Monday, December 7, 2020

2020 in Review: Top Ten Albums

Every single Top Music of the Year List intro paragraph this year is contractually obligated to include something about COVID, and rightly so. It affected how music was made, it affected how music was published, and it affected how music was consumed. It's the latter that helped shaped this list, and I would argue that it's to this year's detriment. Like, I feel like it was just so much harder to absorb music this year, more so than any other year. A fantastic album could be released in April, and then by October I'm forgetting it even existed. It's tempting to blame it on a pandemic, but maybe that just means I'm getting older, I dunno. In any case, here are some albums that I really liked this year, regardless of the circumstances.

Honorable Mentions

All honorable mentions are described in exactly ten words.
 
20. Never Not Together by Nada Surf — Making the made-up term "dad rock" more real than ever
 
19. Welcome to Bobby's Motel by Pottery —Let's do coke and start a Talking Heads cover band

18. Brave Faces Everyone by Spanish Love Songs — Coming to you straight from the Joe K*** algorithm machine

17. NO DREAM by Jeff Rosenstock — Everything you feared is coming true, keep playing pop punk

16. Marigold by Pinegrove — You can both "ignore the wreckage" and not, everything matters

15. Dear Life by Brendan Benson — What if Jack White but normal and a stay-at-home dad

14. Blue Hearts by Bob Mould — Clarion calls that make tattooing them seem not too crazy

13. Imploding the Mirage by the Killers — go ahead, give in, let the Boss flow through you

12. Fetch the Bolt Cutters by Fiona Apple — still standing in the produce section wondering what the fuck
 
11. Honeymoon by Beach Bunny — new year, new female-led pop punk band, same shit, FOREVER
 
Top Ten Albums of 2020
 
10. Sex, Death & the Infinite Void by Creeper
 
I feel like the #10 spot is usually reserved for whatever album I discover around November 1st and can't stop listening to for a month straight. Give Creeper a couple listens, and you'll see why it was able to sneak onto this list. I mean, I dunno about you, but there's always room for some gothic theatrical emo in my life. Sure, they crib from bands like My Chemical Romance, but it's a wonder how many angles they are able to find to attack that particular sound. Every song on Sex, Death & the Infinite Void sounds different, even though, yeah, they all exist on an album about an angel and a vampire falling in love. (...I think? Better yet, don't ask.)

Check out these two songs if you're interested: "Born Cold" and "Poisoned Heart"
 
9. SUGAREGG by Bully
 
I welcome our new grunge overlords, and I would put on flannel and swallow cyanide if Alicia Bognanno asked me to.

Check out these two songs if you're interested: "Every Tradition" and "Stuck in Your Head"
 
8. Silver Landings by Mandy Moore
 
It's possible that I can only swallow large doses of that Laurel Canyon when it comes in the form of a pastiche. It's possible that I just hate Ryan Adams that much. It's possible that I'm in awe of Mandy Moore's ability to play every age from 19 to 65 in the space of a single This Is Us episode, and that awe carries over to her considerable musical prowess. It's possible that this is just my annual contrarian album pick. It's probable that it's all four, or none of them, or maybe I just needed Silver Landings this year because it acted as a balm. It was cool like a breeze and infinitely listenable.

Check out these two songs if you're interested: "Tryin' My Best, Los Angeles" and "Stories Reminding Myself of Me"
 
7. Hit to Hit by 2nd Grade
 
These motherfuckers are so catchy that they literally sing about doing taxes and it becomes a rousing success. Most songs are shorter than two minutes in length, so all the hooks are in and out before you can blink. I used to think that they called themselves "2nd Grade" because the somewhat adolescent nature of their sound, but now I'm thinking that the song length has more to do with it—childhood seems so important when you're in it, but blink and it's gone.
 
Check out these two songs if you're interested: "Trigger Finger" and "When You Were My Sharona"
 
6. folklore by Taylor Swift
 
I read something that Diana Ross was successful because she was incredibly savvy about who she chose to work with. I think when all is said and done, Taylor Swift will be seen in the same light—so good at writing music, and even better at surrounding herself with the right people at the right time. Taylor Swift has writing credits on every single song on folklore, but she shares those credits with two collaborators. Aaron Dessner is the one that got all the press, and provided the hook for an indie dad like me to finally get excited about a goddamn Taylor Swift album. Jack Antonoff is the true hero here, though, co-writing a bunch of the best songs, including "betty," which almost immediately became Swift's best song, full stop. But it all comes back to Swift, honestly. I didn't think I'd be praising this mega-star so much by the end of the year—2020 was weird, yo—but she is clearly masterful enough of a musician to pull of the seemingly impossible.

