Thursday, January 25, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 12: Joe

Prompt: "The title track to an album"

Selected by Joe


"Don't Be Cruel"
Bobby Brown
Don't Be Cruel, 1988

Here's a thought exercise: what's the worst thing that someone could possibly say to you?

I don't know if it's necessarily a good thought exercise, since it gets you thinking some pretty terrible things about yourself. But I was curious if there was an answer. Let me just type a couple hundred words about it while you listen to some New Jack Swing, and then we can move on to the next song.

But I like the question because it's a good examination of one's walls that they put up, and also what one might choose to use as a shield. For me, it's self-deprecation as a defense mechanism.

There's a lot of shit that someone could tell me is wrong with me, but I already know it to be true, so it doesn't really affect me emotionally. Like say if I was called "dumb" or "ugly" or a "pathetic waste of space." Not that I necessarily believe those things to be wholly true, but they are at least half true, and I'd be sympathetic to someone's beliefs if they insisted it to be wholly true. "You're ugly!" would be met with something like: "Well, I mean, I'm not the ugliest dude, but I could certainly see someone's beliefs in that regard to be within reason." And then if they were to say something that I believed was extremely untrue, then that wouldn't hurt me, because I could just chalk it up to the other person acting out in anger or something. Like, if someone said "You're a shitty father," then that wouldn't affect me at all, because it's not true. I fuck up constantly as a parent, and I'm far from perfect, but to say I'm a "shitty dad" would be kinda silly in its hyperbole.

(I don't think I'm counting in this exercise stuff that people could say about those close to me, even if it was directed toward me. I'd get a lot more upset at someone talking shit on my wife and kids than if someone was saying shit ten times worse about me. But that's not what I'm talking about. Plus, my wife and kids are perfect. Tough to imagine anyone talking shit.)

I've trained myself to be self-deprecating and humble so that I can never be hurt. I could see maybe someone saying "he's a shitty writer" having a bit of a sting to it, only because I spend so much of my free time writing as a hobby. But that's why I'm so cautious to never say such a thing and never believe such a thing. It's why I'm careful to underline again and again that this is a hobby of a blog and no matter how much I write on it I'll never be a good writer. If I say it first, then no one else can.

I think it would hurt if someone said something like "I hate Joe because of something that he did in the past that he doesn't even know he did." One, because I am fully aware that I have made plenty of mistakes in the past that I can never take back, and two, because it would catch me off-guard to have to confront another one of those mistakes without the time or distance from it to be able to think about it and consider what ways I can attempt to make amends.

This hypothetical's key aspect is the "he doesn't even know," which is scary, but very real and even probable. I spent a lot of the last two decades of my life in public but without a working brain and thus without recorded memories of those times. Blackout drinking is not an excuse for my actions, and never has been and never will be, but the facts of the matter are that I probably did some horrific shit that I don't even remember, and there are probably some people out there who remember it clearly and have held onto those dark (and very reasonable) emotions for a long time, and haven't had the space or connection with me to be able to confront me about it. So I think I would be hurt and ashamed, if I was ever suddenly confronted with such mistakes. It would be totally deserved, but I'm just answering the thought exercise's question here.

"I'm disappointed in you" is a classic one. That would be probably be rough to hear. There's a reason that's the classic parental disciplinary tactic—it really does hurt more than "I'm angry at you"! But the difference here is that its in the present tense. They are hypothetically disappointed due to something you just did. There's room for change. There's room to address the issue. Whenever I think that someone has an issue with me, no matter how slight, no matter if they are even right or wrong, it keeps me up at night. And so, in the morning, I'm usually doing what I have to do to make amends or apologize or whatever. You get good at apologizing when you fuck up a lot. It feels better to be on good terms with people. It feels terrible to disappoint. I guess sometimes I do the bare minimum to do what's expected of me in life, but the key is that I get it done, if only so as to avoid that disappointment.

Oh, so how about this as a possible answer to the original question: "I hate you and there is nothing you can ever do to change my mind about that." That would hurt because it wouldn't give me an opportunity to fix what's broken, and it seemingly cuts off any opportunity in the future to do so either. It would hurt if I took them at their word. Of course, I mostly likely wouldn't. There are no wounds that can't heal over time. Maybe it takes years or even decades, but I would in this hypothetical scenario hold onto the small glimmer of hope that exists way far down the line, when we're old and gray and I'm still attempting to right my wrongs.

Maybe it wouldn't be the content of what's being said, but the manner in which it is relayed? I'm thinking now of this time back in like 2015ish when I was directed by my supervisor to remove a child from a home because the mom's boyfriend was a sex offender, and she was unwilling to kick him out. It wasn't even my case, I just happened to be the only sucker still in the office at 3:45 PM, and so I had no emotional stake in the matter. Shitty situation, obviously, but even at that early stage in my career, I was pretty numb to it all. While I was there, I had to wait like 90 full minutes for the judge's order to make its way to me before I could take action, and so all I could do was sit on their couch and wait, and listen to Mom. She spent those 90 minutes hurling every insult she could at me. When someone says "You're a terrible person" once, it's fine because you know it isn't true. You can brush it off. When someone says "You're a terrible person" over 100 times in a row, you start to believe it. I did feel like I was a terrible person at that moment (and not just because work made me late to Pam's birthday Beerito).

Oh shit, did I say I was going to write "a couple hundred words" today? Whoops. If you're gonna say the worst thing you possibly can to me, make it: "I don't read anything you write because you write too much." That one is definitely the worst, even though it's understandable and true.

2 comments:

Boober said...

"I don't read anything you write because you write too much."

Boober said...

Yours is actually the first one I read 👍 sometimes I do go… wow 11 paragraphs huh