Follow along in the book HERE. Today's song is at #31 and is featured on pages 202-205.
"Eight Days a Week"
Beatles for Sale
1964
I'm not thrilled to be watching the new season of True Detective (not thrilled about TV in general these days), but I did cackle when, in the first episode, the main character was introduced (she's played by Jodie Foster) by making the claim: "I'm not a Beatles fan." What an efficient way to show us that this character is cantankerous and unhappy! Who doesn't like the Beatles?!
I think about this when confronted with a Beatles tune that is really great but in very boring ways. I have to remind myself that that's okay. Not every song has to be interesting. In fact, I'd say that many of the Beatles' most interesting songs are nowhere near their best. Think about last week's "I Will." I found a lot of the trivia surrounding that song to be quite interesting! But the song is not that great! And so here, with the great "Eight Days a Week," we have sort of the opposite problem. (Well, not "problem," that's a bit of a hyperbole.)
I think about this when confronted with a Beatles tune that is really great but in very boring ways. I have to remind myself that that's okay. Not every song has to be interesting. In fact, I'd say that many of the Beatles' most interesting songs are nowhere near their best. Think about last week's "I Will." I found a lot of the trivia surrounding that song to be quite interesting! But the song is not that great! And so here, with the great "Eight Days a Week," we have sort of the opposite problem. (Well, not "problem," that's a bit of a hyperbole.)
Even our esteemed authors admit that this is basically Beatles on autopilot. "Eight Days a Week" was a #1 hit, and rightly so, but notice its placement on Beatles for Sale. While I have a lot of great things to say about that album, the general consensus is that Beatles for Sale finds the Beatles overstaying their welcome with their old sound, and right on the precipice of blowing things up for real, musically speaking. "Eight Days a Week" is a euphoric sound, but it's nothing they hadn't done before.
I think one of the (many) reasons why the Beatles remain so popular and so crucial to the history of rock 'n' roll is that they manage to be very catchy and very interesting. They aren't the catchiest band of all time, and they aren't the most interesting band of all time, but they are top-tier in both categories. It gives you a lot to listen to, and it gives you a lot to think about. All that being said, it's not like every single fucking Beatles song is catchy and interesting. Case in point here. I'm just saying that they are one of those bands that could be both at any given time, and very often were.
And at the risk of beating this horse to death: the main flaw of the book that we're following, 100 Best Beatles Songs: A Passionate Fan's Guide, is that there are not 100 songs in which the Beatles are very catchy AND very interesting. Occasionally, the catchy songs are so goddamn catchy that they (and we) can't help but rank 'em high on the list, but then, what might there be to write about? You see the problem. (I keep saying "problem." Sorry. There are no real problems here.)
I think one of the (many) reasons why the Beatles remain so popular and so crucial to the history of rock 'n' roll is that they manage to be very catchy and very interesting. They aren't the catchiest band of all time, and they aren't the most interesting band of all time, but they are top-tier in both categories. It gives you a lot to listen to, and it gives you a lot to think about. All that being said, it's not like every single fucking Beatles song is catchy and interesting. Case in point here. I'm just saying that they are one of those bands that could be both at any given time, and very often were.
And at the risk of beating this horse to death: the main flaw of the book that we're following, 100 Best Beatles Songs: A Passionate Fan's Guide, is that there are not 100 songs in which the Beatles are very catchy AND very interesting. Occasionally, the catchy songs are so goddamn catchy that they (and we) can't help but rank 'em high on the list, but then, what might there be to write about? You see the problem. (I keep saying "problem." Sorry. There are no real problems here.)
The only thing we can do (and that's "we," not "they," since Spignesi and Lewis seem to be wary of going down this path) at this point is to make it personal. Yes, "Eight Days a Week" is a good song, probably in the upper echelon (say, Top 50) of the Beatles songbook, but if it didn't really mean that much to the Beatles' story, then what does it mean in the context of my story? That's a road we can travel, if need be.
Not that I have any wild stories about "Eight Days a Week," but when I hear the song, I think about the first time I heard a clip of it, and then the first time I heard it in full, and what that all means. The clip: a brief snippet on the commercials for 1 Best Of compilation that ran fucking constantly on my TV at the turn of the century. I was young and I knew nothing about the Beatles at the time, besides the fact that they had what the TV was telling me were some good songs, and that I should send my money in posthaste to hear them in full.
Hearing it in full: when my friend Ed played his copy of 1 during a hangout in the mid-aughts. The crucial point here, though, is that I heard "Eight Days a Week" after I started to explore the Beatles myself. My entry point was Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, and I think within a few years I was intimate with Abbey Road, The White Album, Rubber Soul, and Revolver, probably in that order (note: music discovery moved at a snail's pace when you needed to buy music to hear it and you lacked any significant funds to do so). So hearing "Eight Days a Week" was one Beatles lightbulb moment in a long series of them. This one said "oh damn, the music from their earlier and technically less innovative days is still just as catchy." This is the song that accelerated my journey backwards into the start of the discography. (I think Ed burned me copies of A Hard Day's Night and Help!, by the way. I declined a copy of 1. Knew from an early age that Best Ofs were a mortal sin.)
See? Not that interesting. The thesis of the story isn't that I'm some unique butterfly who has a sui generis Beatles origin story. That's not true at all. The thesis is that "Eight Days a Week" is a bangin'-ass song, and that when I heard it, I knew that it was a sound worth exploring more. That's all.
Hearing it in full: when my friend Ed played his copy of 1 during a hangout in the mid-aughts. The crucial point here, though, is that I heard "Eight Days a Week" after I started to explore the Beatles myself. My entry point was Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, and I think within a few years I was intimate with Abbey Road, The White Album, Rubber Soul, and Revolver, probably in that order (note: music discovery moved at a snail's pace when you needed to buy music to hear it and you lacked any significant funds to do so). So hearing "Eight Days a Week" was one Beatles lightbulb moment in a long series of them. This one said "oh damn, the music from their earlier and technically less innovative days is still just as catchy." This is the song that accelerated my journey backwards into the start of the discography. (I think Ed burned me copies of A Hard Day's Night and Help!, by the way. I declined a copy of 1. Knew from an early age that Best Ofs were a mortal sin.)
See? Not that interesting. The thesis of the story isn't that I'm some unique butterfly who has a sui generis Beatles origin story. That's not true at all. The thesis is that "Eight Days a Week" is a bangin'-ass song, and that when I heard it, I knew that it was a sound worth exploring more. That's all.
That's all, and that's okay. Sometimes a good song is just a good song. Maybe this Beatles book that we're reading might be a little better if our authors just fucking admitted that more often.
BEATLES TRIVIA: Any Beatles fan worth their salt knows that the phrase "eight days a week" is a Ringo Starr malapropism. And yet! This book documents the fact that Paul McCartney has, at various times, indicated a completely different origin of the phrase. According to Paul, he was making small talk with his chauffeur on the way to John's house one day, and the chauffeur claimed that he (the chauffeur) was working so hard that it felt like he was working eight days a week. Paul then allegedly got out of the car at John's house, and told him that they needed to make a song with that phrase right away. I think I like it better to think that Ringo is just a goofy guy, but I'm also comfortable with the idea that it was originally said to be a Ringoism to build up the Legend of Ringo, even if it was actually someone else who said it. (A third reality might be that Ringo was the chauffeur. But no one has ever made that claim, as far as I can tell. Maybe that's just me buying into the Legend of Ringo a little too hard.)
BETTER BEATLE: The book indicates that "I Don't Want to Spoil the Party" was the B-side on the "Eight Days a Week" single, and the authors remark pithily that "it didn't make the list." I thought it would've been funny if "I Don't Want to Spoil the Party" was actually better than "Eight Days a Week." It's a decent song, but alas, not better. Are there any songs on Beatles for Sale that are better? If I had a gun to my head, I'd probably lean on my affinity for "Kansas City/Hey-Hey-Hey-Hey!," even though that's not a Beatles original and thus not even eligible for this book's Top 100. No such rules on the fucking blog. I'll choose whatever song I goddamn well please.
NEXT TIME: "Day Tripper" at #32
No comments:
Post a Comment