Check out these two songs if you're interested: "august" and "mirrorball"
 
5. Women in Music Pt. III by Haim
 
Over the summer, I speculated that WiMPIII was a grower, in contrast with Haim's first two albums (which were showers). As it turns out—yup, this grew and grew and grew, and now I'm thinking that it's definitively their best works. This thing is absolutely bursting at the seams with ideas, with takes on Fleetwood Mac sounds and Joni Mitchell sounds and everything in between, and all of them work (it's so busy that they didn't even have time to record on fully functional equipment, but hey, sometimes lo-fi works). If you're not on the Haim train by this point, I don't really know what else to say.

Check out these two songs if you're interested: "Don't Wanna" and "Now I'm in It"
 
4. Letter to You by Bruce Springsteen
 
The spectre of death hangs so heavily over Letter to You that I was sincerely worried that Springsteen was going to pull a Blackstar and leave this mortal coil after sharing it with us. I'm not joking. Here's the funny thing, though, about Bruce and his E Street Band—nothing can end the party with these guys. Not death, not old age, not 9/11, not the absence of their soul-sustaining four-hour live performances, nothing. Three of these songs—"Janey Needs a Shooter," "If I Was the Priest," and "Song of Orphans"—were written in the '70s and finally recorded for this album, and they are some of the better and more uplifting songs on it. So Springsteen is looking back, yes, but only because looking forward into the face of death can get tiring after a while.

Check out these two songs if you're interested: "Last Man Standing" and "If I Was the Priest"
 
3. Punisher by Phoebe Bridgers
 
Phoebe Bridgers has a superpower, and she uses it for good. During the day, when she has the figurative glasses on and wearing civilian clothes, she's clever, outgoing, and hilarious. But when she enters the telephone booth and puts on the cape, she's able to pierce my cold, dead heart in ways that no other artist can. And when 2020 turned into Doomsday, Phoebe Bridgers helped protect us all by giving a primal scream into the void.

Check out these two songs if you're interested: "Kyoto" and "Chinese Satellite"
 
2. Teenage Halloween by Teenage Halloween
 
The lead singer sounds like a lawnmower and looks like Steve Agee's son. They are reckless with their hooks and careful about their place in the queercore pantheon. The guitars are extra loud and the sentiments are kinda precious. If this is where the zoomer generation wants to take rock 'n' roll, then at least that's one fewer thing we have to worry about.

Check out these two songs if you're interested: "Holes" and "Clarity"
 
1. Saint Cloud by Waxahatchee
 
It's easier and less stressful to consider Saint Cloud in the context of being a fan of Waxahatchee and a fan of indie rock in general—this is a classic level-up, the culmination of five albums' worth of growth from scuzzy bedroom acoustic guitar strumming to widescreen Americana majesty. It succeeds simply because the craft is there.

It's a lot harder and painful to consider Saint Cloud in the context of the condition of the world during the year this masterpiece was released. It's wild how quickly I've internalized it, but the plain truth is that during the month of April, I was not in a good place. No one was, but I can only speak to my own experience, which was untouched by disease directly but felt with the adjacent force of a collapsing social structure.

Saint Cloud is not important because it "made me feel better," even though it did. Rather, it's important because it was the only album where I saw my twin but opposite desires of safety and escape reflected back at me. Saint Cloud is the album in which Katie Crutchfield finally gets her shit together through sobriety (safety), and Saint Cloud is the album in which Katie Crutchfield's signature sound finds a even fuller life on the dusty open road (escape).

In a normal year, Saint Cloud would've been a great album, but only because I've long been a huge fan of this artist. This wasn't a normal year, and so, perhaps even by chance, Saint Cloud became the best album—for this moment, for my own fucked up failure to adapt, for every lame fucking "bingo card" meme the twitterverse can fling at this fucking shitshow of a year. Saint Cloud didn't rise above to tell you everything is okay; instead, it was down here in the trenches with us, offering soft empathy and doing its part to give us a leg up over the first wall of many.
 
Check out these two songs if you're interested: "Fire" and "Lilacs"

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

See y'all tomorrow for the year's best songs.

No comments: