Tuesday, December 29, 2020

Never Seen It, #27 of 200: Brokeback Mountain

I made a list of 200 movies I've never seen but felt like I should have, put that list in alphabetical order, and started watching from top to bottom. Here's the next movie. It would be cool if I could do two of these per week in 2021, but no promises.


Brokeback Mountain
2005

I usually start with Google, after the credits roll. Not to see if there are any retrospectives or analyses available—there are, usually, but I wait until after I let the movie sink in a little bit before reading what it means to others—but rather just to see if the movie has been talked about recently for whatever reason. You'd be surprised what can show up in the news (remember how we watched The Godfather Part II and Roger Stone's prosecutors had just used the movie in court that week as "evidence"?). Still, it's not like it happens that often, so I was surprised to see multiple stories online dated "1 day ago" regarding the author of the Brokeback Mountain short story speaking out.

Most of the articles had a clickbait title, something like "Annie Proulx Wishes She Had Never Written Brokeback Mountain." What she really meant was that, over the past 23 years, Proulx has had interactions with fans of the story and of the movie who, in her opinion, completely miss the point. The point isn't Jack's love or Ennis's sadness or whatever, the point is the homophobia that keeps them apart.

I don't think that I necessarily needed that pointed out (especially after just seeing Brief Encounter, but we'll get to that). I am interested, though, in the idea that audiences could misinterpret a movie so badly, both in innocuous and in harmful ways. I'll use a personal example for the latter—I had obviously never seen this movie before, and I doubt many of peers did either, but that didn't stop the term "Brokeback Mountain" from becoming a homophobic punchline in high school. Forget misinterpreting—this is perversely weaponizing an anti-homophobia film for the purposes of creating more homophobia. I can't imagine LSCHS was the only all-boys school making such jokes, and it sucks in so many ways, the least of which is that it's such a good fucking movie.
 
So I feel like I need to take particular care in explaining this film—what it's about, what makes it a great film—as some form of repentance for whatever ignorance I've showed toward it in the past, in service of some bad joke or another. I would say something like "you know how teens are," but even ignorant teenagers are part of the fabric of society that takes on these uninformed and hateful views of non-majority groups. If I ever played into that—I can't remember any specific Brokeback-inspired jokes I've made, but that doesn't mean it didn't happen—then I'm truly sorry. Again, I'm especially sorry because the film makes its points beautifully and poignantly.
 
In that vein, let's talk about what Brokeback Mountain really is about. As you may have surmised, this is the story of two cowboys who fall in love. Jack Twist (Jake Gyllenhaal) and Ennis Del Mar (Heath Ledger) meet when they are nineteen, when they are both hired as sheepherders for the summer. A friendship develops and blossoms into a complicated romance. But when the job ends, so too do their interactions, at least for a few years. They both get married, have kids, live quote unquote "normal" lives. But eventually, they reconnect, and fall into a pattern of getting together every few months for a weekend on Brokeback Mountain, living how they want to live and never could back in society.

Or could they? That's the question that Jack poses multiple times to Ennis. Why not just buy a ranch together somewhere, live together for the rest of their days, be actually goddamn happy for once? But they both know the answer, even though Ennis is the only one who wants to say it out loud. The answer is that society (their society being America in the '60s through the '80s, roughly) would never allow it, and would often violently rebuke it. Ennis tells a tale of how, when he was nine years old, his father brought him to see the dead body of the local gay rancher, a guy who lived with his male partner, and for his supposed crime, paid by being violently murdered by locals. Ennis knows the score. He is unhappy, sometimes insurmountably so, but he chooses to be unhappy rather than to be dead. 

That's... well, it should be clear to anyone that it's not fucking fair to anyone in that position, to know full well what it is that would make you happy, and for then to be told you can never have that thing. It's fucked up. Annie Proulx, I get it! I get the point! And it hurts to think about it!

I couldn't help but compare Brokeback Mountain to Brief Encounter, not only because I watched them in back-to-back weeks, but also because they deal with (at least on the surface) pretty similar themes of love unrequited. Whereas Brief Encounter was content to show that love and to violently yank it away, Brokeback Mountain instead acknowledges that that love is always going to be yanked away, regardless of what you do, because of society's terrible constraints. Brokeback Mountain sadly chronicles the toll that can take on a human life, the harrowing truth that happiness could be within reach if there was any justice in the world. At least Brief Encounter's Laura was able to find her way back to her husband. For Jack and Ennis, there is nowhere to turn.

I spoke a lot last week about that feeling of brokenness within oneself when you think you should be happy, and yet you occasionally find yourself very unhappy, for some unexplained reason. While there are a lot of comparisons to be made between the two movies, I don't think they are comparable in this specific way. It's not like Ennis is sitting around wondering if he is broken, and what he can do to fix it. He knows exactly why he is so unhappy. He knows that he only ever found happiness with Jack out there on Brokeback Mountain. He knows that he could find true happiness if he ever allowed himself to be with Jack outside of the context of their thrice-yearly getaways. And yet he also knows that he can never do that, ever.

Jack didn't quite get that, or maybe he got it but was more outward in his disdain for the unfair truth of the matter. Jack is outwardly frustrated, whereas Ennis slowly collapses inward. It is never confirmed in the movie whether Jack paid the price that Ennis so feared (murdered by those with no tolerance for his lifestyle), or if that was Ennis imagining the worst in his mind. Does it matter, really? Whether Jack was murdered or if he really did die from an exploding tire pump, the truth of the matter is that he, like Ennis, was denied those basic rights that are supposedly guaranteed in the Constitution—life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness.

So as much as Annie Proulx hates it, I can't really blame for the audience wishing for a better outcome for Jack and Ennis. We try to imagine that there has to be a better way when it comes to love, no matter how that love is forged. There were enough people imagining a brighter future that gay marriage is legal in America, and that the majority of Americans are now accepting of LGBTQ+ lifestyles. Thankfully, plenty of human beings are able to find love akin to Jack and Ennis's, and they are now able to confirm that love in public without fear of being murdered for it. But we're not quite there, not when the Catholic Church looks unfavorably on it, or the trump administration pushes through homophobic laws, or, I dunno, high schoolers make cruel jokes using Brokeback Mountain as the premise.

I feel like I'm getting a little preachy, but that's just because Brokeback Mountain really got to me. It told an affecting story about how society was really fucked up in its homophobic views. The prejudice really got under my skin. In that way, it is a successful movie.

It's kind of funny that it lost to Crash at the Oscars, isn't it? Crash has been mentioned in countless Your Favorite Movie interviews, held up as the premiere example of undeserving accolades in cinema. It's been years since I've seen Crash, but I recall that it was an anti-racism movie, right? Which is as deserving a subject as anti-homophobia, but... I just can't imagine that Crash came anywhere close to making its case so intimately and effortlessly. Maybe the Oscar voters misunderstood the point of Brokeback Mountain, just like Annie Proulx feared? I'll never fool myself into believing that I understand anything about Oscar voters.

But I do understand Brokeback Mountain—unfortunately. I wish I could live in a world where the only thing keeping apart two men who are clearly meant to be together is their own personal flaws. I do not live in such a world. Instead, I know that I live in a world where two people can find happiness together, and despite that, they will still be kept apart for ugly and prejudiced reasons. Good movies sometimes proclaim terrible truths, but it is for those same movies that we have a responsibility not to look away.

GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Speaking of terrible truths, Bill Murray is coming back to our screens next week in Broken Flowers, so we'll see what our old foe has in store for us this time.

No comments: