Thursday, January 7, 2021

Never Seen It, #28 of 200: Broken Flowers

Still working through my list of 200 movies that I've never seen, and now that this and Record Club are the only things I'm beholden to on this blog, it feels a lot less insurmountable.


Broken Flowers
2005

Okay, time to admit it: I've already seen Broken Flowers. There is definitely a reason why I included it on a "list of movies I've never seen," but before I explain, you should know this. My bad for deceiving ya. I promise that I have not seen 199 movies on this list.

Astute blog archivists will note that Broken Flowers has actually already been mentioned on PoYB. #47 on my erstwhile Bucket List reads as follows: "Discover the meaning of the end of Broken Flowers."

Hmm. What to make of this. A few notes I suppose. First, don't read that whole bucket list. Most are items that I've long since lost the desire to complete (and for some, I've grown to actively loathe the idea of ever completing them). Some of it hasn't aged well at all. The two additional items I completed before today were mostly coincidental (I did attend a taping of Jerry Springer, with mixed feelings; I did have a beer with Jim W. at some point, and I forget if he explicitly set up the hang because of the Bucket List item or not, it's been a while since I've seen my old pal).

Second, I probably should've written "Figure out the meaning of the end of Broken Flowers" instead of "Discover the meaning of the end of Broken Flowers" (better yet: "Figure out what the end of Broken Flowers means," to make it less grammatically awkward). The way I wrote it assumes that there is an "answer" out there waiting to be found. As we know from previous experiences even with movies from this very list, there isn't always an answer provided. I don't blame director Jim Jarmusch for not giving away his intentions to me via Google in 2008. Sometimes you just gotta figure this shit out by yourself, ya know?

Which brings me back to the reason I included a seen movie on the Never Seen It list—it was my opinion then, and it stood my opinion at the time of the list's creation, that I hadn't really seen the movie. I watched it, but I didn't get it. The bucket list made that clear. (This, on top of the fact that it had been fourteen years since my first viewing and I didn't remember shit about it.) In my quest to "understand film," I realized that writing an essay about Broken Flowers might be a chance to see if I'm any closer to that point. If I was able to again watch the movie that clearly stood out in my mind as a movie I should understand but didn't, and was now at this point able to come to a long-awaited conclusion about "what it means," then maybe I'm actually getting the hang of this. (This coming just a week after I spent another blog post breathlessly trying to prove that I "got" the movie, so... sorry for that.)

Either that, or I still have no fucking clue. I dunno, the answer will probably be somewhere in between, but let's get onto the movie and see what we see. I have to imagine that this is the last bucket list item from that particular list that I will ever attempt to complete.
 
Alright, so, Broken Flowers, a 2005 Bill Murray vehicle. Murray's character Don receives a letter in the mail from an anonymous woman, claiming that she had a fling with him 20 years ago, and that Don has a nineteen-year-old son whom he didn't previously know about. Don is content to just forget about the letter, but his neighbor Winston (played delightfully by Jeffrey Wright), being a mystery novel enthusiast, takes it upon himself to plan a solo road trip for Don (complete with Ethiopian music mix CD) so that he can visit all the women he slept with 20 years ago, and find out who the mother of his child is. Don, a regular Don Juan, slept with five women around that time in his life.

The majority of the movie amounts to extended vignettes with these various women. There's the slightly white trash closet organizer (Sharon Stone) with the sexually promiscuous daughter (who is literally named "Lolita," noted by Don as a fitting nomenclature in more than one way). There's the now-strait-laced real estate agent (Frances Conroy) with her conservative husband who hosts an uncomfortable dinner. There's the "Animal Communicator" (Jessica Lange). There's the rural redneck (Tilda Swinton) with the violent biker friends. Oh, and the fifth woman is dead.

So Don goes to visit these women (and a gravestone) with the intention of sniffing around for clues. The letter he received was typed with a typewriter on pink stationery, so Winston advises Don to look for a typewriter and anything pink in each house. The problem is, every house he visits prominently features pink in some way—wallpaper, business card, hilariously an actual typewriter. 
 
But that's not all. Don starts to see all these weird connections between the women and between his experiences on the road trip. For one, all of these houses have basketball nets for some reason. The Animal Communicator's deceased dog is named "Winston" just like Don's neighbor who set up the trip. And yet, none of them give any indication that they have a nineteen-year-old son. Don has nightmares in which he thinks he can make connections between these disparate places and people, as if the answer is right there but he can't grasp it.

To make matters worse, Don arrives home to find another letter with the same typeface on the same pink stationery, but it's from his ex-girlfriend whom he broke up with at the start of the movie. Could it be that she sent the original letter too to fuck with him? It's speculated upon, but never answered, and honestly, it doesn't even matter to Don (or to the audience) at this point. He (and we) are in the zone. Don has fallen into the trap of thinking that there is going to be answer to the big question, and since we're watching a movie, and movies typically have a beginning and a middle and an end that wraps everything up, we assume there is going to be an answer too.

So Don now sees a kid hanging around the diner that he's at, and the kid looks to be about nineteen-years-old. Could it be? He buys the kid a sandwich, and works his way up to accusing the kid of being his son, at which point this clearly non-related person runs away all freaked out. Don watches as the kid gets away, and then all of a sudden, a car drives by, and it's blasting the same Ethiopian jazz song that Don was listening to on his road trip. The guy in the passenger seat stares at Don in slow motion as the song blares, and then... the movie ends.

I'm sorry I had to go through the plot pretty much, and I'm especially sorry if you read all that without having watched the movie and now you're spoiled to it (you should know better). But I had to explain it because now I have to explain what the fuck the ending meant. And here's what I got:

Throughout the movie, Don gradually moves from skeptic to believer. He tells Winston that the plan is stupid, and yeah, continually complains throughout that he still thinks it's stupid, but you can tell on a deeper level that Don is really getting into the idea that this is a mystery that can be solved. Like I said, he starts thinking that he sees clues everywhere he goes. Why does every woman I slept with 20 years ago have a basketball net of all things? How likely is it that the dog and my neighbor are both named Winston? How the fuck is some random passerby playing the same obscure Ethopian song that I just spent the last two weeks listening to over and over?!

He wants to believe that a chance vagabond is his son, because he has followed the clues, and believes that he now deserves an answer, an ending to his quest. But here's the rub: life isn't like that. Life is rarely, if ever, tied up in a neat little bow. Most mysteries go unsolved. Life is full of coincidences, but they are just that—coincidence. It's random chaos, and if you choose to try to find connections that aren't really there, then that's on you.

It's a lesson that the movie wants the audience to learn, even if Don doesn't. Sometimes a story can just be a story. The parts aren't connected, even as you watch them chronologically. Life is chaotic and random and none of it means anything. The answer is: There is no answer.

That's what I got out of Broken Flowers this time around, anyway. It's what I think the movie is "about." I hope that satisfies teenage Joe in nascent stages of film appreciation.

Director Jim Jarmusch has pretty much said as much in interviews that for some reason were not found on Google in the '00s (and I feel like I checked, I swear)—he even uses words like "chaos," which I swear I typed above before I read this interview. (And you can tell that the "clues" presented in the movie really are mostly Jarmusch fucking with us, since the actor who plays the passerby in the final scene is Homer Murray, Billy Murray's actual biological son.)
 
However, Jarmusch doesn't come right out and say "this is what the movie is about" or "this is what I intended by the ending." I think that we need to take the last final steps ourselves, in our own lives, to understand how the false connections of Broken Flowers reflects our own random lives.

It makes sense that teenage Joe would be frustrated with such a concept. When you're a teenager, you think that you're the center of the universe. You think that everything "happens for a reason." It's really, really tough to accept the fact that all of this is meaningless, that we're all just a punctuation mark in a footnote in the history of the human race, and nothing we do makes any sense in the grand scheme of the universe. And if you want to take it a step back toward the movie, we can say that Don Johnston is practically a teenager himself, emotionally at least, and so it also makes sense that he too has a tough time accepting this great and terrible truth about our insignificance and the unpredictability of life.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

I can't end this blog post without at least mentioning Bill Murray's performance, can I? PoYB's perennial whipping boy has returned in what is possibly his most deadpanned, vacuous role of his career.

You'll recall that I mostly take offense to the idea (and the outlandish perception) of Bill Murray as a celebrity, as opposed to his actual acting. The man seems like an asshole unworthy of the charming enigmatic meme-ification, but he can still turn a good performance when called upon. I was taken aback while watching The Life Aquatic—it might be because of ultra-low expectations, but I thought he did way better than I ever could've imagined in that film. That was because his performance allowed a peak through the cracked facade of a hardened exterior.

Nothing like that here in Broken Flowers. Ebert described Bill Murray as such: "No actor is better than Bill Murray at doing nothing at all, and being fascinating while not doing it." I agree with the first statement, and disagree with the second. Yes, Bill Murray is obviously good at doing nothing on screen—his pretty much built the latter half of his career on that ability—but I found that at times, it lacked nuance. I mean, it was just all mumbly deadpan.

Maybe I felt this way because he was constantly matched up with actors and actresses who were stealing the show. Jeffrey Wright pulls all the attention whenever he excitedly speaks next to Murray. The actresses who pair up with Murray in each subsequent scene create unique and incredible tension, and each has such a memorable flair, and I can imagine it was frustrating to pull the cart while Murray sat there and basically did jack shit.

I guess I'm presuming that this was Murray's fault, and not the director's or whatever. Okay, so maybe Don was supposed to be deadpan to the nth degree. Maybe Murray was instructed to act in this manner. If so, good job, you nailed it brah. You really, truly did nothing. Luckily, sometimes "nothing" is a great vessel into which one can fill other, more interesting aspects of a movie.

This is probably just me coming down hard on a celebrity that really, truly fucking annoys the hell out of me. Maybe I want to see it as a bad performance. If it's not, then can we at least agree that it's fucking irritating that this dude can get such high praise from critics for essentially not acting at all?

~~~~~~~~~~~
 
Here's the song, which I'm posting here instead of, like, choosing its album for Record Club or some shit. I won't do that to you guys, promise.
 
 
~~~~~~~~~~~

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: We watch Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, which I assume is a cowboy flick. I'm gonna try to talk to a friend about it and record the convo here, something I haven't done in many months.

No comments: