Pam gets adorably defensive when we're watching a TV show that she chose for us to watch, so she's had her guard up these past few weeks, whenever we talk about The Crown. For the record, I quite like the show. I think it's a well-made television program, beautifully made even. I am invested enough in these characters to want to know what happens next, and also invested enough to avoid reading anything about the actual history of the crown, since that would constitute spoilers.
But that's the really interesting thing to me, the fact that all of this actually happened (regardless of whatever the actual Royal Family is saying to the contrary—I've heard chatter, but I refuse to look it up, since, again, there would be spoilers). It's non-fiction. So that creates an interesting wrinkle in my criticism of this show. Mainly: can you enjoy a TV show when it's based on a subject matter you couldn't possibly care less about?
The answer, it turns out, is yes, but it's a more complicated answer than that. Let's call it a Conditional Yes.
In terms of how I go about my day-to-day life, away from the television screen, I can tell you right now that I don't give fuck about the Royal Family. I don't know jackshit about their family tree. I don't know about any so-called controversies (except maybe that one of them was connected to Epstein?). I do not understand why any American would give even 1% of their attention to any weddings or whatever that happen in this family. It just looks to me like tabloid fodder.
But that doesn't necessarily preclude me from watching a dramatized version of all this. I couldn't give less of a fuck about the New Jersey mob, which is a very real thing, and yet I adore a famous television show about it. One could even say I hate the Jersey mob (though only in the general, since they murder people I assume, I know exactly zero specifics about the history of their operation), just like I hate the idea of monarchy in another country. And yet, if the TV show is done well and is able to elevate its subject matter to an interesting level, then count me in.
There is a big difference between something like The Sopranos and The Crown, however, and it's the criticism I had of The Crown that Pam took offense to. The issue with The Crown is that one of the main plots, or themes, of the show is the constant discussion about "what the true role of the crown is." Especially Season 1, when every episode featured Queen Elizabeth trying to balance her immense power and her responsibility to not abuse that power. I get that that's important, but I don't give a fuck what the answer to "But what is the crown, really?!" is.
It would be like if The Sopranos spent full seasons having its characters consider out loud this question: "Well, I mean, what is the purpose of the mob, really? I mean, what is it we're actually doing?" I would find that annoying, because I don't give a fuck what the answer to that question is either. But The Sopranos, mercifully, did not do that. The mob just acted as a backdrop to the various conflicts that occurred between our characters. On The Crown, the crown is the conflict. BORING.
So, in a sense, the fact that The Crown is mostly non-fiction is actually to its detriment, at least according to a strong-opinioned asshole like myself. My personal feelings about these very real people and their very real roles are going to color my opinion of the story as its acted out on screen. If this was a fictional story about some alien species whose rulers were attempting to discern their exact roles as it would best benefit their alien nation, then it would be a heck of a lot easier to swallow. Instead, we have a ruler continually hemming and hawing about her role in leading England, and I'm sitting over here in America screaming "how about get rid of the fucking monarchy all together?!?!"
Sam wrote about The Crown Season 3 earlier this year, and, yet again, I don't want to go back and read it because I don't want to spoil Season 3 for myself. But I do recall him saying something like "The Crown only has one note, but hits that note well." I'm wondering if the one note he is referring to is the constant internal struggle that Queen Elizabeth has over her role as monarch. I hope not. As we move farther into Season 2, and the subject comes up less often, I'm breathing a little easier. I guess at this point, the Queen knows who she is and what she has to do, and now she can just concentrate the little stuff, like getting Prince Phillip to stop banging random natives in far-off colonized territories.

No comments:
Post a Comment