all surprised. The Academy never takes comedies all too seriously. What Barbie did get nominated for seems more obligatory rather than earned.
- If you can treat Joker like a real film, with Joaquin Phoenix as a serious actor giving a serious performance...
- Ryan Gosling 10000% deserved his nomination though.
- I really really really hope he performs "I'm Just Ken" at the ceremony.
- Maestro is pure, boring campaigning, winning spots in the nomination list over more deserving films and performances. Like Andrew Scott.
- No one saw Nyad. Why are we here? Greta Lee >>>>>
- The Best Actor race is a dead heat between Paul Giamatti and Cillian Murphy. I don't really have a horse in this race. I enjoyed The Holdovers but didn't fawn over it as much as others because it feels like a movie I've already seen. Cillian Murphy is a brilliant actor. So, go for it dudes.
- Best Actress is between Emma Stone and Lily Gladstone. I am pulling for Lily here. Emma has already had her moments, and Killers of the Flower Moon does deserve recognition.
- ICYMI: Leo was supposed to be portraying a 21-year-old in that film!!!!!!
- Supporting Actor is probably going to RDJ, maybe with a DeNiro or Ruffalo upset.
- Supporting Actress is a lock for Da'Vine Joy Randolph. She deserves it.
- Best Director and Film will be Christopher Nolan (who is overdue) and Oppenheimer. The Academy loves a historical biopic. Almost as much as they love movies about movies (See: Argo, La La Land, The Artist, etc.).
- International feature is very likely The Zone of Interest, with maybe a surprise win for Society of the Snow.
- As much as I know, I should see Zone of Interest, but I'm having a hard time wanting to watch a Holocaust film, considering the current state of the world.
- Anatomy of a Fall might get some surprise wins or steals in. It's gaining a lot of buzz, but overall, I think it's going to be a pretty Oppenheimer-heavy predictable year
I love movies. I love the Oscars. Let's go girls.
This Week's Low: Disney World
Trigger warning: if you're a Disney person or Disney adult, this post might (definitely) not be for you.
I was at a work conference earlier this week that happened to be held at a Disney hotel. The facilities were of course nice and clean, and the staff (who Disney calls "cast members") were all excellent. From a standard hotel conference perspective, 10s across the board.
But what I simply can't get past is the Disney of it all. I've never understood the obsession. And after staying at one of the resorts and spending one evening in EPCOT (courtesy of the conference, I would never pay), I understand it even less. I don't have children, so I'm sure some of the supposed "magic" gets lost on me there. But even so, from what I witnessed, dragging kids around Disney seems miserable. So much screaming. So many lines. So. Much. Money.
Nothing actually seems "fun" or "vacationy" about a Disney "vacation." You have to pay extra on top of an already exorbitant ticket price to "skip ahead" in the lines for rides. But some rides are so popular that even if you have said pass, you have to wake up at 7 AM to enter some convoluted online registration which gives you a timed ticket to... wait in an actual line. And to high five Mickey? There's a line for that too. Hard pass.
You can't just eat at a restaurant, even in your hotel. Everything, everything has some bullshit registration system. How does that work with children who are known chaos agents? I’m just a girl, going to a conference, asking a hotel to let me sit alone and eat at the bar.
I also witnessed a lot of parents and adults that seem to be way more into the experience than the actual children who these parks are made for. There's some arrested development happening there, and I simply don't have the bandwidth to analyze. I just... why would you spend THAT kind of money to do so much waiting and schlepping? Why not go to an all-inclusive resort with a water park or some shit?
But I think the Disney of it all really leans into that whole stat about the amount of Americans who don't have a passport. It's not cheaper than going to Europe or South America. Or even bloody Australia. Disney just dupes you into believing it's easier when truth be told, after what I saw, it absolutely is not.
Lastly, the capitalism and consumerism of that place is just gobsmacking, and in my opinion, morally sick. I don't claim to be above it here. I participated in it by going to a conference. I went to Universal Studios like ten years ago and lost my mind wandering around Springfield, because The Simpsons are so core to who I am today. But that was one day, with one admission ticket, and a few Duff beers. It's different at Disney. When you look around and see how much everything costs, all the extras they make you feel you have to do for a "magical" experience, it's hard to feel anything other than unease. How many people here are in credit card debt? How many are choosing this over making rent? All in service of a CORPORATION that is capitalizing on your memories, your childhood, your children.
I feel kind of guilty actually for participating in that place truth be told. But hey, that's me and my gut. I'm not saying you can't enjoy any Disney movies or not let your kids watch The Little Mermaid. I loved Disney movies as a kid. Some of my most cherished memories are watching those films. Do you, but maybe not at the cost of bankruptcy for a company founded by a guy who welcomed Nazis to his studio. Just saying!!!!!!!!!!


6 comments:
The lowbrow this week makes a lot of great points. I've been thinking about all this shit a lot lately, since my whole extended family is heading down there in about three months. All the "extras" that you need to tack on to make the experience worth it, like you spoke of, are the things that make me a little uneasy. Still, I am committed to just shutting up about it and letting the kids have a good time. Hopefully the four PoYB contributors that are taking the trip with me can attest that I haven't complained about anything, not once. My parents are committed to making the trip (and footing a decent amount of the cost, which is probably the unspoken key to this whole thing), and so I will be there, with extremely reasonable expectations.
Excellent slam post. PoYB Sr. Culture Writer Rachel was mentioning to me earlier this week that Disney's economy is bigger than many countries. I went to wiki to get the figures:
According to Oxford Economics (DEFINITELY a bought-and-paid industry consultant group), Disneyworld's financial weight in 2023 was:
Disneyworld "Economic Impact" (whatever the fuck that means): $40.3B
Disneyworld Income from Jobs/Sales/Labor (a much better metric): $12.1B
In relation, here is the GDP of several countries, in $B, 2022:
World Rank - Country - GDP
1 - USA - $27,000
3 - Germany - $4,500
16 - Indonesia - $1,417
xx - FL (State) - $1,389
101 - Libya - $40.2
111 - Iceland - $30.6
150 - Chad - $12.5
151 - Tajikstan - $11.8
161 - Maldives - $6.9
164 - Barbados - $6.2
186 - Seychelles - $2.1
You can see Disneyworld nestled in there between Chad and Tajikstan. And several ranks above many tropical tourism countries in a whole. Thanks Disney, you're creepy!
The Star Wars, Guardians, and Avatar rides are pretty good though.
This is your reminder that Paul Giamatti is the villain in 30 Coins, the Spanish horror show I'm trying to bully Frank into watching.
Guardians of the Galaxy Rollercoaster and the Rattatoullie ride are very cool. All the times I've been the whole bill has been footed for me by a Disney adult (or my parents). If anyone needs a Disney plug find a DINK who's spouse won't go with them anymore. You can get in for free, it's more enjoyable that way.
I had a real good time with the first season right up until the finale. And the I had a baaaad time with the second season. Breaks my heart.
This Oscars write-up is fabulous. I'm also not expecting many surprises. I think Gladstone gets it. I suggest that narratives and optics are always at play in the voting body, and I think they favor her.
Post a Comment