Tuesday, December 1, 2020

8 AM — Song of the Hour: "All I Want"


"All I Want"
Broken Social Scene
from Let's Try the After (Vol. 1) EP
2019

Last year, BSS tried that thing where they release two EPs instead of a proper LP. That's stupid. There were ten songs in the bank, just put them all together on one album and call it a day. If both volumes of Let's Try the After were together, then it would've been a pretty good album! Maybe still Broken Social Scene's worst one, but still not bad! Instead, these two EPs are worse than bad—they are forgettable. Did you remember BSS released two EPs last year? I can see by the look on your face that you didn't, and don't try to blame it on COVID this time.

Probably the only person who has ever pulled off the EP --> LP thing was Robyn, but that's only because her three Body Talk "mini-albums" were eventually combined to create Body Talk the LP, culling the songs into a muscular album. Hayley Williams did something like that earlier this year, pretty much releasing her entire Petals for Armor LP in EP fragments leading up to the LP's release. I get that you want to put your music in the audience's hands as quickly as possible, but maybe also trust that the audience is willing to wait, and will appreciate the payoff even more if you're not spoon-feeding them tiny morsels every couple of weeks?

All I want is for an artist to release a complete work of art instead of turning to the geniuses in the marketing department to figure out how to boost streaming numbers.

No comments: