Writing separate reviews for two "sister albums" released in the same year featuring the same producers, the same talent, and the same general "feel," might be an exercise in futility. If you are the type of person who really likes folklore (raises hand), then of course you're going to like evermore. If you are the type of person who disliked folklore (god help you), then I don't even know why you'd bother reading a review of evermore, let alone listen to it (so, like, what are you doing here exactly?).
For those in the former group, excited to get your hands on another winter-y, National-y Taylor Swift album in your otherwise bleak 2020, then the best I can do in this review is to try to pinpoint some of the subtle—but noticeable—differences between folklore and evermore. Despite having the same general ambience, there is indeed a slight disparity.
First, I'd argue that evermore is more consistent than folklore. folklore had higher highs ("betty," "august," a couple others), but it also had lower lows, spots when it either bored or became background music completely. With many more spins under my belt than I had when I wrote the folklore review, I think now that folklore is a wonderful album but ultimately a flawed album, and those flaws are masked masterfully by some of the better songs that came out in 2020 by any artist.
evermore, on the other hand, doesn't drop to those lows. I'm not hearing anything that comes close to the grandeur of "betty," but I'm also not hearing anything as dull as "hoax" or as grating as "exile." evermore is a slow burn, gentle but assured. I could see that some people might not prefer this. For me, honestly, the more I listen to it, the more I'm thinking that evermore's consistency is working better for me. If I'm not brought to tears during any of the songs, then at least I am fully engaged throughout its entire length. Your mileage may vary.
Second, if you thought that Aaron Dessner's influence was the engine that moved folklore, than just wait till you hear evermore. Jack Antonoff was the sleeper star of folklore, but he more or less disappears here (except for the excellent "gold rush"). Meanwhile, Dessner is working the door, letting all his friends in without paying a cover price. The dream of having Swift duet with Matt Berninger is fulfilled in "coney island," with Dessner's twin brother laying down the string arrangements, and the rest of the National providing a rhythm section. I've seen a lot of talk online that "coney island" is the "worst" song on evermore, but I don't understand it. Maybe if you aren't a fan of Berninger to begin with? But then if that's the case, then you probably don't like evermore in general?
Like I said, this is closer to the idea of "the National as fronted by Taylor Swift" album than folklore was. It's to the point that every time "dorothea" opens, I am tricked into thinking I'm listening to my iPod on shuffle and the National have just come on. (Plus—and this is something only I care about—Bryan Devendorf is finally allowed to let loose on the drums a little bit on "long story short," something he didn't do at all on folklore, and something that he didn't even do on his maligned solo album from earlier this year.)
Otherwise, evermore has a little more fun with its guest stars than folklore did. Bon Iver is back, with a song that is still not necessarily a highlight but at least is less dismal than their folklore cut. Haim provides backup vocals for the silly murder mystery "no body, no crime." It's a song that's hilariously about the grisly murder of Este Haim (hilarious because Este is singing backup on a song about her murder), and I'm charmed by how much fun everyone seems to be having singing about such a bleak subject matter. Even fucking Marcus Mumford makes a background appearance, signifying perhaps most of all the general concept that Taylor Swift has laid out over these past two albums.
That's the thing, though, isn't it? No matter what indie rock cred is scattered around this collection of songs, everything still revolves around Taylor Swift, and she remains a formidable talent in gathering the necessary sounds and stars to fulfill her vision. The songwriting remains sharp, and the vocals remain passionate (and cutting, when need be, especially around those precious swear words). I can't imagine that anyone can get to the end of 2020 and still doubt that Taylor Swift is one of the most proficient talents of her generation.
On the other hand, I realize that there's a very real possibility that I only have kind words to say about her music now that she is specifically catering toward me and my kind. It should be clear at this point that Taylor Swift can do it all, but maybe she can't—and shouldn't—do it all at the same time. If you preferred her country beginnings, her arena-ready anthems, her sneering "Look What You Made Me Do"-isms, or her meme-ready factory-made pop, then maybe you don't necessarily find anything to like in the autumnal dad-folk of her last two outings. I get it.
And I also get that maybe I have had Taylor Swift on loan this year, and that in 2021 she'll reinvent herself once again, and next time I'll be disappointed that she's not speaking my language anymore. That's okay. If Taylor Swift feels like she still has more to prove, then I wish her well on the journey. I just hope she knows that she has nothing left to prove to me.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment